for me i saw the original line up live all them years ago now and i never really liked them after new people started replacing original members,it changed that dynamic. i would now only go to see an oasis concert if the 5 originals lads played and that will never happen again,not in my lifetime.
Noel sacked him as they had a personality clash. Although they all seem to think that he was sacked because he wouldn't of been able to drum on the songs on Whats the story, which is bull**** if you ask me as the drumming was very simple and not that much more advanced on Definitely Maybe.
@zzzzzzz114 Read it. It was one-sided, one-eyed and had a clear agenda. The fact that very little of what he says has been backed up in other interviews leads em to doibt its authenticity.
I dont think it was one sided. he was just defending himself. and who is supposed to back him up in interviews? he isnt in show business. he doesnt have thousands of groupies that will kiss his arse and say anything he tells them to say.
Alot of the stuff Mccarroll says in the book makes sense and he seems truthfull. He never really attacks anyone in the book he's basically just defended himself.
@airmedi27 .......Tony McCarroll,.....Alan White......Zac Starky......Chris Sharrock......& Noel himself !!!!! How many Ex-Drummers in massive bands can YOU think of.....??????
for me i saw the original line up live all them years ago now and i never really liked them after new people started replacing original members,it changed that dynamic. i would now only go to see an oasis concert if the 5 originals lads played and that will never happen again,not in my lifetime.
philkearney0577 1 month ago
I listened to Live Forever after this
RosarioNahu 2 months ago
am not understanding this full tony thing here lol
DAG241 7 months ago
@DAG241
Noel sacked him as they had a personality clash. Although they all seem to think that he was sacked because he wouldn't of been able to drum on the songs on Whats the story, which is bull**** if you ask me as the drumming was very simple and not that much more advanced on Definitely Maybe.
tomgarify 4 months ago
@tomgarify aye. he drummed on Some Might Say which sounds fine to me
TheGalwayFarmer 2 months ago
I love Tony, 'cos he's ex-Oasis, but he's a bitter man.
GallagherWellerBrown 1 year ago
@GallagherWellerBrown
you should take your tounge out of noels arse and read tony's book instead then you would probably understand some things better.
zzzzzzz114 1 year ago 4
@zzzzzzz114 Read it. It was one-sided, one-eyed and had a clear agenda. The fact that very little of what he says has been backed up in other interviews leads em to doibt its authenticity.
GallagherWellerBrown 1 year ago
@GallagherWellerBrown
I dont think it was one sided. he was just defending himself. and who is supposed to back him up in interviews? he isnt in show business. he doesnt have thousands of groupies that will kiss his arse and say anything he tells them to say.
Alot of the stuff Mccarroll says in the book makes sense and he seems truthfull. He never really attacks anyone in the book he's basically just defended himself.
zzzzzzz114 1 year ago 7
@zzzzzzz114 The book seems believable and non-biased to me.
Jcahalane 9 months ago
Mani is a legend
Greendore 1 year ago
at the end of the day he's tony mccarrol, ex-drummer of oasis, and not a lot of people have been able to say that.....well said mani
tony mccarrol was boss on this album, that drumbeat at the beginning of live forever always gets me
airmedi27 1 year ago 13
@airmedi27 .......Tony McCarroll,.....Alan White......Zac Starky......Chris Sharrock......& Noel himself !!!!! How many Ex-Drummers in massive bands can YOU think of.....??????
mickwade1 8 months ago
@mickwade1 mate that comment of mine was a year old. yer a bit late on that reply. alan white was the best drummer for oasis
airmedi27 8 months ago
Poor Tony :(
filmmaker89 2 years ago 2