Brooklyn is a revelation as Oscar, had never heard of her. Her voice/presence is BRILLIANT; her Italian pronunciation could improve a lot, but her singing is above everything else here. My opinion. And who says you will always be discredited if you don't speak very well YET? (Delicate22 and micioamilano....)
What I liked about this production was that it was set in Colonial America. Thus the 1770's costumes. The last ensemble in this clip has remained in my mind for twenty years (has it been THAT long?) because of Pav's voice, Levine's tempi, and the 'joie de vivre' exhibited here and elsewhere in the video. The anacronism of having an 'African-American' in the role as a director's 'statement' I cannot comment on, but if it was a conscious theatrical choice, at least she can sing it well!
I'd have to say that the only one I prefer over this is Reri Grist, but other than that this is fantastic. She's adorable! I think that's one of requirements of Oscar. You have to be a little boy who is just so excited over all of this. She pulls this off brilliantly.
grande cast...........
luwaig1 1 week ago
Grande Pavarotti....
luwaig1 1 week ago
Comment removed
MrBaddel77 6 months ago
J'adore.... Que des géants ! Quel coup de cœur pour Oscar !! Une présence incroyable et une voix sublime !!!
isisnefret 1 year ago
Demain <3
MrSilkyBear 1 year ago
Brooklyn is a revelation as Oscar, had never heard of her. Her voice/presence is BRILLIANT; her Italian pronunciation could improve a lot, but her singing is above everything else here. My opinion. And who says you will always be discredited if you don't speak very well YET? (Delicate22 and micioamilano....)
papagena92 1 year ago
Comment removed
papagena92 1 year ago
Harolyn Blackwell is an amazing soprano!
belissimavoce 1 year ago
I AM ADDICTED to these 4:41 long video ...THEYA RE FANTASTIC!
ESPECIALLY HAROLLY BROOKLYN! :D:D:D
GREAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT
kriklun 1 year ago 9
Perfection!!!!!!
zoekaragouni 1 year ago
What I liked about this production was that it was set in Colonial America. Thus the 1770's costumes. The last ensemble in this clip has remained in my mind for twenty years (has it been THAT long?) because of Pav's voice, Levine's tempi, and the 'joie de vivre' exhibited here and elsewhere in the video. The anacronism of having an 'African-American' in the role as a director's 'statement' I cannot comment on, but if it was a conscious theatrical choice, at least she can sing it well!
jsmoir1 2 years ago
@jsmoir1 I believe this production was set in Sweden like Verdi had originally intended.
cmoesing 1 year ago
Increíble !! soy gran admiradora de Pavarotti... y el rol de oscar me encantó.
Plopsete 2 years ago
I'd have to say that the only one I prefer over this is Reri Grist, but other than that this is fantastic. She's adorable! I think that's one of requirements of Oscar. You have to be a little boy who is just so excited over all of this. She pulls this off brilliantly.
Iareto 2 years ago
La dizione, la dizione....puoi avere la voce più bella che vuoi ma con quella dizioni verrai sempre screditata...è pessima!
Delicate22 2 years ago
The two best versions of this I have ever heard
was with Gigli Circa 1935 and this one with
Pavarotti. Harolyn just rocks in the role of Oscar
plus Sumi Jo tends to go too slow in the role of
Oscar, This version shows the Spontaneity that
it deserves, it just bounces along and shows pop to the piece Bravo Harolyn and Luciano!!!
MAR3668 2 years ago
@MAR3668 mmmh I like Sumi Jo very much as well!
papagena92 1 year ago
Comment removed
MAR3668 2 years ago
Comment removed
MAR3668 2 years ago
Harolyn is the best Oscar I've heard! An absolute delight.
singinciaran 2 years ago 5
What a wonderful Oscar !!
marioegorga 2 years ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I find Sumi Jo is much better
larissamontero 2 years ago
@larissamontero why did someone boo your comment? I like Sumi Jo as well, both are very funny "little boys".
papagena92 1 year ago
BY FAR THE BEST RENDITION OF THIS ARIA IN EXISTENCE.
BEST OSCAR EVER!!
Viva la Harolyn!
LaMostraESopra 2 years ago 2
I'd say Battles' rendition is FAR MUCH BETTER!
micioamilano 2 years ago
of course, typical comparison of black singers, just because they're black =/
bcom11 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
31122051 2 years ago
you are beautiful luciano. i love you so much.
loveluciano1 3 years ago 2
He is GREAT!!! I love you Luciano!
dee1153 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
RebeccaDuren 3 years ago 3
Dizione più che pessima direi! Concordo però che la voce è molto bella!
micioamilano 2 years ago
This is great. Thanks for posting it.
jenni4claire 3 years ago