"Misconceptions of Shi'a" - Ammar Nakhshwani Lecture at MIT

[syedathermasood]

To me you are a Muslim when you say there is one God But Allah, and Muhmmad SAW is his messenger. The thing that bothered me about his lecture that he barely said SAW. May Allah guide us all and protect us.

[sonvai]

may 4ll protect people from evils of his talks.....4ll humma la'nan hum bil la'nan kabiira

[MAK123547]

Mashallah May Allah Bless You  Sayyed Ammar Nakhswani

[anpuification]

brother then my heart broke and i failed to hear his FALSE STORIES just to misguide me in my religion

[anpuification]

third thing that pinched me was that though he said Hazrat Ali (RA) , Imam HussAIn (RA) and other great personalities but i felt that he wanted to play with my sentiments and emotions when he narrated the story of our beloved People (MAy Allah Bless them all in highes place of Janna ,Amen) by associating them with our Holy Prophet (PBUH) , for me it was a fuel for the fire

[anpuification]

third thing that pinched me was that though he said Hazrat Ali (RA) , Imam HussAIn (RA) and other great personalities but i felt that he wanted to play with my sentiments and emotions when he narrated the story of our beloved People (MAy Allah Bless them all in highes place of Janna ,Amen) by associating them with our Holy Prophet (PBUH) , for me it was a fuel for the fire

[kazmi88]

@anpuification What you want to say here is that the association of Ali (a.s), his sons and his wife (Fatima a.s) with the Prophet (s.a.w.w) is (nauzubillah) lame. The Quranic verses about the Ahl e Bait and the Hadiths from Prophet himself are (nauzubillah) not of much importance to present in public to aware them of the position they held or hold?

[anpuification]

second thing that bothers me is that it was nice to know the references of Holy Quran and listening to Ayaats , but it was astonishing not to find them in Holy Quran ... i tried serching them in all Qurans that were available to me right now ...do let me know if you find thm

[kazmi88]

@anpuification First lemme tell you that you have not searched out any of these references and you are lame firing because there are no more Qurans than one and you must check that only ONE quran. firstly Quran may have some minor changes in Quran translations but there aren't any big ones. Secondly the translations Tafseer may be different because every Scholar tries the best of the Arabic words.

[anpuification]

brother the first thing that i am bothered with is that he quoted all sayings of Hazrat Ali (RA) which we cannot find in some authentic book like ahadith ... i would like to explain it ... see brother , Hazrat Ali (RA) was such a great personality that if you say anything GOOD to me and end it with "Hazrat Ali (RA) or Hazrat Imam Hussain (RA) " i would definitely believe it .... i would never be searching for its authentication ..

[kazmi88]

@anpuification :

I would like to thank you for your keen interest in this video.

Brother the is that you watched it critically never thought that the beliefs (in some cases) are quite different from the other school of thoughts in Shi'ite. This scholar cleared the misconceptions and tried to put a positive way in front of us to find intra-faith dialogue. The sayings of Ali (a.s) and the other Imams couldn't necessarily be in the MOST authentic books according to Shi'ite. They have their own.

[anpuification]

Brother , i really appreciate that you are with me in this search of truth , brother the video you presented is a clue to what i wanted to say ... let me vindicate

[anpuification]

can i comment??