why do yo attempt to climb himalaya when you can not climb stairs of your house , that too as a concert and again that too in presence of great manna dey..
@MONKEY5989 Manna Dey is the greatest singer and musicologist in the entire Indian subcontinent. As they say "A tree full of fruit is bending low". I consider it an honor that I had an opportunity to listen to him live and meet him in person. The gentleman singing is obviously "be-sur and be-taal" but look at Manna Dey's greatness that he is accompanying him on harmonium and encouraging him rather than scolding him (which he rightly deserves ! ).
Is this guy for real????The butchering and violation of one of Rafi's signature songs pains me immensly...I think he must apologize...And to have commited such an atrocious sin in the Presence of an equally great singer as Manadey....makes me wonder...Is he playing with 'a full deck'....O Please....Jairaj Singh-Trinidad & Tobago...
GReat presentaion Yash ji i used to meet you in Tandoor rest. on queeens bulvd. in new york in 1991-1992 when Vinney was there, i moved to canada niagara falls and live here with family i was surprise to hear your so lovley voice , do sing any other sons pl post them
Manna Dey must be congratulated for actually accompanying this guy...!!! Listening to him is bad enough, but to sit next to him and play the harmonium....!
It is a disrespect to the singing not a tribute to Mohammed Rafi sahib. Please someone delete this video from this site keep Mr. Soi from future humiliation
Manna Dey is a great classical singer. Rafi admired Manna Dey, along with Talat mehmood, mehdi Hassan and Yashuraj. Thank you manna sahib for saying those kind words about Rafi, whom I consider the greatest singer of all times. I miss spa
Atrocious singing!!!! no clue about Raga or Tala.. Manna Dey saab is trying to cover for him and he is jst singing louder to mask Manna Dey's voice... LOL!
Mr Soi: It was a trerrible start., you killed the beautiful song which I sang much better
than this when I sang it first time as a 6th grader's first appearence in the school function in 1956 in S. Govt High School Bunga Hoshiarpur Panjab. You need to either quit or go back to very basics and fien tune your voice which shivers a lot. You sang the Oh dunia Ke Rakhwale also with the similars defficiencies throught out. May be try it first in the bathroom when nobody is llistening. try it
unfortunately no amount of blessing can make a singer out of Yashpal Soi!!! he has no sense of rhythm!!! wonder how someone like Manna Dey can promote him!!
There is many Rafi and Kishore but there is second Manna Dey and Bupen Hazzarika. Manna dey is not a comercial singer there fore Mr. Manna dey live in heart of all Bangali Yoth.
THIS IS MANNA DEY GREATNESS AND THOUGHTS ABOUT RAFI SAHIB AND RAFI SAHIB SAID THAT THE WORLD LISTENS US BUT WE LISTENS TO MANNA DEY THAT WAS HIS GREATNESS . GOD BLESS THEM BOTH.
terrible singing, why make an effort when you know u have no good knowledge of
music and need lot of practice to even copy the song sung by great singers. Mr. soi, you need lots and lots of blessings to be appreciated. GO BACK TO BASICS
@KSATWAL100 I agree. I admire Manna Dey's patience. He tried to correct him a couple of times. I wish Manna Dey had sung it himself. Loved his speech though.
@KumarTabla Yashvant is singing a classical song sung by the legend - Rafi - in the presence of one of the greatest classical singers of our time - Manna Dey. Takes guts. I admire that. If his singing does not compare well to Rafi's well...no surprise there, of course - no one can match Rafi or Manna Dey.
@jasonarcher2 Oh yes. Manna Ji and Rafi Saab are great classical torchbearers in the playback singing industry. I understand. For sure, I certainly agree with what you are saying.
pathetic effort by yashwant sir... but i appreciate his guts to sing this legendary song by a legend, rafi saab.. we lost rafi saab very early, but hope to see manna saab for a long time to come. i met him recently in kolkata, couple of years back. that was one moment in my life i can never forget.
Thanks for posting this, masbaul14. But could you do all of us a favour? Can you create two separate videos - one for the tribute and the second for the awful singing of the other gentleman...I want to send a link to this tribute to my friends but I do not want them to think that I am sending them a video of the bad singing that follows. Hope you can do this...
KHUKU 41---Manna Dey is a great singer with classical background and a good, humble human being. Mahammad Rafi is unique , a God-gifted genius ! There cant b another Md. Rafi. There is some divinity in his voice . Im shocked at this singer-to-be's audacious effort to sing a song like "HARI OM "! Its a pain. Gawd !----Sorry, but I couldnt contain myself-------.
Mr. Manna Day is a nice person but like he said Rafi was a great singer, that doesn't mean Mr. Manna Day is a less of a singer he is a great singer too. But it's very hard to say the truth, my hat off to you Mr. Manna Day
Mannay dey is better than Mohd Rafi. More accomplished and very well traine in classical songs. Rafi ji has also said that Manna Dey was far better than him.
MannaDay is a great singer no doubt.... And I salute him, while standing on my seat, for what he said about Muhammed Rafi.. I know its so much hard task to give credit to a younger one by a senior one like him...
It is a great privilege to inform that a few of our Shankar Jaikishen Yahoo! group members met the living legend Mannada recently. Thanks for uploading Mannada's tribute to Rafi Sahab. Imagine today's singer saying a similar thing for his/her contemporary. May God grant good health to the living legend.
if you have these doubts just listen to Rafisaab in Baiju Bawra, especially "Man tarpat hari darshan ko aaj," and your doubts will be dispelled. Rafisaab was a great singer and an even greater human being.
i have listened it several times. you are 200 percent correct what you said about rafi saab and his great quality as a human being. nodbody dare to link those great singers to communality. but comment is directed to those (not necessariliy to you, if i am mistaken) who praise a singer only because the singer belongs to their community/religion, or whatever else.
actually Rafi ji always says and believes Manna Dey Ji is a great and better singer than him.
Now Manna Dey ji feels the same about Rafi ji.
As audience we cant help appreciate these giants for their greatness, modesty and respect for each other. That is what true artistic maturity is all about.
this is not a sufi song but a bhajan in praise of the guru Swami Haridas who was music teacher of both Tanna Pandey (Tansen) & Baijnath Mishra (aka Baiju).
It takes a lot of courage to sing Rafi's songs as no one can equal him. This is a classic. Like Manna Dey he sang some great songs as well. A golden era every Indian should be proud of.
@abed83a WANT TO BE RICH? LIVE IN PEACE?MOVE ON TO LECHERIA - VENEZUELA. SALE YOUR ARTICLES, CLOTING FOOD,CURRIES, MASSALAS, MAKE BUILDINGS, MANDIRS, MASK, COLLEGES.TEACH YOUR LAGUAGES HINDI, PUNJABI.GUJARATI, URDU,TAMIL,ECT. DO GREAT BUSINESS! MAKE YOUR IT YOUR OWN; FEEL IN YOUR HOUSE. YOU GUYS ARE WELCOME. GREETINGS FROM EL MORRO, LECHERIA, VENEZUELA, NAMASTE, SALAM. COME WHERE THEY LIKE YOU. TO MIGRATED, THIS GOV. ISN’T ANNOYING ASKING TO MUCH PAPERS OR QUESTIONS.
Mr Soi: It was a trerrible start., you killed the beautiful song which I sang much better
than this when I sang it first time as a 6th grader's first appearence in the school function in 1956 in S. Govt High School Bunga Hoshiarpur Panjab. 400 students and all teachers liked it. You need to either quit or go back to very basics and fien tune your voice which shivers a lot. You sang the Oh dunia Ke Rakhwale also with the similars defficiencies throught out.
paul soi ...gadhe ki ,tarah beh beh beh mat kar,,,audience ko pareshaan kar rahe ho !!!!
BABAMUGHALBABASAHEB 1 week ago
why do yo attempt to climb himalaya when you can not climb stairs of your house , that too as a concert and again that too in presence of great manna dey..
rajesh k ranga
MONKEY5989 3 months ago
@MONKEY5989 Manna Dey is the greatest singer and musicologist in the entire Indian subcontinent. As they say "A tree full of fruit is bending low". I consider it an honor that I had an opportunity to listen to him live and meet him in person. The gentleman singing is obviously "be-sur and be-taal" but look at Manna Dey's greatness that he is accompanying him on harmonium and encouraging him rather than scolding him (which he rightly deserves ! ).
srafiquemd 2 months ago
Quickly watch the original which is on the right column to get your hearing back
lonelydinosaur 3 months ago 2
Manna Dey is one and only and there would be no one like Manna Dey Sahib ever. Lahori Munda From New York.
MAYOGARDENS 5 months ago
its a pain listening to this singer, though i would watch the vid again for manna dey's speech.
subhayu1986 5 months ago 3
LOLzzzzzzzzzzz....................!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
smawla 6 months ago
The song is great and will always be so. I hope the singer would do justice by taking "mauna" and simply shut up.
km7z7 6 months ago
Is this guy for real????The butchering and violation of one of Rafi's signature songs pains me immensly...I think he must apologize...And to have commited such an atrocious sin in the Presence of an equally great singer as Manadey....makes me wonder...Is he playing with 'a full deck'....O Please....Jairaj Singh-Trinidad & Tobago...
jairaj721 7 months ago
GReat presentaion Yash ji i used to meet you in Tandoor rest. on queeens bulvd. in new york in 1991-1992 when Vinney was there, i moved to canada niagara falls and live here with family i was surprise to hear your so lovley voice , do sing any other sons pl post them
ashwani sharma
ashwanica1954 7 months ago
abe gadhe soi ,,,,,,,, mat karo jo nahi atta hai,,, i think i can fart better than wat u
could sing,,,,,,,, audience have not paid to listen to yr " bakre ki taan"
BABAMUGHALBABASAHEB 8 months ago
im sorry to say that this is bad bad singing manna dey was kind enough to do a "wah"but im sure inside he was a laughing his ass off
joshuadiesel 9 months ago 2
yes. dis is actually attitude of greatest artists...salal Rafi sab and Mana dey je
demhaleeda 9 months ago
Manna Dey must be congratulated for actually accompanying this guy...!!! Listening to him is bad enough, but to sit next to him and play the harmonium....!
Coucoutchicou 9 months ago 2
A bloody donkey can bray better
satishnambiar 9 months ago
A bloody donkey can bray better
satishnambiar 9 months ago
Mr Soi: cut it out pleasseeeee
It is a disrespect to the singing not a tribute to Mohammed Rafi sahib. Please someone delete this video from this site keep Mr. Soi from future humiliation
KSATWAL100 10 months ago
Sorry, I meant yasudas and by mistake wrote yasuraj in the previous note. Milahi
Milahi1935 10 months ago
Manna Dey is a great classical singer. Rafi admired Manna Dey, along with Talat mehmood, mehdi Hassan and Yashuraj. Thank you manna sahib for saying those kind words about Rafi, whom I consider the greatest singer of all times. I miss spa
Milahi1935 10 months ago
Be kind. I would be petrified if I had to sing this great song by the inimitable Rafi Sahib and had Manna Dey sitting right next to me!
sam7748 11 months ago
Atrocious singing!!!! no clue about Raga or Tala.. Manna Dey saab is trying to cover for him and he is jst singing louder to mask Manna Dey's voice... LOL!
vinod332002 1 year ago
Mr Soi: It was a trerrible start., you killed the beautiful song which I sang much better
than this when I sang it first time as a 6th grader's first appearence in the school function in 1956 in S. Govt High School Bunga Hoshiarpur Panjab. You need to either quit or go back to very basics and fien tune your voice which shivers a lot. You sang the Oh dunia Ke Rakhwale also with the similars defficiencies throught out. May be try it first in the bathroom when nobody is llistening. try it
KSATWAL100 10 months ago
People who compare these Great Singers are fools.
badaustad 1 year ago
RAFI SAAB IS JUST THE BEST TILL NOW.
Kohrook 1 year ago
@abed83a
This is a TRIBUTE to Rafi sahab; he's not trying to compete with him ...
Let's just appreciate that.
Take care.
oyehoyehoye 1 year ago
unfortunately no amount of blessing can make a singer out of Yashpal Soi!!! he has no sense of rhythm!!! wonder how someone like Manna Dey can promote him!!
sudiptakiran 1 year ago
@sudiptakiran ---- so true ,,,,lmao
BABAMUGHALBABASAHEB 8 months ago
this yashpal soi sucks! an insult to the late rafi sahab. what was manna da thinking when he invited this guy?
leenaketu 1 year ago
Excellent
Asiftabrez 1 year ago
There is many Rafi and Kishore but there is second Manna Dey and Bupen Hazzarika. Manna dey is not a comercial singer there fore Mr. Manna dey live in heart of all Bangali Yoth.
BAPP04 1 year ago
THIS IS MANNA DEY GREATNESS AND THOUGHTS ABOUT RAFI SAHIB AND RAFI SAHIB SAID THAT THE WORLD LISTENS US BUT WE LISTENS TO MANNA DEY THAT WAS HIS GREATNESS . GOD BLESS THEM BOTH.
imtiazf10 1 year ago
Wat ever Manna Dey said is very correct and totally agree with him
TheGoldenRafi 1 year ago
This gentleman has a nice voice, but needs work maintaining Taal, laya etc.
KumarTabla 1 year ago
@KumarTabla
terrible singing, why make an effort when you know u have no good knowledge of
music and need lot of practice to even copy the song sung by great singers. Mr. soi, you need lots and lots of blessings to be appreciated. GO BACK TO BASICS
KSATWAL100 1 year ago 2
@KSATWAL100 I agree. I admire Manna Dey's patience. He tried to correct him a couple of times. I wish Manna Dey had sung it himself. Loved his speech though.
SuperMovies12345 1 year ago
@KumarTabla Yashvant is singing a classical song sung by the legend - Rafi - in the presence of one of the greatest classical singers of our time - Manna Dey. Takes guts. I admire that. If his singing does not compare well to Rafi's well...no surprise there, of course - no one can match Rafi or Manna Dey.
jasonarcher2 1 year ago
@jasonarcher2 Oh yes. Manna Ji and Rafi Saab are great classical torchbearers in the playback singing industry. I understand. For sure, I certainly agree with what you are saying.
KumarTabla 1 year ago
pathetic effort by yashwant sir... but i appreciate his guts to sing this legendary song by a legend, rafi saab.. we lost rafi saab very early, but hope to see manna saab for a long time to come. i met him recently in kolkata, couple of years back. that was one moment in my life i can never forget.
manasmenon 1 year ago
Thanks for posting this, masbaul14. But could you do all of us a favour? Can you create two separate videos - one for the tribute and the second for the awful singing of the other gentleman...I want to send a link to this tribute to my friends but I do not want them to think that I am sending them a video of the bad singing that follows. Hope you can do this...
tonginchic 1 year ago
KHUKU 41---Manna Dey is a great singer with classical background and a good, humble human being. Mahammad Rafi is unique , a God-gifted genius ! There cant b another Md. Rafi. There is some divinity in his voice . Im shocked at this singer-to-be's audacious effort to sing a song like "HARI OM "! Its a pain. Gawd !----Sorry, but I couldnt contain myself-------.
Khuku41 1 year ago
Jhoot bol re laay. Dono chodu bhagat thay.
oreomarch 1 year ago
Mr. Manna Day is a nice person but like he said Rafi was a great singer, that doesn't mean Mr. Manna Day is a less of a singer he is a great singer too. But it's very hard to say the truth, my hat off to you Mr. Manna Day
hunzukutz 1 year ago
Wonderful singing... great tribute to the legend.
rumahale 1 year ago
How can you sit with a Legend and does not know the basic beat. Please learn to respect Legends!!!!!!!!!!!!!
linkinpark2695 1 year ago
what the fuk is this shit wow man what a disrespect to Ustad Mohd. rafi sahib
tabla714 1 year ago
Mannay dey is better than Mohd Rafi. More accomplished and very well traine in classical songs. Rafi ji has also said that Manna Dey was far better than him.
bambaikababu2 1 year ago
Wht an anticlimax to listen to the song after such gr8 words abt a legend frm a maestro....you cud've cut it out buddy
sappy2shail 2 years ago
Comment removed
akshayank 2 years ago
Comment removed
akshayank 2 years ago
Comment removed
akshayank 2 years ago
MannaDay is a great singer no doubt.... And I salute him, while standing on my seat, for what he said about Muhammed Rafi.. I know its so much hard task to give credit to a younger one by a senior one like him...
MannaDay is a Universitay at his own.
winthis1 2 years ago
What a lousy singer?
rebhos1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
why is this guy singing???
elephantskin123 2 years ago
A singer like Rafi Sahab will never exist till this world ends he is uncomparable he has a great voice and Rafi Sahab was a great human being
liverpool1396 2 years ago 3
The mohammad Rafi version of this song from the movie Baju Bawra, named Man Tarpat Hari Darshan is amazing.
klacsanzky77 2 years ago 4
It is a great privilege to inform that a few of our Shankar Jaikishen Yahoo! group members met the living legend Mannada recently. Thanks for uploading Mannada's tribute to Rafi Sahab. Imagine today's singer saying a similar thing for his/her contemporary. May God grant good health to the living legend.
graphikamaal 2 years ago 5
Manna and Rafi are both legends, its not good idea to compare them.. We r proud of them..
raihanrcc 2 years ago 5
yes u r right!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wardak44 2 years ago
Bilkul Besura aur Betaala !!!
kesharma 2 years ago 2
humbling expirence!!!!!
sid8680 2 years ago
nice!!
allahrakhee 2 years ago
Manna Dey is undoubtedly one of the best singers of Hindi Cinema.
kishorepremi 2 years ago
The greatness of Manna Dey comes out in his tribute to Mohammed Rafi. But who is the bloke who sings Man tarapat..He is absolutely horrible
tonginchic 3 years ago 9
Rafi was the best... True legend.
no doubt about it.
Far Superior than any other singer of past and preset.
buttbest 3 years ago
rafi saab was no doubted a great singer. but the tone of comment sounds very communal if you know what i mean
msubrata100 2 years ago 2
if you have these doubts just listen to Rafisaab in Baiju Bawra, especially "Man tarpat hari darshan ko aaj," and your doubts will be dispelled. Rafisaab was a great singer and an even greater human being.
chaalchalancharitra 2 years ago
i have listened it several times. you are 200 percent correct what you said about rafi saab and his great quality as a human being. nodbody dare to link those great singers to communality. but comment is directed to those (not necessariliy to you, if i am mistaken) who praise a singer only because the singer belongs to their community/religion, or whatever else.
msubrata100 2 years ago
rafi sahab is the best no doubt.
nagdaking 3 years ago
Tribute to a Great singer by a gteat singer.
kuckudk 3 years ago 3
actually Rafi ji always says and believes Manna Dey Ji is a great and better singer than him.
Now Manna Dey ji feels the same about Rafi ji.
As audience we cant help appreciate these giants for their greatness, modesty and respect for each other. That is what true artistic maturity is all about.
pimezon 3 years ago 37
@pimezon yes. every great artist has great thoughts
demhaleeda 7 months ago
so true
srilankagangster 3 years ago 2
this is not a sufi song but a bhajan in praise of the guru Swami Haridas who was music teacher of both Tanna Pandey (Tansen) & Baijnath Mishra (aka Baiju).
heavyatheart 4 years ago 7
What Manna Dey told about recent hindi movies and their songs, producers, singers, can not be more correct.
With all due respect to this singer, its far from the original what Rafi sang in Baiju Bawra. That was classic.
abed83a 4 years ago 17
It takes a lot of courage to sing Rafi's songs as no one can equal him. This is a classic. Like Manna Dey he sang some great songs as well. A golden era every Indian should be proud of.
dav19J 3 years ago
@abed83a WANT TO BE RICH? LIVE IN PEACE?MOVE ON TO LECHERIA - VENEZUELA. SALE YOUR ARTICLES, CLOTING FOOD,CURRIES, MASSALAS, MAKE BUILDINGS, MANDIRS, MASK, COLLEGES.TEACH YOUR LAGUAGES HINDI, PUNJABI.GUJARATI, URDU,TAMIL,ECT. DO GREAT BUSINESS! MAKE YOUR IT YOUR OWN; FEEL IN YOUR HOUSE. YOU GUYS ARE WELCOME. GREETINGS FROM EL MORRO, LECHERIA, VENEZUELA, NAMASTE, SALAM. COME WHERE THEY LIKE YOU. TO MIGRATED, THIS GOV. ISN’T ANNOYING ASKING TO MUCH PAPERS OR QUESTIONS.
iTonitoo 1 year ago
Mr Soi: It was a trerrible start., you killed the beautiful song which I sang much better
than this when I sang it first time as a 6th grader's first appearence in the school function in 1956 in S. Govt High School Bunga Hoshiarpur Panjab. 400 students and all teachers liked it. You need to either quit or go back to very basics and fien tune your voice which shivers a lot. You sang the Oh dunia Ke Rakhwale also with the similars defficiencies throught out.
KSATWAL100 10 months ago
mohd rafi & manna dey r indias 2 greatest treasure
hinaz 4 years ago 8
Agreed.
786maq 3 years ago 5
n ghandi :)
triniluv 3 years ago