Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (3,729)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • its hard to appreciate how large the galaxy is when i am actually in it, i need an actual photo please. i want to see a real photo of the milky way and i know that sounds impossible it would take thousands of years at light speed but you guys are magicians i will pay you well to cast magic and i will in reward teach you how to levitate.

    good luck jack

  • where can i find the full video?

  • A very smart video explaining various Universes and not limiting Existence to one Big Bang. We are limited beings, but this video shows the human mind is not - and we are really close to understanding Everything. But there has to be simpler way to KNOW it, than complicating theories. Simple enough that the most uneducated person on an obscure part of this planet can have access to knowing this Everything. Lest, this creation will be meaningless. Everybody has the rights to knowing Everything.

  • As we speak right now black holes are sucking matter out of existence! Maybe on the other end big bangs are being created from black holes! That seems more logical than brain theories! That would answer the question what was before the big bang? Eventually black holes suck all matter out of the universe then recycle it on the other side as big bangs!

  • THIS IS HELL

  • as you your so ALONE

  • it cant be flat and why is that we livein a really weird place it could be to dildos instead of 6 pack of beer

  • i get the feeling the branes ripple

  • and what was before BIG BANG?

  • @bobanmunja wow... you aren't really going to ask that question, right? stupid!

  • No fact no true...

  • I don't think people get that this is still a theory and there isn't solid proof to say this definately happened.

  • @WilliamJsime

    There are no "still theories" in science. Theory is highest form of explanation in science.

  • @Hobu123

    Exactly, so people should stop acting as if its fact.

  • @WilliamJsime

    CMB (cosmic microwave background radiation) has been found in 1964 and has also been mapped out by WMAP (explorer 80)

    CMB is the oldest waves that date this proves quite a bit to the big bang already

    most of the big bang theories have already been proven

    and if you ask me a theory is a idea that is created proven then proven wrong slightly then changed to fit the new evidence :P

  • @WilliamJsime gravitational theory is "still a theory" why not try to prove it wrong, huh?

  • All these speculation of vibrating branes are there so that they (theoretical physicists) may accomodate the String Theory which is the so-called perfect candidate for the Theory of Everything. To me, no one will ever know what truly happened during the beginning and I think we should all stop making theories/stories from mere discretionary assumptions. This is just like creating a new version of a bible except that it contains more "facts" and "proofs" which I think is ridiculous.

  • This is a sloppy theory. Hawking has a much more realistic theory that perfection does not exist. So eternal blackness representing "0" is going to have fluctuations into +1 and -1. These pop into existence and cancel each other out on a quantum level as we speak. They do not cancel each other out perfectly. Our universe was a cancelling out of a larger scale +1 matter and -1 antimatter. that could not fully cancel itself out. Our stars and planets are the "smoke" from the big bang.

  • Where the hell is the 5 video series that was on youtube a year ago, over 1 hour long?????????

  • @006JoeS very true. It is goo to think about though right?

  • god big bang is sooo dummmmb... its sooo clear as day what it could be.. not thaat. thats weirdd.. its like we are in a toe nail of gaint thats soo big the space between his atoms are so vast it seems like theres noting.. hence dark matter... ;) :O *heart attack*

  • That's so fake. How could nothing become something. The big bang is bullshit

  • @jayvinandsavannah  or you are just chips frying moron.

  • So matter and space of this universe was created by a collision of two eternal branes? Alright, I think it's a valid theory if one assumes that branes are eternal. However, where did the laws of physics come from? Without an observer (any kind of life or consciousness) why would the universe come into being in the first place? Or more importantly /how/ could it without an observer? Something with consciousness collapsed the infinite potential and brought about this reality.

  • right brain, left brain, could god be the unexplained? i wonder......

  • I love the cosmos its so surreal. That one question. What was first? But then how?

  • @RosbifFrog the egg or the chicken.. which was first

  • I just can't get my head around this!

  • Somebody had to say when universes collide, that would then be holographic, because it never happens, they just couldn't write "Childhoods End" at all could they?

  • @ftlqed neverending story would be just sitting there too.. like omg .. we gotta start over..

  • Why the **** does it have to ripple? Please...someone?

  • @Amitknight123

    everything right down to sub-molecular particles is vibrating or wobbling

    so it's reasonable to assume that branes do to.

    Also if the branes were perfectly flat there wouldn't have been any matter in the universe only energy (I think), but there is loads of matter in the universe so the brains must have been wobbly.

  • I always ask myself this question why god create all these galaxies and stars and planets why he didn't just create the earth and the sun to focus on all the mankind why he had created saturn and Jupiter and mercury and other planets? if he concentrate on humanity he should create just the sun and the earth and if I was wrong of what I believe then I will say ok if humans give me my humans rights to live then god will give me my human rights more than any human or country about what I believe.

  • @opo736 *sigh*... You religious nuts will never understand existence. you just deceive yourself into believing in such nonsense due to the fact you are scared of death. You can't accept that when you die you simply shut down like a computer. You pretend you will go to heaven and live in eternal self-indulgence. So please keep your psychotic mind to yourself.

  • Then where did the parallel universi come from??

  • @mjc71189 Well obviously god must have created them lol

  • THE DEVIL CREATED EVIDANCE TO DECIVE GOD'S FOLLOWERS, GLORY TO THE TRUE GOD, SCIENCE EXPLAINS NOTHING, SCIENCE IS WORTHLESS, SCIENCE IS THE DEVIL'S HANDICRAFT, REPENT NOW OR FOREVER BE SLAVE TO SATAN.

  • @opo736 Can't tell if trolling or actually insane...

  • @opo736 Ohh how I'd love to rid the world of brainwashed fools like you.

    Sadly the law prevents me :P Afterall an idiot like you isn't worth going to jail for.

  • @opo736 just LMFAO

  • they talk about how there could be time before the big bang, but doesn't einstein's theory of relativity proof that "time" is just a concept of the imagination(that there actually there's no such thing as time)?

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I've been reading through all of the comments, and Im a little disgusted that this entire comment section has become about Atheists against those who believe in God. Why can't we get back to the point- Big Bang Theory and the ACTUAL video?

  • @Qutir111 Because religious people say that the big bang is proof of a god where infact it's not proof at all.If we can proove that there are countless universes beyond ours in hyperspace that will again deal a sour blow to those idiots and their books of delusions.

    They obviously fear this and fight against us and from this a never ending fight between logicall thinking and religous idiocy is born.

    The only reason why religion still exist is that it gives the promiss of immortality.

  • @Qutir111 It's like every scientific video on youtube. Theists feel insecure, and spam everything with their nonsense, this pisses off atheists who then feel compelled to reply, so starts the keyboard-war. You're better off if you just watch the videos and move along :)

  • @VoidDestriant and atheists love to go on and on about things they don't understand and call it science.

    of course atheists are known to support hitler kill the jews

  • @DStrike0083 "Thank god" I'm not american.

  • @DStrike0083 okai so because I do not believe in a god, I support murders of 6 million people? Damn you make no sense.

  • @DStrike0083 what about 9/11? the terrorists who bomb the twin towers were sunni islam which is a branch of Christianity, and btw, its the other way around, christians go on and on about things that they dont understand and explain it with "god created it" how is that even logical?

  • @DStrike0083 unsophisticated monkey

  • @VoidDestriant I could not have said it better myself. An extremely intelligent remark on your part. Thank you.

  • @Qutir111 Thank you! These people always argue as if they know the answer to the universe.

  • I see this in every single video about astronomy. Religious folks and Atheists/Agnostics clash into each other. I am Christian, and I hope that you are smart enough (doesn't matter if you are religious or not), in order to understand my point.

    How about we all look at the skies and gaze into the wonderful perfection there is out there, rendering all of our flame wars insignificant...

  • do you believe in infinity?

  • These "branes" are based on mathematics, which are based on assumptions, which may not have been rational in the first place. Nobody knows, but if anyone can explain it, they should be able to explain it in a way that everyone can understand.

  • before the big bang evry thing was flat thats all i herd im retarded =[

  • Ever blog I read through is the same thing "god vs sicene". Is it not possible that god created us and sicene defined us. I just don't see the point of you people arguing about a subject that you will never know the answer to and if u did you would never understand it.

  • @MrEman561 Science and God combined makes mores sense than either of them alone.

  • @KingGhidorah3000 That's a funny joke.

  • virtual particles can form from nothing. but since there was no universe before the big bang, there were no natural laws and so there was no attraction between them.

    a few particles collided and annihilated to form radiation (nuclear forces)

    shockwaves from the first blasts started rotation and thus electromagnetism.

    what i'm saying in short: the big bang was not big, it was a chain of tiny blasts adding energy to eachother.

    note: they annihilate because they form in pairs of opposite charge

  • @sim5191 (continue from last comment) virtual particles form in pairs of opposite charge. i know what your thinking, that if that were true everything would be gone now. but there's this state called perfect wich is impossible to reach. and so more matter than antimatter formed because of imperfections. the perfect universe is completely empty. why? because the virtual particles there formed evenly and so everything annihilated there.

  • @sim5191 (continue from last comment (again)) virtual particles are coming and going since the beginning of the universal timeline, and they are coming and going while you are reading this. the only place today that these particles can become real is near the event horizon of a black hole, one will fall in while the other escapes. (hawking radiation).

    gods are a concept that was thought of by the ancient greeks to explain the unexpainable.

    i hope this explained alot to the readers out there.

  • Why does everyone think traditional religious people are incapable of balancing accepting this scientific research and theory investigation as legitimate while simultaneously accepting the idea of God? I do fear there isn't enough comprehension of religious people's complex approaches to these things. Surely there are simplistic people, but their blind passion hardly speaks for a plethora of intelligent and intellectual religious people who study these sciences themselves.

  • @joshuare5768 Thank you... -_- I've tried to explain EXACTLY what you just said to my family for years...

  • @joshuare5768 Your use of 'plethora' and 'traditional' are biased towards the numbers of such people you imply exist.

  • Fuck the universe

  • @LazerJames lol. ull be kissing the universes ass when u die.

  • Fuck the Universe.

  • lol, universe.

  • I devote myself to only one's part to be concerned with the body of own positively. Devote oneself to central roots trunk origin and sense it bodily and acquire it by experience and know everything to the minor details end. I know it from hardware to software.

    自分の拘る部分だけには自身の肉体を使って積極的に身を入れて行­くんだ。中枢根幹本源に身を入れ体感体得し枝葉末節末端まで知り­尽くす。ハードからソフトまで知る。

  • So what ARE the branes and caused them?

    Don't say god -,-

  • @sparkymmilarky god's will ;)

  • you know how people use to build stone stuctures with there own hands and worship them?? <-- makes you feel how jee how stupid were they right??

    <-- well these dumb theories that are actually taken seriously must be a joke to then next generation to come.. soon you too will relize " wow, how stupid was i ehh"... good day sir.

  • before the big bang, there was chuck norris

  • b4 the big bang, G-Dragon took an arrow to the knee ijs

  • @MyrAge219 You are the death of the English language.

  • So is Bigfoot real or not? And what about the Mayan calender?

  • @dzsquared1 obviously the Mayan calender is a real thing, you fucking dumbass . The belief that it predicts the end of the world is fucking stupid .

  • @RIXONwhoROCKS Aspbergers much?

  • `so.... is our universe a combination of 2 parallel universes?

  • Is there more parralel universes colide like these every day?

  • @pearsc5d: And you are a nutty creationist. There is plenty of evidence for both the Big Bang as well as evolution. Go watch Dr Neil Tyson's videos.

  • @investmentbonker baahbhahahahahahahahahahahahah­a,and you are willingly stupid . 

  • @investmentbonker you make an assumption about my stance .assumption starts with the word ASS .

  • the big bang is a theory and unproven .it in itself is a religious view point under the name of science .

  • @pearsc5d

    Shouldn't you first at least make an effort to educate yourself about what "theory" means in science? Hint: it means something completely different than in every day language.

  • Comment removed

  • @Hobu123 more babel form the science guy

  • @pearsc5d

    So did you educate yourself about what "theory" means in science? What does it mean then?

  • @pearsc5d

    The big bang theory only attempts to explain how the universe expanded from an infinitely dense point. The big bang theory does not attempt to explain how or why the point originated. So, how exactly does the BBT relate to your religious nonsense?

  • @drche420 more babel .you are as religious as you think i am .

  • @pearsc5d

    Good response. Another declaration without reason.

  • @drche420 It's God's ass cheeks. 

  • @drche420 Think about this. When the universe was an infinitely small point, time did not exist. Therefore causation did not exist. All logic sprang from the big bang, before that, before time, everything that could happen did happen instantly, as there was no time, and from that came the universe as we know it. Without time there is no cause, and a billion years or a minute is meaningless. The universe had to be born, because it could.

  • @rich1051414

    Your entire comment has no point. What are you trying to say?

  • @drche420 Just food for thought for those stumped on the question of what was before the big bang.

  • @rich1051414

    So you're going around claiming that you know there was nothing before the big bang? You can't prove a negative, especially an unverifiable claim. Peddle your prophecy elsewhere.

  • @drche420 It's not a prophecy, its a theory, and no one has to believe it. Peddle your uncalled for hate elsewhere o.O

  • @rich1051414

    It most certainly is NOT a theory. A theory explains an observable phenomena (fact). Your "theory" attempts to explain what occurred (if anything) before the big bang, which is unverifiable. A theory must be verifiable. 

  • @pearsc5d the term "theory" is the highest status possible in science, it means set of mathematical rules and relations that explain what happens and correctly predict what will happen. the thing you have in mind is called "hypothesis" in science. and BBT IS proven. search for and learn something about background radiation.

  • @MidnightSt the day you can duplicate it in a lab with life coming from the ooze you may have a point .but until then it's all babel .

  • @pearsc5d same to you buddy, the day you can replicate The First Word in lab with God crawling from the test tube you may have a point. but until then, it's all mind-control bullshit ;)

  • @MidnightSt based on your response you are a religious man for you have chosen to BELIEVE the babel which you hear .whether it's from the Bible or the babel of man you still chose no matter how you want to label it .good luck in the future with your choice .

    PS.you so called higher educate people are so easy to get going .BAH hahahahah

  • @pearsc5d based on all your responses you are a complete moron and therefore relatively accurate example of most of the religious people, and therefore waste of time and living space. have a happy moronic life in society where literally everything around you is based and built on knowledge and science you ignore and "don't believe in".

  • @pearsc5d i feel bad about calling you waste of living space, that was unappropriate and over the top, you're just a moron and a waste of time. sorry about that.

  • @MidnightSt There is no need to apologize to morons. We should just let evolution take its course and let them become extinct ;-)

  • @pearsc5d

    Scientists are far more closer to creation of life in lab than your idiotic retarded pedopriest has lied to you. Be prepared for the totall collapse of your retarded Bronze Age worldview.

    Anyway, we don't even need to create everything in lab to see that it happens. We haven't created Sun in labs, yet we know that it exists and how it works.

  • @Hobu123 mankind has actually created DNA in a lab now! you can watch the full doc on youtube

  • @Hobu123 We have managed to start fusion in generators, but only for some nanoseconds to 1 second. We just need bigger generators.

  • @zeronesX1

    I think the longest one was 20 seconds, but it was few years ago so they probably have achieved more meanwhile.

  • @Hobu123 Technically we have with fusion reactors and particle accelerators. We utlimately have to be able to observe a thing before we can state whether our predictions bare out, this is also why prooving a god is impossible because it can not be measured.

  • modern science ,bah hahahahahahahaha .what a load of poppycock

  • Religion and science have to be hand in hand. Many things in science do exist, we have seen them. We have proof. But science itself wouldn't exist without something to cause it, a creator of sorts. Matter doesn't come from nothing. That is true. So how would all the matter we have today come from nothing? How is there effect without a cause? God defies the "laws of physics", and so does atheism. "Science without Religion is lame, and Religion without Science is blind."- Albert Einstien.

  • @125sonicboom you comment as if you didn't watch the video at all. existence of something doesn't imply creator, just a cause.

  • Fuck religon!"

  • "perfect, thank you!! God damn it

  • @CallumCotter 1. I posted the comment because I felt offended, and the person who wrote the "go read your bible" part claims to be an atheist. But, I never wrote "atheist=mean theist=nice", I wrote IF an atheist finds it blablabla, I was just contrasting the facts in the situation. 2. About the quote: I did not made it up, I just agree with it. I also found it very appropriate for the occasion, that's all.

  • I don't wanna be those religious fanboys but science is about facts and the fact is that before the Big Bang, there was nothing and only a living ultimate creator, and the power of this one ultimate creator is greater than anything else ever known or to be known!

    Then that ultimate creator will destroy all this that he created since the purpose of his creations has been served.

  • @DragonxxxFire Question is, what was/is that purpose?

  • @MrSandvich1 We already know one purpose of his. He wants to be known so he created us and wanted US to serve him.

    The truth is, we humans are narrow minded, we don't have the ability to know everything, but our creator gave us the ability to learn and believe. The complexity of everything he created is so great that it hurts your head trying to think about it ALL.

    Compare the smallest particle, a quark, even smaller to the biggest star in the universe! We are NOTHING compared.

  • a big bang never occured BECAUSE why is everything in perfect sync? solar systems and galaxies. wouldnt all these things be flying everywhere? theres nothing to hold them in place....

  • @nishblaze dark matter my friend

  • @theapic i see....well scientists are still not sure how the universe was created but have some pretty good theories. but some are really farfetched...like the big bang. something as small as a period on a piece of paper to blow up and create the universe.

  • Hello,

    I am not here to hate, and yes, I'm religious. I see a comment below the video saying some pretty mean words about religion. But what made me really annoyed is the "go read your bible" part. This sounds offensive, and if an atheist finds being mean normal, a religious person doesn't. I have just one thing to tell atheists right now:

    "Nobody talks so constantly about God as those who insist that there is no God."

    Heywood Broun (1888 - 1939)

  • how could this be a scientific video when it is not really scientifically proven. Because many of the science challenged the christian faith, we had to argue back to keep our faith and preach others who don't believe in God....

  • @TheWoshipper If you think science proves things you are sorely mistaken. Science merely explains the way things are. It does not try to prove anything.

  • @TheWoshipper Science simply tests theories in order to justify not prove them. And to be fair this video is not intended to try and disprove god. It is intended to provide a justified theory on how our universe came to be.

  • there are infinite numbers of universes and infinite number of stars, galaxies etc.

  • damn those glasses are big!

  • Why a brane? It seems as if they arbitrarily chose it as the instigator for the big bang. Is there any indication in nature that these branes exist beyond the realm of imagination? At the moment, it sounds quite ridiculous to me.

    I would appreciate it if someone would be kind enough to explain to me as to why these branes are so popular.

  • arguing on the internet is like running in the special olympics...

  • @ElDaumo How original.

  • they have their theory, all the religions have theirs, and i have mine and mine is that ponies created everything, it's just as good as the theories these jackasses come up with and all the 12 year old atheists on the internet.

  • @bmxtrickyman It's sad that most people at/under 12 are automatically considered immature/stupid.

  • ...where did the membranes come from?

  • There's still one thing I don't get.

    If the big band happens after the two membranes collide does that mean that space and time don't exist within those membranes before the explosion? Because in the video it seemed empty until they membranes collided.

    Or is the universe only a small part of the membrane; like a cell of an organ.

    PS. I know these sound like a stupid questions.

  • It's disappointing that 90 percent of scientific videos on here become a religious discussion. Can you take those arguments to religious or atheism videos and let us discuss the wonders of modern science.

  • @hockeybrotoe We listen to you.... only fair you hear us out also

  • @hockeybrotoe Unfortunately many people still refuse to accept the new knowledge that comes with the "wonders of modern science"...knowledge that displaces the ancient myths we've been satisfied with for millenia... so they feel the need to challenge it in videos such as this one

  • @hockeybrotoe

    You cant separate God from the subject--and you certainly cant ignore all these theories are by Atheists. Science has officially jumped the shark now that they finally accept the odds of even the atom's cohesion.

    They have no place to go but multiverses where there is just as much chance as a trillion suns spread out in the universes spelling out "This is the ludicrous world I created to avoid God"--because thats exactly where infinity brings you. Bias destroys their reason.

  • @hockeybrotoe Yeah well let's go ask religious people to be rational : P

  • @hockeybrotoe True true. Tell them to take it to AmazingAtheist videos or ShockOfGod's own.

  • Pure bunk - This video is BS

  • That doesnt answer anything where did the branes in the 11th dimension come from?

  • Comment removed

  • i'm too dumb to understand this

  • I think I've just been skullfucked

  • So...now the next question...what created those parallel universes? :D

  • @DjPulseK And then what created the ??? that created those parallel universes and then what created that ??? that created that ??? to create those parallel universes and so on man it's amazing to wonder what the hell we really are.

  • @jjmillr420 I know dude tell me about it lol...

  • @DjPulseK Whose to say they were created at all. Maybe essentially to me its looking more and more like existence started when something moved, and its been gaining mass and monument like a snowball ever since.

  • @BaboonJihad Now where did that something come from? Lol. This place, this universe we live in is just flat out infinite. The physical state has no start and it has no finish. We live in one big ass paradox, the guys in lab coats can't seem to accept that and the guys throwing religous doctrine use god to define it. In essence: we live here and we live here once. Make the most of it.

  • a lot of internet scientists here.

  • what is this theory called?

  • @chickletpudding its M theory , a collection of 5 string theories , Its theoretical physics , not a theory which is 100 % true , It does not have evidence to support it fully , but it explains things quite well , At present , the best explanation as to what took place before big bang

  • @djay00009 Thank you soo much

    gonna now do some MAJOR READING :D

  • The way in the past people try to comprehend their true existence with out of having a clue why they exists. The same way current scientists trying to explain something with out of any clue what they are talking about? The string theory close enough to the reality but not completely accurate!!

  • no one was there in the beginning of cration... so its pointless trying to find out it just leads more quistions and confusion...

  • i understand what markmusses is trying to say but this is a pointless argument beetween religen and science... science goes by the naked eye of things if its there it egsists if so then their its being hipercritical.. you know as well as i do no one was there at the begining of time not evan science so it reveals a mistery we will all no weather religen is right or if science is right in my eyes it a 50 50 situation..

  • Wait... So when talking about the brains (?) colliding and creating the "matter" that makes up our stars, etc, are they referring to the formation of quarks and gluons, and other sub atomic particles? If someone could please clear this up for me it'd be wonderful.

  • Wait, what? What is this talking about? I love to study astronomy in my free time and I know quite alot about it, but wtf is this O.O

  • its funny how everyone think that the big bang is a true fact.

    they are only guessing, there is no solid proof for the big bang at all.

  • @AeroFiles No one thinks the big bang is fact, it's simply a hypothesis.

  • @AeroFiles what about red shifted galaxies? How about the cosmic background radiation? The entire theory MAY not be true, but it is a fact that our universe is expanding, and at the beginning, everything had be be on top of each other.