Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (273)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • lady gaga can do it, but you can all judge this guy........ shut the fuck up. he can sing, enough said!!

  • But its not a natural voice though... The unique voice is because of the pills making him more of a guy.. Its not real.. its cheating life?? its cheating x factor!

  • @wolfie12344 - He's a man who was put into a body that was perceived as female; life cheated him.

  • @wolfie12344 Actually, it's an injection that one has to take, usually each week, for the rest of the persons life. And the hormones cause the voice to change, permanently. You have to learn how to sing all over again, there is SO MUCH WORK that goes into it. It is natural. It is permanent.

  • Amazing! better than the original :)

  • Nice singing!

    and chills at 4:24 - 4:33!!!

  • continued... We live with GID throughout our lives, and the transition is not a cure. However, it allows us to live more comfortably in the gender our mind was born with. At the end of the day, we are doing no harm to anyone else, and if we go to hell because God thinks we're an abomination then surely that is our choice. As it happens, personally as an aethiest I would end up in hell anyway so it's not the greatest concern to me.

  • Speaking as an FTM, some of the messages on this comment thread really disgust me, but then, they don't surprise me. Gender Identity Disorder is a medical condition just like any other, and here in the UK it is recognised to the point where we can obtain treatment through the NHS. If GID was all baloney and just something we decide to do quite casually, then I'm surprised that medically trained professionals allowed it to get to that status.

  • So handsome, and what a great voice!

  • microphone appears and disappears.... LOOK  4:04 - 4:06

  • wow

    

  • he's soooo cute!<3

  • @phoney98 She.

  • @ImTheonidas umm..thanks for trying to be 'helpful' but i stand by what i said, HE is amazing<3

  • @phoney98 She.

  • Is this an female? My mind is full of fuck!

  • @Papelmusic Male

  • @Papelmusic Female.

  • @ImTheonidas haha all you're doing is demonstrating that you have a LOT of your own problems and a LOT of your own anger at the world. Go ahead and call him "she." You're not going to get the attention you so crave, which is an angry reaction from other people. Other people know the truth about this man and he is a very nice person (not just on the show but in real life). Best of luck to you, darling. I mean that sincerely.

  • @Whitedoggy24 She.

  • Is this a man or woman, Page Elliot Phonix, its hard to tell by that name? He sounds lke a Ellephant.

  • Wouldn't it be great if most of the comments were about his singing ability and not about what he has in his pants? What a good world that would be.

  • @Whitedoggy24 Sorry but im just curious.. uve left dozens of messages and not short ones either. are u a transsexual or is there some other reason you feel this strongly on the subject.. forgive me for any illiteral mistakes i'm not english

  • @Whitedoggy24 If this was just about his singing. The show wouldnt bring this up.

  • @Whitedoggy24 yes, it would be a marvelous world. if none will be interested in what we´ve in our pants or with whom we go to bed. unfortunately... we´re far from that. and yes, it was about his singing, after all.

  • Comment removed

  • Amazing :) i just shed a tear over this. You are so brave Paige to say that on national television. I love you for that!! THANK YOU!!! and i speak for all our brothers and sisters :)

  • Next she will want to be Black. If this girl set her mind to something she will do it. If she convinces herself that doing it with a Animal is ok, she will do it! If she starts to like a Horse's dick and wants to suck on it, she will do it. It sounds gross but just think what she is believing now, its not to far fetched is it?

  • @SingJiya Among many other things, you should learn correct grammar.

  • this is a pethedic sad little girl, confused, this is very disturbing how her girl friend is ok with the wickedness he is doing and she is just going with it both on there way to Hell. This is really stupid, if God was watching what do you think he would think?

  • I met him <3 He's like the nicest person ever!

  • What happened to Paige? Did she get illiminated or had to leave?

  • @archangul In this vid he got 3 yesses, as you see...

  • @archangul He lives and identifies as male, and has a male brain. It's rude and just wrong to call him a "she". As to your question, I have no idea.

  • @archangul YOU MEAN HELLO LOOK AT HIM. IT SPECIFICALLY STATES FEMALE TO MALE. RESPECT.

  • He is freaking amazing! omg :D

  • he is a real man, cos he is brave and couragous like a real man!

  • PERFECT SOUNDS COMING OUT OF HIS MOUTH ! :X

  • He has an amazing voice... he could be the next Robbie Williams! It's a shame he was eliminated so early... Paige you are awesome! <3

  • He´s so cute!

  • he`s hot and such a great guy!you rock Elliot xxxxxxxx

  • I <3 his accent! :)

  • @CLoveX2 oh, this is australia isnt it :)

  • Wow, he's got guts. I can understand that nervousness he felt before letting them know, I've been in that feeling before. You know who he reminds me of? Eric Lapointe. Yep.

    Haha, anyways, ciao. :)

  • He is so brave

  • @TheMoa0106 she*

  • his a woman???

  • @firdausj13 Not any more.

  • @firdausj13 Man...

  • i reckon brillioant great honesty

  • What a homo

  • ronan keating is a sad nasty little insincere cunt.

  • ugly pathetic freak with pathetic excuse for cock. should have kept smelly fish-hole.

  • @VengeanceIsMineBitch hahaa its funny cause you are a pathetic fuck who has no life

  • @VengeanceIsMineBitch hahahahahahahahaha you're so pathetic!! XD thanks for giving me a good laugh at your part of the human race!! XD

  • @Whitedoggy24 you're very welcome faggot.

  • Aaah I can't find Audio Vixens audition anywhere D:

  • i like his voice 

  • i love this dude

  • wtf? 4:04 LOL

  • Comment removed

  • Hes amazing

  • i feel like im a lesbian by saying hes hot?

  • @99blathnaid Not really, already a guy.

  • @99blathnaid Nah.. He's a guy..

  • @99blathnaid go suck his clitoris, erm, i mean, cock.

  • @99blathnaid Actually, he is a man. So if you are a woman and he is a man and you think he's hot, that would not involve a lesbian in any way. I don't know what that question mark you put at the end is doing there, but either way, no lesbian involved. Take care :)

  • the wow factor was this bloke was a woman......must have been have been one ugly tart........but fairplay to the non spunker it wasnt half bad

  • @sherbert500 trans education 101: Paige Elliot's current looks don't necesarrily indicate how he looked as a woman. Testosterone, the male dominating hormone, changes a person's looks from head to toe - everything from facial size and shape, to hair growth, to weight, to muscle gain, to voice. Hence, before testosterone, he looked like a woman. You really should make an effort to learn this if you're going to make the effort to comment about it. Try a little. Take care now.

  • Obviously, since SingJiya wants to see what Paigai's dick looks like...he must be a closet case gay. Those who protest the most are afraid of what they have to hide.

  • @kamuelapaul Well said. I was thinking the same thing about SingJiya and everyone else who is uneducated.

  • WOOOOOOOOOOOW WHAT A VOICE

  • Im in love with this man. I absolutely love him. His voice brought me to Tears cause he is so God Dam Great and talented. i believe people must come to terms and honesty and love themselves first for people to truly love them back. And that is a Big reason wwhy i love this man!! And second is hes beautiful voice. i believe he sung it better than the original band. May success come knocking on Your door Paige Elliot phonix! <3<3

  • @Nourberry shut up you sad blasphemous cunt. crawl under a rock and die.

  • @Nourberry It's a she.

  • I can watch this over and over again, and having known Paige, I am so damn proud, and elated by his journey and success! Love and light bro, love and light!..............xxx

  • @MissNATferfoglia Another Weirdo

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • the fuck I would of never known he was a girl!

  • on singing talent alone this guy got screwed ...best voice

  • haters back off!! christians stop rubbing your beliefs on other your preaching about a book written by monks! <---humans btw

  • I really cried watching this.. D:! Phenominal! I'm so glad he's able to live that way.

  • @dicesan Freak

  • @SingJiya OOh don't be mad he makes a better man than you do.

  • @dicesan  I wonder what is dick and balls look like?

  • @SingJiya friggin hilarious - is hat they look like.

  • @SingJiya Probably as good as your u smelly indian cunt

  • @MrPurple06 I dont get it does she strap a Carrot on for sex or a Klauson Pickle? She looks really happy from 1-10, ten being best I would give her a 0. Ha, ha, ha, ha, Jai Ho!!!!!!

  • @SingJiya why can't you just let people be happy and respect them? honestly, you're sad.

  • @dicesan  Another follower of the Demon Satan!

  • @zoyataylor nope, as I recall, God didn't do that - MAN started WWII ;) Also, part of the reason Paige would have mentioned his identity is that transmen in Australia are virtually invisible and it's a chance to educate people (like yourself) about us and about the fact that we are really just normal guys. Australia really has a long way to go in its acceptance of trans people in general - we are way behind most of the rest of the world on this front.

  • @brighidskiss dont forget, soften the judges up to get to the next round, singing was crap.

  • @SingJiya actually, I'm a singer myself and I can tell you that Paige's voice is pretty amazing - testosterone can really do some bad things to a transman's voice, but Paige's voice has developed really well. He didn't need to "soften" the judges up for anything, he has an amazing voice and stage presence. I'm just sorry you feel so threatened by Paige's existence and so afraid of what you don't (and clearly, don't want to) understand, that you have to be so full of vitriol.

  • he's a good guy, but i dont understand why mix personal id with music. to help to score him points? he looks male and no one would doubt it, until he said... oh i used to be female. ;-\

  • @zoyataylor I get that, but trans education is lacking and grossly misunderstood by society. It is therefore important for people (trans or not) to present themselves as a way of letting society know that normal, loving, talented people are often trans people. He did it to educate. If the world already was educated on it and imbraced it for what it really is (nothing special or strange), then he probably would not have said anything.

  • To all the religious haters: God doesn't make mistakes. He makes people with disabilities and deformities, babies with things like cleft palates, and transsexuals all the time. We are not abominations or mentally ill - He makes people like us, to teach people like you how to love unconditionally as He tells us to ;) Love to all of you who are so threatened by our presence that you have to hate us xoxox

  • @brighidskiss doesn;t make mistakes?.. hm... WW2 was NOT a mistake? nice

  • That was SHIT

  • May god bless all you haters and bigots out there... I personally loved his performance and hope to see him go all the way based on his talent, not his fucking decision to change his sex...THAT is irrelevant..Its a talent show for God's sake... I will be voting for Paige if he gets into the next round.. The live performance!... All of the contestants biggest hurdle... Peace!

  • Frickin A, what a dummy, a chick then a dude retarded. I wonder if her girlfriend knows, I bet she does now. I dont know why they commend her when she tell them she is a freak. The judges are demons to say and clap for that.

  • @SingJiya It's HIS girlfriend, she probably knew everything and she supported him, HE is not a freak, and if he didn't have the courage to mention he was transgender no one of you know-it-all haters would have ever known. It's not your business what people do with their own bodies and lives. And the judges are better people than you, for sure, because they judged his VOICE and not his LIFE.

  • @GerryOptimisteve Are you Friggin Gay TOO?

  • @SingJiya Nope, I'm not friggin gay. I'm friggin transgender. You just talked to a freaky monster who will burn in hell. :)

  • @SingJiya you are so ignorant... grow some brain cells.

  • @SingJiya I haven't seen you write one comment yet that is a grammatically correct or cohesive sentence. That, my pet, says just about all that needs to be known about you. Why should anyone take you seriously when you can't spell? can't learn? can't comprehend languages or other people's natures? You poor little soul. Best of luck to you - you'll need it! :)

  • @Whitedoggy24 Well at least I no that if I were born a Girl, Iam a girll and now a boy?

    You beeing as smartt as you're are showld no this?

  • For those who are trying to rip Paige to shreds, I have met Paige and spent sometime with him. He is an amazing and wonderful gentleman. He is extremely kind. The fact that he is a F2M(Female to Male) transgendered being only means that he is comfortable with himself. For him to stand up infront of Australia and say "I am transgendered" takes alot of guts and that is something that is truely to be admired.

  • amazing story!! truly inspiring.

    

  • You go Paige. Tell the world.

  • greeting from greece, nice story, well done!

  • his Hot <3

  • "Paige Elliot Phoenix"?

    Geeze. That's a really cool sounding name actually.

  • As a FTM transgender myself I have to say, I'm really jealous. :)

  • @AlisterPuddifer totally agree man, if I'm able to sing even half the way Paige can after T, I'll consider myself happy :D

  • @AlisterPuddifer Doesn't he look great? And great singing on top of it. I think it's fab change.

  • @AlisterPuddifer Me too, LOL

  • bellissimo............ from italy.. on kiss for everyone...

  • Ahhhh, this just makes me want to transition more.. 

  • @graffitiMANZ I agree more than words can describe :)

  • He sounds great (:

  • @LisaSpringfield

    Learn psychology, my lovely. It is our mind that determines who we are, not our body.

  • I can't believe all the fuss about psychology, transexualism,is 'it' gay etc etc.

    She was a girl, now he's a guy...very simple

  • If a dude shagged it, would they be gay?

  • @StrangeConcoctions "it" is such a derogatory term. don't EVER call a human being "it."Paige is a man ,so use male pronouns. but yes, if a guy had sex with Paige , then he would be gay, or bi sexual.

  • @StrangeConcoctions yes. gay or Bi.

  • @LisaSpringfield Fuck you biggot! Learn psychology you disgusting waste of a human.

    Genitalia = assigned sex at birth.

    Gender = assigned identity according to your mind.

    A man who is infertile, or has prostate cancer and had to get his testicles amputated doesn't make him less of a man. Also it's funny how you assume I'm a lesbian just because I stood up for this MAN.

  • @krazbar1 But he's not a girl.

    He's a dude. o_o

  • @zaswerty Yeah thats what i thought.. he/she.... was born a girl n now try's to be a boy n he/she dose a good job

  • As usual the youtube keyboard crusaders and the god-squad are out in force. IF Jesus existed, he was supposed to be forgiving and accept everyone for what they are. You should get over it though, we evolved.

  • @GrandInquisitor7 hey you dumb ass fuckhead, YOU WILL BE GOING STRAIGHT TO HELL FOR THIS COMMENT, YOUR ASS IS EVIL. GOD LOOKS AT YOUR HEART DUMB FUCK NOT YOUR GENDER. SO YOU CAN SPREAD ALL THE HATE YOU WANT, BUT WE ARE ONLY GETTING BIGGGER ARSE WIPE.

  • @GrandInquisitor7 Wow! The whole of Australia is cursed by God. That's deeply worrying. Any other countries as well? There is such a thing as intellectual incest, i.e. only reading things that confirm your own opinion and talking to people who agree with you. If I look at your profile I wonder whether you can open up to other people's views.

  • @GrandInquisitor7 oh boy, you sure are funny. I don't see Australia having sunk in the sea, till now.

  • @GerryOptimisteve God punishes the wicked perverts on his own time, not yours!

  • @GrandInquisitor7 and you're so awesome that you absolutely know what God thinks.

  • @GerryOptimisteve It is our Duty as it is every living souls Duty to Crack Open a Bible, and look up the standards of Almighty God! It is your Duty to read the Bible! The Bible tells you what God's stance is on homosexuality and all manner of sexual perversions! Repent Dummy!

    Have a nice day!

  • @GrandInquisitor7 I'm sorry pal, I can't accept a God who is into hating people. Most of my friends are LGBTQ+ and I refuse to reject them (and myself) just because a dude wrote so in a book claiming to be God's words over 2000 years ago. Times change, and so should the views of people for the world.

    Yeah I know, I'm going to Hell.

  • @GerryOptimisteve I'll be right there with you. I hear the music is better down there anyway! So many ignorant and blindsighted people in the world. I love how people use the bible as a reference to hate on things they dont understand. If there were more people like us in the world and less of those narrow minded fools the world would be a better place.

  • @katiebooth1983 You're awesome and I like you. :)

  • @GerryOptimisteve Why thankyou very much. Sentiments whole heartedly returned. (what a terribly English response!)

  • @GerryOptimisteve You can say all that, but it doesn't change a thing! Either you repent and Obey God and he blesses you, or you disobey and he curses you.

  • @GrandInquisitor7 You know, the more I read your comments and see your channel, the more I'm convinced you're just a random troll who likes to pick fights. There's no way there's a person so narrow-minded. You pretend to know everything, but you know nothing. You have the arrogance to believe that you know what God thinks, and will spend your entire life trying to obey God, never being truly happy, never embracing the world, just condemning it. I pity you. Mind your own business and stop hating.

  • @GerryOptimisteve Hush Up you clod! The Bible tells us what God things about homosexuality, deal with it!

  • @GrandInquisitor7 and some people don't give a shit for what the Bible says, and what people like you find as excuses to hate others. Deal with it.

  • @GrandInquisitor7 How do you know this? Because of what someone told you when you were 8? Because of what you were spoon-fed in junior high and told what to believe? There is a huge difference between putting your beliefs on automatic pilot and making an effort to form your own views and love based on the true nature of the world. I don't know how you can claim what "god" said when you're just another human, like me. You're so blind to this concept, you'll only be defensive.

  • @GrandInquisitor7 ooh, actually the almighty doesn't hate anyone. Just you. See the difference? I think you should worry about yourself and your happiness instead of making sure others are put down for who they are. How would you feel if someone disliked you for the root of who you are? You wouldn't be able to change that about yourself. That wouldn't feel too good would it? You could try meditation, yoga, eating well, labotomy, anything really to calm that hate of yours.

  • @GrandInquisitor7 If God didn't want this, he wouldn't have made it either. Now go read some lovely children fairytale books.

  • @gbardan1 Wow, thank you for gracing us with your ignorant comments but no one cares what you think buddy,

  • @gbardan1 I know you wish to have intercourse with transsexuals, and there is nothing wrong with that! But I do not think they would find your ignorance to be attractive in the least. ;)

  • I applaud the audience for their acceptance of Paige after his backstory being told. I can visualize an American audience walking out on him, sad but true. Paige is an incredible singer and I wish him the very best during the competition.

  • Comment removed

  • Go Paige !!! Go !!! You are Incredible. Buona vita.

    Linda

  • fukn hell....coulda fooled me

    

  • @dukkmann ROFL

  • Thank god Mel B didn't change her gender!

  • Paige, you ARE a man!