Phil Plait 3/7 (The Amazing Meeting 2)

[94jmcorrea]

wtf is this guy talking about?

[GMBCATASTROPHE]

I went to Phil's debunking of Planet X and its just not there at all. Of course there are many Planet X's. We just found 40 more planets in the last few years. Why would anyone be so stupid as to rule out new planets prior to each being found in turn?

Phil is a moron. Like all the people at Randi's Phil is an idiot.

[BortolanAlexandre]

@GMBCATASTROPHE except, there's really no planet X in the way the doomsayers say, which is what Plait is saying. Too hard to understand?

[GMBCATASTROPHE]

@BortolanAlexandre No thats bullshit. That we have planets and moons means that there must be many such planets. Since for us to have these planets and moons, these planets and moons must have one time been captured. And Venus was captured very recently. We have to expect that there are many thousands of planet X's. What the fuck would Phil know? He knows nothing. He's so fucking stupid he thinks that comets are snowballs.

[BortolanAlexandre]

@GMBCATASTROPHE Except that comets are made of volatile ice, so calling them snowballs is a good approximation if you are trying to explain what they are, and Venus is over 600 million years old at least, and it was not “captured”, it formed when the solar system formed, look up what the “nebular hypothesis” is. You fail at basic concepts, so calling someone else stupid really isn’t your work. Get an education first.

[AndreaZ64]

Although the screen is black, this talk still is great.

[cjdaweasel]

This video would be better if there was video.

[stardustme]

The black screen is proof Phil Plait is dark energy.

[LovelyYTRocks]

NICE BLACK SCREEN!

[Nereied]

I'm septic too

[brotheroftheelements]

u septic? really?

then go to hospital ;)

(sorry 4 being a smartass, but i just had 2)

[Malithion2001]

The screen isn't supposed to be black? Hell I still enjoyed it. Awesome! Thanks :)

[AJvsRonin]

Ever thought about releasing the amaz!ng meetings on DVDs? or are they already out? where from how much?

[TheFriendlySkeptic]

Amaz!ing Meeting DVDS are available and James Randi Educational Foundation website. randi dot org is the url. Go to the JREF Store.

[Clausfarre]

"Never mind the black screen - here's Phil"

[AmazingMeetingVideos]

Re-encoding this video to get the video working.

[frodocrockett]

Hmm. It's still black for me.