Christina Aguilera - 17- Hurt - Live Back To Basics DVD HD

[Progamelanet]

oo shut up and listen ppl

[archmage2k6]

this is diffently not playback

or lip syncing ,shes diffently singing it live

[ana34972]

she is amazing singer

[bertuchi19]

not live

[scoobii124]

i'm an extreme christina fan, but she is clearly lip syncing. nothing wrong with that at all. you can just tell by the whole vibe she has on stage.

[MsTreysongz1]

omg she is lipsycing i watch her other versions and while she singing live and u can tell the difference ad plus her facial expressions and they way she is not exaggerating on the singing .. but it 's a hard song to sing but i have seen her sing it live and she has done it well.. maybe she was tired

[shaniali]

I don't think it's live, I think she's lypsynching to another recorded version, the sound and her lips don't match, I don't blame her, it's an incredibly hard song to sing

[temposify]

For all of you that say she is lip syncing this, I played this video with the original song from the cd and there are many differences and additions that are not on the studio version.

Those differences are at: 1:20, 2:40, 2:57, 3:09, 3:26, 3:33, 3:40, 3:45 and many more. Also she missed two notes at 1:57 and 3:03. And overall, her voice sounds a bit different in the video.

You can do the same thing I did and see by yourself. So, shut up, and listen to this beautiful, powerful voice.

[MsTreysongz1]

@temposify she has sing it live before and has done it well not lip singing but i am surprised that she is lipsycing

[temposify]

@MsTreysongz1 My point is that she is NOT lip syncing.

[briobrandon911]

@MsTreysongz1 shes not lipping the song. the video is a second late, and this is a DVD release, it should be assumed that they dubbed some parts in, and edited the scenes. every singer does that, Mariah, Beyonce. To put more vibe into the concert DVD version.

you know it is edited when you can only hear certain "crowd" howls. if you watch raw or amateur videos of xtina's concerts, you will hear the difference and her live singing.

[hsg2012]

@temposify well sometimes singers record a different version for the live performance...i'm not saying she did but performers do that all the time so that it seems like they're not lip syncing... :)

[temposify]

@hsg2012 Some "singers" maybe. A true one like her - never! :D

[hsg2012]

@temposify actually i believe that she did because her mic technique is completely off and you can tell she's not singing by her throat...i'm just saying i believe she is lip syncing here...she did a long show that night so she had to rest her voice somehow

[temposify]

@hsg2012 I still do not believe she lip synced it, but I don't mind you do. Different people, different opinions. :)

[KxPatz]

This is absolutely live, without a doubt. & No bitch, I'm not blind.

[pernichanche]

it could be lip synced, because at 2:30 she's singing really quite and at 2:33 she starts singing much louder but she doesn't take the mic away from her, as she does when it's live... but i could be wrong :)

[dequeenqueen]

undoubtedly true...she is the best singer in the world!!

[royalty099]

is she left-handed

[GayAsnBoy]

Everyone thinks she lipsyncs because they can't sing like her.

And this is a super hard song to sing even without all the power lol.

[Fearlesss4Life]

pure perfection

[martijn4life1]

She is one of the best. That voice is so amazing

[kirstybbe123]

i love christina but this is mimed its way to clean and you can justtell unless you'r blind

[christinaaguilera3]

its even better live then on the cd cause the strengh of her voice comes out ;D love her sooo much <3

[mannypulido94]

I have no idea how anyone could question if that was live. First off, it's CHRISTINA AGUILERA, she has had amazing live performances her entire career, with a few off days. This is not surprising. Not to mention she alters small portions of the songs every time she sings them live, which is obvious in this performance. She's incredible and this is just one more reason to love her.

[JARERE1]

100% sang, how hard would it be to mime that, amazing one of the best singers in the world

[guisousacunha1]

love that intro.

[anatolevich1]

она лучшая,идол!!!!

[deukid67]

great singing is ridiculously under appreciated now a days

[90Christin]

.... yeah. this is pre recorded. just like 'enter the circus' and slow down baby.

[Fabiuguz]

@90Christin this is a semi lip sync... not all song is pre-recorded

[90Christin]

@Fabiuguz maybe you're right. i think at the end it's her singing live

[Fabiuguz]

@90Christin unfortunately yes :( i want to hear singing the entire song

[ashybline]

@Fabiuguz people like you annoy me. Just accept the fact she is one of the worlds best singers and don't need playback or lip syncing unlike britney nutcase spears. It is clear she singing live.

[Fabiuguz]

@ashybline same 4 me... you annoy me, if you are blind and cant see the truth its not my fault... and don't read what i write ,thanks ;)

[ashybline]

@Fabiuguz you're the one who's blind. Everyone can see it's live, listen to the CD then listen to this. She doesn't clear some of the high notes in this performance that are on the CD and you can hear her breath when she moves the mic away.

[Fabiuguz]

@ashybline did you ever head about pre-recording? -.-

[ashybline]

@Fabiuguz but it's not pre-recorded it's live. Why would she only sing half the song live. Don't think her fans would think much of her doing that

[Fabiuguz]

@ashybline maybe you don't know something about voice... voice is fragile, is she sings when is sick, she can damage the vocal chords... and plus she was pregnant...

[ashybline]

@Fabiuguz she's a strong woman, she wasn't sick. Did you see her 'Fighter' performance, pregnancy didn't seem to affect her then, and i suppose you're gonna say that was pre-recorded aswell. Just accept it, whatever condition she is in, she sings live and brilliantly at that.

[Fabiuguz]

@ashybline and so what? Fighter was not pre-recorded... but so what? i'm a xtina fan but i admit when she lipsync, im not blind like you

[ashybline]

@Fabiuguz well, you must be, end of discussion, watch her interview about the tour, she will even tell you she sang 100% live.

[XxFantasyCamyxX]

@Fabiuguz It's surely live, because she says "There's nothing i wouldn't do to hear your voice again" in the 1st and in the 2nd verse. If she had not sung live she would have said "To have just one more chance"..She was wrong in the lyrics..But she's so fantastic!!!!!!

[chewerboy]

the bridge part of this song is different from the studio track so its 100% LIVE!!!

[waldemarspetany]

unbelievable !!! 

[XtinaAGLRFan]

Oh my God...i love her so much...it`s perfomence very amazing))))

[Jakkzxx]

i think she lip synced some of this song. not because i think shes incapable of singing it but because if u watch a performance she did of it in germany every note & breath she takes is exactly the same so i think the beginning is a recording of that performance she did but i do think she sang the end live. that is clear :-) & she is amazing !!

[DOCDNB]

Gives me goosebumps . shes amazing

[xoktqt]

You can hear her breath bounce of the microphone, especially when she says when it comes to this.

She's not lipsyncing. She just can sing live, unlike other people.

[Dance18sC]

why does ever1 think she lips?

She's 1 of those singers who doesn't lip,,

no a days everbody lips but christina... you can hear clearly that it's live :S

[bibeca23]

Parece playback, pero no es. Aqui se demuestra lo buena artista que es, suena igual que en el disco

[TheBleuDolphin]

omg.. She took tht moon and put it in her baby's room.... it looks exactly the same.. lol

[valnsav]

its not lip singed at all. listen tew the beginning carefully its her singing

[fffeeemmm]

its not playback!!! listen to the studio version carefully, you will know why...christina has an amazing voice and is always amazing when shes live thats why you can be mistaken when she doesnt add her 'extra' notes to a song, which makes some of you think playback when its not!!

[Adiaf8oros]

It is not a playback, I haven't seen an artist performing playback in his/her concert... But that's not the reason. If it was a playback wouldn't they correct 2:13 where she isn't heard? And would she fix that thing in her ear to hear heself better? Also at 3:43 when she takes away the microphone, we can hear she does... Anyway, i love that her voise is so perfect that we argue about this video being live... She rules, totally, and the song does, too...

[DOCDNB]

AMAZING X

[sproggos]

you can tell it isn't playback fools

even the first part..

the first part there is a subtle difference... listen to the way she sings 'mistake' at 1:33 and then listen to the way she sings it on the album it's different.

and the second part her falsetto sounds evidently different to the album..

so stop making false claims

[JakeHeartBeat]

the beginning looks as if she is lip syncing but towards the ends we can see she isn't

[drzshory]

wow..that's a dumb assumption..it's incredible that you can't give christina aguilera the benefit of the doubt before you judge her singing..seriously like she isn't gonna sing at her own concert

[xtinaroma]

maybe the first part it's lipsynched...

[sixleen]

Christina is the best...this is a great performance!

[franku56]

non è in playback RapstilesHeadshot don't understand music oh...

[Bounzey]

its live you punkass bitches

[RapstilesHeadshot]

WTF??

This is a Playback song

Boring

[2fast4ju]

nix live!

I love christina, aber nur live.

Playback is nix for so a great singer!

Das Lied ist trotzdem aber ihr allerbestes!

[Larengasiempre]

es hermosa y me pone

LA PIEL DE GALLINA

[mafaldasmile]

BRAVO

[ciprianpetcu86]

she's the best!!

[lunia123]

Wow her live performance is just amazing. Too amazing to the point so many thought she lipped this haha.

[MrTenisMaster]

you have to listen studio version a lot.....to see the difference :DD

so good

[samsy37]

sooo good

my god at her voice

so impressive

i love this song sfm

[Powft33]

Of course she is not lip synchs !!

[TheDarkViolin]

it seems like she's lip synchs but SHE'S NOT...above all at the end of the song you can notice that she's singing live...this performance is perfect!!!

[nontrovo1cippadinick]

no doubt that she's singing live... i'm not her fan, but it's clear that she's one of the few artists that can REALLY sing. i think she's the best voice in the world, today

[anthonyrawly]

I am a huge Christina fan. Sure she can do shit performances...But when she is good she does the impossible.

[Lenochka250292]

шикарный голос))) просто слов нет)))

[MiissR93]

magnifique

[xbabyjake]

amazing!!! i love this song and beautiful legendtina

[nanushkananushka]

Os costará creer que haciendolo TAN PERFECTAMENTE SEA DIRECTO pues LO ES ES EN DIRECTO ELLA ES ASI DE PERFECTA

[stopisebas]

si miran el dvd se ve bien ella no hace playback

en el dvd se ve bien

[stephanielynnewoolf]

she's not lip singing.

you can hear her voice echoing in the mic.

if you listen closley you can hear the mic when she tries to catch a breath.

[JerryDon25]

she sings one sentence wrongly! that impies that she sings live and doss not need to lip-sync!

[jonoindahouse]

everyone knows she can sing... but everyone knows that she lips this song...

[Hyperion3000]

You must not know how to tell when an artists lip synchs. She is NOT doing so in this song. How dare you accuse her of that? she's done it before, but this is the real deal. She's just sitting there, calm, so she can let us listen to her full and beautiful voice.

[alexlai0618]

u stupid hater!

[WalkLikeALegend]

perfect

[jamezyboy1988]

nobody is perfect , her name is nobody.. right ^^

[solonely17]

lipped. watch the rest of the videos. suddenly her voice here sounds ok, hitting all the high notes? pre-recorded, very much like celine.

[Truesonicfan16]

ohh please u dont know anything! this is 100% live! it sounds different and so beautiful! sorry not to be mean but are u deaf????! CHRISTINA IS THE BEST!!!!

[precious207]

She doesn't lip-sync actually. She is an amazing singer and unlike Britney Spears, Christina can actually sing and dance at the same time! This song sounds so perfect because she is just standing there and not moving around a lot like most of the other songs.

[sosofell]

She is perfect !

[LeaBieneAbFzZ]

oh yes she is!