I HATE SM! I wonder how you would feel if you were dead sick! Dammit. You guys sound like your taking some drugs. Your probably the reason why your shutting SMTOWN down! Your the reason why I don't want to be a singer anymore. Your the reason why we are going through waves of sadness. Your the reason why I dont support you and that you have very little views. Well if you haven't found out why it's because hankyung isn't in them anymore. I hope hankyung is doing well. You are messed up people, d
i made a pool under me by crying so hard at this i miss the old suju <3 can anyone tell me plz why did he leave suju aslo why did kibum leave them too anyone help
I HATE SM !!!!!!!!!!!! If it weren't for SNSD, f(x) , Shinee , TVXQ and Super Junior, you would be nothing and yet, you've managed to make TVXQ into 2 members instead of 5 , and lost Hankyung
this is so heartbreaking... i cried the moment heechul's crying picture appeared. it was sad. it suits this song. thanks for the video. =) *thumbs up*
seems a bit harsh on hangeng, u've made it sound like he had a choice. he left SM because 1: he wasn't allowed breaks to see his family 2: his schedule was so harsh that he developed gastritis and kidney disease. 3: SME rejected offers for hangeng including acting roles and endorsements and he had no right to any decisions 4: he and his family were treated poorly compared to korean members. His contract had only one condition: 'Hangeng must comply with all of SME's plans and interests'.
@dawnmoon90 last but not least, they've abused human rights. Apparently they forced him and Siwon to perform when they were both unwell and there was this issue about IV drips too.
@pakjai umm... yeh the first three points are human right violations. and about what u mentioned with siwon and IV drops is what im talking about in point 2. but to expand on ur point, hangeng and siwon once were both rlly sick and couldn't perform but they had to, so they were taken to the hospital for IV drips. however they didnt have enough time to even finish the drips so they just set it to max for a while and rushed them back to the stage. there were many cases like this, so i generalised.
To be honest !!!! I WON'T BLAME HANGENG ! I'LL NEVER BLAME HANGENG T.T If he leave , IT WILL BE THAT STUPID SM who make him leave ! Hangeng will be 4EVER SUJU <3 4EVER & EVER <3 ELF WILL alsooooooooo LOVE HIM ..
SUPER JUNIOR have 13 members FOREVER ! NO have 14 or 15 ! Leeteuk Heechul Hangeng Yesung Kangin Shindong Sungmin Eunhyuk Donghae Siwon Ryeowook Kibum and KyuHyun Start Teuk,End Kyu ' 13+1=0 13-1=0 13+ELF=The one ! AND SM.Go to hell ! Elf love SUJU ! Elf Protect SUJU Forever !!
it was definitely hard for him... after reading some articles and fan vids about HANKYUNG leaving SUJU, i realized that it was a hard decision for him, it wasn't easy, we all know how SUJU loves each other, they consider themselves as BROTHERS, he always love his suju brothers, but to push him to the limit, made him decide to leave SMEntertainment, and leave his brothers. well i guess its all in God's plan, there's a reason.
I love this video and, ya, I miss Hankyung. Really, really miss Hankyung. But remember, Super Junior is always 13. There's no goodbye for Super Junior. Hankyung just want to focus with his dream, become an actor. WO AI NI/ SARANGHAE/ I LOVE YOU HANKYUNG OPPA!!!...
I'm very touched, when a word '..Now he is standing aside, because he know that the only one that can make him happy...he is now gone.." Ohh... I'm so pity of Heechul........
กรุณาซื้อมีอัลบั้มที่ 5 จาก Kpoptown หรือ SJ - โลกโปรดเราต้องการความช่วยเหลือจากเอลฟ์ทุกคนในโลก((please buy there 5th album from Kpoptown or SJ-World please we need help from every elf in the world)请购买有Kpoptown或SJ世界第五张专辑，请我们需要从每一个ELF帮助在世界
I'm glad he stood up for himself and even tho it meant to leave well he had to and I respect that.
I really miss him but his health and human rights come first... I just wish all the oppas are safe and I hope one day they will be at peace without sment, they have all suffered.
exact things happened to DBSK :(
although the dbsk situation was worse, I don't want suju ending like that, it would be too painful to see dbsk and suju like this... they took shinhwa away, dbsk, and suju?
i learned to love super junior bcoz of hankyung and now he is already left super junior, but it doesn't mean i don't like suju anymore, instead it makes me love super junior more..but it doesn't also mean that i don't love hankyung anymore,he'll be in my heart forever..and i missed him so much already..
..i know that the possibility of him coming back is already impossible, but i can't help myself in waiting for him to be back with his brothers..
OMG! Cry to video I met Super Junior without Hankyung, but i love Heechul, and i know how painful it was for him, and it hurts!! D:! T___T!and also i know that.. Hankyunfg was mistreated by SM!! D:! and I wish all the best for u in China, and Fighting! ^^
I cried...and cried......and cried.........and cried............and flowed all my tears of sorrow towards him showing how much I love him. Hope Suju becomes 13 again including Hankyung.
You did really a good job !! I cried so much!! this really hurts, even after monts!! And he wasn't even my friend, just thinking about how his friends must feel if I even I cry than really it breaks my heart!! I just can't believe all of this!! I tried to think like ' this is not true, he will come back and bla bla' !! Everyone thinks how they want, and they way I think about him can no one change!! I don't support him!! I'm selfish and want him to be with Super Junior again!!
I do not want to forget it. these are our memories. I will always remember you and wait for you. please back to me again. but ... if not then I will pray for you happiness and success in your way. I love you. Hankyung! I love you and will respect your decision! fighting
@aimi1998 because on chinese interviews he hinted that he was treated badly and he was crying saying he had sucidal thoughts... but if you knw sm.. sm is know for the harsh treatments and unfairness to their groups.
@aimi1998 your welcome(: i dont like how so many ppl blame him from making heechul cry and stuff but its not cuz he wanted to leave suju. its cuz sm treated him so badly.. he got offered movie roles but sm automatically rejected without even telling him. but i respect his decisions and i think him and heechul still communicate lol heechul advertised hangengs new solo album on his youngstreet radio show. (x
i've seen how exhausted it is for him to be in SM...I'm happy and sad that he left SM...happy because he can finally get the rest that he deserves and sad that he won't be with his SuJu family...i will alwayz love him and think him as still part of SuJu no matter what...True ELF would always love him not matter where he is...
it's sad... especially for that great loving hanchul friendship but if i could change anything i wouldn't... i know many elf's want him to return to suju... that's not gonna happen... after all it's his hapiness that's more important right?
Hankyung was depressed. God damnit, he thought of suicide. Seriously, stop arguing. I miss him too, i miss him too much. I wish that, he would be back. Not only because of ELFs. Because of Heechul. We all know, that Heechul isn't the same without him. And please, stop saying that Super Junior isn't the same without Hankyung.
I'll always love him, no matter what. Always & forever.
@riinumuz excuse me, but he never even mentioned word 'suicide'. those are exaggerated articles. he just couldn't adapt in his ex-entertainment's system.
the second i saw the picture of heechul standing alone, i honestly started to cry!! i miss Hangeng so much, he really completed super junior! :( <3 we still love you Hannie.
i hate how people tend to make it sound like Han Geng made Heechul cry because he lost his best friend. i'm sorry but people should wake up to reality. first of all, Han Geng isn't Heechul's only friend and he wasn't the only one hurt. why don't people think about how Han Geng was feeling? second, if their friendship was really that strong, they will still stay in touch and support each other. and third, he didn't just selfishly leave SJ to chase his dreams, he was being inhumanly treated by SM.
@Mixxsu I agree with yOU!!! I DONT GET how ppl can blame hangeng for all these? why does not anyone try to empathise hangeng even though he does not show it? it does not mean he is not suffering just becos he chooses to smile to the cruel past!! FU*K those stupid ppl who r cursing hangeng for their own idols! I MEAN IT!!
@Mixxsu i don't think hangeng's choice was wrong but....you know, one of reasons of heechul's depression was that hangeng was lost contact with him. i wish for hangeng's happiness. but if he can happy after erase those memories with suju members then....i'll be sad.
@gwajadanji well, how do u know that Heechul lost contact with Han Geng? Geng said that he still keeps in touch with some of the members once in a while but didn't reveal which members. if they really were such good friends, i believe Heechul should be one of them. and he never said that he wanted to erase those SJ memories, where did u even get that idea from? yes, he left and is not a part of the group anymore. but that doesn't necessarily have to be the end of their friendship.
maybe you think you are good because you thinnk this way, but that's just you, how I see it is you being naive, not trying to be rude, you guys always say, 'oo because we love them, we suport him!! whatever you do is best' really I don't think that's the smartest thing to say!! If wanting Super Junior and Hankyung to be happy is cold than okay maybe we are cold!! you just prentend that everything is alright and try to be happy while it's not!! in my eyes you are the one who's cold!!
Ah... I was just watching the tears episode in EHB... They pretended that shindong was leaving and all and everyone started crying... in the end they said it was okay that they were pranked as long as they were together... This makes me REALLY sad.
can we ever see Hangeng with the boys on stage again? everything looks and feels so empty. one member. just one member, can make a huge difference. one member can make me cry buckets of tears,
Hankyung meant a lot to me. & I really miss him. My words to him (only wish I could say them to him:
Hankyung u were & always will be loved. Fans supported u & admired u. We know u were mistreated by SM & we know u had to make the choice. It doesn't make the hurt of u leaving any easier to bear. Heechul isn't the same w/out u there by his side & though he tries his hardest it shows. Maybe someday u can come back & bring his smile back w/ u. Love u now & always.
Heechul isnt the member i love the most in SuJu,but see him cry and upset made me feel sad too!Heechul and KangIn is the two person i know who dare to say what they mean!Heechul say straight out that he is still in contact with HK!(:
But b4 i sleep i think over how its going with Heechul,since HK isnt there anymore,and KiBum isnt there either.I think Heechul is verry lonely now!T_T
I feel so bad for him! But KiBum will return back til the 5th album!Cheer up SuJu+HK<3^.~
@SamMyoRayFan well, i know about geng mentioning heechul but i never found about heechul mentioning geng..except the one that he wish to see geng when they get married..if u have the article or link,if you dont mind to share with me?
I think it would be nice if us fans support him rather then arguing about why he left. In ways SM was discriminating him and not properly promoting him along with Super Junior. He may not look like hes upset, but I'm pretty sure deep down hes heartbroken. I mean wouldn't you? Being in a boy band with 12 other people and going through so much. I might be wrong about some facts, I haven't been listening to Super Junior for a while.
--continuation---i really want to ask if he ever considered other members those memories they shared?wont he miss those times?and the ELFs..elfs keep on fighting for them to bacome 13 no more no less,when they heard the news that the company will add 2 more members...but.. .thata his decision we cant blame him cause his the who feels the cause of his leaving...im just sad...but i know suju will continue on their success even if hangeng leave suju...SUJU MORE SUCCESS...just always be happy.
is it really a goodbye for hangeng...i feel sad because now suju will become 12...and this year they are 10..its very sad and i know that other members are sad too...the remaining super junior just keep FIGHTING!..i hope hankyung will be back in the future and suju will bacome 13 again...
i had read in the past that ELFs dont want suju to become 15...and now we cant do nothing but to let him leave cause that's what he chose...so sad..iwant to see them complete....
everyone respects his choice, but ti's a big deal because they were so close and now he's gone. no one is trying to blame him or say he betrayed them, it's just sad mostly, and he can't even have contact with them.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
What's the big deal ? he left super junior , so what ? he is still alive right ? .. It's his choice, god i dont know why you guys are making it sound like a big deal ..
@NotKellyYet We're making this sound like a big deal because we're Elfs and we know the situation. I don't wanna be rude but pleas shut up if you don't understand shit.
@NotKellyYet Of course i have time for it, when im on the computer , why would i be on the computer if i didn't have time ? And your english is really hardcore, must say !
@lilhershey7 Wow, really ? enetertaining, you must be a real fag if you start arguing with me about hangeng first and entertainment after. Lol, it keeps me entertained that youre actually are replying me .. I am just doing duh joke bby <3 ..
@NotKellyYet To you, it might not be a big deal. But to us ELFs, it is. We love super junior as a group of 15(including henry and zhoumi). I know he has the choice to choose what he wants. But, super junior as a group of 15, is much more better.
@NotKellyYet Because it's a GREAT deal for d SuJu members and most of all, HeeChul. You may had never lost a friend like this but they did. So, can you at least think from their state? If you're still saying these kind of shit comments then why bother watching these kind of video? It's for E.L.F and TRUE E.L.Fs only. Sorry if I offended you. I just wanna state out my opinion because SuJu is the best boy band I ever knew of. And I <3 them very much.
@0123NiGhTgAlZ456 Did i say i wasnt a fan? i just say that if fans is making it sound like a big deal and saying that he betrayed the other members and stuff, i just feel bad for hangeng! God! ppl just looove to missunderstand me !
@NotKellyYet just shut up ..if its not a big deal to you why did you click on this video ?we elf can feel the pain whenever the suju members feel it ..we care about them so much thats why its a big deal to us ..if you dont even care then dont watch ..
@ickanazz13 OH MY GOD! i did i even say that i didnt care? NO .. i just said that, by making it sound like a big deal it kind of hurts hangeng more. BTW? why the hell did you suddenly comment this? IT WAS FUCKIN' A MONTH AGO
@NotKellyYet i know this was a month ago ..i can still reply even if its 20 years ago cant i ?..the way you say its not a big deal sounds like you dont care ..like you dont understand how it hurted heechul when hangeng left ..i hate to see him crying and feeling lonely ..i hope you understand ..
@NotKellyYet Because We care about Han Kyung! and their getting Fewer!!
We're ELFs! IT WONT BE SUPER JUNIOR WITHOUT HAN KYUNG!!!! BUT I LET HIM GO ALREADY,, BECAUSE I WANT HIM TO BE HAPPY!, i AGREE WITH WINTIF0O!! And we love han kyung like a brother!
@NotKellyYet if you are not an elf then why the hell are you watching this video when you dont even know what the f*ck is going on! dont you have any true friends? thats why you cant even feel the pain that suju felt?! dont just barge in gurl..
@BeBeAyumi Actually he doesn't betray us. He is just doing the right thing, he had too much pain in Sment already. Even though it's sad when he leaves but Elf still support him :)
@BeBeAyumi You know what, they are not bastards! Hangeng leaved because of Sment. Kibum wants to concentrate himself on acting but he will probably come back one day. And Kangin leave to do his military service for 2 years and he will come back after so don't say that they are bastards because you're wrong!
I HATE SM! I wonder how you would feel if you were dead sick! Dammit. You guys sound like your taking some drugs. Your probably the reason why your shutting SMTOWN down! Your the reason why I don't want to be a singer anymore. Your the reason why we are going through waves of sadness. Your the reason why I dont support you and that you have very little views. Well if you haven't found out why it's because hankyung isn't in them anymore. I hope hankyung is doing well. You are messed up people, d
RoleIsland 15 hours ago
oppa I hate you nut I LOVE you more
13YukiELF 2 weeks ago
SUPER JUNIOR HANKYUNG - HANGENG I MISS YOU SO MUCH.
13YukiELF 2 weeks ago
WOW SM is really horrible! DBSK and now SUJU? what is there problem!?
TeddyCupCake 3 weeks ago
i made a pool under me by crying so hard at this i miss the old suju <3 can anyone tell me plz why did he leave suju aslo why did kibum leave them too anyone help
mblaqfreak 1 month ago
@mblaqfreak Kibum left because he wanted to focus more on acting.
jamsrjp 4 weeks ago
@jamsrjp so he is not in suju anymore :( ?
mblaqfreak 3 weeks ago
SM....>< Video make me cry so much
BenSJ208 1 month ago
All because SM! I miss you Hangeng!! T__T
OtakuJacob 1 month ago 2
It wasn't just because of acting. Health and family is far more important and sometimes even the cost of losing your best friends....
POROR0FX 1 month ago 2
MISS HIM SO MUCH....
anissa589 2 months ago
I HATE SM !!!!!!!!!!!! If it weren't for SNSD, f(x) , Shinee , TVXQ and Super Junior, you would be nothing and yet, you've managed to make TVXQ into 2 members instead of 5 , and lost Hankyung
watevergurl999333 2 months ago 3
omg, i'm crying hard... :"""
angyalevi 2 months ago 3
i miss hangeng.. Can he join back SJM like the two members - Henry and ZhouMi? My little wish...
Missout4fun 3 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
I DON'T WANNA SEE A GOOD BYE OF HIM^^^^^^Ooohhh SH!!!TT Y AM I CRYING :**:*^I REGRET 4 WATCHING THIS^^:SOMEBODY BRING HIM BACK PLEASEE....^^
babefoxify 3 months ago
Comment removed
babefoxify 3 months ago
this is so heartbreaking... i cried the moment heechul's crying picture appeared. it was sad. it suits this song. thanks for the video. =) *thumbs up*
immachix 3 months ago
seems a bit harsh on hangeng, u've made it sound like he had a choice. he left SM because 1: he wasn't allowed breaks to see his family 2: his schedule was so harsh that he developed gastritis and kidney disease. 3: SME rejected offers for hangeng including acting roles and endorsements and he had no right to any decisions 4: he and his family were treated poorly compared to korean members. His contract had only one condition: 'Hangeng must comply with all of SME's plans and interests'.
dawnmoon90 3 months ago 3
@dawnmoon90 last but not least, they've abused human rights. Apparently they forced him and Siwon to perform when they were both unwell and there was this issue about IV drips too.
pakjai 2 months ago
@pakjai umm... yeh the first three points are human right violations. and about what u mentioned with siwon and IV drops is what im talking about in point 2. but to expand on ur point, hangeng and siwon once were both rlly sick and couldn't perform but they had to, so they were taken to the hospital for IV drips. however they didnt have enough time to even finish the drips so they just set it to max for a while and rushed them back to the stage. there were many cases like this, so i generalised.
dawnmoon90 2 months ago
I'm crying at 3:19 oTATo
he's so lonely :((
capuchinocatto 3 months ago
To be honest !!!! I WON'T BLAME HANGENG ! I'LL NEVER BLAME HANGENG T.T If he leave , IT WILL BE THAT STUPID SM who make him leave ! Hangeng will be 4EVER SUJU <3 4EVER & EVER <3 ELF WILL alsooooooooo LOVE HIM ..
peiqiSJ 3 months ago
Aww thats too bad. Well I wish you all the luck in the world Hankyung. ^-^
SugarNSpice2010 3 months ago
How i hope that i can see 13 of them standing on a stage together ! no matter how long , i just want to see them together on stage !
janisnana 4 months ago 7
i should really think twice before watching this with eye makeup on...
ThatAsianChickXD 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
protectSuJuElf 4 months ago
sm.lplease learn how to treat ur artist well.
aksarafication 4 months ago
Somebody know if him continue his relationship with the others members?
daymalup 4 months ago
I love Hangeng
daymalup 4 months ago
it was definitely hard for him... after reading some articles and fan vids about HANKYUNG leaving SUJU, i realized that it was a hard decision for him, it wasn't easy, we all know how SUJU loves each other, they consider themselves as BROTHERS, he always love his suju brothers, but to push him to the limit, made him decide to leave SMEntertainment, and leave his brothers. well i guess its all in God's plan, there's a reason.
jinayafer 5 months ago
As if the maker of the video disses his choice! SM is obviously not always a great company, cos DBSK broke up and sued them as well
notalot100 5 months ago
hankyung didnt really want to leave
xmuseyflamerx 5 months ago
hey! are heechul and hankyung lovers or they're just close friends? i just wanna know... no one should get mad ok! i'm just asking!
mommybangs 5 months ago
@mommybangs really good friends
tryanda 5 months ago
@tryanda oh i see...
mommybangs 2 months ago
Comment removed
mommybangs 5 months ago
The first paragraph of the song is a piano, it hurt me to the broken hearts :-<:(
heoquynh1992 5 months ago
Omg this video make me cry!! I will miss you!!! Poor heechul, he miss you too!!
hayleyalexander1 5 months ago
really a good job we all will miss u hankyung
MsLeeola 5 months ago
I love this video and, ya, I miss Hankyung. Really, really miss Hankyung. But remember, Super Junior is always 13. There's no goodbye for Super Junior. Hankyung just want to focus with his dream, become an actor. WO AI NI/ SARANGHAE/ I LOVE YOU HANKYUNG OPPA!!!...
07galiper 5 months ago 2
I'm very touched, when a word '..Now he is standing aside, because he know that the only one that can make him happy...he is now gone.." Ohh... I'm so pity of Heechul........
Jiroxxxchenxke 5 months ago
This is so sad.. :(
MsLolipop21 5 months ago
Congratulation... You make me cry...
safirya 6 months ago
ฉากเก่าๆ ยังจำไว้ในใจ ♥
เคยรักเธอยังไง รักเธอดังเดิม !
ภาพทุกภาพยังตามติดอยู่ไม่หายไป.เสียงหัวเราะบนความอ่อนไหว
ป๋าอยากกลับมาไหม ? อยู่ตัวคนเดียวไม่เหลือใคร
เหงาเกินไปบ้างไหมป๋า ??
รออยู่ไม่ไปไหน ปล่อยให้เวลาผ่านฉันไป
เพราะลืมเธอไม่ไหวไม่ได้อยู่ดี :')
ThePANDASLIM 6 months ago
ทำเสียน้ำตาก่อนนอนอ่ะ - -
MUKIIZZZ 6 months ago
ของจริงนี่ไปแบบไม่มีร่ำลา ไม่เห็นน้ำตาของคนที่อยู่ข้างหลังบ้างเลย - -
thefcukyouu 6 months ago
โฮย โหดเหลือเกิน จัดกันหนักจริงๆ
euneun13st 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
กรุณาซื้อมีอัลบั้มที่ 5 จาก Kpoptown หรือ SJ - โลกโปรดเราต้องการความช่วยเหลือจากเอลฟ์ทุกคนในโลก((please buy there 5th album from Kpoptown or SJ-World please we need help from every elf in the world)请购买有Kpoptown或SJ世界第五张专辑，请我们需要从每一个ELF帮助在世界
koko90hoho 6 months ago
I'm glad he stood up for himself and even tho it meant to leave well he had to and I respect that.
I really miss him but his health and human rights come first... I just wish all the oppas are safe and I hope one day they will be at peace without sment, they have all suffered.
exact things happened to DBSK :(
although the dbsk situation was worse, I don't want suju ending like that, it would be too painful to see dbsk and suju like this... they took shinhwa away, dbsk, and suju?
please don't
mexi133 7 months ago
i learned to love super junior bcoz of hankyung and now he is already left super junior, but it doesn't mean i don't like suju anymore, instead it makes me love super junior more..but it doesn't also mean that i don't love hankyung anymore,he'll be in my heart forever..and i missed him so much already..
..i know that the possibility of him coming back is already impossible, but i can't help myself in waiting for him to be back with his brothers..
143geng 7 months ago
OMG! Cry to video I met Super Junior without Hankyung, but i love Heechul, and i know how painful it was for him, and it hurts!! D:! T___T!and also i know that.. Hankyunfg was mistreated by SM!! D:! and I wish all the best for u in China, and Fighting! ^^
Yuukicami 7 months ago
until now, I dont know what I'm waiting for :(
Danitymt 7 months ago 2
heechul, please cry on my shoulder :)
heedi4ever 7 months ago
fuck the people who disliked this video ..Hankyung oppa TT.TT
marianenciu 7 months ago
Nothing to say except..........GoodBye
soomin558 7 months ago
Missing Han oppa 源庚
2hly1185 8 months ago
I really miss him..
i Miss the couple of "HanChull"..
it reminds me, that super junior always take care each other. .TT____TT
yesungcloud 8 months ago
why is he out of the group?
nhelle03 8 months ago
i cryyyyy TT.TT
HE is soooo awesome and cute
come back TT.TT
TheKpopKitchen 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck you sm!
pame0193 8 months ago
I cried...and cried......and cried.........and cried............and flowed all my tears of sorrow towards him showing how much I love him. Hope Suju becomes 13 again including Hankyung.
miger224 8 months ago
................... sad!!
139anime 8 months ago
This clip is for the breakup eh
soomin558 8 months ago
theres no need to say goodbye.
xxFarenheitxxSHExx 9 months ago
God..plz bring him back to Super Junior...T.T
Serena6316 9 months ago
fuck you sm!
pame0193 9 months ago 46
Good bye, Hankyung. I will miss you. <3
But i will definitely continue to support you in your solo activites :) In my heart, you will always still be a member of Super Junior-OHEYO! <3
SUJULOVES13 9 months ago
m thuc su da khoc rat nhieu khi xem video nay.mac du moi chi biet han chua day 1 tuan.vi m ko fai la fan cua kpop.thank ban rat nhieu.
swallow1203 9 months ago
You did really a good job !! I cried so much!! this really hurts, even after monts!! And he wasn't even my friend, just thinking about how his friends must feel if I even I cry than really it breaks my heart!! I just can't believe all of this!! I tried to think like ' this is not true, he will come back and bla bla' !! Everyone thinks how they want, and they way I think about him can no one change!! I don't support him!! I'm selfish and want him to be with Super Junior again!!
far8away9 9 months ago
เอ่อะ
euneun13st 9 months ago
I do not want to forget it. these are our memories. I will always remember you and wait for you. please back to me again. but ... if not then I will pray for you happiness and success in your way. I love you. Hankyung! I love you and will respect your decision! fighting
katemin13 9 months ago 48
Comment removed
katemin13 9 months ago
I don't get it............. How do u guys know he was treated badly by sm?
aimi1998 9 months ago
@aimi1998 because on chinese interviews he hinted that he was treated badly and he was crying saying he had sucidal thoughts... but if you knw sm.. sm is know for the harsh treatments and unfairness to their groups.
mylovablewebkinz 9 months ago
@mylovablewebkinz awww i never knew that.....i think i'm glad he left cuz i wouldnt want him to kill himself! thanks for telling me anyways^^
aimi1998 9 months ago
@aimi1998 your welcome(: i dont like how so many ppl blame him from making heechul cry and stuff but its not cuz he wanted to leave suju. its cuz sm treated him so badly.. he got offered movie roles but sm automatically rejected without even telling him. but i respect his decisions and i think him and heechul still communicate lol heechul advertised hangengs new solo album on his youngstreet radio show. (x
mylovablewebkinz 9 months ago
@mylovablewebkinz exactly!!<3 sm is pretty harsh
aimi1998 9 months ago
i've seen how exhausted it is for him to be in SM...I'm happy and sad that he left SM...happy because he can finally get the rest that he deserves and sad that he won't be with his SuJu family...i will alwayz love him and think him as still part of SuJu no matter what...True ELF would always love him not matter where he is...
nkaujhmooblishlubkoj 9 months ago 2
for me his not leaving...i don't want tosay goodbye...
jenny881003 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
for me his not leaving....i don't want to say goodbye
jenny881003 10 months ago
Comment removed
jenny881003 10 months ago
NHớ Han wó
mika123789 10 months ago
it's sad... especially for that great loving hanchul friendship but if i could change anything i wouldn't... i know many elf's want him to return to suju... that's not gonna happen... after all it's his hapiness that's more important right?
AyanamiRei5kyu 10 months ago
T.T
TheJokerhyunae92 10 months ago
Hankyung was depressed. God damnit, he thought of suicide. Seriously, stop arguing. I miss him too, i miss him too much. I wish that, he would be back. Not only because of ELFs. Because of Heechul. We all know, that Heechul isn't the same without him. And please, stop saying that Super Junior isn't the same without Hankyung.
I'll always love him, no matter what. Always & forever.
riinumuz 10 months ago
@riinumuz excuse me, but he never even mentioned word 'suicide'. those are exaggerated articles. he just couldn't adapt in his ex-entertainment's system.
gwajadanji 10 months ago
FOREVER 13 + 2 = SUPER JUNIOR!! .. FIGHTING!!
internationallover07 11 months ago
the second i saw the picture of heechul standing alone, i honestly started to cry!! i miss Hangeng so much, he really completed super junior! :( <3 we still love you Hannie.
fairmanvermette 11 months ago
Hankyung oppa-which one do you like??
being solo or with super junior??
NasrinELF 11 months ago
@NasrinELF of coz wif suju..but he cant...
gdresultloh 10 months ago
@gdresultloh thts what i'm really sad about..i'm sure he feels lonely
NasrinELF 10 months ago
@gdresultloh i know that... but i really am wondering...why?
NasrinELF 4 months ago
i hate how people tend to make it sound like Han Geng made Heechul cry because he lost his best friend. i'm sorry but people should wake up to reality. first of all, Han Geng isn't Heechul's only friend and he wasn't the only one hurt. why don't people think about how Han Geng was feeling? second, if their friendship was really that strong, they will still stay in touch and support each other. and third, he didn't just selfishly leave SJ to chase his dreams, he was being inhumanly treated by SM.
Mixxsu 11 months ago 3
@Mixxsu I agree with yOU!!! I DONT GET how ppl can blame hangeng for all these? why does not anyone try to empathise hangeng even though he does not show it? it does not mean he is not suffering just becos he chooses to smile to the cruel past!! FU*K those stupid ppl who r cursing hangeng for their own idols! I MEAN IT!!
jean1571991 11 months ago
@Mixxsu i don't think hangeng's choice was wrong but....you know, one of reasons of heechul's depression was that hangeng was lost contact with him. i wish for hangeng's happiness. but if he can happy after erase those memories with suju members then....i'll be sad.
gwajadanji 10 months ago
@gwajadanji well, how do u know that Heechul lost contact with Han Geng? Geng said that he still keeps in touch with some of the members once in a while but didn't reveal which members. if they really were such good friends, i believe Heechul should be one of them. and he never said that he wanted to erase those SJ memories, where did u even get that idea from? yes, he left and is not a part of the group anymore. but that doesn't necessarily have to be the end of their friendship.
Mixxsu 10 months ago
@Mixxsu this is why i think foreigners are cold unlike us. yes, it is just culture difference. maybe.
gwajadanji 10 months ago
@gwajadanji
maybe you think you are good because you thinnk this way, but that's just you, how I see it is you being naive, not trying to be rude, you guys always say, 'oo because we love them, we suport him!! whatever you do is best' really I don't think that's the smartest thing to say!! If wanting Super Junior and Hankyung to be happy is cold than okay maybe we are cold!! you just prentend that everything is alright and try to be happy while it's not!! in my eyes you are the one who's cold!!
far8away9 9 months ago
@far8away9 i never said that hangeng is cold. i said that to mixxsu
gwajadanji 9 months ago
@gwajadanji oh one article hangeng said "heechul remains to be my best friend"
mylovablewebkinz 9 months ago
คนแปลกหน้าที่รู้จักกันดี
kwnzkwan 11 months ago
It's because we want to keep him. But we can't. ):
I feel sad for Heechul<3, sad for Hangeng<3, sad for SUJU<3. Or should i say depressed.
Hangeng<3 is Heechul<3's 2nd half, but he's gone now.
Good bye, Hangeng<3, all the best :)
SUJULOVES13 1 year ago
hankyung will be back.. believe that elf :)
arsytania 1 year ago
@arsytania how ? T-T
AyameAmuro 1 year ago
@AyameAmuro i don't know.. but I don't want to believe that hankyung leaving suju.. i want him comeback, although it's difficult
arsytania 1 year ago
@arsytania yes you right T-T
AyameAmuro 1 year ago
heechul oppa...ur supporters will always be there for u...no matter what happen next...thats because we love u n care about u....heenim sarannghaeyo
GeungSukLover 1 year ago
Kyuhyun....look so cute in this video n_n
Demon91970 1 year ago
Ah... I was just watching the tears episode in EHB... They pretended that shindong was leaving and all and everyone started crying... in the end they said it was okay that they were pranked as long as they were together... This makes me REALLY sad.
kittyboy19 1 year ago 2
suju's dead without Hangeng. That'll be 13+2-1...
Hope4freedom76 1 year ago
can we ever see Hangeng with the boys on stage again? everything looks and feels so empty. one member. just one member, can make a huge difference. one member can make me cry buckets of tears,
WittyKyu 1 year ago
i see that this video is supporting him but i kinda feel like its blaming him also
Tiera4689 1 year ago
i haven't cried for hanchul fanvid for a long time...but this one makes me cry
421only 1 year ago
Hankyung meant a lot to me. & I really miss him. My words to him (only wish I could say them to him:
Hankyung u were & always will be loved. Fans supported u & admired u. We know u were mistreated by SM & we know u had to make the choice. It doesn't make the hurt of u leaving any easier to bear. Heechul isn't the same w/out u there by his side & though he tries his hardest it shows. Maybe someday u can come back & bring his smile back w/ u. Love u now & always.
shamanking48 1 year ago 50
I love SuJu verry much!!
Heechul isnt the member i love the most in SuJu,but see him cry and upset made me feel sad too!Heechul and KangIn is the two person i know who dare to say what they mean!Heechul say straight out that he is still in contact with HK!(:
But b4 i sleep i think over how its going with Heechul,since HK isnt there anymore,and KiBum isnt there either.I think Heechul is verry lonely now!T_T
I feel so bad for him! But KiBum will return back til the 5th album!Cheer up SuJu+HK<3^.~
SamMyoRayFan 1 year ago
@SamMyoRayFan well, i know about geng mentioning heechul but i never found about heechul mentioning geng..except the one that he wish to see geng when they get married..if u have the article or link,if you dont mind to share with me?
farah6734 1 year ago
may I know the title of this song?
hirumayoichi21 1 year ago
I think it would be nice if us fans support him rather then arguing about why he left. In ways SM was discriminating him and not properly promoting him along with Super Junior. He may not look like hes upset, but I'm pretty sure deep down hes heartbroken. I mean wouldn't you? Being in a boy band with 12 other people and going through so much. I might be wrong about some facts, I haven't been listening to Super Junior for a while.
RainyLove86 1 year ago
--continuation---i really want to ask if he ever considered other members those memories they shared?wont he miss those times?and the ELFs..elfs keep on fighting for them to bacome 13 no more no less,when they heard the news that the company will add 2 more members...but.. .thata his decision we cant blame him cause his the who feels the cause of his leaving...im just sad...but i know suju will continue on their success even if hangeng leave suju...SUJU MORE SUCCESS...just always be happy.
sujukisshineess501 1 year ago
is it really a goodbye for hangeng...i feel sad because now suju will become 12...and this year they are 10..its very sad and i know that other members are sad too...the remaining super junior just keep FIGHTING!..i hope hankyung will be back in the future and suju will bacome 13 again...
i had read in the past that ELFs dont want suju to become 15...and now we cant do nothing but to let him leave cause that's what he chose...so sad..iwant to see them complete....
sujukisshineess501 1 year ago
poor heechul..
his like for ever alone!!
well dont worry heechul im always here to be with you!!
:)))))
jaz182607 1 year ago
poo heechul..
his like for ever alone!!
well dont worry heechul im always here to be with you!!
:)))))
jaz182607 1 year ago
Heechul is pitiful.. He always drinks with hankyung. He's the closest to hankyung. I'm sad that Hankyung left. ):
The Stupid SM entertainment is so bad. They don't even care if they left.
Super Junior dropped from 15(Including Henry and Zhoumi) to 12.
DBSK(TVXQ) dropped from 5 to 3.
I hope SHINee or SNSD or any other K-POP groups would not experience this.
jacexiaocute 1 year ago
This is all SMENT's fault...i cn cry everyday thinkin how hankyung and heechul wld feel
MsButtercupButterfly 1 year ago
Let Hankyung do whatever he wants.. As long as he's happy, I'm already satisfied..
Himedeloy 1 year ago
Hannie... Miss you so much T__T Come back to Super Junior. We need you!
TheYourBetrayal 1 year ago
this vid made me cry.
i think i'm a good ELF..becuz i did get angry with him b4.
the good thing is he's still fine and i believe everything great n peacefull will come to him.
he's still a part of 13.
CassyYuen 1 year ago
TT^TT
yuazchan 1 year ago
everyone respects his choice, but ti's a big deal because they were so close and now he's gone. no one is trying to blame him or say he betrayed them, it's just sad mostly, and he can't even have contact with them.
squeakysquiddles 1 year ago
I don't think super junior is a big mess now that hangeng is gone ..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What's the big deal ? he left super junior , so what ? he is still alive right ? .. It's his choice, god i dont know why you guys are making it sound like a big deal ..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet We're making this sound like a big deal because we're Elfs and we know the situation. I don't wanna be rude but pleas shut up if you don't understand shit.
wintiF0o 1 year ago 84
@wintiF0o lol, making it sound like a big deal, and leave hangeng a guilty feeling, wow , thats kind of .. like.. bullshit !
and HAHHAHAA, " we're making it sound like a big deal cos we're elfs "? WTF ?
lol, if youre a true fan you whould have respected his choice, and leave it like that ..
Lol, laughing really hard right now ..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@wintiF0o yeah you're right! >:D we're ELFs!! :D
but Im really sad.. :C
MysteriousKpop 10 months ago
@NotKellyYet u got alot of nerves for sayin dat
if u were a fan of super junior u wuldnt b sayin crap lyk dis
leave it up ur ass
lilhershey7 1 year ago
@lilhershey7 Haha, why not .. leave the childish act to somone else.. im getting sick of it ..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet haha like i care
get sick of it some more than
cuz dats all ur gettin
lilhershey7 1 year ago
@lilhershey7 lol, good, cos if i were getting some more i bet i would throw up ..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet i thought you wuldnt hav time for my "childish act"
y r u replying bak
u must miss talking to me
i bet ur so annoy
im having fun messing wit u
lilhershey7 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet Of course i have time for it, when im on the computer , why would i be on the computer if i didn't have time ? And your english is really hardcore, must say !
Bet your a tag ''''''
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet wow i didnt kno shit comes out of ur mouth too
u must have recite this to urself ova n ova again
anyways learn how to reply bak to me so i can actually get da message
well unless u wanted to reply to urself for some reason
and i kno im good at being hardcore u suld try it sometimes =]
lilhershey7 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet Lol, fail.. IRONI DA DIN IDIOT..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet lol WEAK!!!
y not? laugh everything off
u must b in a straight jacket to type like dis
MENTAL IDIOT!!!
..yawns..
not entertaining
lilhershey7 1 year ago
@lilhershey7 Wow, really ? enetertaining, you must be a real fag if you start arguing with me about hangeng first and entertainment after. Lol, it keeps me entertained that youre actually are replying me .. I am just doing duh joke bby <3 ..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet plz i aint ur baby but u r my bitch ; )
fyi i started dis game but its so full of boredom
anyways i understand u miss me
keep the love coming gurl or fag i suld say
wow ur starting to make me laugh
lilhershey7 1 year ago
@lilhershey7
Go fuck yourself , i like icecream ..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet sing it with me
where is the love?
where is the love?
where is the love?
the love
the love
...wait neva mind im feeling the love bby
lilhershey7 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet To you, it might not be a big deal. But to us ELFs, it is. We love super junior as a group of 15(including henry and zhoumi). I know he has the choice to choose what he wants. But, super junior as a group of 15, is much more better.
jacexiaocute 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet Because it's a GREAT deal for d SuJu members and most of all, HeeChul. You may had never lost a friend like this but they did. So, can you at least think from their state? If you're still saying these kind of shit comments then why bother watching these kind of video? It's for E.L.F and TRUE E.L.Fs only. Sorry if I offended you. I just wanna state out my opinion because SuJu is the best boy band I ever knew of. And I <3 them very much.
0123NiGhTgAlZ456 1 year ago
@0123NiGhTgAlZ456 Did i say i wasnt a fan? i just say that if fans is making it sound like a big deal and saying that he betrayed the other members and stuff, i just feel bad for hangeng! God! ppl just looove to missunderstand me !
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet just shut up ..if its not a big deal to you why did you click on this video ?we elf can feel the pain whenever the suju members feel it ..we care about them so much thats why its a big deal to us ..if you dont even care then dont watch ..
ickanazz13 1 year ago
@ickanazz13 OH MY GOD! i did i even say that i didnt care? NO .. i just said that, by making it sound like a big deal it kind of hurts hangeng more. BTW? why the hell did you suddenly comment this? IT WAS FUCKIN' A MONTH AGO
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet i know this was a month ago ..i can still reply even if its 20 years ago cant i ?..the way you say its not a big deal sounds like you dont care ..like you dont understand how it hurted heechul when hangeng left ..i hate to see him crying and feeling lonely ..i hope you understand ..
ickanazz13 1 year ago
@ickanazz13 get a life
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet thats what you have to do
ickanazz13 1 year ago
@ickanazz13 Im not goint to waste my time arguing with u , so just let it be .. or just grow up! omg..
NotKellyYet 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet whatever ....there's nothing to be argued about ...seriously
ickanazz13 1 year ago
@NotKellyYet Wat do u noe bout them huh???
if you dnt even care bout them then y did u even bother watching this video!!
Maybe u dnt care but atleast let people do wat they want to do....
They care bout singers juc like if u care for urself or ur lovers friends and family.
shiningstarz209 11 months ago
@NotKellyYet shut the fuck up bitch. we're ELF's and we know what we are doing! >.<
wynt96 11 months ago
@NotKellyYet Because We care about Han Kyung! and their getting Fewer!!
We're ELFs! IT WONT BE SUPER JUNIOR WITHOUT HAN KYUNG!!!! BUT I LET HIM GO ALREADY,, BECAUSE I WANT HIM TO BE HAPPY!, i AGREE WITH WINTIF0O!! And we love han kyung like a brother!
MysteriousKpop 10 months ago
@NotKellyYet if you are not an elf then why the hell are you watching this video when you dont even know what the f*ck is going on! dont you have any true friends? thats why you cant even feel the pain that suju felt?! dont just barge in gurl..
lady4767 9 months ago
darn i cried again b/c of kim hee chul!
nerotsuya 1 year ago
what's that vid where heechul cried because hankyung leaves?
syjoy 1 year ago
this OPV made me sadly again TT^TT
ButterflyAndSunflowe 1 year ago
I'mstill hoping he will be back. And i always will hope! suju 13! <3
GroficaOdMetropole 1 year ago
he is one of my favorite member...上帝保佑 (Shàngdì bǎoyòu) and 我愛你 (Wǒ ài nǐ)!! i will surely miss him...
charmstarter89 1 year ago
I'm going to miss Hankyung. Even thou I don't know him that well. But from all the vids I've seen of him he's really funny.
FFNut20000 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
bye hangeng, you & the other 2 bastards made me like suju, but you betrayed us a big time...
BeBeAyumi 1 year ago
@BeBeAyumi Actually he doesn't betray us. He is just doing the right thing, he had too much pain in Sment already. Even though it's sad when he leaves but Elf still support him :)
wintiF0o 1 year ago 22
@BeBeAyumi You know what, they are not bastards! Hangeng leaved because of Sment. Kibum wants to concentrate himself on acting but he will probably come back one day. And Kangin leave to do his military service for 2 years and he will come back after so don't say that they are bastards because you're wrong!