Paul is dead - the rotten apple 6

[cooks24]

@TheAbsorbant Depends also on how you play.

[jjadiel2011]

C'mon Paul never died! It was just a Trick to make money! Iamaphoney, its nothing against you but Why you are obsessed with this?? why you are so convinced that he is dead??

[TheSuperLegoMan100]

@NoirFan i agree and I would finally know the truth.

[ladybuglove4all]

i think the guys who made this, didn't really had anything better to do....

[NoirFan01]

Pres. Obama was forced to produce his birth certificate (as stupid as that was). So, "Paul" should submit to a DNA test to prove he's the real Paul.

[Rebel4evermore]

@NoirFan01 dang rite!

[OoyamatsukamioO]

dario



[sdsheep195]

@xNikkaX3 I often point with my middle finger. Lots of people do it!!! It;s not taht hard to learn to do it either...

[TheGamanic]

Well they would first have to find someone exactly like him enough to fool millions and they were the most photographed band in the world. Then he would have to have the exact same voice, and be extremely talented on all instruments and have a genius-like ability for melody,along with adopting a perfect scouse accent without sounding fake or telling his friends or family.Surely if u know that you are looking at someone who died if you were Lennon, you would be well freaked out and uncomfortable

[beatlejuice1969]

The subtitles seem misquoted to me. He says, " Those films we look at.... that's us doing it." Really a stretch on this one, pretty weak.

PLUS, if this is a replacement Paul, why would he talk that freely about it all w/ a camera rolling????

[Americanpye66]

It's 'mental' enough that people actually believe Paul is Dead... but to dedicate websites, youtube channels and blogs to it? I'm sorry, but that's the absolute height of ignorance, stupidity and obsession. Some people are obviously obsessed with proving this nonexistent rumor as fact...and guess what? It will NEVER be proven, because it didn't happen...it's a dreamed up conspiracy theory by people with seriously too much time on their hands.

[mrocc12345]

@Americanpye66 Thank you, if there going to start this rumor thought why not say that everyone died, and got replaced.

[Americanpye66]

@mrocc 12345 - You're welcome...it's funny because I've been asked by a few disturbed PID'ers to 'take off the shades" and "open my eyes"...well, guess what? I have my eyes wide open, sans shades and their 'so called' facts do not add up...Never have and never will. Some people simply OBSESS over conspiracy theories and spend their lives trying to prove something happened....it's pointless and absurd, albeit, extremely humorous to read.

[byemynameishi]

-,- this 'clue' is really reaching..

[k0stil]

0:19 - he`s pointing at george - that means that he`s dead (he also tells "fuck you" to john by showing his middle finger)

[AlicelnWonderIand]

Yeah.... I like to think that this is the same person. Because you CAN"T really replace someone like this.... But if somehow he was replaced- I LOVE THEM BOTH

[HoldenCaulfieldXXX]

WHAT DOES THIS VIDEO MEANS???

someone could pls tell me, because most of this guy videos...i dont get it!

[xander7ful]

@HoldenCaulfieldXXX I think Iamaphoney is trying to point out that this "Paul" is a replacement for the real one and that he studied films of the band before he came on board.

[HoldenCaulfieldXXX]

@xander7ful Uau! so the video is worse than i could possibly imagine :P

[AristYdes]

its funny to think that they are there rehearsing with a secret pauls replacement

[horbergaren]

they are just bored

[totheumbrella]

as someone else commented, this isnt even the correct audio! the real audio in intirely different. search: paul and george arguing.

[thedayitriedtodie]

this is just a band rotting on the inside...

they look so bothered to b there... specially John.

[xNikkaX3]

It's Paul. Paul always uses his middle finger to point or whatever unknowingly and he's doing it.

[greatsilentwatcher]

Paul is holding a guitar pick in his left hand, and the middle finger then becomes the one he points with.

[xNikkaX3]

Yes I know but he points with it even when he doesn't have a pick in his hand.

[TheAbsorbant]

@xNikkaX3 He's holding a guitar pick between his thumb and index finger. That, for some of us, leaves the middle finger sticking out. I know I do it.

[euro944t]

His Clone is talented, "Wings" had some good music.

His Clone sings as good a original or better.

[susan251]

'i buried paul' het is allemaal wel goed verzonnen hoor maar ik weet niet of ik het nou moet geloven of niet!

[SoldierFrontOwns]

het is niet verzonnen het is wat andere vertellen aan je dat je i buried paul hoort dan gaan je hersenen op zoek na het sutkje van i buried paul en hoor je het ook

Ookal zeg je luister goed je hoort im very wrong dan hoor je dat ook

[querant]

algun español k me pueda traducir lo k dice mccarney

[tutenkhamen5]

um...segun el video...

paul les esta diciendo que ellos lo hacian antes...refiriendose a poner significados en canciones dichas al reves.

les dice que el ya vio los videos y ha escuchado canciones que dicen algo de la muerte de Paul alreves.

[David709321]

his mouth dosen't move

[Memorandumi]

Wtf was that?

[NoLifeGamer17]

what the fuck does this have to do with the rumor about Paul being dead?

[tsimon1234]

I think they may have been talking anout the backmasked messages of Pauls death. So you could be lookin at Pauls replacment saying. "Hay Way dont we put in a hidden backwards message?" The other Beatles then say no and he says "But you used to do it." Reffering to Pauls death and the hidden hes dead messages.

[pajamysamy]

because the paul on the video is insinuating that he wasnt around when they used to do certain things thats y he said "thats how u all used to do it" not how we used to do it. and he also says that he has been watching some videos implying he does so to attempt to look n act n speak like the real paul. hope i helped

[Shizalumni]

That isn't the audio for that footage. I think this series is just meant to be a joke.

[tommywm24]

HAHA the audio is wrong...completely wrong. You should have chosen better footage wanker! This is one the pivotal scenes in Let it Be when Paul and George argue and you've stupidly dubbed with it different audio to seem as if all this bullshit is actually true! Just type in 'Paul and George arguing' and you'll see what I mean!

[misshookedonchronic]

lol this crap reminds me of when i was in school and we used to look at a dollar bill to see a spider or sumthin the Beatles are bigger than currency hehe

[nume26]

Hey, they might even be bigger than Jesus.

[misshookedonchronic]

haha very true

[blabadiblabla]

I'm checking this one off as "No evidence" in your series.

[78uh]

this doesnt prove anything even if he did say you used to do it lads that doesnt prove paul died

[cky727]

someone explain this one to me?

[ladyunebarton]

he means U used to do it in the song, Or the way he just to play...I think..

[joescout]

yup

[keys4ever2]

About this series: I'm still on the fence about Pauls so called death but, as for these videos (the first 6 anyway) I have seen no real evidence yet. A little back masking and fancy video manipulation you can make this all sound like anything you want. This video (#6) uses footage from the LIB film and audio from another source, probably from the LIB sessions. Very cleverly done BTW but not real evidence. Look for my postings of future rotten apple videos for more INTELLIGENT COMMENTARY hehe!

[Xandrino]

yes it does...U used to do it lads...get it? The new Paul said that because before he wasn't in the band...duh Paul is Dead!

[Janne112]

wow, this one had no clues on PID whatsoever

[orbandsceptre27]

If you don`t understand and accept the holographic world we inhabit, if you know little or nothing of NWO, if you think humanity is the top of the hierarchy on this plain of existence........ then ure not going to ever "get" or accept the PID phenomenon so go away and do ure homework. When you start to understand PID, then a whole other "pandoras box" begins to open.

[JGuildersleeve]

If I ever saw any actual evidence, rather than some series of vague clues that could produce thousands of interpretations, then I might actually consider it. But given that these conspiracy theories insist on flying in face of actual evidence, it becomes nothing more than an excuse for people to pretend like they are 'in the know' and tell people to do their homework.

[orbandsceptre27]

How are you so sure that I`m not "in the know?" - Never assume anything ....... you should have clear and substantive evidence before you proving that I`m not "in the know" before making insinuations to the contrary (according to you anyway). Has it never occurred to you that defendants have been found guilty in jury trial murder cases with little or no direct evidence linking them to the crime. Do you really need everything put on a plate for you before you eat it?

[JGuildersleeve]

I can be sure that you are not 'in the know' because I haven't been given any evidence to suggest there is anything TO know. As for your point about defendants being found guilty: what you are talking about are cases that have not followed Western jurisprudence, which is supposed to be followed in all cases and aruges that there must be direct evidence before a person can be convicted of committing a crime. This is entrenched in law.

[JGuildersleeve]

Paul says, "Those films of us" but "of us" is conveniently left out of the text box.

[jevesmybags]

laurancameron is right he does edit alot of stuff just type in paul and george argue he doesnt say anything close to this

[CryHepZero]

paul FLIPPS everybody off @ 00:00.2

hes a baddddddd man! you used to do it lads!

some of this stuff is not believable but some it really strong

[laurancameron]

This clip is from,"Let It Be," but I just watched this same video clip of Paul talking to george and the audio is completely different. This audio of "You lads used to do it" is not what he is saying. They are actually talking about how toGeorge should play the song they are working on. iamaphoney is the phoney.

[to761983]

The more I watch this clip, the more it seems that Faul realises he's just verbally slipped (on camera), starts to ramble, corrects himself by saying "that was US doing it"; then is Harrisson (also aware they're being filmed) just scratching his nose or giving a little sign ("be careful/shut up") there?

[quastheunseen420]

lol i have this movie, it has nothing to do with pauls dead conspiracy

they are just talking about getting a song right or something to that degree

[hagront]

I really hope there's nobody here that claims he's dead for real!!

[hagront]

i don't get it, they are just speaking

[Kainlarsen]

Don't fret it, Iamaphoney is a troll, and these people are all stupid.:D

[Katsnjammer]

yea, I can't get it neither

[mattfatherofgrace]

the idea behind it, is that Paul is talking to the other guys and saying "you used to do it lads" "but we did, I mean you know those films I've been looking at"...your supposed to get the idea that this is Paul's "replacement" and he's talking to the guys...and when he says I mean those films ive been looking at, leads to the possibilty that he is trying to do what the beatles used to do so that they dont figure out he's a fake....hope it helps.

[to761983]

Whooosh!

[mattfatherofgrace]

the idea behind it, is that Paul is talking to the other guys and saying "you used to do it lads" "but we did, I mean you know those films I've been looking at"...your supposed to get the idea that this is Paul's "replacement" and he's talking to the guys...and when he says I mean those films ive been looking at, leads to the possibilty that he is trying to do what the beatles used to do so that they dont figure out he's a fake....hope it helps.

[jonsey1976]

ok so paul is dead..

who really gives a fuck???

[easytoremember246]

I'm confused. If The Beatles wanted to hide the fact that Paul is dead, why would they give clues? It's like a murderer leaving hints to his address.

[daddyboom1]

They wanted to tell their fans, but it would ruin their band, so they left clues to try and break the news.

[easytoremember246]

so if they had told us it would ruin them, and that's why they're trying to tell us? would hinting ruin them less?

[to761983]

"It's like a murderer leaving hints to his address."

Yes, like "cereal" killers (mostly patsys anyway) and the system making movies about such rubbing our noses in what they've done and presenting it as "fiction".

You must understand these are not normal people we're dealing with here.

As to your question, the system was taunting/revealing to us and to what extent the band were in on it or how much their handlers were responsible is debatable.

[easytoremember246]

A) it's got to be really hard to kill cereal

B) how could the band tell us without being in on it

C) I don't think the Beatles would go through all the trouble of finding sentences that backwards hint, sort of, to their friend being dead.

D) I think speculating about this takes away from the great music.

[to761983]

a) That allusion went over your head.

b) Yes, they were all in on it, the satanic freaks.

c) Normal people wouldn't but you can ignore any back-speech and just focus on the visual/symbolic clues anyway.

d) The music was part of the plot.

[easytoremember246]

im confused did you mean serial? or were you making a stupid pun?

also so what if he's dead? they didn't try to hide it when john died and he was more popular! or when george died. and like i said it still takes away from the lovely music.

[to761983]

Read Michael Hoffman. "Serial" killer is an occult play on words - "cereal" killer derived from agriculture/earth "Goddess" Ceres. It's a phrase coined by the masonic Federal Govt (an FBI higher-up). If I recall it alludes to "harvesting" victims or somesuch.

[easytoremember246]

wow, when it has to go that deep, no wonder it went over my head.

[to761983]

No problem, I didn't mean to come across rude.

Once I didn't know this stuff. There are people who know more than me but I don't want to waste my life "studying" occultism.

One tip: don't expect normal human behaviour from "them" - they're batshit insane you know.

[easytoremember246]

Insane, no. High on LSD all the time, yes.

I'm not saying that if Paul is dead I would be angry or surprised, I just don't think it's true.

[to761983]

I wasn't referring to the Beatles.

[elperromagico]

You know what George was thinking there? "I wish you really *were* dead, you wanker."

[henrythe8thhh]

this video sucks

[KyleB1988]

BUUUUUUUUUUSTED, good spot like!

[tbone76a]

Busted!

[georgekush]

he isnt dead, there was a bigger point to what the paul is dead hoax was about more than just record sales. It has to do with ancient egypt.

[heather23renae]

interesting. please explain!

[cyntv]

paul is alive

the so called evidence is bull

john said it, ringo said it

and george doesnt wanna comment

says something about them?

im just watching it to laugh :]

[bettysaidulied]

paul is alive and kickin' im just watching b.c im board! lol

[shalzi17]

lol i agree with you. I find that people believe this a funny thing and I like to watch and laugh lol.

[yhshvh10]

That's why George doesn't want to do it.

[tikvision]

ok this part was weak. Anyway i will say it: BRILLIANT AUDIO-VIDEO WORK (so far) Try to get the "other" let it be film, not the one with the bad out-of-sync audio, it has better quality also

[Tdani81]

I guess imaphoney is saying that by 'Paul' saying "YOU used to it lads" means that he is excluding himself from the group.

[brittykate]

yeah, but the funny thing is he says "WE used to have a lot more incentive then" right after that

I think it's hilarious....you could take my conversations out of context and you'd think I had a double also!! what a laugh!!

[to761983]

Maybe once he realised he slipped with a camera watching he changed back to "we" and made a point of mentioning it.

"Those films I've been looking at". Just him? Why? To catch up with the band's habits and techniques?

[to761983]

-1 LOL.

[rog944]

I agree. I am a sheep.

[to761983]

Nah, you're just a cunt.

[PKMSW]

i dont get how saying that shows that hes dead...

[Psychedelicacy]

i dont believe he's dead; i'm just watching these because i'm bored. but i think because he says YOU used to do it, it's meaning that he wasnt there when they did it...cause it's not him.

even though i think it is....

yeah....

[tonbonthemon]

yeah me to i dont believe hes dead and im watching the vids cause im bored

[madaboutmika75]

i totally agree with you

xx mavvy xx

[bgumbyguitar]

If you play IAMAPHONY backwards it says "I love it in the fudge hole" While listening to Beatles backwards.

[bdown4l1]

man dont you have any thing better to do? your on every fucking comment list saying the same shit! if dude is a phoney then why is your looser ass going to every post he's got and leaving comments? your the phoney!pretending you have some sort of life! and i bet you have NEVER had sex cuz your always on the enternet!!!!!!!

[bgumbyguitar]

THat comment was 3 weeks ago asshole. I copied and pasted it in protest to another asshole named iamaphony saying shit about the beatles. It was on 5 of his 70 plus retarded paul is dead clips. And i'm the one with nothing better to do. Ive moved on since and no longer look at this crap.

[darkisrael]

PAUL IS NOT DEAD. tHIS IS A BILL SHIT!!!. OOOPS. JOJOJOJO

[spillthemilk]

Woah Woah! can someone tell me if this clip is forward then backwardS? and is this a part of what video?

[Truthseeker47]

The thing is if it was Faul who said that about the films he's been looking at... We've already figured that he must've been studying films of the boys to better fit in with them as "Paul".

[lplate67]

Andthis is supposed to prove that the Paul sitting there isn't the real Paul Mc Cartney???

Oh brother!

[aliebear]

ahahahaa george was trying SO hard not to pick his nose BAHAHAHAHAHA paul is NOT dead...

[beatlesrock13]

PAULS NOT DEAD

THIS IS BULL

[ponypride111]

Um...is no one noticeing the middle finger? He did that in 64, and he STILL does it!! The whole PiD thing is STUPID! And he talkind about George and Johnny, Finding a sound on guitar!!

[mralw1969]

why is the creator of this video in Paul McCartneys friends list?

[dfhsdghadfgbhkijuihu]

is that true?

[JimBoggia]

It's interesting that you didn't transcribe the words Pual says immediately after "Those films I've been looking at" which is "That was US doing it." Play it again and listen.

[francisjavi07]

you're right Jim he DID say that was us doing it

[Zanzubar502]

Why he says "You" is because he's referring to the two guitarist, as he is typically a bassist, like "You guitarists" Not "You real beatles" lolz.

[magoo5309]

This Paul is dead crap is pure stupidity.

[RockXLight]

You, saturnstar, are a dumbass. You were pretty sure it was fake huh? Through the entire series, he has overlayed audio over mismatching video. A common practice in documentaries, einstein. And oxalicman: It's painfully obvious to anyone with half a brain that they are talking about a guitar sound. What's not obvious to someone like you is that the implication is not that they're talking about Paul is dead but that Paul who is referring to the band's past is implying he wasn't even there.

[RockXLight]

You, saturnstar, are a dumbass. You were pretty sure it was fake huh? Through the entire series, he has overlayed audio over mismatching video. A common practice in documentaries, einstein. And oxalicman: It's painfully obvious to anyone with half a brain that they are talking about a guitar sound. What's not obvious to someone like you is that the implication is not that they're talking about Paul is dead but that Paul who is referring to the band's past is implying he wasn't even there.

[RockXLight]

God, you're all idiots. Especially you, saturnstar718. You thought you were so clever seeing how "fake" this was, didn't you? Moron. It was obvious that he was dubbing the audio over a different video, just like it was painfully obvious that they weren't talking about Paul's death. The implication, for dullards such as you, saturnstar718, or you JamesStarkweather, is that Paul was referring to the band's past as if he wasn't around in those days.

[JamesStarkweather]

Do we really have to keep this hoax going? If so, why?

[oxalicman]

The audio IS from the original video. But they're not talking about Paul's death or so. They're talking about searching a sound on guitar.

[nicklele]

where'd you get the audio?

[nicklele]

where'd you get the audio from?

[iamaphoney]

it is not fake - he is saying what he is saying-but i just used some video to make it more nice-i have only the audiotape.

[oxalicman]

Is this passing?

[saturnstar718]

Nice try, but I'm pretty sure this is fake.

[kula1]

in this clip on the let it be film paul isnt saying what he says here.Either this is a fake overdub or the let it be clip is an overdub.