"Ana" is a very good pianist, tell that to her. It's a very hard piece to play, VERY hard. She adds an extra note at around 0:23, incase you realised.
im playing this piece for my grade 6 now! im taking the exam in dember and i agree with other people, i think you're playing too fast at some bits and you're missing stuff out. other than dat, you're great =]
I prefer it played faster. It's an opinion. I wouldn't act like there's an universally objective notion of correct tempo with Chopin, let alone Satie.
nice piece and you play it quite well except you are missing loads of bits out. follow the score as you listen to this video and youll se what bits youre missing out.
It's always seemed to me that there are two takes on Satie: flowery and embellished or terse and minimalist.
I think you need to rethink what you've done here. Your playing is good, really good, but you're interpretation is killing me. Enough with the arbitrarily fast and slow tempo, if you just play the melody straight, the three measure phrases will make themselves apparent. You're so *close*.
that was beautifully played! i bet that took a long time to learn! but i wish i can see both hands and not one and part of a knee. but i still love it though!
Very beautiful. Seems to drag a bit... and you should really build to draw out the beauty of the notes that I beleive to be the turning point (at 1:50/2:45).
a bit slower
HASRET901 9 months ago
Try to play a bit slower ^^
Hennalovessailing 10 months ago
Comment removed
UFRAIDEESREP 10 months ago
"Ana" is a very good pianist, tell that to her. It's a very hard piece to play, VERY hard. She adds an extra note at around 0:23, incase you realised.
mabz9 1 year ago
I'm playing this song too
But my left hand is a bit softer
van0905 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if anyone has this sheets of music, could you send it, snowxmf@gmail.com
I'm looking for it from long time... :( please
snowmery 1 year ago
Not too fast at all! Ciccolini is considered the Satie master and he played it even faster.
marvy1118 2 years ago 2
not bad, just try to be a little more fluid..
SophosVII 2 years ago
Have a listen to mine if you get the opportunity. Thanks.
KallistiMusic 2 years ago
im playing this piece for my grade 6 now! im taking the exam in dember and i agree with other people, i think you're playing too fast at some bits and you're missing stuff out. other than dat, you're great =]
jenpen41 2 years ago
sooo effective
thatadamthing 2 years ago
It's very good, but It's too fast.
Try to play it a bit more slowly
sstupefy 2 years ago
Not too fast, great tempo. Too bad the sound quality of these videos is so bad, I love the Gnossiennes so much!
Will upload a recording of the Gnossiennes myself in some time.
wouter1988 2 years ago
I prefer it played faster. It's an opinion. I wouldn't act like there's an universally objective notion of correct tempo with Chopin, let alone Satie.
How ridiculous.
elevenwhy 2 years ago 2
Ridiculous? I play Satie too, shut the hell up.
sstupefy 2 years ago
Comment removed
UFRAIDEESREP 10 months ago
yea they are syncing!
cherrykissesxo94 3 years ago
Nicely done, but the video's not syncing? Your hands dont match the sound... =]] otherwise, lovely.
allyougottadoisswing 3 years ago
Fair.
Buckley153 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
keep practicing. Yikes.
ao666777 3 years ago
nice piece and you play it quite well except you are missing loads of bits out. follow the score as you listen to this video and youll se what bits youre missing out.
aoife92 3 years ago
great piece...i dont normally like playing in minor key but this one is an exeptional. you've played it nicely :)
citygirl2lyf 3 years ago
i love this piece. i think its quite easy tbhh
SkinsCassieFan19 3 years ago
Very well Done.
FourtySven 3 years ago
i got play it in forto of hundred peoples. They make me so much applouse. It's a lovely music
JCFadil 3 years ago 2
lovely!
Jsingles589 3 years ago
beautiful :) minors are great, i love gnos 1,3,and five :)
bamseescratch 3 years ago
Not bad, but the first thing to do is to respect the score. Look at the score, some bars are missing in your performance.
Good luck with Satie !
Pierre from Paris
pierrecharbs 3 years ago 2
This is my favorite Satie!!
klastiaan 3 years ago 5
Great !
Fabjan2008 3 years ago
very nice
WoozyJos 3 years ago 2
nie oszukuj widać że puszczałaś z płyty i udawałaś że grasz
zosiaczek123 3 years ago
I loved her style to play this piece. I love it so hard.
raphaelarj 3 years ago 3
beautiful
ValerieLokas 3 years ago
the left hand is so heavy, play with your heart
xo4udessert 3 years ago
the best interpretation that I have found on youtube...in my opinion slower means better for this piece
gdyby 4 years ago 3
I play it even slower, I know that´s not the way it should be, but I like it much better when it´s slow
gozerdude 4 years ago
Yes , why tempo is so low on too hear that.
hose Satie interprétation ? Maybe Satie wrote some tempo on the musique ? Anyway: always love t
philipchek 4 years ago
tempo is too low
fewzebrank 4 years ago
melodias del alma
bluedemon43 4 years ago 4
It's always seemed to me that there are two takes on Satie: flowery and embellished or terse and minimalist.
I think you need to rethink what you've done here. Your playing is good, really good, but you're interpretation is killing me. Enough with the arbitrarily fast and slow tempo, if you just play the melody straight, the three measure phrases will make themselves apparent. You're so *close*.
davevontexas 4 years ago
bravo
damageinc24 4 years ago 3
i love that
apolejka 5 years ago 2
very good music beautifull
RobaczeQ 5 years ago 2
beautiful interpretation
a154352 5 years ago 3
that was beautifully played! i bet that took a long time to learn! but i wish i can see both hands and not one and part of a knee. but i still love it though!
iheartwillow 5 years ago
Knees melt my butter.
irishmonkey 4 years ago 2
Very beautiful. Seems to drag a bit... and you should really build to draw out the beauty of the notes that I beleive to be the turning point (at 1:50/2:45).
molliescent 5 years ago