I don't wanna get into the whole 'better than the original' debate. It's pointless, and it's all in the ears of the beholder anyway. I will say this: I like it, and the structure of the song actually fits well with what the brothers do. I''m sure Paul Simon would be flattered to know these guys are covering him in live shows.
Respectable cover but they struggled to hold a note on "A good daaaayyyyy". They had to pull away from the mic to mask the breaking of their voices. Not remotely close to the subtle emotion and flawless delivery of Paul Simon's original. I think there are people who love this band deeply so they think they sound better than they are: Phish or Grateful Dead come to mind. Their flaws become evident when they cover other material.
Put Paul to shame? That is foolish. For starters, no cover is better than the original, ever. The harmonies are forced and overwhelming most of the time. As a matter of fact, I couldn't even watch the entire video because I had to go listen to Paul Simon as quickly as I could type. Learn some respect. Damn hipsters.
I don't wanna get into the whole 'better than the original' debate. It's pointless, and it's all in the ears of the beholder anyway. I will say this: I like it, and the structure of the song actually fits well with what the brothers do. I''m sure Paul Simon would be flattered to know these guys are covering him in live shows.
zulumoonshine 1 month ago
Respectable cover but they struggled to hold a note on "A good daaaayyyyy". They had to pull away from the mic to mask the breaking of their voices. Not remotely close to the subtle emotion and flawless delivery of Paul Simon's original. I think there are people who love this band deeply so they think they sound better than they are: Phish or Grateful Dead come to mind. Their flaws become evident when they cover other material.
elderc01 1 month ago
Put Paul to shame? That is foolish. For starters, no cover is better than the original, ever. The harmonies are forced and overwhelming most of the time. As a matter of fact, I couldn't even watch the entire video because I had to go listen to Paul Simon as quickly as I could type. Learn some respect. Damn hipsters.
mrsnikda 1 month ago
i feel so guilty saying this, but i truly believe this version is better than the original
dirkdiggler213 3 months ago
They put Paul to shame.....sorry Paul. The harmonies are genius!
JJWoosh2 6 months ago