I´ve just realized, that the melody from beginning is similar to melody from verse of The Cranberries - Zombie.. don´t want to say the DT are plagiarists, there are perfect musicians, but I wanted to share this knowledge.. What do you think ?
@fernetsrumom At first it seemed to me that you were right, it does sound a little like Zombie, thought when i listened for the 3rd time, it wasnt that similar.
@fernetsrumom Somewhat similar, but I certainly wouldn't go so far as to call it plagiarism. There are only a finite number of notes people would actually want to listen to, and a finite number of sequences that sound good, bound to happen now and again that you get a few that sound similar. Now when it's an entire song that sounds familiar, or a very long major piece, then you can begin to suspect that someone stole it, but just that bit, I wouldn't assume plagiarism. That's just me though.
@Nejizero666 if you read my posts better, you see, that I refused to talk about the plagiarism, but there are some similar notes. This debate makes none sense, we both talk about that same. Have a nice day with DT :)
@fernetsrumom I read it just fine, don't take what I said as an argument or insult. I agree they sound similar,and that they aren't similar enough to call plagiarism lol.
@Nejizero666 yep, theres only 12 notes in total. most songs are based in 7 notes unless theres key changes like dream theater, classical, prog, and jazz music. theres also standard or common chord progressions such as the famous I-vi-IV-V that is widely heard in popular music. It's amazing though, the amount of music coming from 12 notes.
I think this song speaks novels to me. I grew up around strings, and I LOVE STRINGS. The intro of this song pretty much grabbed me by the throat and had me feel this instant sadness. Rudess' keyboard line....so powerful.
And I agree, this is easily my favorite song with LaBrie, next to Sacrificed Sons. I love listening to this song. I can hear it whenever, and always feel that same sorrow at the beginning and end.
i find it as the best song of Dream Theater. I DONT CARE WHAT PPL SAY. it has a great msg. in fact, it's about someone getting saved. John Petrucci wrote the Lyrics. Therefore, John Petrucci is considered a Hero. RIP in a respected manner
@YoungDrummer92 naw, if you were a drummer, you would consider the test that stumped them all or this dying soul or metropolis or the dance of eternity, etc.
This song is so inspirational. I remember him because, even in death, he gave me life. Through all of your trials remember that God is with you. We are living in a world without love and God has been replaced by selfish ambitions. He will niether leave you nor forsake you. What a message. There is reason to press on. Never give up and never give in. Do not be afraid to take his hand. It's almost over now. Jesus will return and set right all of the wrongs and defeat the father of lies.
This song is absolutely amazing, seriously, gives me goosebumps every time I listen to it. I only discovered it a couple of days ago and Ive been listening to it ever since. Thanks so much for this, live version is great, but studio is better! Thanks :D *living in a world without love...*
I love this song gunna ask brother to teach me how to play it
BlazingFireForever 1 week ago
how the fuck is possible to not like this song? i don't get it
BrunoCostaa94 3 months ago
ajde da smo i ovdje glavni ;)
CyberCrazy1990 4 months ago
Fuck FUCK FUCK . gone MAD listening to this. FUCKING AWESOME>
aliwesker 5 months ago
Whered i just go??? I was lost in epic awesomeness!!!
OnFire624 5 months ago
DREAM THEATER = GODS
pattyo1231 6 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
its a beautiful song
dreamslayer2011 6 months ago
Simply awesome. One of my all time favourite DT songs!
drummerdude100 7 months ago
1 soul rejected by the ministry of lost souls.
namskalxxx 10 months ago 4
this is unlike any song i've ever heard before...then again, it is dream theater :)
Poonard 10 months ago 2
rox
155Beto 10 months ago
solo @ 9:26 = EPICNESS
PersianLord1995 1 year ago
espectacular esta obra maestra
tizzitotizzon 1 year ago
I love the intro its beautiful and epic and just WOW!
PayneRigo 1 year ago
que weeena!
csampans 1 year ago
Jesus listened to this song and was jealous
welovedickblake1 1 year ago 3
I´ve just realized, that the melody from beginning is similar to melody from verse of The Cranberries - Zombie.. don´t want to say the DT are plagiarists, there are perfect musicians, but I wanted to share this knowledge.. What do you think ?
fernetsrumom 1 year ago
@fernetsrumom At first it seemed to me that you were right, it does sound a little like Zombie, thought when i listened for the 3rd time, it wasnt that similar.
Anyways, thats my opinion.
Floresteye 1 year ago
@fernetsrumom I think your ears deceive you
rosen34z 1 year ago
@rosen34z absolutely not.. just listen to both songs and you will hear some similar tunes
fernetsrumom 1 year ago
@fernetsrumom Somewhat similar, but I certainly wouldn't go so far as to call it plagiarism. There are only a finite number of notes people would actually want to listen to, and a finite number of sequences that sound good, bound to happen now and again that you get a few that sound similar. Now when it's an entire song that sounds familiar, or a very long major piece, then you can begin to suspect that someone stole it, but just that bit, I wouldn't assume plagiarism. That's just me though.
Nejizero666 1 year ago
@Nejizero666 if you read my posts better, you see, that I refused to talk about the plagiarism, but there are some similar notes. This debate makes none sense, we both talk about that same. Have a nice day with DT :)
fernetsrumom 1 year ago
@fernetsrumom I read it just fine, don't take what I said as an argument or insult. I agree they sound similar,and that they aren't similar enough to call plagiarism lol.
Nejizero666 1 year ago
@Nejizero666 yep, theres only 12 notes in total. most songs are based in 7 notes unless theres key changes like dream theater, classical, prog, and jazz music. theres also standard or common chord progressions such as the famous I-vi-IV-V that is widely heard in popular music. It's amazing though, the amount of music coming from 12 notes.
hellothereimasian 10 months ago
TANTA ROBA
Shawatsi 1 year ago
this is just a AMAZING SO NG the lyrics ssssssssssssssooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo SWEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEET
dolanforever1 1 year ago
7:11 to 7:20 is the best 9 seconds of dream theater I have ever heard.... wow 100000/10!
Joshn8r007 1 year ago
amazing, these guys are great
lestothepaul1 2 years ago
I think this song speaks novels to me. I grew up around strings, and I LOVE STRINGS. The intro of this song pretty much grabbed me by the throat and had me feel this instant sadness. Rudess' keyboard line....so powerful.
And I agree, this is easily my favorite song with LaBrie, next to Sacrificed Sons. I love listening to this song. I can hear it whenever, and always feel that same sorrow at the beginning and end.
DT FOREVER
jounin404 2 years ago 8
I actually don't think that this song is about God. Anyway, it would make me dislike that song, so I don't want to.
I think everybody can interpret it in different manners.
The song is just magical, beautiful, absolutely awesome.
mzelleZerbinette 2 years ago
Amazing...!
sakis512 2 years ago
can someone tell me the notes of the melody at the beginning? i feel like playin this on my piano xD
Nongamblerpokerfan 2 years ago
You are right, James Labrie is magical here... as is the rest of the band. My all-time favorite band, every one of them great and gifted musicians.
bwijsen1 2 years ago 2
the end impressed me!
milchbubi2503 2 years ago
i can't believe people think labrie sucks. he is AMAZING here.
J0000OOOO 2 years ago 8
i had to admit, his good on studio version, but he can't keep his voice up like this in live performances
Stiener7 2 years ago
@Stiener7
Have you seen him on the last World Tour? He was simply amazing. Even better than he was in 1992. So don't spread your bullshit on the web!
Octa1981 1 year ago
i find it as the best song of Dream Theater. I DONT CARE WHAT PPL SAY. it has a great msg. in fact, it's about someone getting saved. John Petrucci wrote the Lyrics. Therefore, John Petrucci is considered a Hero. RIP in a respected manner
absgke 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Well said dude, magical... deep... perfect
Fucking love this song, i listen to it everytime i get from school.
Evilme75 2 years ago
so magical, so deep. . .awesome
Burrumbumbum 2 years ago 40
@Burrumbumbum That's what she said
zmannx25 1 year ago 6
@Burrumbumbum So dream theater
lmaa19 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Burrumbumbum So Dream Theater
lmaa19 1 year ago
@Burrumbumbum indeed
ivica39 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ayşegül aldinç - beni hatırla
bu şarkıyı hatırlatıyor hep bana (:
R41nm4k3 2 years ago
I think this has to be the best Dream Theater song ever. It's soooo epic!
YoungDrummer92 2 years ago 26
I AGREE!!!!!!!!
CHANOK04 2 years ago
@YoungDrummer92 naw, if you were a drummer, you would consider the test that stumped them all or this dying soul or metropolis or the dance of eternity, etc.
trevoxisssxxx 1 year ago
@YoungDrummer92 the song immediately before it on the album also rocks....well, the song after it too lol.
greenradio1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the best song ever
TheElephant2009 2 years ago 2
RIP that guy was a hero...
celedeox54 2 years ago 2
This song is so inspirational. I remember him because, even in death, he gave me life. Through all of your trials remember that God is with you. We are living in a world without love and God has been replaced by selfish ambitions. He will niether leave you nor forsake you. What a message. There is reason to press on. Never give up and never give in. Do not be afraid to take his hand. It's almost over now. Jesus will return and set right all of the wrongs and defeat the father of lies.
fishguru73 2 years ago 8
@fishguru73 yuhr actually ryte. wat a s0ng? very p0werful msg that this s0ng has.
Andrew65664 1 year ago
it is a perfect song
34883788 2 years ago 5
Most of the team at OD love Dream Theater, and underground metal in general. I'm looking at a tab for this song at the moment (no solos just yet =D).
OranjiDesigns 2 years ago
masterpiece
nabbestemmia 2 years ago 4
the most under-rated song ever
metalv150 2 years ago 5
most under-rated band ever :(
celedeox54 2 years ago 7
HELL YEA! IF I DONT HEAR THIS SONG AT LEAST ONCE EVERY 3 DAYS IGET CRAZY!
this is my favorite song
and my favorite band
MrGuitarmetal13 2 years ago 7
One of the best DT song's In my opinon....
talos21992 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
such a great song
DKballer22 2 years ago 2
This song is absolutely amazing, seriously, gives me goosebumps every time I listen to it. I only discovered it a couple of days ago and Ive been listening to it ever since. Thanks so much for this, live version is great, but studio is better! Thanks :D *living in a world without love...*
BrokenxRosesx 2 years ago
yeap... nice song... shame that many people don't have a chance to watch it... or listen to it....
i love Petrucci's solo along the band...
Feeling scared...
She's prepared
lucaciandrei 2 years ago
saludo desde COLOMBIA!
robertexit 2 years ago
it is a very good song
GeminaXMike 2 years ago 2
This video doesn't nearly have enough views. I feel sorry for anyone who hasn't heard this, to be quite honest.
d1shwasha 2 years ago 2
Beautiful song.
d1shwasha 2 years ago 3
definitely a favorite of mine too, gotta hear this a couple times a week or I go into convulsions. fatal tragedy too.
bogistjoe 2 years ago 3
tyvm for uploading this :)
J0000OOOO 2 years ago 2
thanx 4 the studio version..I mean..live version is totally awesome but..studio version is awesome too!!
I love this masterpiece 4 real!!
DT 4 LIFEEEEE
MrIRONMAN90 2 years ago
i have the chills, incredible song.
Cuddleskillsuall 2 years ago 3
incredible
blondiebarbie333 2 years ago 2
beutiful song i will make my song cover of this wait for me promise
Theaerozepellin 2 years ago
Just for uploading this thing again, you get a 5/5. I'm not even going to touch the song, because I don't need to.
quadrupleplay 2 years ago
Thanks for the studio version :)
x0xr1kux0x 2 years ago 2
wowim the number 100 that heard this song
i luv this master piece :)
imabitch4u 2 years ago 3
one of my favourite songs of Dream Theater, and good job
Puppets7 2 years ago 2