Added: 2 years ago
From: MicheleBell1
Views: 32,673
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (55)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow, a stellar performance by Judy. Too bad she was robbed of the academy award for this role.... that award went to Grace Kelly for a mediocre film called The Country Girl.

    Sorry Judy, life is not fair.

  • Magnificent

  • I don't think it's fair her daughter won an Oscar for Cabaret and Judy didn't win one. :/

  • she has the kind of voice that the pitch/tone appeals to alot of people, alot of people.

  • do you think you could make this without the sides cut off?

  • Lilly Savage said that she herself, wasn't 'born in a trunk' but was put in one, soonafter.

    .

    Cheers

    from

    del-boy.

  • she made me the big mo that I am and she is to be held responsible for earthquakes and other 'natural' disasters that occur now

    The sad horrible truth of it all

  • i heard they're remaking this with Beyonce..like no offense to beyonce your great and all but wtf is that you cant remake this at all!!!

  • !?!?!?!?!?!?

  • Three people (dislikes) are dicks without taste!

  • That lillte bitch Grace Kelly stole Judy's OSCAR!

  • @MrThesheenster everytime i hear her name i go into an all out cringe and i actually really messed up my neck from hearing that abomination. also hyperventalation is a common occurance. that name once came up on tv while i was babysitting....it could have been dangerous

  • I can't believe how young she was here and how she looked much older than her years.

  • THE biggest and worst BLUNDER in Oscar History ...Judy not winning the Academy Award for Best Actress for this perfect , Amazing performance !! Shame on you Academy ...Shame , Shame , Shame !!!

  • judy was and still is one of the best singer actors ever. She should have won the oscar for this movie but Hollywood stinks. Judy we love you miss you and thank you for every note you ever sang and thank you for Liza!!!!!!

  • @MrFrankangelo All I can say is I agree with your appraisal 100%. She was a living miracle of talent.

  • I am going to go out on a limb here adn say that I dont think this was half as good as what people have built it up as.....its incredibly similar to the original in 1937 - certainly not oscar worthy. Dont get me wrong, i love judy as much as the next person - but the acting 7 years later in judgement at nurembourg was far more superior - as was the movie itself. as for the born in a trunk number, i dont see its point of it other than it being a show case for her singing...

  • Powerful, powerful voice; never heard her sing this well before or after. Amazing.

  • Those 3 people that gave this a thumbs down are COMMUNISTS!!!!!

    This is America!! And Judy is a national treasure!!!!!

  • @disney1678 What The FUCK doesn being a communist have to do with not liking the clip?!! Let the people who don't like the clip express they're like or dislike without you throwing your ignorance at them!

  • Beautiful. Sad, because she eventually ruined her voice from singing in a flat, full-throated style. (pretty, but it wore her down)

  • Absolutely brilliant.

  • the note at the end is AMAZING

  • Every time you watch Judy, you get the sense she was talking to you, that the song was meant for you. each performance was undoubtedly from her heart. :)

  • @ArielBlaise I couldn't agree more; she was a true talent.

  • Pocatello, Idaho

  • dammit she should of won the oscar for this movie!

  • An explosion of genius. Brilliance oozing from every pore.

    Though I am NOT proud of it, I did do a little scrunch/squash on the edge of Grace Kelley's tomb in that church in Monaco, when I last went there. It was impulsive.

    No offense to Grace, but I sort of kicked her headstone. Discreetly. Totally unplanned, and I pray Grace is resting in absolute peace, but I think Judy would've laughed her ass off.

    Maybe she was.

  • @Vengeance509 Ha ha that made me laugh. I agree, the Oscar shouldn't have gone to the 'Ice Queen'.

  • @Vengeance509 that's the best comment I have ever read! :D

  • @Vengeance509 BEST COMMENT EVER.

  • @Vengeance509 Well...I was! you're my hero

  • Ooooh! I Enjoyed every minute of the performance,she really was great and full of warmth,MGM wuz damn lucky to have her,screw Louis B. Mayer and his "hunchback" comments,bravo judy! BRA-VO!!

  • do you have access to the wide-screen version? you did a nice job with this, would be great if you can do same with widescreen. composition is so great with original perspective.

  • i love this movie so much!! i cry every single time i watch this!!!

  • oh yea gay people really love judy

  • @selenabritroma : I think most people who were around when she was around, and even afterward are drawn to her...not just gay people. She IS talent. Period!

  • @bosma64 I totally agree. I am a masculine 42yr gay man who is out and not afraid of who I am. I am not the stereotypical gay guy but I have great taste and even before I realized I was gay I loved every thing Judy did. She is the Greatest Entertainer the world has ever had. I can only imagine how magical it must have felt when she was alive and on stage. Because her work is so incredible on film, TV and in recordings, I can't image the feeling what people experienced when they seen her LIVE!

  • @selenabritroma and you you don't have not most interesting to say. stupid.

  • thank you for sharing this! it's been a LONG time since I saw it and it really is fabulous.

  • I ABSOLUTELY LOVE JUDY GARLAND !! SHE WON MY HEART OVER WITH HER WONDERFUL PERFORMANCE IN "WIZARD OF OZ !!" SHE WILL LIVE IN MY HEART FORVEVER !!

  • Man I love Judy Garland with all of my heart!!!

  • @mrspatrickcampbell Judy looked dreadful here? She looked the healthiest she had in years and in these segments of 'A Star Is Born' she absolutely glowed. Look at her in the late 60's and she looked painfully unhealthy...but even then she had charisma no one has ever been able to match.

  • this is an amazing song, with an amazing woman, with an amazing voice. Amazing.

  • You're pretty cool, huh?

  • i am watching this in my music class :D

  • very cool

  • Her voice is just vibrating with raw emotion and experience. A very honest performance that is so much like what she really experienced in her own life. Her voice is so powerful and she really lives up to her Power-Lungs description that they gave her as a child.

  • @415montgomery - so true....it striles me how the "late" Garland seems already to anticipate the "early" Liza Minelli....

  • I liked the Judy "flashbacks", but that sequence looking for a job, and that LAST part of "Yes!" "No!" was just the Best!

  • @VideoSam16

    Haha! I so agree. The movie is spectacular. Damn Jack Warner for brutally cutting a perfect movie! I long for the fully restored version.

  • Judy Garland: beautiful voice, beautiful image, beautiful soul. She was one of the most beautiful people that ever graced this earth. Words cannot describe how much she has changed my life through her talent. :D

  • Terrific and what a great clear picture with great sound. You did a wonderful job. Thanks so much for posting!

  • Oh, how I admire you Judy Garland!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more