Great Job on this, just a thought that the final words / clip (In some foreign field the gunner sleeps tonight - what's done is done) could of been the scene where Lewis as Winters shoots the young nazi lad in the field.
great tune, great lyrics... ive jumped and this is really what its like.....war... what is it good for >? what do we as ex soldiers get out of it ..... we take land... then the politicians give it back.......its a waste... a folly... with my life on the line... and for what ?
so i get a medal... the politicians get the acclaim and are remembered for "doing good"...
God, do I love this song, and what a great video treatment of the song. It's nice to get a new view of something that's damn near written into my DNA by this point.
minute 2:16, only Pink Floyd can do a fix like that, you wont know when the sax starts and when the voice ends, today anybody can do it with a computer, but Pink Floyd use to do it without mixers, thats freaking awesome..........!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Pink Floyd - The Final Cut. Last Album with Roger Waters and Gilmour together, i just love it..
I love Pink Floyd! Match up the metaphore with the song," On The Trning Away, with the 9/11 tragidy"! Really sends the point home! It is almost like they knew!
This song compairs the loss of life with the loss of love., it lets you know that loss of life is easier.. It says, that all dreams have worth, and all relationships. but unfortunitly, reality will be harder to accept than death...
Beautifully done - despite the British nature of the album the images were carefully chosen and I think transcendent for all nations. The video was really emotionally affecting. On Veterans' Day my heart cries for the sacrifice of the young for our failures to be fully human. BRING THE BOYS BACK HOME!
@grandpasacko wat do youmean despite the british nature mate im a brit my grandfather fought in that war and now i fight in afgan i do hope your not dissing the brits
Great job! I think I saw the beginning of this movie but never any further. War movies are not really my thing, but this song fits perfectly with your images. Very well put together.
I remember seeing this video a while back. Glad to see it's been put back up. I especially like the sync at 3:40. Waters should have made a film of this quality for the entire album. The videos that Pink Floyd put out for some of the songs really aren't very good in my opinion.
GREAT JOB MAN! Many people fail to see the simple use of "Metaphores" in Pink Floyd Music. I really Like the way your point of view comes across in this video with the Metaphorically Choriographed Video with Pink Floyd Music! It Fits absolutely perfectly. 5 Starzzzzz !
this was beautiful. made me tear up haha
olanza13 3 weeks ago
Great Job on this, just a thought that the final words / clip (In some foreign field the gunner sleeps tonight - what's done is done) could of been the scene where Lewis as Winters shoots the young nazi lad in the field.
SadisticFella 1 month ago
Good video. Really nice edit.
ShizuokaDolphin 1 month ago
that sax... ive rarely come across a solo of any instrument with such power of emotions...
guillaume1111111111 1 month ago
this is battlefield 2#
orlandi82 1 month ago
Floating down through the clouds ........
munghi 2 months ago
great album!
banq0o 2 months ago
Damn
xiLLxCRoWx 3 months ago
Great Video
DIBBLE6366 3 months ago
Awesome
sproutyDP 3 months ago
yes the final cut is a very under rated album
wonderstuff1971 3 months ago
Some amazing editing...even coincides with gunfire. Wow!
ositofreitas 4 months ago
This wonderful music of Pink Floyd!
silvanaf1980 4 months ago
Awesome song! I love the video.
Seattlecarnut 4 months ago
very good thank you
popacapov 5 months ago
great video all the same, just enjoy
billbellart 6 months ago
sad to see that there are only 21k views...........
RVBeEtZ 6 months ago
2:18 I love it when his voice becomes a sax :)
olbaard69 6 months ago 2
Goosebumps. Nicely done.
northcoasthelicam 6 months ago
Does the piano in the street have any significance?
ryuuzaki53 6 months ago
@ryuuzaki53 maybe its a reference to saving private ryan when Private Adrian Caparzo (Vin Diesel) gets shot and falls on the piano.
xavier71996 4 months ago
@lukacho999
Thats what my father says.
ThatUJohnWayne 8 months ago
this was done really well good work keep it up
derek110110 8 months ago
great tune, great lyrics... ive jumped and this is really what its like.....war... what is it good for >? what do we as ex soldiers get out of it ..... we take land... then the politicians give it back.......its a waste... a folly... with my life on the line... and for what ?
so i get a medal... the politicians get the acclaim and are remembered for "doing good"...
never again !
00001terry 9 months ago 2
Love it, just love it. Great vid :)
Glitchyo 10 months ago
did you had an account on 123video.nl?
miel1945 11 months ago
only the dead have seen the end of war...'plato'
maxrome67 11 months ago
omg! great job . thanks for uploading made my night
rupman27isback 11 months ago
Winters died how sad. True hero
Kemjmcg19 11 months ago
This is one of the best videos on the tube.Congrats brother.Love your work.Subbed as well
INKfectious 1 year ago
Awesome!!!
paganiniviolin 1 year ago
God, do I love this song, and what a great video treatment of the song. It's nice to get a new view of something that's damn near written into my DNA by this point.
mahajohn 1 year ago
RIP MAJOR RICHARD WINTERS
IN USA (RET)
bruzer75 1 year ago
this is so awesome, makes me want to just live every moment i get to its fullest. not take it for granted.
Crazy4Tediz 1 year ago
minute 2:16, only Pink Floyd can do a fix like that, you wont know when the sax starts and when the voice ends, today anybody can do it with a computer, but Pink Floyd use to do it without mixers, thats freaking awesome..........!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Pink Floyd - The Final Cut. Last Album with Roger Waters and Gilmour together, i just love it..
casasbojorges 1 year ago
i love this song, this song is the best of pink floyd for me
pinkfloydordep 1 year ago
Thanks to those for fought for us.
manta400uk 1 year ago
thanks for posting........the song and the video.......awesome........Pink Floyd forever.
TheArihudaya 1 year ago
Thanks for making that vid I thought it was awesome!
jakeyclarke07 1 year ago
I love Pink Floyd! Match up the metaphore with the song," On The Trning Away, with the 9/11 tragidy"! Really sends the point home! It is almost like they knew!
musdeemx 1 year ago
almost the way i would have made this] video.....very good....and thank you for bringing the story to my favorite song~!
jerbaldi 1 year ago
Waters is saying there is a fine line between love and war.......
hamptonervolina 1 year ago
This song compairs the loss of life with the loss of love., it lets you know that loss of life is easier.. It says, that all dreams have worth, and all relationships. but unfortunitly, reality will be harder to accept than death...
hamptonervolina 1 year ago
not what the song is about, but good analogy,, thanks.
hamptonervolina 1 year ago
@lukacho999 mate glad you liked it.
mts00007 1 year ago
Wonderful! Thank you for sharing with me!
misredkimmy 1 year ago 3
One of the finest pieces of work you will find on youtube.Fuckin first class.
MRSICKANDTIRED01 2 years ago 9
this is the original VIDEO , sompe pll have changed it a little to try and copy this!.
FUCK YOU ALL that steal.
mts00007 2 years ago
@mts00007 calm down dear
lionkillingnebbish 6 months ago
I just wish you put the some of the Medic Eugene Roe in the video, favoirte character.
xerxerxex 2 years ago
that saxophone is incredible.
xerxerxex 2 years ago 5
This may be the best video I've ever seen on youtube! This is a powerful song that deserves powerful images! Amazing work. Beautiful!
bluebeastsrt 2 years ago 5
Beautifully done - despite the British nature of the album the images were carefully chosen and I think transcendent for all nations. The video was really emotionally affecting. On Veterans' Day my heart cries for the sacrifice of the young for our failures to be fully human. BRING THE BOYS BACK HOME!
grandpasacko 2 years ago 6
@grandpasacko wat do youmean despite the british nature mate im a brit my grandfather fought in that war and now i fight in afgan i do hope your not dissing the brits
wardster638 1 year ago 3
@wardster638 , fuck that mate.... You are right!!! Cheers, thanks for what you are, and what you do......
hamptonervolina 1 year ago
Great job! I think I saw the beginning of this movie but never any further. War movies are not really my thing, but this song fits perfectly with your images. Very well put together.
Floydian1988 2 years ago 7
Bravo! Five stars, very well put together!
flydfan 2 years ago 4
just found it again. still just great (:
gragntK 3 years ago 12
great. just great.
gragntK 3 years ago 15
I remember seeing this video a while back. Glad to see it's been put back up. I especially like the sync at 3:40. Waters should have made a film of this quality for the entire album. The videos that Pink Floyd put out for some of the songs really aren't very good in my opinion.
thunderbolt468 4 years ago 24
@thunderbolt468 totally agree with everything u said
rupman27isback 11 months ago
GREAT JOB MAN! Many people fail to see the simple use of "Metaphores" in Pink Floyd Music. I really Like the way your point of view comes across in this video with the Metaphorically Choriographed Video with Pink Floyd Music! It Fits absolutely perfectly. 5 Starzzzzz !
c0mfor7a31yNum3 4 years ago 26
@c0mfor7a31yNum3 I agree
PugilistRick 3 months ago
Very good job!
Stepp1a 4 years ago 15
Great job man, loved it.
Jabberwocky72 4 years ago 16
you did this perfectly my friend
DarkFloyd28 4 years ago 16
This video is amazing. Beautiful scenes from Band of Brothers and one from my favourite pink floyd songs.
dcieniuch 4 years ago 15