@circuitdesign Sarah McLachlan originally wrote it when she saw a story about a woman who's husband was dying of AIDS, and because Sarah was inspired by her strength, she penned this song. But regardless the song has been transformed into a healing grace and shared with all circumstances. I believe THE ANSWER might have been written for a friend with cancer, that is one heavy song to grasp with your heart.
I love how passionate yet respectful her fans are. As soon as she starts to sing, all the screaming and clapping will just get turned off like, immediately.
I listened to this song four months ago when my husband/best friend was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. I cried and played it over and over while he slept. We knew we had very little time. Now that he's gone, I listen to this song and I'm grateful that I got to have such a love in my life, despte the loss. Sarah has put into words and music the way it really feels... I would never have been able to create such a perfect expression of the love and the loss. Thank you...
I love her and all her songs, it's kinda sad that I always remember to hear and watch their videos when I'm not in the best moment of my life, but I think that listen to this makes me feel better in some ways, makes me feel calm. more than 12 years listening to her and I never get tired. So bad I never got to see her live.
@81kikyo Aww...Sorry to hear about Kevin. Pets rule...He's crossed the Rainbow Bridge to heaven and you'll see him again someday. Just like my Charlie
From the sound of the heart to my ears it comes, translates into my being and then i just float free, hear open to the stillness accepting the unknown and just what is available. :)
Sarah's music,for me, bypasses my thinking and speaks only to my heart and soul. She is an amazing singer, songwriter, and so beautiful. I find most of my friends who have never really "heard" her music-end up being loyal fans like I have been since I was introduced to "Fumbling towards Ecstacy".
Imagine that, someone who can actually sing that looks as beautiful as anyone I've ever seen. So, I guess it's not about showing boobs and butt. Wow. LOVE YOU SARAH.
This Song is so beautiful and i listen to it all the time and always will...It makes me get chills....God im coming to see you on Sunday in Church and i have alot to tell you..(;
I had a bestfriend with cancer. He went into remission for 2 years. It came back in his lungs and would not respond to chemotherapy. I listen to this song and think of him. It breaks ny heart everytime I listen to it. I also find some sort of peace in my heart. This is a beautiful song as are all of her songs!
@charityguthrie Sunday, July 4 12:05 - I thought of your friend and said a prayer - may ever lasting peace comfort him, as well as you - you're a good friend
This song is the essence of beauty. It just doesn't become more perfect than this. Beautiful song, beautilfully sung.......get to the core of me and makes me so touched I cry.
When I saw her sing this song in concert... I cried. This song hits me like no other. I lost my father in 1987, I was 12. It was the hardest thing I ever went through. I'm thankful for RED and songs like this that brings awareness. I was alone and hurting when he was sick. Then he passed away. This song reminds me of how I felt when I was 12 years old. It's been over 20 years. Love you Dad!!
You'll be strong tomorrow and will see another day
and we will praise it
I love the light that brings a smile across your face."
So no, he's not dead (yet). He's just sleeping, but he could die anytime (i.e., in his sleep) and hence the lyric "I lie awake and pray, you'll be strong tomorrow and will see another day and we will praise it."
I heard this song for the 1st time while taking care of my dying grandmother 3 weeks ago. When we laid her to rest last Monday we played this at the funeral. It now brings me a lot of comfort.
I Love Sarah so this is not an attack in any way shape or form. The studio version is a total emotional experience that I believe is lost here. For those that love the live version I totally respect that. I just get something out of the song that is not conveyed in this live version and I think it has to do with the band as Sarah has complete control in the studio. Wow, where did all the artists go. I miss when music was like this.
i'm really reluctant to leave a message because if its anything less than positive people savage you! .... i LOVE the live version of this i have on CD... but this live version is faster and feels rushed through! for me it loses all feeling. this feels like a popped up version to appeal to the kiddies... i dont like it at all. too much false emotion! its SHANIA TWAIN BAD! "am i in heaven here or..." from 1:511:55! AGGH!! PAINFUL!!.. just my opinion :)... ok... kill me!
I like it! But I like the slow version too...I am down with your opinion though...it makes sense. I see where you're coming from. I just like it every now and then when she speeds things up--I think it shows her versatility.
Sorry I must disagree, I love this live version way better than the cd version. It has more emotion to it with the drums and background music. The first version made me want to go AGGH! and yes the pause at the end is for dramatic effect.
Incredible song and incredible performance! I wish I knew the story behind this song.
circuitdesign 3 weeks ago
@circuitdesign It was written for a friend who later died of cancer.
SympatheticSam 1 week ago
@circuitdesign Sarah McLachlan originally wrote it when she saw a story about a woman who's husband was dying of AIDS, and because Sarah was inspired by her strength, she penned this song. But regardless the song has been transformed into a healing grace and shared with all circumstances. I believe THE ANSWER might have been written for a friend with cancer, that is one heavy song to grasp with your heart.
ilovesushirolls2012 6 days ago
ahh..... always love her music
masashi080808 3 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
I love how passionate yet respectful her fans are. As soon as she starts to sing, all the screaming and clapping will just get turned off like, immediately.
Vispering 1 month ago
@Vispering Er, they probably just switched the audio to the instruments and turned off the mics that could pick up the crowd for most of the song.
Stabby666 3 weeks ago
This live version of Hold On is my favorite song...ever.
ptwonline 1 month ago
Haunting...
riverking19 1 month ago
her music is like a warm hug that transcends your body and heals your soul when you need it the most
5howpei 4 months ago 3
Comment removed
epictongue 4 months ago 3
I listened to this song four months ago when my husband/best friend was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. I cried and played it over and over while he slept. We knew we had very little time. Now that he's gone, I listen to this song and I'm grateful that I got to have such a love in my life, despte the loss. Sarah has put into words and music the way it really feels... I would never have been able to create such a perfect expression of the love and the loss. Thank you...
like2think2much 5 months ago 5
@like2think2much God is blessing you every day!
maryz2201 4 months ago
@like2think2much So sorry for your loss.She says what few ppl can put into words....brings so much comfort. She's so talented!!!!
BxaGramsy 4 months ago
I love her and all her songs, it's kinda sad that I always remember to hear and watch their videos when I'm not in the best moment of my life, but I think that listen to this makes me feel better in some ways, makes me feel calm. more than 12 years listening to her and I never get tired. So bad I never got to see her live.
muysobrio 5 months ago 2
I always come back to sarah. Not only in sad times but in times where im "There"!
SimpsonVlography 6 months ago 2
she could sing a song about checking the mailbox and make it layered and complex and beautiful
MrDeerecub1977 6 months ago 4
I just lost my cat Kevin and decided to listen to this. Love you Kevin.
81kikyo 6 months ago
@81kikyo Aww...Sorry to hear about Kevin. Pets rule...He's crossed the Rainbow Bridge to heaven and you'll see him again someday. Just like my Charlie
Trund27 6 months ago
DIVINE <3
xoxoxify 7 months ago
Her voice is so pure...
djintheatl 7 months ago
God, she is gorgeous
halation777 7 months ago
I worship SARAH
She is sooo awesome. I can't quit listening to her.
alicewallfore 8 months ago
yeah she is
abrett1000 8 months ago
went to see her in concert WOW so pleased i did her voice is better live.
goonbob 9 months ago
I LIE THE LIVE VERSION BETTER THAN THE CD VERSION.. BUT EITHER WAY, THIS IS A BEAUTIFUL SONG..
nuthowse 10 months ago 2
love her voice.. it's so good here.. live.
billyli3 10 months ago
me encanta esta mujer, tiene alma en su voz, proyecta y vibra al encantar cantando, soy su fannnnnnnnnnnnnn
9sheiky 10 months ago
Whoever lost this amazing woman is one heck of a fool.
raindog491 11 months ago 6
@raindog491 Look up at the drum set - he's the fool. I hear he cheated on her. What as asshole.
mermaidofsuburbia 7 months ago
this song me through some rough times thANKS saRAH!!
TheEomommy 11 months ago 3
Sarah isn't just beautiful she is a smart writer too.
m1sabo 1 year ago
Simply haunting.
I had a friend that died 11 years ago - this was a song that comforted his wife. Kills me to hear this song - but I have to.
MrBleacherbum1970 1 year ago 3
(...heart open....)
lolomica 1 year ago
From the sound of the heart to my ears it comes, translates into my being and then i just float free, hear open to the stillness accepting the unknown and just what is available. :)
lolomica 1 year ago 4
Can someone who has the Mirrorball Album Please put up Possession?? Thanks.
Starr196 1 year ago
Comment removed
Shezrie 1 year ago
I have this CD and will buy more from her...love the video and to see her emotion in it.
magnalady97 1 year ago
@magnalady97
U have this CD can U post Possession? Please & Thanks.
Starr196 1 year ago
Trite
PsiCaptain 1 year ago
I love you Sara Mclachlan !!!! Your music is as beautiful as you are !
chrisachey 1 year ago
Comment removed
chrisachey 1 year ago
she's an angel to behold and listen to.
grabengbastos 1 year ago
my 2010tunedstring
lilyloha 1 year ago
oh how i miss my sister
xXxChiefGurlxXx 1 year ago
No words!
bytton 1 year ago
Sarah's music,for me, bypasses my thinking and speaks only to my heart and soul. She is an amazing singer, songwriter, and so beautiful. I find most of my friends who have never really "heard" her music-end up being loyal fans like I have been since I was introduced to "Fumbling towards Ecstacy".
Which is the greatest album ever!
gravelandgrain100 1 year ago 2
Imagine that, someone who can actually sing that looks as beautiful as anyone I've ever seen. So, I guess it's not about showing boobs and butt. Wow. LOVE YOU SARAH.
biteen83 1 year ago
i love this version: )
masashi080808 1 year ago
caricias para el dolor alma!!!!!!!!!!!!!! thankyou sarah
spiritusnoster 1 year ago
This Song is so beautiful and i listen to it all the time and always will...It makes me get chills....God im coming to see you on Sunday in Church and i have alot to tell you..(;
Emma9627 1 year ago
I wish ...
segamtius 1 year ago
I had a bestfriend with cancer. He went into remission for 2 years. It came back in his lungs and would not respond to chemotherapy. I listen to this song and think of him. It breaks ny heart everytime I listen to it. I also find some sort of peace in my heart. This is a beautiful song as are all of her songs!
charityguthrie 1 year ago 3
@charityguthrie Sunday, July 4 12:05 - I thought of your friend and said a prayer - may ever lasting peace comfort him, as well as you - you're a good friend
dewaynecullen 1 year ago
This is better than the studio recording. Outstanding performance.
SickOfPeopleMan 1 year ago
she,s a brilliant artist i realy love her music:)
darkride68 1 year ago
amazing....still gives me chills. Love her
missmelissamiss 1 year ago
Miss you Bob. You loved her, and this song will forever make me think of you.
carissadm31 1 year ago
She is so beautiful
TracynWilly 1 year ago
This song is the essence of beauty. It just doesn't become more perfect than this. Beautiful song, beautilfully sung.......get to the core of me and makes me so touched I cry.
MsErudite 1 year ago
All the songs on this live album blow away her studio versions. EPIC live album. Hold on one of my all time favorites. I love this gal.
MrHCify 1 year ago 11
@MrHCify
absolutely.. this is by far my favorite album of hers. she's awesome live.
caitylovesorane 1 year ago
appears to be a custom hand built piece...one a kind deal...
AMIRTALMUSICdotcom 1 year ago
Tim
Fly free, Love
deadswanwalking 1 year ago
When a song leaves you speechless and yet you feel the tears roll down your cheeks, that is THE hallmark of true talent by the musician.
Unpressured emotion and feeling, Sarah McLachlan is a true angel-love always from a fan who has been there.
gravelandgrain100 1 year ago 3
When I saw her sing this song in concert... I cried. This song hits me like no other. I lost my father in 1987, I was 12. It was the hardest thing I ever went through. I'm thankful for RED and songs like this that brings awareness. I was alone and hurting when he was sick. Then he passed away. This song reminds me of how I felt when I was 12 years old. It's been over 20 years. Love you Dad!!
elsewhereroad 1 year ago 3
one of the best live albums ever
whitneylova 2 years ago 3
soo good.
SteelRocker 2 years ago 4
Carla please hold on to our love and never doubt my love for you is strong. I would give anything to hold you again!
snazinhouston 2 years ago 4
This kills me, Sarah Mclachlan at her finest hour.
mwadevilg 2 years ago 6
"so now you're sleeping peaceful"
does she mean that he is dead when she says that?
SlayerSokka 2 years ago
the full lyric is
"so now you're sleeping peaceful,
I lie awake and pray
You'll be strong tomorrow and will see another day
and we will praise it
I love the light that brings a smile across your face."
So no, he's not dead (yet). He's just sleeping, but he could die anytime (i.e., in his sleep) and hence the lyric "I lie awake and pray, you'll be strong tomorrow and will see another day and we will praise it."
machintos 2 years ago
I don't know what I love the most: Her voice or her lyrics
bianca13fialho 2 years ago 3
Excelente interpretacion, me encanta esta cancion.
thundergirl77 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this song...
TheNoobist 2 years ago
This is the BEST. Nuff said
wewoninrotterdam 2 years ago 4
Sarah's so beautiful
RaidersRock 2 years ago 30
in my opinion the best canadian singer. the master of sad beauty
jfrog1000 2 years ago 6
I heard this song for the 1st time while taking care of my dying grandmother 3 weeks ago. When we laid her to rest last Monday we played this at the funeral. It now brings me a lot of comfort.
my4boysandme 2 years ago 4
Sara: Live, Studio... it's all good. I love this woman, not in a stalking/weirdo way but out sheer respect for persona and her gift.
DBC229 2 years ago 2
I'm picking up a lot more emotion in the live performance. I just can't really get into the studio version very much.
Mutnt 2 years ago 2
She wrote this song from the perspective of a woman whose husband was dying of AIDS. So emotional. So powerful. And so awesome to hear her live!
athletixbc 2 years ago
I love love love this song. Most singers live just don't sound the same. She's even better live than recorded.
Thanks for uploading.
Maidenmarmalade 2 years ago
I prefer the live version. Alot more feeling in it. Not drowned with other sounds like the studio one! Love Sarah!
springybee 2 years ago 4
I think this song is incredible.
I have to apologize though that I think this live version totally destroys it. Take a listen to the studio version and hopefully you see what I mean.
cont....
pitatoe 2 years ago
I Love Sarah so this is not an attack in any way shape or form. The studio version is a total emotional experience that I believe is lost here. For those that love the live version I totally respect that. I just get something out of the song that is not conveyed in this live version and I think it has to do with the band as Sarah has complete control in the studio. Wow, where did all the artists go. I miss when music was like this.
pitatoe 2 years ago
this is pure art
parting6 2 years ago 2
This is the song I heard when I found out my grandpa was dying. This song gives me peace.
davotchka 2 years ago
very nice beyond words
wolfgang8u 2 years ago
This song is amazing...
halifaxboyns 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
1 c0ver y0ur m0uth with y0ur hand
2 make a wish int0 it
3 cl0se y0ur hand {make it int0 a fist}
4 h0ld y0ur fist t0 y0ur heart f0r 5 sec.
5 send dis t0 3 m0re vide0s
6 t0m0rr0w will be y0ur best day ever
semamase 2 years ago
I love you susie!!! my love, you know that ur my best friend, u know id do anything for you!!!XoXoX
jodigirl1971 2 years ago
One my favorite songs. Love the meaning behind it. SOOOOOOOOO
GOOOOOOOOOOOD
terriesales 2 years ago
i looooove this version so much better <3 better to sing
SistahxofxMetal 2 years ago
she has true talent!
TSTA1920 2 years ago 4
awsome....
juliet825794 2 years ago 2
beautiful...
BELLAvita9919 3 years ago 3
I love this version, it's the way that I originally heard it. She is and always will be my absolute most favorite artist out there! :)
MusicIsMyLifeNC 3 years ago 2
she calms me
oneworldone 3 years ago 6
she is beautiful :)
lonelyleaf 3 years ago 40
This is amazing. You can tell she honestly loves the music she makes.
JamieDiana06 3 years ago 7
It's a good song but she is always good, fast, slow she does a good job
96meimei 3 years ago 5
Sarah "helps" you "hold on." Beautiful.viewpoints3
viewpoints3 3 years ago 4
Es magnifica
NaruHinaFan89 3 years ago 4
im in live with sarah mclachlan
aktake2 3 years ago
i'm really reluctant to leave a message because if its anything less than positive people savage you! .... i LOVE the live version of this i have on CD... but this live version is faster and feels rushed through! for me it loses all feeling. this feels like a popped up version to appeal to the kiddies... i dont like it at all. too much false emotion! its SHANIA TWAIN BAD! "am i in heaven here or..." from 1:51 1:55! AGGH!! PAINFUL!!.. just my opinion :)... ok... kill me!
ronotron 3 years ago
I like it! But I like the slow version too...I am down with your opinion though...it makes sense. I see where you're coming from. I just like it every now and then when she speeds things up--I think it shows her versatility.
HeartRocksOut 3 years ago 3
Sorry I must disagree, I love this live version way better than the cd version. It has more emotion to it with the drums and background music. The first version made me want to go AGGH! and yes the pause at the end is for dramatic effect.
stargazerlily86 3 years ago 3
I like the live version better just because it was the first one i heard. And i do think this one has more emotion.
I think it was good of you to express your opinion with out worrying so much about the negative marks.
emma6rose72 3 years ago 3
I've seen her live twice now and she really
kills this song. Fully. Just awesome.
Waynos73 4 years ago 5
man, id kill to see her in concert.
aprilarleneann 4 years ago 10
me too!!!!
moonfingers 3 years ago
this song brings still brings alot of emotion to me everytime i hear it
tink2682 4 years ago 5
OMG! Excellent voice and excellent live performance! Sarah such a talent!
acehayashi 4 years ago 6
I love this song, still one of my favorites from Sarah :)
butterflywings24 4 years ago 3
Excellent! I've been looking for this for a while.
surrealseraph 4 years ago 4