Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (273)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • that was beyond!

    

  • cant stop watching that video and wondering why nicole didn't chose her

  • wow this wonderful

  • gaihaltai uneheer gaihaltai tengerleg, sonsood l baimaar... hasagdsan ni sonin yumdaa

  • Love, HER! very very great voice! mwah xoxoxoxo

  • wtf she turned it into a nigger gospel choir song

  • I want see you sing all this song... She have PERFCECT woise

  • naozaj je super, klobúk dole

  • Sadly shows like Idol and Xfactor remind us how the music industry filters great singers out because they don't have "The Look" to sell albums. Last time I checked I listen to music I don't look at it.

    Elaine you touched my heart with this one. At least twice a week I play this video.

  • mother of god!!!!!!!!!! and she let dexter through? nicole should be fired!!!!!!!!!!

  • @RankinMatt simon fired paula and nicole

  • Nicole looked at every singer who was better than her and decided not to put them on her team. If nicole is part of the voice next seasona s a judge i will not be watching. A hot piece of ass but a terrible little judge

  • no way its better than Oasis ...

  • the best version.. even better than Oasis...

  • ooh. she is FANTASTIC.

  • dokonalé!!!!

    

  • fantastic!! how did they leave this one behind?

  • shes good but not great. i think that without the music she would just sound like shes shouting. just my opinion

  • What a granny to have!

  • The original is the best... Oasis - Greatest band in the world. LIVE FOREVER

  • this was the winner right here! nicole picked dexter for television not for talent. what a mistake.

  • I bet Nicole regrets not keeping her... This was an amazing performance by an amazing singer! Love her version of this song!!!

  • She's so good.

  • <3 One Love to her beautifull voice

    

  • I love her voice it's so beautiful she deserves to win

  • I love this!

  • oh my god!!! why wasnt she selected.... what an amazing singer!!

  • best best

  • Better then Leona Lewis. It's very powerfull

  • OMGOSH! Her house is amazing!!!

  • This is incredible. Goosebumps AND it made me cry. So beautiful. She will go far in the music industry. It's such a shame that they eliminated her, she could have won the entire thing just with this performance.

  • Love it! <3

    

  • She is an amazing singer!!! Her version is better than the original version by Oasis and also by Leona Lewis

  • @dopomo umh lol no doubt she's amazing probably was the best contestant on xfactorUS but if you've really heard Leona's version especially live, without being biased hers is on another level. Leona's voice is full it doesn't crack, like towards the end Elaine couldn't control her voice which dropped her c6 attempt into a falsetto turning it into a mix voice whereas Leona slays in high and long notes with her killer head voice

  • Can someone hire her, if i just have money i will be her producer. I want to hear a full version of this song.

  • Better than dexter and stacey

  • i can make a remix on house music with her voice at the beggining awesome voice

  • La masssss que desatinada Nicole

  • shes just amazing, how could she be eliminated, shes the church singer simon is referring to isnt it not, stacy francis

    

  • She is really Amazing. Been listening as a motivation song to move on with life... I m sure she go far even without X factor!

  • the biggest epic fails ever on tv show when this golden voice lady got eliminated, fuk u nicole.

  • Nicole made the biggest mistake in this show by eliminating this woman. I don't know how she can sleep at night.

  • noclee you are stupidddd! she is so amazingg i cant believe youre not taking her to thee showss -.-

  • Fuck off nicole, she is so amazing!!!

    Although i m asian, i also know what does she sang and it's really touch and nice!!!

  • esta mujer tiene una voz grandiosa.. no puede creer que nicole dejara a dexter por Diooos ese hombre no canta nada.. eso fue solo un gesto.. no se puede comparar con elaine... :( muy mala eleccion! :(

  • I was surprised when I first heard Leona Lewis' version of this song. It is just a bore compared to this amazing performance. full of emotions! can't get enough of Elaine's voice.

  • Damn she can sing. She'll make. I pray that she does

  • OMG, I just have to write again, Nicole come one!!! Elaine sings like an angel!!

  • Nicole WTF!!!!!!

  • Absolutly love this song, Elaine Gibbs a moment to remember..

  • soooo special song but she deserved to be there.

    I wonder! that decision? she's a good artist.

    VIVA PANAMA

  • Should of made it too the live shows over Dexter.

  • this video 108466 visits .. Dexter 77800 .... The people choose the better... Elaine !!! Nicole U don't have the X factor to be the judge >:@

  • Fuckin' fat blackie! Noel Gallagher would die if he hear this! Epic meh!

  • wow es hermosa saludos desde Panama!

  • the better unofficial version of this song ever..! better like leona lewis version... her has great future..! very high and nice voice..! cheers

  • And to be honest guys, even though I love this, Nicole would have had to kick someone out in the first week anyway; choosing Dexter made it that much easier especially when you consider that Elaine and Stacy are too similar ... not very, but too similar - and the public seem to connect more with Stacy because of her story, wild range and she is a bit more current.

  • I really want her to record the whole song

  • she gives me boosebumps everytime i listen to her

  • me gusta mas esta version que la de Leona Lewis... que vaina firmee...!!!

  • @Khrolin la mejor es la de OASIS..

  • I want a Elaine Gibbs CD.... pleaseeee!!

  • As long as she keeps going I see a great future for her. Her voice is kinda like Patti Labelle and she's still putting butts in seats... Can't wait to buy her music!!! Sing it Elaine...

  • I GOT THE CHILLSSSSS! Feels like i just had a religious experience esp @1:16

  • She is definitely a superstar. Wish she could have made it through

  • Absolutely powerful, beautiful voice! Wow! I hope she'll be famous in some way even though Nicole didn't pick her. What a shame. She would have been a great asset to the show, and man I love this, the way she sings! Wow!

  • SHE GOT ELIMINATED???!!!! NO WAY!!!! Argentina is broadcasting the elimination tonight, so I'll see it then. NOW I DON'T WANNA! BUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

  • Los veo desde Argentina.... el mejor grupo fue el de mas de 30....increibles!!! obvio que importa lo comercial pero no deberían haberlos entusiasmados al menos

  • Better singer than Nicole... Fact!

  • nicole is an idiot! motherfucker! elaine gibbs i love u!!

  • leona lewis go sleep

  • love love love her she sing from the happiness

    I can't stop smile hope she be famous in some way

  • csodaszép dal, kiváló énekes

  • How could Nicole have picked Dexter over this amazing lady?? She could have won simply because she's great!. Such a voice! Dexter is an average singer, Elaine is an AMAZING singer. What a shitty decision you've made Nicole......

  • nicole its a bitch and will be a bitch untill she died i hate this girl since the pussycat dollls,,, bitch you desrve be morder!!!

  • @nextstar123able fuck off dude and grow up.

  • @cwestlee06 fuck of you...

  • Love this woman... I can't believe she didn't make it through!!! She deserves to be famous for sure.

  • dumb judges dont know how to chose listen to her 100 times beta than that dexter dude

  • I CANNOT BELEIVE SHE GOT ELIMINATED NICOLE IS AN IDIOT! SIMON SHOULD HAVE GOT THE OVER THIRTIES GROUP. DEXTER? WTF IS THAT ALL ABOUT!

  • @brendontreloar nicole SUCKS !!! MOST Of the judges chose the worst !!!!!!

  • @pelarena1 and enrigue? WTF was that blues clues doing there, random...i saw his facial expression when elaine was singing, hes like durrrr into space...

  • @brendontreloar

    I agree with, Nicole´s deciion was unacceptable This either better version of the song then Oasis (too british - too boring, but thumb up for their authorship)

  • @brendontreloar I Know Stacy Francis Is Ear Torcher Prepared To Her

  • the biggest mistake nicole have made, put dexter through and elaine out, shes crazy

  • Nicole is soo STUDID. Where's mariah carry when you need her. She would have made her go through and plus she's a better singer than nicole. She can't tell what talent is if it's looking her in the face literly !!!! Why put a dude that SUCKS than a woman that clearly is the entire package!

  • unfortunately Elaine, those dumb judges did not get it. I thinlk that the wind was blowing too hard past Nicole's and Enrique's ears and they just missed it. Elaine's voice will appeal to the many adults who are tired of listening to the crap recorded by teeny boppers and who are forced to distance themselves from the music industry and resort to listening to old tracks from yesteryear. Please bring her back Simon....Please, we beg you

  • Nicole is a fukn idiot!!!! wtf does she know about music to b a judge?!?! she fukn picked dextor over her!! hope someone slaps her dumb ass in the street for doin that!! dumb ass!! smh

  • Its an Oasis song...

  • amazing!

    

  • like her too!

  • I can not believe that Elaine wasn't put through.She is one of the best singers I've ever heard. So much soul so much passion so much life in every note she sang. X factor you made a huge mistake.I've never written to you before but felt I had to. I'd by her songs over here in the UK and so would my pals.

  • She should record this as a full song....

  • this woman made me realize that how great melody maker Noel Gallager is.

  • Nicole what are doing????? This woman is amazing! Better than Dexter Leroy! O my God!

  • It should've been Elaine instead of Dexter passing through to the live shows!! What a shame... I just think Dexters voice sounds "broken", if you know what I mean... It is "used"... Sad, but he's a great performer though - I just don't think that his voice is strong enough for all those live shows, but Elaines voice - OMG - a soulful and magical voice!

  • @Mplaehner dexter is a former crack head or something. look at him!

  • how it is possible that she didnt get through???? SHE WAS AMAZING!!! Shame on you Nicole,shame on you!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • amazing

  • christa collins and elaine gibbs were my favorites from this group.. i am disappointed :(

  • I'm SOOOO DISAPPOINTED Elaine didn't get through. She's amazing.

    Nicole, what were you thinking????

  • Unbelievable! I like Oasis, but I must consider, that this is much better than the original. I believe her every single word she sang. It has so strong emotional charge, than when i hear it I want to scream. Absolutely amazing performance of this song! Wow

  • ROBBED.

  • So let me get this right. Nichole lets in dexter someone who is not a great singer and someone who thinks he is little richard and passes on Elaine WTF ?? remember kids crack kills and smoking it while having to make important decisions really makes you look like a douche bag on live tv....

  • i'm sooo disappointed that she didnt get through :(

  • If Elaine dont win, thats it for X factor for me..

  • time to spam Nicole's twitter

  • how could nicole put a homeless bum through to the finals but not this lovely woman:O,it was crime not to put this very talented woman through:(

  • i mean ar you kidding me?she is way better then many others who made it..who the fuck said she is not ok for the finals???????

  • Its by Oasis you fucker. and she fucking nailed it. She will win justlook at her song choice!

  • I've got goosebumps from this performance, if this girl didn't get through, three words. WHAT THE FUCK.

  • och

    

  • I just love her , great song, great voice , great personality she should make it , she Was the best!

  • loved it too bad she didnt make it

  • Come on Simon, LA Reid.... give her a record contract. Nicole... judge the talent ! not the sob stories......

  • Elaine is clearly one of the better performer. Stage presence, voice, presentation. She has it. I guess Nicole just cant see how she can work with Gibbs...

    Clearly, Gibbs is amazing..

    If any of the other 3 judges were to be in charge of the over 30's, Gibbs would easily have gotten in.

  • she was robbed Nicole made a huge mistake. Dexter the former crack head got through, and not her -_-

  • i think she should gone though she was GREAT!!!

  • Elaine,, if you see this,, please know that you are AMAZING,, your voice is a powerhouse of emotion,,,, find a record deal,, let us know what you will do?,,, You have a global fan base now

    We will support you

    YOU GO GIRL !!

  • Amazing!

  • respect Elane!!!!!!!! You deserve place on a finals

  • nicole you are disgusting,,,, bitch

  • nicole you are bitch...disgusting

  • So wonderful

  • NICOLE........ BITCH,HW COULD BE SO BLIND,WHN U ARE SUPPOSED TO BE BLONDE??????

  • She's an amazing!

  • beautiful !!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • If Simon gets to pick a fifth person for his team, the other judges should also have that power. Elaine Gibbs for Nicole, The Anser for Paula, whoever for LA.

  • I preferred Elaine over Stacy ...Elaine had more control and her tone is really beautiful....

  • Its weird, the judges as "qualified" as they come in most cases chose potential over clear-cut talent. It's just like with LA Reid, he chose Phillip Lomax (Sinatra wannabe) who has potential, but when you sing Sinatra every performance, it gets dull. Then Paula chose the "Disney" kids group, they have lots of raw talent, but stronger than the Anser? Not at all. Then Nicole choosing Dexture over Elaine. Blows my mind. Potential can be so overated because it is rarely reached.

  • @Bucboy1001 I agree with you on some choices LA reed makes... I dont agree with LA. In the case of Lomax though , Lomax has awesome stage prescence , awesome voice and commands the stage. He's a star !

  • Nicole, what in God's name ever happened here???? You have to fix this. Is this another case of Pia Tuscano on the A.I show? Elaine Gibbs needs to be in your top four and you know it. Your four ought to re-read Stacy, Josh, Elaine and Dexter in that order. Fix it Nicole or lose the most beautiful island in the Caribbean.

    Ken Munroe Brown from sunny Trinidad and Tobago

  • I think i cried a little when she didnt make it! Shes amazing but no body sees it! This show is somewhat screwing people over! There putting more people that arent as good over the people who have real genuine talent.

  • 0:14 Elaine: I beg you to put me through because this is amazing to me

    0:16 Nicole: Shut up and sing!

  • Stargazer shut the fukk up

  • Dexter blows .. Elaine rawks

  • I would have picked her over Dexter. His judge's house performance was a mess.

  • Love this performance but they should show the whole performance

  • Here's a question. Why are there four groups? If there is only one winner then your competing against all acts. So should it not be that way all the way? I hate seeing someone like this get booted out when there are weaker acts in other catagories. Must say though I wouldn't want to have to choose the winner a lot of good acts in there this year.

    And for god sake stop bashing other artist who have made it through. They got off their butt and gave it a shot and should have the respect.

  • i dont know why she put that gross nasty ass weak ass sinigng stacy francis through over her! she should be through

  • Oasis! Live Forever!

  • WTF?!! this bitch dishonored this song... fuck you!!!!

  • fuck it, Liam should kill you

  • can't get why she was sent home :(

  • I can't , in good conscience watch that show anymore . This lady was probably the best singer in the whole bunch , and they send her home ??? ... ~ cannonsville69

  • @cannonsville96 WHAT? she was sent home? :(((

  • Comment removed

  • 2 people cried their heart out

  • Who will comfort ELAINE GIBBS ? It's God. Eric said "Am confident, she will make a superstar" but NICHOLE dropped her. I bet you Nichole, Elaine is one of your best shot to winning the $5M price, but you never notice. Don't worry ELAINE, if no one fight to call u back, surely,God will fight for you to show someday. Great song, great voice, great charismatic, and a great song.

  • @scholarobert I fully agree with you Nichole messed up big time 

  • @scholarobert Nicole, Nicole, Nicole and Nicole.

  • Best version of this song; Best contemporary singer of the group; HOW COULD THEY GO SO WRONG?

  • She freaking put Dexter through?????????????? I'd rather listen to fingernails on a chalk board than him sing.This woman's voice can take you places........ Dexter's takes me to the local dump bar on karaoke night.

  • Nicole looked so amazing at @0@.@2@7

  • She got screwedddddddddddddddddd.

  • Nicole should go back to hosting the show. She along with Simon made a great mistake. But then, Simon fixed his mistake.. Nicole, you can go jump off a bridge.

  • i just added this to one of my favorite.

  • I was so sad they didn't put her through. This was an amazing performance. I'd buy this version of this song NOW.

  • So would I ! I'd buy this version also! What an amazing voice!! Yah, sad too she didn't get put thru. Added this one to my favorites I'd pay to see her!

  • Injustice was done with this lady

  • Elaine Gibbs got dumped???!!! What a mistake!!!!

    Nicole Scherzinger made the wrong choice. She's on methadone.

  • I liked her INFINITELY more than Stacey Francis!! I find her so much more likable and that gospel-y tone to her voice is just powerful. She would have been a breath of fresh air -- she's a good old-fashioned belter.

    Stacy has nothing 'wow' about her. THIS is a 'wow' performance.

  • Haha Oasis!!!! I don't agree with crediting Leona Lewis with the song, she covered it, Noel Gallagher wrote it, get your facts straight.

  • i can't believe this great voice didn't make it to the final four. how insane. i hope someone hires her. i'd pay to see her

  • Comment removed

  • Beautiful. The description credits Leona Lewis?! It's written by Noel Gallagher, performed by the late, great, Oasis.

  • I hate that this kind of talent is being overlooked, mean how the fuck does this only have 33, 707 views? This woman is amazing, her voice is immense.

  • 1:16-1:47 i get goosebumps. cant stop pressing replay.

  • WOW.. I LOVE IT! perfect voice!