超級星光大道 20100402 pt.19/24 蘇芷妤-Open your eyes

[byon1009]

在星光的態度瞬間從酷酷型變成綜藝型囧

[seafairy]

直接一点XD ， 不怎么好听乜。。。

[Woesszz]

She's hawt o:

[jctc85]

who didn't give the last point???

[realxxoo]

歌聲很好. 雖然唱功還有進步空間 但感情的表現很好<3

[garda96]

hińskie guwna nieźle dają ;p

[lucifer5130]

對手太強

輸也沒辦法啦

[ikikage99]

OF course, most Americans, or English speakers like Lin Yu Chun better, because we can UNDERSTAND him, and relate to what he is singing. I, personally, like her better.And of course we didn't understand what she's saying. She's speaking Chinese, geniuses. But I could clearly understand what she said in English. She's absolutely amazing,

[nightybunny]

@ikikage99

Eh, I feel like she has less control over her voice than Lin did. I'm a vocal coach, and listen to a LOT of Asian songs and bands and I was blown away by Lin's voice not because it sounded like Whitney, but because of the range and control he exhibited. Such control is hard to obtain, and you can tell the kid has really REALLY worked with his voice.

[x2036457]

蘇唱得也很不錯呀

[PLUMeeRiiTaaw]

I can understand Lin yu chun but not the girl

[PLUMeeRiiTaaw]

I can't understand a thing shes saying but shes good

I still think Lin Yu Chun was better T.T

[lichien666]

哈哈！心想事成～～苏芷妤好可爱。

[kydchanoo]

心想事成

..哈哈哈哈是酸嗎XD

[allen521803]

蘇芷妤的聲音怎麼聽都好聽><

加油!!!! 希望你可以發片!!!!

[tky0414]

看一看夏芮絲Charice歌喉嗓音，绝对震撼！！

watch?v=LS6SJj6kM6s

[ActiveAnimeEnt]

Amazing...^__^

[W1313iY]

小胖....就是一粒超光亮的星星

[bunyilo]

小胖唱成這樣沒拿滿分，真是太神奇了～

[godwatelsecani]

觉得这是到目前为止她唱得最好的一次

[jacksona333]

This gal can make u feel the song better than the fat guy.

[SHEEN0998777]

WHO CARES Lin Yu Chun IS UGLY ! HES NOW A MILLIONARE , BETTER THAN MOST OF U PREETY FACES OUT THERE !!!

[vananhdo]

I have to say she sang with EMOTION but the fat guy has his own style to grab people's hearts too. ITS VERY HARD TO DECIDE.

[o0forever0o1]

The fat boy sings exactly the same like Whitney Houston. But do we need two Whitney Houstons in the world? He got the techniques but with very less emotions.

On the other hand, this girl did a very great job, she sings with emotions and the techniques are good too. Please be fair to her as she's only 17 years old and she got the guts to stand on the stage. The fat boy's already 24, he just looks young but he's already an adult.

[YueLinG1013]

i like her~蘇芷妤~ =)

[m3jgo3]

哈哈 我也只是想看看林育群的評語

[teddy928]

有 F E E L !

[readyforupten]

Vote for Ryan if you support her!!! Xin Guang Da Dao Popularity Vote at the Xing Guang Da Dao official website.

Keep on voting!!

[ca369753]

上一個唱英文又那麼有爆發力的歌  下個感覺整個就遜掉了...((個人認為

[adelaide427]

最愛你唱這首歌 很好很好聽 加油 未來的路 不一定是星光冠軍

[cain1099]

genial

[jacky9584412]

哈我也只是想看小胖的評語耶

不過有點失望= =

如果是我我一定跟足球主播一樣一直吼來吼去= =

[benson8564]

他得聲音真的很棒~這次表現跟以往不同~感情面表現得很棒^^

[opus1990]

Hi, I wish I spoke your language so I could participate fairly in your game - Your participants have so much talent

[Ottilie1118]

差一分不代表他唱不好

評審本來就會有各種考量

也許評審覺得他真的很棒 只是好像少了什麼

我覺得他唱I will always love you比較完美

[barry1530b]

我聽只是為了看小胖的評語........哈哈哈哈

[quest20080223]

恕在下無知 林育群並非星光六之成員 被刷掉是指??

如果是指唱中文歌17分那場 還有五百多萬人背書嗎??

[poi5201314]

台灣的歌唱評審只是為自己.節目.唱片業來對參賽者打分數.對於­真正唱歌好聽的比重只佔10%評分.林育群歌聲好不好現在全世界­有500多萬人幫他背書.不是那些少數不入流評審說一句不好就可­以刷掉的.

[poi5201314]

台灣的歌唱評審只是為自己.節目.唱片業來對參賽者打分數.對於­真正唱歌好聽的比重只佔10%來評分.林育群歌聲好不好現在全世­界有500多萬人幫他背書.不是那些少數不入流評審說一句不好就­可以刷掉的.

[nttt7898]

she needs change her hairstyles :D

[Heavensdust135]

Shes kickass and after this week and next week's performance she has become my fav, because her voice is great and she has a cool sense of personal style.

Sure Li Yu Chun did fantastic, but I don't think he was better or at least he didn't pwn her.

[ObfuscateOkashi]

@Heavensdust135 What is this girl's name? I've looked everywhere but I can't find it! She's amazing too, she just got lost in the shadow Li Yu Chun's performance :/ And there's nothing about her!

[Heavensdust135]

@ObfuscateOkashi - Her first name is Suzhi. Spelled exactly like that. I'll have to translate the others comments to find her full name.

Did you watch the most recent episode?

[LujaxChan]

@Heavensdust135 it's a male...my friend...so it's HIM OKAY??

[Heavensdust135]

@LujaxChan - Thats not what others have been saying......

[Schwengelhorst]

na habadere gortntirl

[BakaRice]

@_@'

[wade4423]

我今天第一次看星光六~

所以還算客觀啦~

第一次聽起來~ 蘇芷妤  唱的真的滿屌的~

有把心裡的聲音給唱出來~ 用比較自然的歌唱技巧來詮釋~

Feel 很棒 真的~ XD

期待她的發展~ ~~

[bensan8088]

好不好不是一時間就要下定論,如果評審就這樣一直讓他贏下去就會­有更多人說是在護航,人的表現不可能一直維持在非常高的水平,他­上次表現比這次好,自然評審會有其他想法,評審的觀點是綜合各種­角度去評論的,人家既然當評審,節目也播出很多年了,培養出很多­很棒的實力型藝人,人家能當評審自有本事,如果這些評審真的這麼­爛早就沒人要看這種節目了

[Firithfenion]

Nice performance! You have a lot of good singers in Taiwan. I hope the world will see/hear more of them.

[navycaptain911]

台灣的評審沒有國際化的眼光 難登大雅之堂 可悲 不過小胖已在國際成名是事實 如果今天沒有youtube我想小胖已經被這些沒眼光的人趕回家­吃自己了

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 怎麼個沒有國際化眼光?你這是嘴砲還是真的有分析論點可以提出來­?說來聽聽

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 台灣評審沒有國際化眼光,你有喔?星光評審還講的出有建設性的講­評,比起許多國外選秀節目純粹作秀式的講評,台灣評審多爛?你這­樣純粹是在嘴砲吧

[navycaptain911]

@bensan8088 很明顯小胖唱得很好 居然還輸 世界上任何一個人都會說小胖唱的比那個甚麼還好 但小胖為何而敗? 太胖? 太醜?

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 好比包小X2人組,毒蛇炒效果,一開始有賣點,久而久之也沒有人­要看,星光評審很難得的是真的能以客觀,多角度去評分,你這樣說­他唱的比那個誰好,你可以提出你的看法,大家討論看看是哪裡比較­好,這樣一昧的罵評審,感覺就只是為反對而反對

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 人紅是非多,星光藝人的實力大家都很肯定阿,所以才會有如此收視­率,原因就是評審夠中肯,節目要長久,就要拿出穩定的東西,而不­是純粹爆點效果,既然星光評審拿的出穩定的講評,那麼你這樣說他­們未免也太不公平

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 再說你也不是評審,你的想法可能就沒有評審來的中肯,評審的專業­是磨練來的,不是隨便像觀眾聽一聽看一看就決定誰比較好,不然要­評審來做什麼?

[navycaptain911]

@bensan8088 我結果論台看的 小胖時在強過那個時麼的很多 會輸 是不是要說評審不公? 或許公平只不過沒國際眼光?

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 如果只是想把藝人推上國際舞台而無視其他參賽者好不好,比賽辦的­就無意義,評審也都白搭,歌唱比賽目的在培養實力唱將,也許長相­好不好會影響一個仁在台上觀眾對他的看法,但這是第一印象問題,­不能說我們客觀其他人就客觀的不去以他長相評分,而這些都不是重­點,回到前面,歌唱比賽不是為了把藝人推上國際舞台才舉辦的

[navycaptain911]

@bensan8088 你都說了 歌唱比賽不是把藝人推上國際舞台才舉辦的 所以承認我一開始的觀點吧-台灣評審沒國際觀點 不知到你吵那麼多 是怎麼樣

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 你也承認我說的:歌唱比賽布是為了把藝人推上國際,那尛小胖輸不­輸就是評審對於他進步退補以及對手其他優缺點的綜合評量,你這樣­講評審實在太沒格調,你也講不出評審到底哪裡上不暸國際水準,只­會一昧的為反對而反對

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 還有,歌唱比賽不是為了把藝人推上國際,這點跟台灣評審有沒有國­際觀完全兩碼子事,原來你連基本的關連都搞不清楚,講再多都沒用­,你只會堅持你那句一竿子打翻一船人的批評,你要真的這麼行,你­去應徵評審來講評給大家看

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 連最基本的:尊重評審的講評都辦不到,你乾脆不要看算了,反正評­審講什麼,做出什麼決定你都聽不進去,只會瘋狂的支持自己認為好­的,根本是無意識的瘋狂粉絲,沒有任何評審觀念的人應該是你吧?­

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 評審評的不好?哪裡不好你講不出來,小胖比那個誰哪裏好?你講不­出來,台灣評審為什麼上不暸國際水準?你講不出來,你講的出來的­,就是那句沒有任何觀點支持的批評

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 評審不只是把兩個人哪一個唱的好聽評出來,要是這麼簡單,乾脆開­放給觀眾投票讓你這種膚淺的人選更快更公平,評審評分還要針對各­個參賽者今日以及前幾次的表現作比較,西洋歌曲一套標準,中文歌­一套標準,綜合各觀點給的分數你要是不服你就講哪裡不對,什麼都­不講,卻說:小胖唱的比那個誰誰誰好多了,膚淺至極

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 問我吵這麼多是怎樣?我提出的是有觀點支持的說法,而且保持客觀­,不像你只是草草打兩句話就扼殺掉評審的講評還有參賽者的努力

[navycaptain911]

@bensan8088 就是因為我不專業 所以沒辦法講出個所以然 不過小胖沒得滿分實在還蠻誇張的 因為就算在怎麼不專業 也能聽出小胖的聲音是滿分的 如果沒辦法聽出小胖的聲音是滿分 豈能還能自詡為"專業"的評審呢

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 評審不只是對歌聲評分,還有台風,造型等藝人站在台上應該要把握­的元素,少掉那一分大概就是在其他部分,歌唱比賽也等於是在培養­一個能在舞台上表演到滿分的藝人,所以要面面俱到

[navycaptain911]

@bensan8088  22分 24分隨他們心情好不好亂給?

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 每個人每天對同樣事情的價值觀本來就會有所不同,今天他們聽是2­4分,明天稍微對某件事情的標準放低了些就可能變成25,評審也­不可能完全客觀,但因為他們是最專業的,最公平的,所以才能當上­評審

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 我沒有很固定的去收看星光,今天只是站在一個對大家都客觀的角度­去看待這件事情,評審會這樣決定自有其原因,難道評審會阻擋一個­參賽者前進嗎?培養出好藝人對他們來說也是相當具有成就感的事情­,今天輸了很難保証是對小胖不好,或許他會成長更多不是嗎?

[bensan8088]

@navycaptain911 你說小胖在國際成名是事實,但如果缺乏培養,就只會淪為國際新聞­一時的小插曲,無法長久,頂著國際媒體親睞的光環就更要努力,小­胖很有天份,但也不能因此無視其他參賽者,我說過人的表現無法長­久的維持在高水準,其他參賽者總有優點,評審的工作也就在發覺這­些普通人難以注意的優點

[totlshininstar]

eh... mad me fall asleep...

[holehole]

她的聲音讓人覺得很舒服 是當歌手的料 :)

[curetw]

評審?suck?

[ASIL75722]

很喜歡蘇芷妤

要繼續加油^^

[speedkevin]

可能連評審都沒辦法唱的比他好+1

[shoupa1221]

She's pretty good and cute!!!

I like both of them!!!

[silentgosupro]

这是谁，声音那么好，不比原唱差，我只是路过而已。

[pidfouoiuef]

@silentgosupro

這是一個17歲的小女生

有這樣表現已不錯了！

[pk5690797]

@sexfuck078 哪你來唱阿

[jessiegirlx]

I personally prefer the boy boy better even though she did well too.

[andy316800]

she s good. i prefer her actually!

[mohabiraq1]

she's good but the boy did better

[LoveHoro]

She is great ^^

[joy845756]

很喜歡蘇芷妤唱這首歌的感覺,

很棒!!

[lisy1991516]

好可惜

[kkryotego]

wt a pity, yue dun giveuup

[bboyfeellucas]

真正的屈機

[MUILAN12345]

唱得好好呀，聲音有感情，比肥仔好多了，肥仔唱歌沒感情呀

[long79109]

看著她會一直想到張芸京 ~"~

[gomuib21]

風格不同罷了

[ditakai]

原來是在明日之星被刷下來的蘇芷妤

[mrpuann]

因該說...

台灣人聽歌~已經習慣中文~所以聽到中文都覺得還好....

但是說真的...

小胖唱成這樣...不拿滿分...我想評審耳朵有點問題...

可能連評審都沒辦法唱的比他好喔!!!

[chiming139]

@mrpuann 可能是小肥最後有噴到mic

[chiming139]

@chiming139 可能是小胖最後有噴到mic

[bbss916]

臺灣人習慣中文~你聽到的都還好~但西方人的尊重~和接受不同意­見的度量在你身上完全沒法體現?~~意見不同就批評對方耳朵有問­題?說真的你的評論令人不能苟同!

[TukasaHikaru]

she can sing like this after hearing xiao pang's perfect performance, it's good/brave also. no need to be cruel on her.

[quest20080223]

將一百分按照五等份比例分配

1: (0~20) 2: (21~40) 3: (41~60)  4: (61~80) 5:(81~100)

81和100就是都給5分 這樣解釋可以嗎 ^o^

[johnnyfresh888]

good job~ 蘇芷妤唱得很有感覺啊!~

[habe4567]

評審給的五分或許是不同意義的五分

[ruithael]

You guys need to stop talking about my girlfriend that way. She's the best, I keep telling her. He He. :-)

[Ohwellrt]

she got served by that kid lol

[he214ab]

差天共地, 後者可以回家睡了.

[joyce921]

xiao pang sings better than this girl, but this girl put more feelings in the song than xiao pang did for his.

[pidfouoiuef]

This girl is just 17 years old

Please don't criticize her thus

17 years old have this performance have been good

[Heavensdust135]

@pidfouoiuef - O wow really? I did not know she was 17.

Shes actually my fave. Great voice and a cool sense of personal style.

[tigerhei]

平心而論呀，真的!! 兩位絕對都唱得非常好!!!

只是兩首歌的技巧等級是完全不同的，是不能拿來被比較的。

...對嗎 我說得對吧 =_=

[ntuchenn]

唉!! 這裡完全反應星光評分制度有多可笑，分數差兩分，代表至少有三個­人給了同分，

(林育群分數一定是55554) 結果一個人因為這首歌紅到全世界了，請問那三個給同分的標準在哪­邊???

[iammonkeychi]

@ntuchenn 給同分? 那當然是覺得他們都唱的非常好聽 就是這樣

[mimitheear]

@ntuchenn 不管標準如何 畢竟林唱的是 I will always love you.

華語流行歌曲和西洋流行的演唱方式與風格本來就差得天南地北 像是台灣很紅的歌手到歐美不一定會紅起來阿 所以不能說評審評分沒有標準阿

[formosaofloveocean]

She's has a nice voice.

But xiao pan sings better than her!

[formosaofloveocean]

She's has a nice voice.

But xiao pan sings better than her!

[99pppeee]

haha xiao pan is singing at the back,cute:P

[nagajay]

she must have felt like crap going after what she just heard

[blacxmage]

2:51 She definitely just said, "Nigga."

[jasonnimneil]

@blacxmage HAHAHAHAHAHA

[chan14264]

shes ok, but other guy was too good.. completely different level

[P0KERH0NTAS87]

not bad, but no chance....

[xxjojanxx]

CHILESE 4 EVa

[joecheen]

女生的態度好討厭

[PrincessChooz]

the song not nice

[Harthorn]

she got pwned for sure..

[nottymiao]

i just can say, the god is fair~ but she is not that bad...you cant compare a chinese song to the english song...isnt it...different way of expression...

[gfreeman556]

Poor girl, she "got served"

[Sporty36girl]

she = generic :P

Lin Yu Chun = GODDESS VOICE :OOOOOOOOOOOO

had to stop that vid before halfway cuz shes too ....not that special...just ..okay :\

[iafnahc]

The fat boy sang better than Houston, but she didn't sing better than Ah Mei. That's the difference.

[yanjaex2]

She did really well, but considering what she was up against... you gotta feel sorry for her.

[Ngelcanfly]

She's good. However, the guy before her was stunning!!!

[ItzDaKing]

Before the Whitney kid performed, she laughed at him and said "I got thisss!" ... well he sure served her gooood... she was... aite. just aite.

[Lythenna]

Sorry, but the kid before her, served her good! He was WAY better!

[jameshsu4518]

awesome performance

[xo0raine0ox]

Does anyone else think she looks like Ella from S.H.E.?

[dingnling]

@xo0raine0ox - i do! i think she looks like ella!

[pisces2222]

@xo0raine0ox TOTALLY haha

[nellie2581]

Not bad

[YukiNoYumeProduction]

Love it <3

[xxsoundasleepxx]

aw shes cute :3

[RunningWolf09]

To me- this chick is really HOT! But she didn't sing quite as well as Lin Yu Chun.

[MrDeathbypenguin]

She was great, what are you people talking about. I bet none of y'all could match her singing ability.

[BloodyScreams]

Well, she's cute at least.

[symbiosychotic]

She's actually really good. She's easily at the quality of recording artists. Her only fault was getting matched against Xiao Pang.

[DjAchillies]

the guy that sings like whitney is 10X's better. But she's "okay"

[vasDcrak]

even my cat sings better

[ozmafairy3]

Xiao Pang was awesome. :D

[Cwingchong]

芷妤真的很不错了，只是人算不如天算。。。她遇到怪物了！

[HengLucy]

She got the highest score of 22 among the 11 finalist right? She still perform well with such a good competitor...

[doctorj816]

she's not that bad. it's just that xiao pang was really good.

[googlemonkey217]

damn she sucks...

fat kid served her ass wit dat whitney houston song

[itsyourboyl]

@googlemonkey217 lol

[rgvarney]

@googlemonkey217 Actually, Dolly Parton did it first.

[Beorning1972]

@googlemonkey217 What a cruel comment. She's a good singer by any measure.

[MsFuenf]

好听！

[ellamizar]

芷妤再次發功了~! 要繼續高分下去, 奪走星光六的冠軍喔!!

[maybeeemaybenot]

他唱得最好的一次!  聽了很感動。加油!! 你很棒!

[miumiuniu]

的确不错

[iammonkeychi]

進步了噢^^

加油!!

[yulilin]

蘇芷妤今天有讓我起雞皮疙瘩

[Anitdragonhin]

蘇的樣子越來越順眼了!!