Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,339)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Best game, by far.

    Amazing soundtrack.

    This game COULD NOT be better!

  • My favorite red dead soundtrack

  • ICH LIEBE DIESES LIED!!!

    I LOVE THIS SONG!!!!

  • "You see in this world there's two kinds of people my friend, those with loaded guns, and those who dig, you dig."

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I just finished the game. The is game ok but the horse riding throughout the world is extremely boring... Other than that I liked the game.

  • @Ratmir1983 You were aware that aside from the use of train or wagon fast travel, travelling by horse is essential in a western - a time of the man, his gun and his horse?

  • Comment removed

  • @55DJL

    RDR was a spiritual sequel to Red Dead Revolver :|

  • @55DJL have you forgotten the max payne series? 

  • They should release a DLC where Marston hunts zombie terrorists from outer space!!!

  • I've never heard this song in the game!! WHERE can I find the ambient music that I constantly hear throughout the game???

  • I MISS YOU JOHN

  • 10 people havent been lucky enough to play RDR!

  • @Averross yes, bad for sequel, but thats exactly what i did when the game ended lol. I had nearly no bounties on me, but at the end when John died i was like "fuck it, killing spree!"

  • This game is a fucking masterpiece. Rockstar has yet to fail me yet.

  • Imagine a gang of outlaws, John Marston, Thomas Magruder, Hollister, and Bill Williamson. badass

  • EPIC

  • Comment removed

  • Games most wanted from 1-3.

    1. Red Dead Revolution - John in his outlaw days with Dutch.

    2. Red Dead Reborn - Red Dead Revolver all over agian but more realistic and with a RDRedemption feeling to it.

    3. Red Dead Reloaded - Jack in the last days of the dieng west and New Austin now becomeing modernized and Blackwater even bigger or play as Red Harlow after the events of RDRevolver, posebly meeting Landon Ricketts in the events.

  • @xCrazyKidz421x But Red Dead Revenge?

  • A sequel is out of the question. Any attempt to further the reputation of this flawless game would only blemish its originality and thus risk losing its throne as the greatest video game of all time.

  • AMEN to that!

  • @iLecter nobody said you can't make a prequel though

  • @RyanD051 it could be about John growing up in dutch's gang

  • @Aveross i.e uncharted 3

  • muito bom mesmo por favor continue postando!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Rockstar Games doesn't continue on a story with the same characters and setting. They never do continue the story of one character. They start a whole new story. The 3rd Red Dead will have nothing to do with Revolver or Redemption, it may contain little references to the past games but that's as close as they will get to relating the games. Don't plan on seeing Red Harlow or John Marston ever in the future of Red Dead games. It's time for a whole the character when the next Red Dead comes.

  • @Legion640 It'd be tricky making a sequel since Red Dead ended with the very end of the Wild West era. They would have to skip back in time, which means we would lose out on a lot of the cool technology in Redemption like the gatling gun.

  • @RyanD051 Id thought about it quite a bit. I was thinking follow ricketts as a kid in the civil war (rickets as a boy soldier in the CS army with Uncle. they get betrayed at the surender) Follow josey wales story and showdown tumbleweed. Have like a corupt governer/ union officer and have a massive battle and show the town get blown appart. perhaps make apearences such as red drags jack s to find a doctor and gets healed? Bufflao soldier fights the governer again ect.

  • whaT THE ONE that goes dum dada dum dudda dum dum caled

  • @xFPSRussia wut

  • @xFPSRussia if you are talking about the one with the trumpet that was in all of the ad's i know what you are talking about and i too have been trying to find it FOREVER

  • the music of Red Dead Revolver was much better

  • @TheShadowwolf76 that's because either you're deaf or just plain stupid

  • @guiquiguiqui I am surprised if its deaf and I am far from stupid, I just find that the music revolver are better now because it is more of western emblamatique

  • music epic !!

  • I love this game, it's just like playing a classic western movie

    <3 Bonnie MacFarline

  • RDR 2 should be the life of John when he was in the gang, and instead of being able to choose from bad or good, you have to be bad

  • @DunnJProductions that sounds like a great idea

  • I want to say that R* needs to have a sequel, but I also don't want them to run the series into the ground lol

  • @CrazyCat162 It would be great a sequel, but honestly, i'd prefer a prequel, in wich we play since jonh's childhood, at the orphanage, until he is left behind by his gang.I think it would be really awesome!! :D

  • red dead redemption 2 has been mentioned in game informer, it is confirmed that you will play as Jack Marston's son

  • @croioi You mean John Marstons's son, Jack Marston

  • @croioi that's just impossible, by the time you'd play as Jack Marston's son it wouldn't be the old west no more

  • 1. Red Dead Revolver

    2. Red Dead Redemption

    3. Red Dead Reborn

    LOL I got that off the top of my head :D

  • red dead revolver is also awesome

  • this is awesome and it should be a movie

  • Next game of Red Dead Redemption should be about John in his Outlaw days!!! IT NEEDS TO BE MADE!!!

  • Perhaps a prequel to the game is needed...Red Dead Redemption 2. People play as young John Marston in the gang he was once in?...but then again, you really wouldn't have much of a choice and decide your fate in the game xD;;

  • I can't stand GTA, but RDR is a masterpiece with highly inspired and dramatic music. Out of all the video games, it will be one of the few that sticks in my memory.

  • @Noremorse10 yeah GTA is stupid but this... :,)

  • @Lao, you DO realize this is a sequel to Red Dead Revolver right?

  • @Bcupzz No, only a spiritual sequel. None of the characters are the same.

  • Is it me but every single rockstar game has been fucking brilliant

  • taking place after ross´s death, jack meets someone, and jack teaches that person how to be a gunslinger. Jack becomes a legend while the boy its unknown, Jack and his gang train the kid to the words of John, but he seeks further. Now Him and Jack fight with other gangs to find out whose the one that shall be called The Legend of the West. RED DEAD ROAD or RED DEAD RIGHT. And at you can get Johns outfit, and Johns gun, It would be called the Marston Revovler =D.

  • @kakuseiloki7 At the end Jack would reveal his true thought about his father and give you the Marston Revolver inside John´s grave.

  • @kakuseiloki7 That wouldn't work out. It doesn't fit the theme of RDR at all.

  • a Prequal would be good though. not a sequal a prequal because we never played as John in his outlaw days. Just my opinion but that would kick ass, considering i hated playing as Jack

  • Perfect single-player. Capavating narrative stroyline. Wonderful characters throughout the whol world. Amazing soundtrack. Brilliant DLC. Fun multiplayer (when it works) Brilliant open-world gameplay. Another perfect game from R*

  • @lankinator24 I just wish it was longer, and west dickens would stop yelling for no reason.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • this is one of the best games i have ever played in my life not just best rockstar game

  • By the end of the game on the last mission you are in town with your son some guy threatens your son so you defend him. Turns out that the guy was the only survivor of the gang that killed you father. You are shot from behind and taken to your house. While you are ill you the gang attacks your house and it is up to your son to save his family (you play as the teenage kid). After you finish this mission you recuperate and are able to play as the main character, his son or wife. The end.

  • @thegreat1pr that sucks

  • @pillowsinmypants what? the end or the whole story?

  • @thegreat1pr good story, but what would the characters names be? also i had an idea to of a new Red Dead game

  • @thegreat1pr Thats a poor idea. ><

  • @olie266 Well... I had to throw what was on my mind... but in case anybody wonders my story is based somewhere in between the story of Wyatt Earp and William H. Bonnie (many of you know him as Billy the Kid)... I wanted to bring a story that was based on actual people... 

  • Later in the game you discover that justice is not so just and pretty soon a gang enters your town kill your younger brother. The law don't do much so you must take vengeance to your hands and therefore you are dispatch from your position as US Marshall. Beginning part 4 of the game. After you take revenge on your brother's killer and are dispatched from the law enforcement you decide to settle down, get married, buy a house and have a kid. Have a few missions as a farmer managing your farm.

  • One's you (and your brother) become U.S. Marshall you en the second part of the game and start the 3... As U.S. Marshall you'll both have mission in which outlaw most be brought down, towns, ranches and people most be save from gangs entering your town and meet the women you'll marry in the end of the game.

  • As they grow up the father's friend dies and they learn about who was they're real father... They set out to find they're father's killer they take him down. Then one's they find him and kill him and his gang. They are soon persecuted by the law until the U.S. government find out who was it that you killed. After they find out that you and your brother brought down the most notorious outlaw they give you the position of U.S. Marshall in a county.

  • Red Dead Retribution

    I think it should follow a new character back in the mid 1800. A teenage kid that loses his father, a reflection of Jack Marston; he is left with his younger brother. They are picked and taken care by the one friend of your father, he teaches you the way of the west and how to survive. That would be the first 1/4 of the game...

  • this is one of the greatest games ever made this is way better then any grand theft auto this game is epic u rly feel like an old western hero or villian

  • I've liked the idea of "Red Dead Revenge" from the start; playing as Jack. But I also think, for once, in a few popular games there should be female characters in the storyline.. Just sayin O.o

  • I'd rather see a prequel of John's life in the gang with Williamson, Escuella and Dutch, than sequel about Jack.

  • @cdubcoop To you also, thanks for showing support for my idea. I love Red Dead as well :) However, I really need some evidence that what you say is true. I would like to take your word for it, but I'd like to see some information for myself. I'm sure that quite a few of the people who are calling our friend collosus a "Bullshitter" would like some proof as well.

  • @Collosus165 THanks for liking my idea, but i googled Red Dead Revolution, and the only things i saw were comments and blogs about the mexican chapter from The storyline of Red Dead Redemption. Do you have a specific link I could follow to see the page you saw?

  • @MyFaceBurns hm... could you elaborate? dont just hat my idea without reasoning. I'm very open to suggestion on what could be changed. Details buddy, details :)

  • the title for the new game is Red Dead Revolution.

  • If ever another game, Gotta have that Title that rings. Red Dead Revolver sounded and is badass. Red Dead Redemption Sounds and is Seriously badass, Undead Nightmare Sounded and is Badass lol,. you get what i mean tho?? I want them to keep some kickass titles and another great story. but its debatable weather or not it will have familiar faces or and entirely new story and characters. which will be insane! but awesome. Which do you guys think it might be??

  • @Colossus165 Whatever, the difference in nationality is confusing the entire conversation. However, I do know that the next Red Dead has not been announced by any official sources.

  • @Colossus165 No, I've played the story literally over 20 times, I know everything that happens in the game, and the main story takes you into Mexico, into the revolution. You have to help with the revolution to win your information

  • @Colossus165 Also, that comment keeps popping up as unread and the more I see it, I just have to say.. the game has nothing to do with the mexican revolution? are you retarded?

  • @Colossus165 It just wouldn't be interesting to return to the mexican revolution. Also, you're still bullshitting

  • @Colossus165 They already did a RDR game based in the mexican revolution, it was called Red Dead Redemption. now quit bullshitting

  • Now this is what true music is! true epic music to such an epic game!

  • @Colossus165 when & where?

  • John Marston=Chuck Norris

  • @DanyWEE334 John Marston > Chuck Norris

  • Anyone know the instruments used that sounds like a guitar but kinda doesn't

  • Very Nice Sound

    i love this game :)

  • Much abliged

  • best 5 video game characters

    1) john marston

    2)altair ibn la ahad

    3)ezio auditore da firenze

    4) nathan drake

    5)zombie marston

  • @MrUkcarnage my top 5:

    John marston, John Marston, John Marston, John Marston, and John Marston.

    because he spits hot fire!

  • i love this game, the story is no nice! im dont like john marston die

  • Next game:

    Red Dead Retribution

    You play as Jack hunting down the one's who killed John, as people already mentioned.

  • @djphad sounds more like Red Dead Revenge

  • @djphad

    but you killed the old guy who killed your father at the end of RDR

  • I can't wait for Skyrim.

  • Red Dead Redemption is the second one of its kind; before it, there was Red Dead Revolver. C:

  • GTA 5 Announced

  • I am a chick, and I LOVE Red Dead Redemption.

    The game is so beautiful it never stops amazing me.

  • This game was great but I think GTA IV is still better. More replay value.

  • RDR 2 would easily be placed to the time when marston was running in that so called "marston's past"

  • Mi Nombre Es John Marston!

  • EPIC :D

  • Cousin!

    Want to go bowling?

  • @poyp777 NICO !!! fuck youuu! xD i hated roman when he called me go bowling in the middle of a fight against the Noose :D

  • they gotta make a sequel to this game

  • every time i play this game and carefully listen to the music, it always makes me want to go to the grand canyon....this game is the best.....lol....i even envy the people who might have this game and also live in the west

  • @jigs. I did sell it a few months ago but I got it back and im so glad I got it back

  • the worst thing about the game... friken John's son's mu stash.

  • @Michie1456 True

  • This was THE best Rockstar game i've ever played in my life

  • Next game "Red Dead Revenge" you will play as Jack and hunt down each and every one of the people in Johns firing squad. You will meet some of johns old friends, and make some new ones of your own. Of course, Herbert moon will return amnd so will the tyrannical governor Nate Johns. Thumbs up ladies and gentlemen, if you wish for this to become a true game!

  • @Laopaspdi Actually, I think Red Dead Retribution makes a better title.

  • @Howler452 yeah, it sounds better, but i think that revenge makes more sense. thats just my opinion.

  • @Laopaspdi then that will be the best game ever!

  • @HotDesertCooler haha you can say that again (:

  • @Laopaspdi he already had revenge

  • @CorreaLang against Edgar Ross, but not against Archer or anyone else in the shooting squad (90% of which were members of the bureau btw) and plus the "I Know You" guy was in the firing squad too. anyone else notice that?

  • @Laopaspdi Well, that sounds terrible.

  • @Laopaspdi it is actually titled Red Dead Revolution. No offense to your information though i really love red dead!

  • @Laopaspdi redemption and revenge meaqn the same thing

  • @ModderWarfare2 Redemption: means to redeem ones self as if make up for something

    Revenge: To give payback

  • @Laopaspdi i think it would be cool to start out in WWI cuz hes only like 17 right before the US joins the war

  • Comment removed

  • @mastergmoore He an outlaw due to the fact that he killed ross, so it wouldn't work

  • @Laopaspdi That's a terrible idea. A sequel that sulks around in it's predecessor is the worst kind of sequel because it just sits around feebly attempting to pay "respect" to the original and needs to die. Plus, it's just a stupid concept seeing as he already got his revenge on Ross and hunting down and killing a bunch of nameless soldiers is just idiotic and pointless. Thumbs down.

  • @Averross I agree, however if they had made John's death the very end of the game, then a sequel may be possible with Jack hunting down Ross and those responsible for his dad's death

  • @Averross What if it were about someone who looked up to John Marston and tries to search for him but finds out he died then searches for his son, Jack, for some reason I can't think of yet. Now that I think of it, it doesn't sound right...

  • @Laopaspdi Sounds good to me.

  • 5:18 does anyone know what chord that was on a guitar (if it was a guitar).

  • they should make red dead redemption 2 marston revenge!

  • Any one know if there's a sped up version of this song? It's fucking insane! Those trumpets!

  • if i ever rode a horse i will hear this music its awesome fits red dead redemption so well

  • RED DEAD FUCKING AWESOME

  • Next Red Dead:

    Red Dead Retribution, Good guess?

  • "LucasArt's Outlaws SOUNDTRACK", emphasis on the word SOUNDTRACK.

    It's like, fantardism is so blinding, that it really does affect your ability to read other people comments.

    Fantards...

  • @scarf0 All their work is dead "fantard" troll on someone else's sight obviously you don't have taste for music my opinion yet its not fair to these fans to listen to some kid bitch about this music.

  • So butthurt.

    Here kiddo, take some healing suppositories, you know those little things which look like bullets, you shove it up your ass, and you're gonna feel all good. ;)

  • @scarf0 Why are you suggesting that i should have things up my ass. You must be gay for suggesting it. Go suck you boyfriend's baguette faggot.

  • @Rolfchoppa007

    Cause you're obviously B.U.T.T.H.U.R.T. and I'm just trying to help!

    You know those anal fissures are not going to heal by themselves, you have to do something!

  • @scarf0 troll somewhere else kid

  • Best game I've ever played by far and probably one of the most successful games ever.

  • Lucas Arts is dead now they are desperately fighting to reign supream again.... George Lucas and Steven Spielberg are basically licensinging bad stories just to keep both star wars and indiana jones alive. Star wars is dead since that shitty animated tv show came up and indina jones died in the last film and god forbid them actually releasing the allegeded indina jones 5. PS2 days were their peak of glory with the battlefront games and their lego games

  • VOTE DOWN SCARF0 FOR BEING A GIANT FUCKING DOUCHEBAG PLEASE

  • BEST. GAME. EVER.

  • @scarf0 1 of ONLY 10, so obviously its a matter of opinion, being wise doesn't come from an opinion.

  • don't like the game that much. Epic setting, but pretty lame story. Beginning end end are awesome, but the entire mid part sucks...always the same =(

  • Ezio Auditore is the ancestor of John Marston. The 'Dead-Eye' is just another example of 'Eagle Vision'.

  • @StuffedGames Well said...

  • @StuffedGames point man is john marston's son

  • @StuffedGames fear 3

  • @StuffedGames well said

  • @StuffedGames Red Dead Redemption AKA "The adventures of Chuck Norris's great grandfather"

  • Just finished the game yesterday. This is truly a masterpiece. The story is very well driven and, for God's sake, the end is fucking epic. I'm not a 'sandbox' lover, I'm more of a FPS and RPG gamer. But playing this game made me forget about genres and gamestyles... the game itself and the quality speak for itself.

  • @Hanadi901068842359 Your plan's pretty see-through. There's a multitude of flaws in what you just said.

  • i knew this game was special, when it was 4 a.m and i was still hunting armadillos...

  • @CplDunneh I love those armadillos...

  • call me bonnie u fool!

  • Comment removed

  • this is one of the most well-made video games i've ever played, if not THE most well-made.

    props R*. now make us another dammit