Added: 3 years ago
From: Elcrazyz1
Views: 11,135
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (54)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • great! of course Yundi had this impromptu recorded in a professional studio on a Steinway which explains the quality difference. Well played throughout, even a fluent. I thought it was great! the middle section was a little slow for me, some phrasing and a bigger change in dyamics would be nice (although this could be poor due to quality) but it's your interpretation. You handled this piece nicely. Keep at it! what's next?

  • He's not yun li , but he tried , good !! =]

  • The piano is out of tune, agreed, but the player is wonderful.....a bit too much sostenuto perhaps............

  • u guys watched a lots of Yudi Lee, I guess that is why o_O

  • your playing is soooo awesome!!!!! psst does he have any extra hands???? cos i dont see any....

  • posting this as a video response to yundi li's performance is surely a pretty gutsy thing to do. people will invariably compare your playing with his.

  • great playing bro.....one must learn to crawl before one walks...surely with practice in this level you will be able to play it faster and i understand why u play it slow now...great job again

  • I don't care about untuned piano, it actually gives a different mood to the piece so it's not always bad. You're playing it on the half speed, however I wish I could even play it in the 1/100 speed. Well done bro. Keep it up

  • Wonderful music

  • you play a little bit to slow some part but I understand its a very difficult piece and you are very good I can't play it because im a begginer thi is my second year in piano but you did a good job. awsome !!! ;)

    oh and sorry for my english !! :)

  • Great job :D I'm learning this at the moment, maybe one thing you could have added is some rubato to deliver the phrasing, however it is a hell of a piece! I'm 18 and struggling to complete with A Levels so I can't talk, I may post it up in a few months

  • I'm sorry man that they couldn't even tune the piano for you! You totally deserved better than that...

  • it just needs to be a little faster

  • I actually like the way he plays it. am i the only one that thinks this doesnt have to sound like a bat out of hell?

  • Wow people stop bashing on the tempo or his piano Tune, i doubt even 80% of you can play it even as good as him, post a vid of yourself first playing this before you start bashing about how bad he is, which he isnt because this song is EXTREMELY difficult to master, retards

  • You play it very technical, try to add some emotion into your playing. Remember, the the rhythm can always change, so change it to the mood of the song.

  • i think u should tune your crappy piano

  • your interpretation is vgood mate! technique u take with time, soul u born with it! ;)

  • Now I know how hard it is to play this master piece... God I should have watched this before I watched Yundi Li's version...

  • Your play is not so bad. But the Piano ist very untuned, this is the main problem!

  • @Klaviererlebnis The problem is not the piano but the camera. I recorded that with a very old camera... Sorry for the poor quality but thanks for you comment!

  • @Elcrazyz1 Or maybe the room.... from here, it seems the room accoustics is not that good. You should however try a better sound capture, try something else, not the camera mic, you mix the audio and the video afterwards.

    Nice performance!

  • @Klaviererlebnis No, the problem is really the untuned Piano :) Of cause the sound ist really bad to, but the main problem is the untuned piano. In the bass you can hear it very clear.

  • people r such haters . . .

  • don't listen to what everyone else is saying, that was a good try just keep practicing and I know you'll have another version out that's better ;)

  • GOOD TRY ;)

  • no matter what those jerks are saying, you did a great job! I leartn this piece and it is hard! can they all record themselves playng it and post it on youtube? hitting the right keys and memorizing the notes by heart ? I doubt that! i enjoyed listening to you.

  • if i'm going to be critical of this i have to say props for being able to play the piece but your dynamics are lacking big time. Più Affettuoso ma non troppo. Con brio! Con Spirito!!! The audio quality was very bad too. try putting the mic closer to the opening of the piano so you get more of a dry tone and not so much reverb. The room you were playing in was so wet i felt like i was swimming.

  • rozstrojony fortepian ; D

    ale. ładnie.

  • You link your vid as an video answer to yundi li??? Who the hell do you think you are? your performance is as mean as all the rest here in youtube except from yundis...

  • lol, however please forgive the performer, this piece is just extremely difficult

  • @uwoee888 for you, but he plays it quite good

  • worst record quality ever

  • Dude learn how to play it in its right tempo and dynamics..then post it on youtube.

  • at least he's trying... i bet half of yall cant play this song.. so shut up

  • @MsGamer09 hey i can!

  • @MsGamer09 I cant... but my sister's friend's mom's friend's husband's daughter can =]

  • @MsGamer09 music.

  • Is this the real tempo you're playing? Could you make it faster, like hurried? :-)

  • very nice

  • too much of the pedal but the notes are fine

  • You're supposed to use the pedal every measure...I think there's some italian wrod for it...

  • je préfère la partie centrale un peu plus rapide; joue la fin plus passionnée, avec plus de forte et le piano à la fin de chaque mesure. Good job!

  • Eh bhein...Pour jouer un truc aussi difficile... Tu dois etre vraiment fort... Continue!...(Frédérik)

  • VERY NICE!!!!

    Cariños

    Isis

  • do you have the sheet music?

  • Great pianis, mediocre piano

  • Tu geeeeeres, abusé vieux ^^ tain sa donne envie d'apprendre lool

    Continue guy =D

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more