I agree. And I don't understand why Marillion fans still go around saying "BUT FISH!!"...I actually prefer Hogarth. For the sound this band is going for H IS the right man for the job.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Dear Marillion. You need a much more talented singer than "h" is. Why did you let Fish go? He needs you, and you need him. You owe the world a good singer and lyric writer and that ingenious music you made with fish in the 1987s. Wish you'd never split up.
Fish left Marillion because he was done with them and he doesn't want to come back. Steve Hogarth has been frontman for the band for nearly 20 years now and if you actually have been collecting their albums maybe you'd realize "H" is just as talented a singer and songwriter as Fish, albeit a very different one.
"Normal" is a relative term...that doesn't really mean anything. To me they are still outstanding. My only criticism with their older material is sometimes it sounded a little too derivative of other neo-prog bands.
What are you all on about, especially ravagebang! Marillion ceased being a prog band the day misplaced childhood was released. Dont get me wrong, im a massive marillion fan, love Fish marillion (saw them at bathgate university back in 82) and hogarth marillion is good too, (that version of the space was poor tho) but Marillion dropped the prog label YEARS ago when Fish was with them. Fish would certainly NOT make them a prog band again. Bands like Pendragon and IQ have stuck to their prog roots.
I Agree with Fdelphinus. Fish is progressive, Hoggart is not progressive. Neither Fish nor Hoggart are Marillion, but I believe that only Fish can step back Marillion to genuine progressive rock band again...! the true essence of their music.
have you ever listened to This Town-The Rake Progress-100 Nights? What about This Strange Engine, Interior Lulu or The Invisible Man? These are truly progressive concepts and some of the best songs Marillion ever composed.
Fish elitists can't give better comments than "Fish was progressive - H is not progressive" AHahha... so hilarious... do you think people care about the music genre? You never listened to music, if you only care about the genre.
@ravagebang don't forget there are always 5 people that an cast a vote in whatever it is that they do, a man like "H" can not turn a band on his own, democracy is, even in Marillion, a greater good
steve H make me sick!! he has completely taken over this band, an they sound like they can`t agree how to sound anymore! Marillion was without a doubt my nr1 band, up until "brave", after that they can`t seem to find the magic anymore! sorry but they lost my vote!!
i absolutely agree with marcuse68, H colouring this band with his beautiful side, makes the songs very2 great, no rescue is needed to this band, still this band is a prog rock band in different way and that's the best thing happened to this band
@bubbeers don't forget there are always 5 people that an cast a vote in whatever it is that they do, a man like "H" can not turn a band on his own, democracy is, even in Marillion, a greater good
Thts wt I wnt 2 no! lol iam 16 last yr or year b4? well i ws lookin at pics from thm in the 80's, couldent stop listening 2 the fish era thn decied 2 give H ago looked at some pics and i am like The hair wheres the hair gone? lol
Love this. Always love marillion, Does anyone know in which session this was done? It's amazing!
DuketheFish73 5 months ago
classic track..!
SovereignBeing 6 months ago
I don't even know whether I've commented on this before, but even if I have, I can't help my self, this is perfect.
humblefofdeath 7 months ago
A great version of a great song by one of the best bands EVER .
I was fortunate to see & meet them in Amsterdam in 2007 (Snow where else tour)
Amazing stuff
Please everyone, do yourselves a favor & catch these guys live - truly unforgettable !
Burrellian 1 year ago
great...
creativerm 1 year ago
ooh maan what a brilliant version!
Ian is not just a brilliant rock-drummer
hes pretty much allround...!!!
not that this is a difficult thing he plays! But bloody brilliant!!!
gasarvid 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this song.... So deep....
Petula1985 2 years ago
What a voicee!
ytsename 2 years ago 3
Heard fish sing lately????
No thnx MR H is the right man for he job
Marillionair 2 years ago 13
I agree, bought the anniversary DVD of Misplaced Childhood :( it was painful to watch, I'm afraid to say...
Vigil in a Wilderness of Mirrors was Fish's finest moment post-Marillion (in my opinion)
FlyingHarlequin 2 years ago 4
I agree. And I don't understand why Marillion fans still go around saying "BUT FISH!!"...I actually prefer Hogarth. For the sound this band is going for H IS the right man for the job.
JewX0 2 years ago 4
Hogarth is a God.
lfotmm 3 years ago 7
couldnt agree more. <3
illesjev 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dear Marillion. You need a much more talented singer than "h" is. Why did you let Fish go? He needs you, and you need him. You owe the world a good singer and lyric writer and that ingenious music you made with fish in the 1987s. Wish you'd never split up.
mengenstrom 3 years ago
Dear mengenstrom,
Fish left Marillion because he was done with them and he doesn't want to come back. Steve Hogarth has been frontman for the band for nearly 20 years now and if you actually have been collecting their albums maybe you'd realize "H" is just as talented a singer and songwriter as Fish, albeit a very different one.
Chuixupu 3 years ago 9
Yes, and it's that difference that I dunnot like. They were outstanding, and now they are "normal".
mengenstrom 3 years ago 3
"Normal" is a relative term...that doesn't really mean anything. To me they are still outstanding. My only criticism with their older material is sometimes it sounded a little too derivative of other neo-prog bands.
Chuixupu 3 years ago 6
What are you all on about, especially ravagebang! Marillion ceased being a prog band the day misplaced childhood was released. Dont get me wrong, im a massive marillion fan, love Fish marillion (saw them at bathgate university back in 82) and hogarth marillion is good too, (that version of the space was poor tho) but Marillion dropped the prog label YEARS ago when Fish was with them. Fish would certainly NOT make them a prog band again. Bands like Pendragon and IQ have stuck to their prog roots.
markovanwho 3 years ago
Have you ever listened to the songs "This strange engine", "Interior Lulu" or "Ocean cloud", marko? Don't tell me that's no prog.
mostlyanthony 2 years ago 4
If there is another singer that is more passionate about what he does and what he writes then please do tell me
Marillionmad 3 years ago 2
ian mosely's a drumming god tho.
spunjz 3 years ago
one of the few marillion songs with steve i enjoy...killed!...sorry!
spunjz 3 years ago
I love this song :) This version is beautiful as well
Uceroy 3 years ago
I prefer song´s style like "Jisaw", as an example of Marillion band I always keep in my mind.
ravagebang 3 years ago
I Agree with Fdelphinus. Fish is progressive, Hoggart is not progressive. Neither Fish nor Hoggart are Marillion, but I believe that only Fish can step back Marillion to genuine progressive rock band again...! the true essence of their music.
ravagebang 3 years ago
have you ever listened to This Town-The Rake Progress-100 Nights? What about This Strange Engine, Interior Lulu or The Invisible Man? These are truly progressive concepts and some of the best songs Marillion ever composed.
frankibio 3 years ago 3
By the way... this video is a great version of another masterpiece of the H era
Fdelphinus 3 years ago
Fish elitists can't give better comments than "Fish was progressive - H is not progressive" AHahha... so hilarious... do you think people care about the music genre? You never listened to music, if you only care about the genre.
Fdelphinus 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
a desperate band devoid of ideas going over old songs in diffrent ways.Sad!
seanseventy 3 years ago
that is simply not true.
marcuse68 3 years ago
If you think this is jazz,you are a complete ignorant in music...Marillion has always been a band that was not afraid to take a step further
into the very essence of their music.
Perhaps among the most brilliant yet underated groups of modern rock history.
ObsidianHelios 3 years ago 2
INCRÍVEL PERFEIÇÃO...
jorginhogrumari 3 years ago 3
Hogart turned Marillion into a Jazz Band. I hope Fish come back and rescue a Progressive Rock Band Marillion was.
ravagebang 3 years ago
Lol... It's acoustic concert, so they arranged this song like jazz song :P And it's HogartH.
accidentalpicasso 3 years ago
theyre both great
ruberinhimself 3 years ago
sorry... Jazz band?? what is the band you're talking about?? can't be marillion.
marcuse68 3 years ago
@ravagebang don't forget there are always 5 people that an cast a vote in whatever it is that they do, a man like "H" can not turn a band on his own, democracy is, even in Marillion, a greater good
cloggy12003 3 months ago
steve H make me sick!! he has completely taken over this band, an they sound like they can`t agree how to sound anymore! Marillion was without a doubt my nr1 band, up until "brave", after that they can`t seem to find the magic anymore! sorry but they lost my vote!!
bubbeers 4 years ago
I absolutely do not agree. h's influence is the best thing that could happen to this band.
marcuse68 4 years ago 5
i absolutely agree with marcuse68, H colouring this band with his beautiful side, makes the songs very2 great, no rescue is needed to this band, still this band is a prog rock band in different way and that's the best thing happened to this band
desaseberang 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bubbeers don't forget there are always 5 people that an cast a vote in whatever it is that they do, a man like "H" can not turn a band on his own, democracy is, even in Marillion, a greater good
cloggy12003 3 months ago
great.......
robekaz 4 years ago 2
Marilliooooooonnnnn!
ytsename 4 years ago 2
BELLISSIMO!!!
starless1969 4 years ago
Is this whole concert available on DVD?
This interpretation is so catching that i have to wipe tears out of my eyes.
I must get my hands on this concert.
AudiofeelStudio 4 years ago
OMG I cry too when I hear Hogarth sing! I don't know how he does it, but he soooo unbelievably good!
vampiroangelico 4 years ago
IT IS MAN..I HAVE IT..WANT TO TRADE??
batatacollins 4 years ago
How can you get any better than Marillion?
No progressive band is THAT tasteful.
Dream Theater gets worse with every CD....
vampiroangelico 4 years ago 5
Very nice.. I love Marillion
Nice version of The space :)
Uceroy 4 years ago
" H " IS GREAT !
dzo26 4 years ago
Demasiado arrecho!!!
peyibi 4 years ago
aRRECHISIMO MI PANA !!Marillion es lo maximo no???
batatacollins 4 years ago
Please, when writing a commentary, Try to write in a correct english!
Ujio7 4 years ago
MARK KELLY,What did happen to all that hair?
kipslip6 4 years ago
Thts wt I wnt 2 no! lol iam 16 last yr or year b4? well i ws lookin at pics from thm in the 80's, couldent stop listening 2 the fish era thn decied 2 give H ago looked at some pics and i am like The hair wheres the hair gone? lol
Marillionmad 4 years ago
i think steve ate it all lol
trottet 4 years ago
Thanks for this song!, this version is great, very accoustic, It is between my favorite concerts.
alejandraleiva7 4 years ago
Wow, that transition is great. Still doesn't have the whole of Cinderella Search though...
HollowCauses 4 years ago
Or you could buy the DVD. ^^ x
lonneke8990 4 years ago
Wonderful! Please do continue to upload these, it's much appreciated.
lindsay3119 4 years ago