what a sense of humour he has! but what he does is magic and he knows how to transport that magic to these young people. Great rehearsal music by the way, never heard it before...
Hello, I'm sure conducting is not about the shallow judgment of a conductor, but emotions, concentration and vision, which are displayed in this video very well. And on no account about human language skills. I saw a Prokofiev-Rachmaninoff interpretation by Gergiev last weekend, and the orchestra worked very well. That's the point.
True it is, but I have to give more credit to the orchestra who can actually figure out what he's trying to do with his hands/arms. Sure doesn't make it eas y for them. Take the downbeat to his Mahler 2 - it looks more like he's having a seizure than conducting. Though there are times when he appears very old school a la Stakowski. Certainly not a stick waver hence the highly emotive qualities which can be distracting.
the border line between great musicians as Gergiev and normal muscians is the capability to understand that conducting is make music not beat the tempo.
@panosJ3 I'd have to disagree. I would not call anyone who believes that beating time is conducting a musician at all. Musicianship starts with this understanding.
what a wonderful, deep, caring, passionate conductor!!
Thylovely4you 1 week ago
great students.
jin12345678 3 months ago
is it possible to know the name of the song starting from 2.22 - 2.57 ? it sounds so beautiful.
Pookja 1 year ago
Rachmaninov, Symphony No. 3, 2nd mov.
MaestroSerge 1 year ago
q teso! muy bn
sararonald 1 year ago
james lowe by far and away the best of the students
padsax1 1 year ago
what a sense of humour he has! but what he does is magic and he knows how to transport that magic to these young people. Great rehearsal music by the way, never heard it before...
dajohnthomas69 1 year ago
2:20
ivolva 1 year ago
Comment removed
ivolva 1 year ago
What's the fiddle concerto here? Sounds great.
ilkinond 1 year ago
It just shows you how much of a God Gergiev is, look how little he does in that scene and yet how well it works!
kotetsu131 2 years ago 6
2:23 very good!!
hornplayer84 2 years ago
Rachmaninov's Third Symphony is a jewel.
DarkRaimundo 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
DarkRaimundo 2 years ago
3:50 signature Gergiev hand motion =D
FungoBoy 2 years ago
Well done!
maxicaas 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
From what I've seen of his own conducting, Gergiev is the LAST person who should be giving a conducting masterclass!
Biber0315 2 years ago
Hello, I'm sure conducting is not about the shallow judgment of a conductor, but emotions, concentration and vision, which are displayed in this video very well. And on no account about human language skills. I saw a Prokofiev-Rachmaninoff interpretation by Gergiev last weekend, and the orchestra worked very well. That's the point.
theMerghe 2 years ago 2
True it is, but I have to give more credit to the orchestra who can actually figure out what he's trying to do with his hands/arms. Sure doesn't make it eas y for them. Take the downbeat to his Mahler 2 - it looks more like he's having a seizure than conducting. Though there are times when he appears very old school a la Stakowski. Certainly not a stick waver hence the highly emotive qualities which can be distracting.
Biber0315 2 years ago
@Biber0315
It's Mahler Symphony 6 I think. ;)
silk2626 1 year ago
No. Mahler 6 is at the end of this. The "fiddle" portion is from Rachmaninov: Symphony No. 3 (Mov. 2)
logenisti 1 year ago
the border line between great musicians as Gergiev and normal muscians is the capability to understand that conducting is make music not beat the tempo.
panosJ3 2 years ago 6
@panosJ3 I'd have to disagree. I would not call anyone who believes that beating time is conducting a musician at all. Musicianship starts with this understanding.
SuperSax875 1 year ago
Hello people making up work, or doing work one year from now...
failedassassin 2 years ago
the image quality is amazing!
you can even try hi-definition next time, so ppl can watch it in full-screen!
CIinton 3 years ago