Re: My Views on 3D Sonic Games

[iceskater55x]

sonic rider: good as a game but not a sonic game? what is a sonic game?

sonic heros: repetitive, slippery, and interactive level design. 

[TheMole2005]

Sonic Adventure 2 is overrated like hell

yeah, they put the fishing out, but sadly, they overused treasure hunting and mech shooting, plus downgarding both, these stages take forever, because the mechs are so slow, it's repetitive and boring after 2 or 3 stages, let alone having 12 of them

and treasure hunting.... was there any reason for downgrading the radar, digging in walls (which can take 10 or more tries), giving cryptic hints etc.

this game is completely overrated

[DaBlueShadow]

@TheMole2005 SA 2 deserves the ratings it got and is one of the best Sonic games of all time. Still Sonic games today are lacking alot against this game.

[TheMole2005]

@DaBlueShadow prove it

Treasure Hunting is shit, and Mech Shooting is boring, and they take 2/3rd of the game

the Music could be better, and on the Gamecube Version the control also lacks

so tell me, why does everybody love it, like priests like children

[DaBlueShadow]

@TheMole2005 "Boring" is your opinion of saying how rubbish it is but I find is "enjoyable" is another way of saying it but doesnt really prove a point. My dealings of how a good a game is normally portrayed out by the purpose of the actual gameplay it represents and quality. Both in terms of shooting and treasure hunting were designed great and quality of actual platforming built in. This is why it was rated so high and the music was loved by majority of fans as always.

[TheMole2005]

@DaBlueShadow you can't be serious

the radar alone is reason enough to hate the treasure hunting games, I don't mind the huge stages or the cryptic hints, but this broken radar is completely pointless, since when does a radar show you a chronological order? thanks to this, treasure hunting takes longer than neccessary

And the Shooting stages are redundand and repetitive, they're fun the first time, yes, but if 1/3 of the entire game is like this, it is just teadious

[DaBlueShadow]

@TheMole2005 You missed my whole point because I knew you was going to say that since the majority of the fanbase always has the same excuse nowadays since the new 3D Sonic games are "fast". The radar designed a purpose of making the gameplay more harder as its purpose and it worked. Controls and quality of the gameplay is excellent. I could go on but theres no point since your opinion wont change of the way how you see it. Your still in the minority of how good this game is overall.

[TheMole2005]

@DaBlueShadow it's hard enough that the stages are bigger, there was no point of downgrading the radar

besides, Treasure Hunting depends on luck anyway, it has nothing to do with challange or skill, either the emeralds are nearby or far away, and the fact that 1/3 of the game is like this is just shocking

and no, I don't mind different gameplay

take Sonic Unleashed for example, I liked the werehog, though it was overused, it was satisfying

but SA2's gameplay is mostly boring

[DaBlueShadow]

@TheMole2005 The Werehog gameplay was even worse, the stages take 10-20 mins each time and forces you to keep tapping one button to defeat a horde of aliens to progress onto the next section. Not to mention the controls in 3D for that game was unresponsive and lead the stages and puzzles the same throughout all the stages. There was no momentum to the physics as there was an alternative to use the run button and that was not even fast. This and a few points on the day stages gave this game 3.5.

[TheMole2005]

@DaBlueShadow maybe on PS3 and Xbox 360

The Wii Version was great, the Werehog stages were about 4-10 minutes long, and the daytime stages were just beautiful

and personally, I think it's much more satisfying to slash the living shit out of enemies, than shooting at them with a lame vehicle and target searching explosives

but these days are past, now we have Sonic Colours and Sonic Generations is on its way

sadly not for Wii :(

[DaBlueShadow]

@TheMole2005 The Wii version lacked in comparison and was treated unfair due to there were less Werehog stages and was more automated progress throughtout the stages to make the controls simple and playable. Sonic Colours was still an improvement but these still did not progress anywhere further in terms of the 3D segments compared to Unleashed, as it lacked any platforming or ideas through it but 2D deserved it praises for that game.

[TheMole2005]

@DaBlueShadow personally, I think these were better 3D stages than in the Adventure series

it just didn't work for me, that the 2D platforming was now brought to 3D, I can't really handle it

nowadays, I beat the Adventure series with no effort, but still, I have problems when it comes to control

Unleashed and Colours on the other hand were much easier to manoeuvre, I had no problems with those 2 games at all

[DaBlueShadow]

@TheMole2005 For me its the other way around as the Adventure series had better 3D stages than Unleashed/Colours. Colours was proven good only for the 2D part, 3D was bad. Unleashed was very linear and lacked any sense of control in 3D , they planted in quick step motions to move side to side which makes it very one dimensional in terms of 3D gameplay. The Adventure series planted in good platforming areas mixed in speed just like how the classics did it but a good progress towards 3D gameplay.

[chaoazul]

Best Sonic 3D game EVER...

Sonic Adventure

fact... /humpf

[TheMole2005]

@chaoazul not anymore

it was, before Sonic Colours hit the scene

[thedragoonknight]

You did good, the only thing I didn't like was the spax like yelling xD

[Sonicfanallways]

sonic 2006 is the game most people hate but i thought it was cool. but not the best. shadow the hedgehog i didn't like at all

[familyguyforever2]

@Sonicfanallways What the fuck is wrong with you? Shadow the Hegehog is like a fucking masterpiece compare to 06

[eliotcownden]

Your not suppost to run fast in riders thats the point of the boards.....

[prettynoose89]

lol this is exactly like spax3's review.

[metalshadowoverlord]

i love how everyone praised Bioware but the game Sonic chronicles sucked balls! It's the only Sonic game I dislike!

[NeoKokoro20]

3D Sonic games in general are grossly underrated.

[foofighter1290]

nice, but a really remember watching spax's. you pretty much ripped off and repeted all the things spax said.... =(

[IWriteUrbanHymns]

I was watching this TV programe about Sonic and it turns out he is chronically depressed because he got drug tested before the nintendo wii olimpics and tested positive for speed and cocaine so he is currently suffering withdrawal symptoms. Also this programe discribed how sonic likes to touch himself whilst looking at a slide show of roadkill. I hope this is a message to all you drug abusing hedgehog's out there. Also i once raced sonic over 100 metres and it turns out his speed is egsadurated.

[metalgearzelda02]

good job reviewing this games!

[darkgomugomu]

i was also wondering if i should get sonic next gen. cause of the gamespot reviews. but most of the reviews lie, saying the graphics suck, zebrahead was a mistake, and they just hate sonic. when i found out that the reivews lied and the bad parts were only minorities, i was enraged. so once i get a ps3, im buying sonic next gen. no matter wat

[goldw1993]

i telling you that you are making a big ass mistake. dont waste your money on that glitchy ass piece of shit. it's slow, you die if you go too fast, you die if touch the controls, oh my god i fucking hate that game. buy sonic unleashed.

[darkgomugomu]

i am gonna buy sonic unleashed, but i still need the actual experience of sonic next gen so i can get where silver came from

[goldw1993]

silver probably not ever going to be in a sonic game again

[darkgomugomu]

silver was in sonic rivals.

[eliotcownden]

Yeah I dont think he will be in a main canon game.

[Luffymon88]

Ryan Drum will always be better than Jason Griffen

[supersonicfan69]

i actuly dont care about the voice acters cuz thats how it is now

[mariorules4life]

Don't review games you haven't played. You can't say "It felt slow" and "I wanna check it out some time" That doesn't make any sense

[sharingansasuke75]

this is way to much like spax`s review

[Addicted2gaming]

this review is exactly the same thing as Spax's.. you know you could come up with your own stuff Oo

[LG65]

True... Much of it is like Spax's opinions. However, he mentioned that he did not include Sonic Shuffle. I said stuff about Sonic Shuffle, so... yeah.

[ninjapoyo]

I agree *nods* I love Sonic Heros <3

You should send an email to Sega and tell them well suggest ways to improve... I mean I want to hear about a new Sonic game that is good cause I am tired of hearing about how the new ones are bad. They may not read it but there is always a possibility

[supersonicfan69]

i wonder why they havent made sonic heroes 2 are a sequal to it

[DigitalLameFan]

pretty straight forward reviews. You could have added abit more critics.

But you did well on this one so ill give you five stars