RTHK功夫傳奇II之再戰江湖01： 形意本源 2012 1 14

[Firedogbeam]

Is there any english translation to this ? Americans love kung fu too .

[max534545]

三體式步 好熟悉... 好似降龍有悔 出招不能出全力

[eeeiki]

王映海老師型到爆!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[progressive9111]

很正!!



[k98hk]

可惡的中共政權，將中國傳統破壞得體無完膚!

[agutinoff]

但卻很點文人 比較特別!

[ForwardIntent]

wing chun best

[iambee]

很好! 以前我對中國功夫有好多誤解

呢個節目幫到我好多! 以後唔排除會揀其中一種中國功夫去學

中國功夫應該係實戰既先顯到出來 真係出手就唔攞命的

[lovein1874]

主持人都好感性，果然是一個老少鹹宜的節目！

[lovein1874]

猴形大師兄好快！

小弟覺得內勁一定要練得好好，若果唔是實戰可能未必掂。 但2+應該幾難，古人就可以成日都練武，現代人講求效率。 傳統武術可能真是要活化下，多D同現代融合。

[answer2479]

港台好野！很好的節目！ 香港正是缺乏這種節目！武術、歷史、文化包含在一個節目中，尤其­是男兒三藝這一集，展現了大漠風采，令人響住

[cwmak70]

it was humans who had turned it into a sport and that goes for some martial arts. Maybe some MA. I have to agree with you on some but not all kung fu are meant to be turned into a sport. Sanda perhaps can be picked to represent the Olympic.

[arilus8]

Thank you for sharing this wonderful and meaningful program. I really enjoy watching it.

[bigwoklun]

Would love to see this in English or with English subtitles.

[binjinhwang]

我覺得這個紀錄片強在於不只記錄國術, 更表現出其歷史和文化傳承的部分. 我很高興他們能在山西的古城合院之中拍攝且訓練, 就像每次我看到日本的古流武道紀錄片, 在他們的神社/武德殿中拍攝, 那種濃厚的文化韻味每次都讓我羨慕不已.

[KinkedouNow]

乜氏物氏，講到尾中國人就係太儒家私想，難聽d講真係幾自私

[hugo9323]

很欣賞jerry, 蛇形的大叔也非常的強, 越來越好看了^^

[henglonghao]

@PS3DLS

这只能说明你跟本不懂得内家拳

[PS3DLS]

宋老師雖然是傳統武人,但卻很有點文人風味,感覺比較特別!



[HalfStepBC]

Although not the focus of the episode the host's Wing Chun was played well in this episode. Great show!

[henglonghao]

打实不打虚，是拳经里的话。

出自心意道



[henglonghao]

这个视频可是正宗心意和形意对外家拳的实战视频，人家香港人真的­态度谦卑，明明占了上风，却还是谦虚地学习。

问题出在哪里呢？这是关键的要点，大家切切听明白了。视频中的内­家拳手的打法根本违背了内家拳的宗旨，内家拳是什么？内功拳法啊­。何谓内功，就是很厉害的惊人的功，好比重磅炮弹，外家拳是机关­枪。结果呢，内家拳手不用重磅炮弹，却用机关枪，这不是以短击长­么。

什么叫偷鸡摸狗，上面拼命地摸，下面努力地偷，结果两家好亲热，­上面乱摸，然后再突然下偷撩阴。

还有那种所谓的放松拳法，就好比拿了鸡毛掸帚去打仗，根本是错误­的拳法，却当成真理。

那么正确的内家拳该是怎样的打法呢？ 一句话“打实不打虚”， 对方的拳头是实的，不要试图去绕过那个拳头，尽量朝对方最厉害的­地方杀过去。他的拳厉害，你就去炸他的拳。

大侠与老美拳击手比武，一个虎扑就把双手扑在对方的双拳之上，一­旦粘上了，而对方居然能够挺住不倒，那么立即短肘膝打连续攻击，­一个回合三到五秒钟解决问题。

内家拳是用内功去炸毁他的机枪，而非机枪互射。如果要摸，就要摸­个彻底，一摸倒底，决不象火中取栗那样的摸法。两者缠上了，那就­丹田爆炸，打人如亲嘴。

[PS3DLS]

@henglonghao 切搓而已,何來上下風之分?

而且幾位老師都近中年,拳怕少壯,香港主持在速度與反應上明顯好­一點,

但若來真,未必有任何優勢!

[cyli8833]

@henglonghao

師兄玩什麼拳?

[cellarjudge]

@henglonghao 確實：力不敵技　技不敵功　功力才是至頂的關鍵～砲彈出　黏手沾　身腳隨　貼身肘靠　吋接吋拿～　暗勁透發　爆炸墜裂

大體上這個是玩技　非玩功　玩技是拳怕少壯　年紀大就輸了

但是尋師訪友貴在和　同門較技留力不留技　怎麼玩都是少年人贏

要體現功力　除非生死相搏.....那是不可能的

[Emilechen]

@cellarjudge 網上總是看到一大堆人一大套理論，現實卻連木條也打不斷，真正練­武之人才有發言權，如果是外行，講再多也沒用.

[Emilechen]

@henglonghao 又是这种网上的空论，当然你们有你的自由，但你们与其长篇大论，­不如发几个视频，做几套有难度的动作给大家示范示范，证明你们不­是外行，否则，有甚么说服力/

你说人家香港人是谦虚，人家可不是傻子，而是散打代表，不是吃饱­撑了到山西旅游，算了，我还是好好看看节目，难得听评论里的废话­，我从来没有在论坛里学过甚么有用东西，因为那里‘天才’太多.­

[cellarjudge]

可惜沒有辦法看到形意拳在身體貼身撞擊（靠）上面的表現～

[PS3DLS]

打打下變左詠春vs 形意,

但係好勁!

[TheDirectorWong]

I watch this video and realize tradition way of chinese life is so beautiful. Why do the modern generation have to change?

[cellarjudge]

翡翠台播出的這個功夫傳奇都幾好！！可以把傳統武術分享給許多華­人看～真的是非常好的！傳統武術確實有不凡魅力！！

[Emilechen]

@cellarjudge 是啊，一流的节目，让以为中国武术是花架子的人闭嘴，哪些人在网­上是天下无敌，精通世上一切武术，在现实跑两公里就虚脱，

找机会传到国内视频网站给大家分享分享!

[devtang666]

痴線...個肥佬每次臨中招都退一退...卸晒d力...==

[mykatharsis]

Very nice. English subtitles would be awesome.

[raymond1689394]

拳怕少壯！

練拳不練功，到老一場空

氣力氣力 .... 有氣先有力！

[sese8888]

好正呀!快D下星期啦

[gandolflink]

real quan is not a game, but these exchanges are. This is a poor representation of xing yi.

[eastpaw]

@gandolflink Can't really blame the XY people. XY really sucks at point-fighting. When you have to restrain yourself instead of charge through the opponent, you leave yourself a sitting duck. Which of course may be your point exactly.

[cwmak70]

@hkshit1 Judo and TKD are both Olympic official martial competition game because It's a Game. Chinese Kung Fu is not a game.

[arilus8]

@cwmak70 I disgree. Neither of them is a game. They are sports (and so is Kung Fu). Kung Fu is a general term for Chinese martial art. There are many different forms of Kung Fu. My guess is that it is hard to pick one to respresent it in the Olympic.

[gandolflink]

the core of quan is not in the mixing of technique. true path to quan is not in a style. the condition is the process from which expression flows. 10,000 martial artists do not know this. asking them all cannot substitute for real understanding. look to your natural actions in real life. real quan is natural quan, not what you think it is. feeling may mislead, many things seem real. take nothing for granted. how does one arm raise?

[sundayli]

太精彩了！第二集呢？

[blynmusic]

love this ..we need to get English subtitles for this video keep up the good work

[standard101]

谢谢你！



[gokillerbee]

最後個肥佬講到點勁點勁,一埋牙就食屎,我諗一個練過兩年box­ing或者泰拳嘅人應該可以輕鬆收佢皮

[soloissac]

@gokillerbee 咁又未必ge, 其實我覺得雙方都一定有所留手, 始終係切磋, 唔通真係拳拳打落去咩, ,我硬係見佢地都係用手掌拍一拍佢咁就算一拳, 睇到我好冇引 ==" 不過可能切磋就係咁, 接觸到對方身體就算該招勝利, 又冇任何既護具防身, 如果真係一拳拳打落去....我覺得可能會搞出人命的, 特別係形意拳 =="

[cellarjudge]

@soloissac 形意跟八極都有雙拆趟子 因為不能真正實戰對接(練到小有成的形八雙拳 整勁炸裂 貼身肘靠 都是 整體合勁～ 非死即傷)

小弟出拳也不習慣局部 也是習慣身動腰足隨 三盤自可齊的地步～所以這種拳不好跟人切磋～都是玩靠撞肘點　跟拳擊 空手道的打法差距甚大

[cellarjudge]

@gokillerbee 老兄您沒有注意到人家老師父埋身馬型就要出去了嗎?跟形意拳玩貼­身埋身都是危險的～這老師父是有收手的～在埋身那個地方 只要命門放虎形或是馬形 直接可以卸肋骨的～這是”切磋”　不是”生死相搏”吧～　何必出狠招

對練的最要緊的不是分勝負　而是雙方都有練到功夫

[ALEXWONGGOR]

@gokillerbee 下下都搵哩D比,你仲識咩==

[tonychan2288]

打得几好

[bullomega]

@hkshit1 日本同韓國都唔係得柔道同跆拳, 並唔係所有派別都被選出做奧運項目