Whitney Houston, Live in Kazakhstan, 2008

[Ichisokeno]

Now, after her passing, when she sings "All at Once" its very sad. I've always loved that song

[MrKeyuan]

I think she needs to rest her voice and have a doctor look at her vocal cords she may need surgery on them because her voice is there its like her throat stops the voice from coming out fully

[blondboyful21]

i think she working her way to bring her way back to the begining she got her 90 voice back just listen to her 2011 i wanna dance with somebody it sound like her 90 voice and soon she have her 80 voice back i beleve she will god is on whitney side i know she get her gift back

[EnglishAB1]

I think it's unfair to call this sh!t. It is slightly, BUT she does have some good bits.

Like the 'and IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII' and the 'YOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU's. they were great.

[simonXSCREAM]

omfg i love 5:47 (l)

[born4singing80]

Horrible! so very sad! Embarrassing!

[fatboy55100]

this makes me wanna cry how her old voice pops in and out....so sad

[Kentake73]

WHITNEY was also a cigarette smoker - probably did more damage to her voice than other drugs.

[xXstaywithmeXx3]

so so so so so so sooooo sad. even now in 2010 she sounds horrible, not nearly as tragic as this though. I was talking to my dad and he was saying how she was just the SHIT in her prime, like she was IT she ruled the world. I mean watch late 80s-early 90s vids....jesus christ...so sad..so sad....

[cdcruizer05]

i dont think she really is trying her best to sing. Kinda like she know she has to be ther so she'll just do a little of this and a little of this. Nothing great. So glad she sounds so much better than this now.

[Lindow]

How painful to listen to the audiences 3-second- applause at the end. She so totally bombed that night. But I will always love her.

[lorimneal]

gd..she really should have gotten a voice coach b4 venturing out again.  i dont care how well she improves after this..this video will always be available for the world to see forever. gee zus!

[sl0wgrind]

Ha!!! Still Love Her

[MannyGiovanni]

LoL at 0:34

[RikoIsHere]

@MannyGiovanni I cant stand you lol

[MannyGiovanni]

@RikoIsHere

Haha I cant stand her!!

[RikoIsHere]

@MannyGiovanni Whyyyyy

[MannyGiovanni]

@RikoIsHere

First of all. I really love the lady... Cant stop listen to her musik.. Thats why I ended up here.. But I cant stand watching her latest performances where you can see clearly how she struggles with the high tunes and does'nt seem to realise that she no longer can sing.. Its sad and heartbreaking.. And a little bit funny actually. Like in this case, when she scream "and no other maaaaans gonna do". She cuts my ears..

[lorimneal]

@MannyGiovanni ita...i am shocked that she was doing this in front of a live audience. i thought it was a rehearsal initially....

[JohnDaniB]

I observe this woman to every detail and every performance. And I can tell she was very nervous. She gets extra extra silly when shes nervous. And i can see why-this performance was the first time she has been back in a looong time. Her nerves arent really there any more in her new performances. Shes GREAT. I love her. I love her spirit, her voice, her beauty. she rocks. you have no reason to be nervous whitney. your always gonna be the greatest!

[mcifami]

i never heard of this concert....its beautiful she has worked on her voice and after her world tour is over she will perfect her voice, and she'll be back

[JohnDaniB]

@mcifami yes your right. her voice will be perfection...but what kinda stage is that?!?!?!?! lol. That stage is HUGE. i have NEVER seen a stage that big in all my years of seen performances. WOW. whitney looks so good. omg.

[troynellsantana]

I went to her concert in austraila and she stills sounds the EXACT same.....and this performance was in 2008....

So if her voice hasnt gotten better yet.....IT NEVER WILL

[keemy281]

Eventhough her voice is raspy there are still some high points to the performance.

[justathought25]

i'm so glad she is so much better than this now....if yall hear what she did in tokyo a few days ago you will see that she has got use to singing again..she tapped into her love again and is begining to sound like old school whitney again with new school flavor... and plus it looks like the musicians didnt know what the hell was going on either...lolol...but this is performance is kinda scary.but Thank God for Jesus and her growth...lol

[ghyslou]

I could not watch it till the end. Too much discomfort. It's so sad what she has done to her vocal cords with all her years of drug abuses. She's incapable of using her head voice anymore or hold notes properly. So many wonderful hits she'll never be able to revisit and top in concerts. To hear her ''speaking'' them is just lame. She'll have to build a new repertoire of songs adapted to her limited vocal capacities. The Diva as we knew her is dead but I still wish her the very best. Good luck.

[kapuso2]

she can't sing her song anymore....good thing she is still beautiful...

[mOnTiCeLiO]

this isnt that bad...I mean...she's coming back...and I will always love this woman!!

[TheSanctifiedSoldier]

I hate to say this but meltdown is scarcely the issue...it's arrogance...

I don't know why she feels she doesn't have to rehearse properly and keep her mouth shut before performing...

Whitney, Mariah, Celine, and even Madonna suffer from vocal strain when they overuse their chords...doctors have instructed them all on silence before performing and minimal talking during tours...

I already know she can't keep quiet but the mere fact that she should be able to see these performances in hindsite

[durhamboy2]

I can hardly watch this. It's so tragic! And not only does her voice sound awful (which she doesn't seem to notice), the stage is far too big for her, she's just wandering around aimlessly and where the hell are the backing instruments!!!! Apart from 'I will always love you', there is just a couple of strums from an acoustic guitar. It looked like a public meltdown if ever I saw one. She obviously did this abroad so there wouldn't be a lot of media coverage so she could get her confidence.

[Jawhitney123]

I remember watching this (Almost two years ago now) and feeling pretty sad, however now she's sounding one million times better and I couldn't be more proud (L)

[moroney1]

@Jawhitney123 ur deluded if u think shes a good singer, you're liking the idea of whitney, not what she actuaqlly has done over the last decade

[Jawhitney123]

@moroney1 Excuse me? have you not see her personces on Oprah,Ama's & Italian X Factor? And I don't think she's a good singer, I KNOW she's an amazing singer.

[moroney1]

@Jawhitney123 You proved me right, '' i KNOW she's an amzing singer'' lol well you can know tht till the end of ur days doesnt mean its true. The woman doesnt have the breath control at all anymore, her tone is badly changed and she is extremely shaky

[grabbit1966]

She's getting better, day by day, just like the rest of us.....

[roquetasmedapart]

Absolutlely awful performance. She does too much farting around rather than just singing and he vocal range is worse than someone on Kareoke hitting the odd decent note.

[Topher286]

I'm so glad that most of the raspiness we hear in her voice in this clip has disappeared. She sounds great now -- well on her way to reclaiming her (late) 90's voice. The best! :)