Have a cigar - Foo Fighters Live

[packeropie]

holy f-in moley. that was insane!

[RailcarFerrostaal]

Dave playing drums gives me the impression of watching him playing nirvana again, what a chill!

[007sasherman]

must be tough being Daves drummah

[chrisantema]

so hot!

[theoldproject2011]

come rovinare una canzone storica!!!

[scottleo100]

big me deixe ela?

[erenxbjk]

04:03 awesome.

[scartissue94]

Something about Dave's drumming, I'm always hypnotized by it.

[dividedguy]

camarorider67, perhaps I wasn't being very clear. I was simply trying to say that "Have a Cigar" is the only studio recording (besides maybe "Great Gig in the Sky")that didn't involve an orginal member SINGING the lead vocal. I could be wrong. I'm not claiming to know EVERYTHING about Pink Floyd. It sounds like you do, though. Enlighten me, man. Impart upon me your vast knowledge of Pink Floyd. Good luck hunting around for other YouTubers to burn. Get a life.

[alterfloyd1]

@dividedguy

You are correct, Have a cigar is the only Pink Floyd track where they let someone else do vocals. Great Gig is actually considered an instrumental because the vocal does not contain lyric. Original Have a Cigar sang by Roy Harper. When Floyd played it live Roger and Dave basically belted it out together. I like the original but it would have been cool to see what it would have sounded like with dave or Roger singing it on the original.

[colepants1]

Watching Dave Grohl play drums is one of the most beautiful things I've seen in my lifetime:)



[FOOFIGHTERSRULE987]

@colepants1 more like taylor and dave at the same time (:

[dividedguy]

The only Pink Floyd song recorded that didn't involve an original member of the band. That's kinda why this cover works so well.  Brilliant!

[camarorider67]

@dividedguy You don't know very much about Pink Floyd, do you?

[xoxonceuponatimexox]

I love taylors voice!! <33

[serefable]

just shut the fuck up man. they're burnin!!

[matiasaero]

bueno pero que haga el punteo el cagon del violero

[jossy2112]

No one there could play the solos. Brian May did the solos on this cover, and quite technical as it is. Gilmour's solo is still the best 

[konfusionn]

lol Taylor "I can't sing"

I think he sounds awesome.

[francisco444]

No solo??? 

[sunshineschnauzers]

Pink Floyd is and always will be my favorite band, but damn i love Foo Fighters!!! Awesome cover of it, Taylor sounds awesome, Nate did a great job on bass, sounds a lot like Roger Waters! and of course Dave Grohl did his own amazing version of Nick Mason's drumming. Wish they did the solo, but thats a Dave Gilmour thing really, no one can quite compete with him... sorry!

[joacka]

dave grohl on drums rules

[ffloydmen]

I'ma fan of foo fighters but simply hierarchical levels where they can never reach

[abbeltuinstra]

he has a good voice

[jakominiful]

A great grunge rendition of a Floyd classic

[fydsg]

nick vs dave: daves win

[casualtySR]

too fast, but still cool

[ChiTownGirl2]

Love this version- it's got soooooul

[superbeavo]

Quit Smoking Taylor!



[EricAngelOlivo]

that's taylor singing, right? he sounds like robert plant from zepp (:

[shavethebravedave]

@EricAngelOlivo definitly .... noot :)

[pecucanalla]

good!! but... I still prefer the Pink Floyd version!

[annc94]

So kick ass. They could pull anything off with their senses of humor, and talent!

[littlememmole]

Great cover!

[MrGrungeMusician]

This cover is better than the original song

[JohnSkywalker]

@MrGrungeMusician

You have to quit drugs



[domdom111111]

A really good cover and it was good to see Dave behind the drums again!

[ebaymotion]

Foo Fighters are Gods. Enough said

[BuchananRockStar]

this is what we sane people refer to as a badass cover

[Diaz126025]

the songs not have a cig, Taylor Hawkins

[JuditasDude]

43 people here didn't have a cigar....

I can't even begin to understand how could someone NOT LIKE THIS, but well, live and let live, everything's ok.

[ronelvis]

The studio cover they did was much better than this.

[smilelikedevil]

they are fucked up ....... they just blow up the song

[reed311]

Damn, this sucks and I like Foo.

[bigsammieking]

The crowds hardly jamming ?!!! This is one of the best "Floyd" covers I've heard in a while

[chattileigh]

not bad

[Rodrigok7]

pqp,dave grohl na batera é um monstro,muito foda!!!!!!!!

[Rodrigok7]

pqp,dave grohl na batera é um monstro,muito foda!!!!!!!!

[1ENGLANDFOREVER]

not bad 

[poobumchumable]

not to dis the foos but this song is nothing with rick wrights keys and gilmours guitaring. i was in a band that wanted to cover this and i flat out refused, not that i didnt wana play it, just didnt wana kill it

[poobumchumable]

cant believe some had the nerve to call david gimour "boring"!! are you freaking kidding me!!!! idiots i tell you

[bergice1]

Wtf, crappy vocals!!!

[jeffah]

Who wants a BORING Gilmour solo? Not me!

[davizin1]

@jeffah LOL!

boring?

get a life, man

[TheCadet37]

@jeffah you should probably stop listening to music then

[poobumchumable]

@jeffah the guy from blink 182 is boring, gilmour is a musical genius. RECOGNIZE!!!!!

[mlb0226]

@jeffah Who wants to suck it? You do!

[willmymon]

come on all the 1's complaining its live = u not hearing how it was played thier at the time. love them for doing some thing they love which is some thing u do gzzzz

[omarsvolta86]

suicidalstan, i can't hear any harder riffs come on! this is their version but i think it's kind of meaningless

[jesse5852]

Not a good cove to loud

[jesse5852]

No solo, no synth, no music executive role playing.

[toriinprogress]

Dave is a fucking monster on the drums <3 Love those faces XD

[Hableable]

I'm a Pink Floyd Fan and I like this version. This is more about Dave Grohl's amazing drumming.

[Daring36]

No guitar solo? Best part of the song. But still a good cover. Foo Fighters are still amazing

[wthrfish]

Where do people get the notion that a cover of a song is supposed to sound exactly like the original? Christ allfuckinmighty, just enjoy a good band having fun with a good song.

[WESRULE531]

why are u haters hating of the Foo Fighters there legit.. In alot of ways there better than Pink Floyd

[aczepsmith]

@WESRULE531 the foo fighters are OK pink floyd is like 100000000000000000x better if you were s,art youd know that

[wolff990]

@ fedepf do have any idea where dave grohl come from? do your fucking music history - cock!

[ClassicIron15]

what the fuck!!! these assholes fucked it up

[aczepsmith]

@ClassicIron15 EXACTLY

[gymrachel]

oooh yeahhh!

[LEANDROCBA92]

grohl beat the shit out of taylors drums xD:P awsome

[L1Scouser]

i like the foo fighters but theyve murdered a great song there thats just noise

[Flosydian]

Pink Floyd:-- Have a Cigar

Foo Fighter:- Have a cigarette

floyd rules!

[leafrikans]

@fedepf what a crap comment.. did you at least read something about music... what a stupid kid!

[retisef]

taylor should sing in his own band!!!!!!!!!

[SoKrItIcAl]

@retisef he does...

[retisef]

@SoKrItIcAl no shit, what band?

[SoKrItIcAl]

@retisef Taylor Hawkins and the Coattail Riders

[thejakeludwig]

Why did that on guy who got on drums had to take out his earrings first??

[donjuanpuneet]

@thejakeludwig those are in ear monitors they use on stage to hear each other

[retisef]

@thejakeludwig that guy was dave grohl. and he didn't take out earrings, he took out ear plugs.

[333sfoster]

Taylor Hawkins is yummy.

[paddogg07]

anyone dissing grohl's drumming is a fucking idiot, the mans a drumming legend!

[drsta84]

personally i love their instrumentals on the cover, vocals are ok.

[OracleUndone]

too fast, too heavy, shit singing and... just ... crap. dont even attempt to change a floyd song, coz it'll never be anywhere near as good.

[jesusonectasy]

@OracleUndone At least it's different retard.

[dylano92]

@OracleUndone The Primus version is FANTASTIC!

[ReD6MarK]

....che schifo...

[GertPants]

Where is the groove!? Fail!

[almor619]

@GertPants everywhere !

[closer49]

tremendo cover !!!

[waller1976]

Grohl totally rushes the groove. Not impressive at all.

[dud0r]

wow look at his cocaine eys :o

must be great to be a rockstar

[Gilmourisgreat]

Pink Floyd is the actual best music in the world. Ive never seen a cover of it that was bad tbh just great damn music. this is awesome i would love to see this live haha

[Kurvstol]

I think the vocals match the heavier drums, and he actually hits most of the notes! Damn kool beans if you ask me

[bumchoda]

im a huge floyd fan, and i must admit i do like this cover. The audio in this particular video is pretty bad, but the good quality version of the foo fighter's cover is pretty damn good. I always like hearing covers of pink floyd songs.

[CuuijqyMuruqdte]

I actually prefer THIS live cover than the studio version cover. Still, I think Primus' version is WAY better than this.

[mauroadreim]

yeahhhhhhhhh,foo fighters

[kubbyt]

primus version was better

[rickvice90]

Taylor Hawkins was so fucked up that night. haha

[brunomsbh]

Isso é um sacrilégio!!!!

[malehawk]

Although a big fun of Floyd, my first LP at the age of 12 bought with my own money from Xmas carrols was "The dark side of the moon" and now in my 50's i have to say that this is a pretty decent cover..

[suicidalstan]

Not sure what everyone is complaining about. Foo Fighters did their own take with some harder riffs and great vocals. A great tribute Floyd and this song.

[CuuijqyMuruqdte]

harder riffs yes, GREAT VOCALS no fucking bloody hell way.

[damonlee43]

FU, Pink Floyd is brutal! Be thankful Foo did this song.

[666767]

fuck you ya baw bag what the fuck do you no ya dickhead about good sounds so shut the fuck up you little piace of scum

[MoveOverCasanova]

they play like idiots. simply ridiculous

[nirvanaispus]

How dare a truly awful band - the Foo Fighters do a cover, any cover from one of the great bands of all time. This band needs to disband before more harm is done to music. Haven't they enough already?

[alxbrnd1]

a wuebo la original es mejor

pero FF es una gran banda

de mis favoritas

[rockeroalfredo]

no mamen pendejos ingleses de que hablan dicen que foo mierda es mejor que pink floyd hahahaha si que son graciosos el cover no esta mal pero la version original en la voz de waters es incomparable al igual que gilmore porque no van a seguir escuchando FF(shit) que apenas son niños comparado con lo que es pink floyd

[erikklerf]

I like this. Interesting take on the song.

[MelodeathAddict]

See? This is the reason I hate my fellow Pink Floyd fans. -_- You guys are too damn critical of things like this. This is the Foo Fighters, they covered it the way that fits their sound.

Pink Floyd are my favorite band, with Foo Fighters being in my top 5, so whatever :P

I like it.

[halofan332]

This is so damn coarse and choppy. There's a difference between reinterpreting and destroying the feel. Not to mention - where's the guitar solo? Repeating the riff does not make a solo.

[elWray00]

taylor did better on other songs

[DavelovesRealMusic]

THIS SUCKS...He is SCREAMING not singing and the playing is off. Let the MASTERS (FLOYD) ONLY play rthis...whats Next..,.GREEN DAY does ANOTHER BRICK IN THE WALL? you kids have to stop listening to this crap and listen to the ORIGINAL ALBUMS/.CDs of PIUNK FLOYD

[Redrum4409]

first and foremost, when you type in all caps you look like a jackass.

second I appreciate different versions of the same song, covers that sound like the original are boring, there is nothing wrong with putting your own spin on a song..

and last you dont give us 'kids' enough credit even tho at nearly 29 to most I'm not a kid anymore, I was a fan of Floyd before FF's even came out, personally I appreciate both versions of the song.

[only1joe4life]

@DavelovesRealMusic I like Pink Floyd alot, I also like this..

Stop being so enclosed and broaden your horizons...

[TheGreenPicks]

it's very hard to cover a pink floyd song, especially have a cigar. but they did ok here. 4 stars

[cauchmarfuckyou]

fuckin awsome song but dave he is the man but he is beating the shit out of the drum set

[MISTIKOROCK]

i want to hear big me now hah

[Muertodesde1969]

dave grohl is a fucking machine

[NcBambi]

es su forma de tributar una banda , cual es el drama?

[Muertodesde1969]

@NcBambi el drama de esta gente es que si no les gusta no te metas a ver el video, xq entrar xa criticar es absurdo no?

[HateIronMaiden]

Pink Floyd's version is real, and FLYFIGHTERS DOES NOT PLAY MUSIC, BUT THEY'RE ONLY SCREAMING! Stop the fucking death metal!

[MrPeterGroove]

stop livin life like a pussy

[Skoog13]

loool, you think this is death metal ?

hahahahahaha, lol.

[musicofsounds]

so is the drummer also singing on the studio versions?

[jesusonectasy]

Dave Grohl is easily one of the best drummers of all time!

[ThinkAboutTheRequiem]

it's totally different than the floyd's version, but that's what makes it so good: they don't try to cover the song, they make their own impression of it

[Lioanimals1977]

Impressionante en par de bale!!!!

[DifferenceDiversity]

wow weak as piss no talent bar chord thrash solo , please dont do any other floyd covers , it started off ok but no solo and no minimoog = a shithouse version and HEAPS of repetition , sorry lol . Dave is badass on drums tho

[lachiripiorca]

q ganas de arruinar un tema

[blackryptonite]

Totalmente de acuerdo, espero que Gilmour, Waters y compañía no hayan visto esto...es para denunciarles XD

[notori4057]

taylor could def be an ex president

[gunsnroses742]

I love how Dave beats the shit outta drum sets X-P

[hanssemann]

Dave is a proper all round musician, probably one of the best in the business these days. Good to see him wack the drums again :)

[true2blues]

Awesome!

[JulianDJ5]

no guitar solo? are you fucking kidding me?

[Gillty101]

well theres no keyboardist soooo.....

[CarryingNoCross]

@JulianDJ5

Well, they had Brian May on their studio take. But if you don't have a real guitar hero in the band, perhaps it's better not to play a solo on a Pink Floyd at all.

[elijahinky]

@JulianDJ5 yea I was disapointed

[drumsforever101]

nick mason would be proud of you dave

[Mikeyski4]

The point of a cover is to not have it sound exactly like the original. I thought it was badass. Foo Fighters playing Floyd tunes? Fucking awesome.

[JuliaWis82]

it's not that bad--just a different way to cover the song. primus' version is closer to the original. although, I can't understand why anyone would prefer a cover version to the original

[Kurvstol]

You cant have heard lots of covers then! The drummer sings pretty damn good if you ask me

[finalfinal1000]

what kind of fucking retard would dis this cover, yea pink's was bet, but it's a COVER and dave demolished those goddamn drums you fucking ass pirates

[samsharpeye]

THIS IS SO GOOD

[Rush303]

This version sucks lemons!

[finalfinal1000]

are you on crack

[foo2985]

BEST COVER EVER !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[rafaescate]

shit cover, pinky rules

[Iceman5545]

that singer is gay as fuck

[ido8]

but, but, the guitar solo, where is it?

[Zendrix3]

So glad Dave grew his hair out again...and the beard is forever ill.

[westernearth]

Dave Grohl on drums for a pink floyd cover what else could you ask for........???

[laihoz]

fuck yeah.. he beats the living shit out of them

[least93]

Foo Fighters made this song better. Pink Floyd are good but the Foo's just made it better.

[junnybungle]

Uh, no.. dont say that.

[fullthrottle7061]

to the ones who did like this check out leatherwolfs version of ccr bad moon rising

[zooyork419]

This sucks!

The point of doing it the same is because Floyd Made it, and Foo fighters ruined it! That's why bands play it the same way because it's not their song to change around. I mean this looks like a fun jam but it's to different from the original floyd version

[Zendrix3]

The studio one isn't bad, but he sucks live on vocals.

[fatcat363]

terible cover

[Smokinjoewhite]

'm a floyd fan, and i like the foo's version, at least they didnt just copy it like most other people, what is the point of doing it exactly the same.....having said that, nothing beats floyd.

[sassanmaleki]

Terrible... They even didnt do the guitar solo. It was really terrible.

[shot990]

FAIL!!

[GreatDylan420]

i think its cool all you die hard floyd fans needa relax if i was in the foo id have a fun time jammin to this

[IrockNoKen]

if gilmour will hear this... haha

[Galwanzie]

He would be proud to see how influencial his music is to newer bands...

[madchemist5926]

Damn you Dave Grohl, you sucked the soul right out of this beautiful song. You devoured it and shit out a loud alternative rock mutant baby.

[blewsrose]

They fucking butchered it. This is shit in a blender.

[TheDIZZYDAZ]

This version SUCKS REALLY BAD. Leave Floyd alone. If I were David Gilmour I would be embarrsed as hell. MrPeterGroove why don't go back to listening to the Johnas Brothers!!!

[Lopinjop1238]

Awesome

[CONCRETE13]

To all the haters,

Its called a cover you fucking idiots. What would be the point of playing a song, note for note, as the original? To show how much you studied the music?

Keep fucking playing the same old same old. Let others with a sense of artistic expression play something that doesnt sound like it was taken off of the original record.

Now, go play your Pink Floyd covers and make you get them as close to the original as possible so noone accuses you of being artistic.

[Soroki121]

Concrete, it may be called a cover, but there's a point where it should at least be recognizable. This was barely even recognizable as Have A Cigar, they completely fucked this song up in my opinion.

[MrPeterGroove]

Soroki121 said:"they completely fucked this song up in my opinion. "

WELL,IN MY OPINIO,YOU RE COMPLETELY FUCKED UP