Not great hook... Perhaps too much repetition. Try making your piece too abstract. And try not to use the infamous 1st, minor 6th, 4th, 5th chord progression :P people tend to be bored by it because its probably the most generic chord progression there is.
Other than that, i thought the melody of it was outstanding... but try to make it more complex. not the melody itself, it needs to be simple. but try using a wider range of styles to bring the melody out, instead of just using single notes
Its very predicable... maj... minor... maj(lower)... repeats over and over and voer again... nice asian pop style but people will get board. Although the melody is unique... its too random... no trade mark... Over all I'll give it a ok for effort.. but you'll get their
You are right about the predictability, but some of Mozart's most famous pieces are predictable. Beethoven is a different story, however both are fantastic composers. Also, for the record, there's a "t" in "predictable", it's "bored" not "board", and "there" not "their".
woah thats too pretty (:
spazosquirrel 1 year ago
Wonderful, I really loved it!
ScorpiusMusic 2 years ago
very beautiful song. my favourite composition ive seen on youtube for some time.
keep it up
millimusical 2 years ago
very talented ;D
Magicbeansx 2 years ago
Not great hook... Perhaps too much repetition. Try making your piece too abstract. And try not to use the infamous 1st, minor 6th, 4th, 5th chord progression :P people tend to be bored by it because its probably the most generic chord progression there is.
Other than that, i thought the melody of it was outstanding... but try to make it more complex. not the melody itself, it needs to be simple. but try using a wider range of styles to bring the melody out, instead of just using single notes
rattyboydave 2 years ago
lovely and gentle -- much appreciated!
RobCatterton 2 years ago
you have a beautiful tune, but you need to work on the "details" as I call it. You repeat quite a lot in the song.
but other than that, I really loved your song! It was one of the best I've heard in a while... :D
coolkitty154 2 years ago
ooh beautiful!!I want to have the notes:)
Faithinmeiseasy 3 years ago
You are amazing :) This piece sounds like it really came from your heart, keep up the wonderful work ^^
Resirance 3 years ago 2
a magnificant piece, you are soooo talented....your are my idol
GinasGotDrama 3 years ago
thanks...how flattering!
smcam3 3 years ago
@GinasGotDrama
4 chords and he`s your idol? you must be an idiot
frododoingo987 8 months ago
great song.
SphincterBoyJenkins 4 years ago
This is an amazing piece. Keep up the good work!
guyof07 4 years ago
c'est tres calme, j'adore!
tiportosdu76 4 years ago
simple & beautiful, great!
daniquevh 4 years ago
Beautiful! Simply beautiful.
JucHugi 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I dont think you wrote all of this, the main melody, I have heard before, copyright
coolcatnumber2 4 years ago
that is sooo beautiful, I know why you called it longing, you conveyed that word very well!!
ezflow505 4 years ago
The next Yanni. Great job!
gwithadream 4 years ago
a well thought out piece.
composer14 4 years ago
Its very predicable... maj... minor... maj(lower)... repeats over and over and voer again... nice asian pop style but people will get board. Although the melody is unique... its too random... no trade mark... Over all I'll give it a ok for effort.. but you'll get their
davidchentheman 4 years ago
You are right about the predictability, but some of Mozart's most famous pieces are predictable. Beethoven is a different story, however both are fantastic composers. Also, for the record, there's a "t" in "predictable", it's "bored" not "board", and "there" not "their".
guyof07 4 years ago 2
Make sheet music and sell it!
DamienTaubman 4 years ago
not bad. it's a good piece. keep it up!
junnuj34 4 years ago 2