Palestine's history - Alan Hart with Ilan Pappe (part 2)

[KingDavid14218]

What a sad joke..A misguided & willfully ignorant Jew has no more sway with Zionists than lost Christians or lost Muslims or lost Atheists.

Only the Truth matters.The WHOLE truth,the WHOLE story,ALL of the facts. This,and GOD'S WILL..HIS will be done,not ours.

This hateful book "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine" purposely confuses the real Palestinians,the Jews,w/ the Arab occupation..It is the Jews who are facing ethnic cleansing in their own land of Palestine,Judah,Israel.All the same.

[bayreuth79]

@KingDavid14218 What extraordinary arrogance! Who said that the Jews have an exclusive right to the land of Palestine?! Please don't quote the Torah to me! From the inception of the Zionist movement the intention was to completely dispossess the Palestinian Arabs of their historic homeland, driving them out into the surrounding Arab lands. That is not ethnic cleansing! Let us not forget that the Torah has this concept of herem: ethnic cleansing (think of Joshua).

[KingDavid14218]

@bayreuth79 "Who said that the Jews have an exclusive right to the land of Palestine?!"

God?..Who founded Palestine,especially the part of Palestine the Muslims are demanding possession of:Judea,Samaria & Jerusalem?

"...the Palestinian Arabs of their historic homeland..." Their [homeland] going back how far?.The so called "West Bank" is the heart of the Jewish [homeland] going back several THOUSAND years.

"...driving them out into the surrounding [Arab] lands..." Where they are from.

[bayreuth79]

@KingDavid14218 You should be grateful to the Palestinian Muslims who have historically been a refuge for the Jewish communites. Have you read any actual history?

[KingDavid14218]

WHAT IS THE ALTERNATIVE?

WHERE are the Jews supposed to go?..If the Jews were self-loathing and masochistic enough to surrender Israel to the Muslims,THEN WHAT?.Where do the Jews go,but into the sea.

& for how long would the Muslim world remain satisfied after vanquishing the Jews in Israel?..Do not Muslims want to convert the whole world?

"But the Arabs just want the West Bank"..The so called "West Bank" is Judea, Samaria AND JERUSALEM,the very heart and soul of the Jewish homeland.

[maxfedor1]

@KingDavid14218 the alternative is jews living in diaspora like they did for 1500 previous years. last time i checked jews are doing great in the uk,france,germany,austrailia,c­anada,usa,argentina,south africa.and jews that follow the religion that gave them their name dont have to surrender israel cause yahweh took it from them.zionism outs the state of israel above god, contrary to the fundamentals of judaic faith.judaism is the heart and souls of jews not land.read the torah

[KingDavid14218]

@maxfedor1 It is the imposter Palestinian Arabs who should leave & live in "diaspora"..Palestine as we know it,a desirable place 2 live,would not even exist if not 4 its founders,the Jews..It is their land,including the so called "West Bank".

The Jew hating world only wants this land bcuz the Jews HAVE it..It's all about hatred of Jews AND wherever they enjoy safe haven,it doesn't matter WHERE..Consider what happened in Europe..Satan & his legion want the Jews off of the entire planet,period.

[maxfedor1]

@KingDavid14218 many of the jews from ussr after it fell chose to go to france,uk, and canada. but israeli government put pressures on those countries to curb jewish immigration. the zionist basically forced them to come to israel against their own wishes. sounds pretty democratic to me. if you like i can give you links to show these facts. zionist dont care about jews unless they help fight the demographic problem in israel.rabbinical authority for most part against zionism, thats a fact

[KingDavid14218]

The Jews ARE the Palestinians.The real Palestinians are Jews.

The part of Palestine that the Jew hating world is bent on stealing was founded & developed by the Jews thousands of years b4 Muslims or the UN existed..The so called "West Bank" is Judea,Samaria and Jerusalem,& is the HEART and SOUL of the Jewish homeland.

It is the Arab squatters who are the "occupation"..The Jews only occupy land that belongs TO THEM..Jewish,Israeli and Palestinian history did not start in 1948.

[ram321z]

The facts about the ethnic cleansing of Palestine will haunt the Jews to the end of time.

[a72ou7a]

ilian pappe is the most respected historian in the middle east , so you better listen to him

[omarshereef]

all good people in history(some of them are prophets and saints !!) were speaking the truth and for the good for everybody and humanity for Mr Allan great job .and for some jews who hated him i say he is doing good for u he is showing that there is a lot of brave jews are for justice and peace!!

[Sparrow5708]

This guy is delusional, even Palestinians don't claim these ridiculous claims, not to mention another historian, jewish or not. Complete distorion of facts.

[beaujam90]

ilan pappe is a great man honest man!

The world would be a better place if there were more people like him.

[wownouser]

What the hell is he taling about? What are these ludicrous accusations? I though historians should back their statements with evidence. Where's his evidence? what are the factsd he relies on?! his own tormented imagination? rape? shooting ten of thousands palestinans in Jaffa and Haifa?! what are these nonesense?

[Dream23fb]

Read the book dumbass.

[antonvanl]

@wownouser the evidence is in the footnotes of his book. You should read it, he uses mostly sources of the different israeli armed forces, who admit all this internally.

[maxfedor1]

@antonvanl why would one read a book with footnotes? dam i dont want to learn anything. i want to continue living in ignorance just like politicians like it. iam too stupid to understand facts, the reasons are too complicated for my lil brain. i just goto work give half my money back to governments and i will trust them to look out for me, thats what democracy is all about. another great book with footnotes is written by Yakov Rabkin. zionism dissected by rabbinical authorities. great book

[gjylymsere]

God bless llan pape for speaking the trutH!!!!!

he does have evidence for his so called claims!!!

read his books!!!!!!

[solotunes]

No historical evidence? Did you even read his book, or do you just parrot what your Zionist elders say? Please take a look at the historical evidence before spewing your hatred!

[Dengatube]

Till now I don't know anyone who bashes Pappe and has read his book. They don't know the evidence.

[omriprice]

this is disgusting!!! Pappe has no historical evidence for what he offers and talks pure shit about zionism!!

Alan Hart is a pro-terrorism bastad - regardless of what you think of israel - Arafat killed children in cold blood - terrorist

[bounce132]

Fuck You omriprice ..... I wish to stuff my dick down your throat!