Added: 11 months ago
From: rumerofficial
Views: 315,906
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (205)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow, in the Karen Carpenter echelon, and singing David Gate's song! Wowwie.

  • Walter, thanks for staying inside on that rainy day. I do believe that inspired Rumer to record this !

  • why she and adele distant so far?

  • Comment removed

  • She has an amazing beautiful clear voice. You don't have voices like this anymore. Pure and natural not forced into what the music big wig want.

  • i was thinking the same thing as I listened to this song

  • Comment removed

  • Absolutely beautiful!!!

    

  • ohhhh very nice voice like Karen Carpenters voice

  • Her voice is so similar to Karen Carpenter´s voice, she has a really nice songs like "saving grace"

  • @vivianovich i thought the exact same thing

  • just the kind of music i like

  • so 70s. I love. This isn't Rumer Willis, is it?

  • @daiser720 No she's British singer

  • lol.. the guy in this video makes me laugh every time he pops up.

  • Comment removed

  • Sounds kinda like Karen Carpenter. Very nice to hear this style again instead of all that KRWrap music!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Great to hear these songs again after many years. Her voice reminds me more of Dusty Springfield than Karen Carpenter.

  • She has an incredible story, she also has the voice too :)

  • OMG. Karen Carpenter really got reincarnated...O_O

  • @TheIncredibleDanaB And David Gates from the group Bread had a big hit with that song way before Hootie...back in 1978. It was the theme song from the movie "Goodbye Girl."

  • She looks like my teacher.

  • Comment removed

  • this song is good, but why the view is that low??? so weird

  • I love ♪Goodbye Girl♪

  • i love her so much.

    i use to listen to her music when i am naked taking a shower. <3

  • Flat. The original is better.

  • oh.. it's touch my heart., miss that one who said "goodbye" to me.

  • The song and the voice oft this woman are just magic. If you take a look at the video two or three times you can find artistic scenes created like photographs that suits perfect with the lyrics. Love it.... Cheers from Mexico City

  • This is a song by the great David Gates of BREAD fame. Rumer has a lovely voice....first heard about her because of the the recent JOHNNY ENGLISH film [end theme I believe in you].

  • SUPERB!!! (^_^)v

    ★★★★★ Like Click

  • This song sounds like something from the Carpenters and she does sound like Karen C.

  • @Starkardur There have been a LOT of Karen C. comparisons here... and I DO see some similarities in their

    phrasing.. BUT- KC's voice, being a contralto, was usually pitched a fair bit lower.. I think Rumer is her own person, a great singer in her own right. Plus, her music can cross practically ANY demographic.. it's not

    hard to imagine all kinds of people, from Kids to Grannies, getting into this... it's just sweet music, period.

  • NICE...NICE... :) :) :)

  • The Goodbye Girl with Richard Dreyfuss and Marsha Mason.... aaahhh, lovely. One of my all time favourite films. Neil Simon is brilliant. Nice version of it.

  • let me tell you goodbye...doesn't mean forever....

  • SHE HAS A GOOD VOICE, SHE HAS THE TONAL QUALITY OF A KAREN CARPENTER, BUT NOT THE DEPTH. SHE SINGS THIS SONG LIKE SHE CAN'T SEEM TO HOLD A NOTE VERY LONG. PLUS WHERE WAS THE EMOTION BEHIND THE WORDS? IT FELT A TAD FLAT TO ME. HOPEFULLY , RUMER WILL KEEP WORKIN ON IT.

  • @77USMCvet Agree!

  • awesome cover... david gates will be proud. rumers voice is like cough syrup on a really sore throat...soothing and gentle. ps. love the guy in the video

  • karen carpenter 11....

  • My fave number by david gates..

    Yes she does a nice job..

    Lovely voice..

  • My heart's so crushed. So I just kept on listening to this song. It makes me feel better.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • love this really makes yu feel all your emotions at once xx

  • David gates cant be beat on this tune. Altho she is really nice and i like her voicw all the same.

  • isnt that girl in the video is the rumer willis of sorority row?

    im confused

  • less then a million view ? why?

  • @karl984 the rest haven't got the internet :P

  • @karl984 everyone enters doodbye girl and then gets diverted to goodbye by spice girls.

  • @karl984

    help and a million views is just a beginning... promote what you love.

  • WOW its just sounds like karen carpenter, amazing voice.

  • @helen4131 Nice, i was thinking the exact same thing

  • Never thought I'd hear Karen C again ..... wow

  • The carpenters , the return

  • This has always been one of my favourite songs by David Gates in his days with Bread. Have to say that Rumer makes a good job of this cover. Of course, when a song is superb in the first place, a cover version always has a chance.

  • WOW WOW GREAT VOICE LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I already heard similar song that was「I'm In Love-takuro yoshida」.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • can't stop listening to this song beautiful

  • I saw her for the first time over the weekend at Glastonbury.

    Lovely singer, Beautiful Girl!

  • きれいな歌=beautiful song

  • Comment removed

  • very reminiscent of karen carpenter beautiful voice

  • "Baby it's called 'goodbye' because we'll never together again"

    X)

  • Eleven out of ten stars. This song is perfection.

  • I love her voice.

  • I wish would cover Find me by David Gates.

  • Really like this. I wish Rumer would do some of the Carpenters numbers as her voice has the same distinctive depth and quality of Karen Carpenter. The same style of music as the Carpenters certainly evokes some happy childhood memories.

  • @birstallwatch MY MOM SANG KARENS SONGS TERAS OF MANY MEMORIES GOOD TO WATCH AS I REMEMBER MOMMA AND GREAT COMMENTS

  • @birstallwatch MY MOM SANG KARENS SONGS TEARS OF MANY MEMORIES GOOD TO WATCH AS I REMEMBER MOMMA AND GREAT COMMENTS

  • @birstallwatch I fully agree!

  • @birstallwatch I totally agree....I thought that same thing when I heard her. Good feature on her this morning on CBS Sunday Morning. I am her newest fan!

  • let me tell you goodbye doesn't mean we never be together again :)

  • goodbye mum, untill we meet again. R.I.P XX

  • Well, that's breakfast and the washing done, now to the library, see you.

  • SUPERB

  • hooo sweet ! good job Rumer!

  • touching... nice rendition..

    

  • Goodbye doesn't mean we'll never be together again. Goodbye doesn't mean forever

  • This is a cover from the 70's and God, I hope we're moving toward more true blue songwriting like this. One of my favorite songwriters is Tony Terraciano. Hope to hear some soulful songs from him soon. Saw him about a year ago. His site only sports one song, but I heard him with a guitar and it was amazing. Plus, he's sexy as shit! The UK always taps into the trends and hopefully it trickles into the market here in the USA. God knows we need it.

  • superb!. :D

  • I, too heard her for the first time on NPR today.....The clarity and purity of her heartfelt vocals, reminded me of other artists from an earlier era. BRAVO!

  • awesome..

  • Heard Rumer on NPR this morning...absolutely love her! Sounds so much like Karen Carpenter. Lovely!

  • Wonderful song and a wonderful new voice.......

  • She reminds me of Karen Carpenter....a great voice. When is she coming to the United States?

  • so easy on the ears.what a lovely voice rumer has. a comfy chair a cup of tea.and this song playing. ahhh bliss.

  • Such a wonderful, warm, classy voice. Blissful !

  • Love this, & for very personal reasons right now. Makes me think of someone special each time I hear it. x

  • My mum calls me her goodbye girl because I emigrated to Australia 3 years ago and said goodbye! Very emotional for me, great song, love it.

  • she has an amazing voice, shes the tops , karen carpenter would have been proud of her beautiful song

  • She sounds so much like Karen Carpenter...love it :)

  • Whoever are the 5 people who disliked this must obviously not know what music is

  • holy i love her voice so tender, its make me so emo(*_*)\,,/

    

  • really like the song on her voice...

  • Excelente cover de David Gates...que recuerdos

  • love it

  • cool song,thank god for you tube,the new carpenters!

  • I love this song! Beautiful voice, beautiful sentiment; like a new dawn on old worries and lost loves...

  • Heard this on the radio and iv been looking for it for ages- I hate radio statios that dont tell you the songs detailes,

    Thank God I found it, she had an amazing voice

  • This song was written by David Gates and he recorded it with his band Bread way back. Nice to know it's getting another interpretation.

  • Brilliant!

  • I once let a lady go to the other side of the world 25yrs ago .Now we are in contact again .Love this song and love Rumer's voice

  • @davetrucker I know what your feeling bro, ...my thai girlfriend had to go back to thailand 2 weeks ago and these past two weeks have been hard! but one day I hope we will be together again .......this song reminds me of her!

  • i once let a lady go to the other side of the world 25yrs ago. we have just got back in contact love this song from the first time i herad it. Rumer as such great voice hope she goes far

  • A wonderful voice - such soaring vocals. And yes, I too thought this was a KC track.

  • The first time I heard this round a friends house on their ipod deck, I asked, 'Which Carpenter song is this?'

  • @BethBist u know what i said exactly the same thing..was it a lost carpenters song

  • I thought Karen Carpenter's voice was basically a one in a million....

    I was mistaken...Rumer you are amazing and i really think you should go for some carpenters songs as i know you can match her voice...

  • It's like a song for the Eurovision song contest in the 1970's...

  • Lionel Ritchie - Easy. Enough said.

  • Karen Carpenter of the 10s!!! 

  • awesome she sounds like the greatest ever female vocalist Karen Carpenter r.i.p a bright future me thinks thanx for posting

  • I'll be leaving a special lady very soon to start a new job away. One day 'special lady', one day ........ I'm going to miss you. Will you miss me though ? Now that's a whole other question ! x

  • Horrible... all her songs sound the same...

  • Remember going to see the movie Goodbye Girl and was a David Gates fan since teen years .A really great cover by Rumer 

  • Amazing!!

    

  • Rumer has so much class.she is awesome

  • i dont know if it is me or if anyone else feels the same way but this lady singing this song sound just like karen carpenter even when she sings live.

    i find that quite spooky but in a good way as i just love the carpenters and im only 28yrs lol.

  • @michealknight1000

    You're right! The first time I heard her, I thought hearing Karen Carpenter....

    Sooooooooooooooooooooo great!

  • Whoops - The Goodbye Girl stars Richard Dreyfuss and Marsha Mason!!!!!!!!

  • If you like this video then check out the original film that the song comes from. It's called 'The Goodbye Girl' and stars Richard Dreyfuss and Marsha Hunt and it's one of my all time favourite films. A great bittersweet comedy and one that I can watch over and over again. Also check out the original version of the song written and performed by David Gates, the songwriting genius from Bread. I love this cover version which Rumer performed brilliantly on her recent live tour. Hit - yes please!!!

  • I did not know that she was from Pakistan.

  • I would love to hear her singing a duet with Josh Groban. That would be

    heavenly. !

  • Yeah this was on the radio a few hours ago and I asked my mum who it was and she said "Umm Carpenters"...and I was like what's it called and she was like "Goodbye something"...and I was like I own enough Carpenters albums, how would I pass a beaut like this, just checked the station and it's this. Stunning!

  • I can listen her album all day

  • love the video - but feel I want part 2 to it :-)

  • What a great singer. It's a great song as well. Sarah is amazing!!

  • Her voice gives me goosebumps...effortless like Karen Carpenter. Wow well worth the wait for a voice like this ...C x

  • This girl sounds like the late Karen Carpenter i never thought we'd the likes again

  • we thought it was Karen Carpenter when we heard it on the radio at work !

  • Reminds me of the Great Karen Carpenter and Dusty Springfield, Wonderful.

  • oh my god she sounds just like Karen Carpenter

  • @joannewyers I actualy thought it was Karen Carpenter when i first heard this!!

  • So nice and easy to listen to

  • LOL!

  • best voice since Eva Cassidy

  • She has a beautiful voice. I'll have to see her live. Fantastic vocals.

  • Great Cover

  • Superb voice so smooth and easy on the ears...........  mmmmmmmmmmmmmm

  • this is such a charming tune!!! i could hear it over and over and it will still be so special to listen to!!! such a valuable member of the music business!!!!! LONG MAY YOUR SUCCESS CONTINUE!!!!! XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX­XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

  • Wonderful concert in Brighton , it was so nice to meet Rumer afterwards . Loved ' Take me as I am ' and was pleasantly surprised at her versatility in covering ' You really got a hold on me ' and ' Stoned soul picnic ' . Outstanding talent .

  • Went to see her live on tour in brighton, blew us away, simply stunning, and have worn the cd out !

  • Oh just so wonderful.... great cover... really suits her voice, her style. She really is SO talented!

  • Rumer - your bed is a bit narrow!

  • Absolutely beautiful!!!

  • wonderful, simply wonderful!

  • Two things what wally put a dislike to this video, omg what are you doing here? 2, this has been  re-arranged from the video,,good song but prefer make it with you.

  • The vid is soooo 2011. x

  • @icetemper The video is soooo 2011 ? How about 2007 Kate Nash Foundations made by dir. Kinga Burza.

  • Unexpected, The new Duo, Ready to Storm the Charts!

    Rumer is alright as well ;)

  • LOVE, LOVE, LOVE THIS WONDERFUL GIRL... SHE IS PHENOMENAL... I WILL BUY THIS... SPINE TINGLING AS I LISTEN******* THANKS RUMER **** XXXXX

  • Didn't read the title properly and thought it's a new song, lol.

    Great video, can't wait for the next album!

  • Great video, the only thing i would say is, i would have looked better than the guy you had,lol x

  • Dave Frost

    YOU NEVER STOP AMAZING ME WITH YOUR BEAUTIFUL VOICE X

  • I love u rumer, amazing. <3

  • Brilliant London show, - loved your version of Alfie! cant wait for the next album!

  • It's a cool song, but the video is kind of weird.

  • Comment removed

  • Just wonderful. Loved the Oxford gig, where you turned every song from the Album into my favourite. One downside. It ended. Can we do it all again this coming Saturday!? ;-)

  • Love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Tremendous artist, even better singing live! Enjoyed Glasgow concert in December (she's very warm and friendly to fans, even takes time to talk after the show), and look forward to tomorrow's one in Edinburgh. Hope she manages some time for sight-seeing before heading back 'down south'!!

  • Great cover and I love it....When I hear this song it make me feel everything is ok with the world.

  • this video captures the essence of the person - stunning

  • seen Rumer perform at Gateshead on Tuesday and only thing I can say is Superb!!!! Both her and her brilliant band and backing singers were just fantastic