I am from Hong Kong and your Cantonese is not bad atall !!!! You really achieved a lot in 3 years, and you should be proud of yourself, cuz it is more difficult to learn Cantonese than Mandarin.
Besides, I can totally understand what you are saying so cheers !
You speak very fluent Cantonese, but you probably have picked up some "Toi Shan" accent from somewhere like China Towns of your country. However, Most Cantonese can't speal English as fluent as the way you speak Cantonese. So don't feel bad about your Cantonese.
Cantonese is much harder to learn than Mandarin. I believe cantonese has 7 tones and Mandarin only 4. You are doing great! Don't take bad comments to heart. Accents don't matter in the real world. Being able to understand each other is most important and I certaintly understand every word you said. Congrats!
You're absolutely right! Native Mandarin speakers often have difficulty with Cantonese tones because there are more tones in Cantonese than Mandarin.
On the flip side, Cantonese speakers often don't have difficulty with Mandarin tones but have difficulty with the pronunciation of some words like 只 because of the "r" sounding beginning.
You're already speaking quite good Cantonese compared to some Chinese who are raised up outside China/Hong Kong. So don't be too harsh on yourself.
I have the same problem as a Cantonese speaking person learning Mandarin (so I can talk with my girlfriend in her language, hehe...). Even though many words are like the same, it's hard to get the pronunciation right.
Anyways, keep up the good work and don't give up :)
I am learning German as a native Chinese and I know how you feel. Sometimes it is annoying hearing German people complain about how weird my German is. But then I will say back, my native language gives me ZERO advantage into German, The same like you, you should tell them how hard it is as foreigners to learn Cantonese.
Good job. I'm very impressed. FYI, I've found that a big factor to learning a foreign language is speaking it with confidence. If you feel shy or hesitant, it will only hold a person back.
Your accent is okay.Don't be too hard on yourself.I know a lot of Mandarin speakers who don't speak Cantonese as well as you do even though they have been in a Cantonese speaking environment for years.Keep on the good work.
You're 90% there already. Well done. You'll do just fine in HK. Cantonese is tough to learn. You did well!
trent8002003 1 year ago
Well ... you speak quite good, not bad. Strictly speaking just a bit not very local, I can listen to all your words, keep it up!
johnsonlamhk 1 year ago
great,U are perfect,i like all of ur video.
Narahitaya 1 year ago
white + vietname
CanCayate2 1 year ago
@CanCayate2 ----- ??? I'm not vietnamese.
cantehk2 1 year ago
cantehk,
guon do xian pei xi gem.
fuck your '南粵共和國'
CanCayate2 1 year ago
客家人,獨立吧!
washingzoo1 1 year ago
希望更多廣東人鼓勵你,繼續學,繼續講,而唔好咁多批評其他學廣東話既人 !
Hope more and more Cantonese people encourage you to learn more ! You are very good already ! Keep it up !
washingzoo1 1 year ago
獨立吧,廣東。前進吧,南粵共和國。
cthakka 1 year ago
唔洗唔開心架!我覺得你已經講得好好架喇!只要多啲練習就一定會講得岩!唔洗驚!
No need to be sad ! I think you've done a great job already ! Practice makes prefect ! No worries !
AVRILARKSON816 1 year ago
I can understand 100% :)
danielairy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
are you chinese?
lukethewall 1 year ago
i can listen,100%
not bad
MrOh4 1 year ago
GOOD
加油
2wp0218 1 year ago
I already watched around 7mins about yourself introduction !!
Actually do u know Cantonese is the most difficult language to learn on the world??!
If u ask me wt do i think your Cantonese......i just can answer to u......
WELLL!! Is very Good!!!
And i admire your patience......also your video show me you really love your Hong Konger Wife...it's so great!!!
Anyway, Keep Going!!! Never give up to improve your Cantonese!!^^
P.S : Please check your msg box on youtube when u're free..
morris8268 1 year ago
u r pretty good!!
POONyukfai 1 year ago
I am from Hong Kong and your Cantonese is not bad atall !!!! You really achieved a lot in 3 years, and you should be proud of yourself, cuz it is more difficult to learn Cantonese than Mandarin.
Besides, I can totally understand what you are saying so cheers !
surefireaccount1989 2 years ago
You speak very fluent Cantonese, but you probably have picked up some "Toi Shan" accent from somewhere like China Towns of your country. However, Most Cantonese can't speal English as fluent as the way you speak Cantonese. So don't feel bad about your Cantonese.
woowoototo 2 years ago
sounds like it's a regional dialect from guangdong somewhere.
djonutube 2 years ago 2
Cantonese is much harder to learn than Mandarin. I believe cantonese has 7 tones and Mandarin only 4. You are doing great! Don't take bad comments to heart. Accents don't matter in the real world. Being able to understand each other is most important and I certaintly understand every word you said. Congrats!
KingOfBeatdown 2 years ago 3
nahhh, ur cantonese is fineee, ppl r just critizing u, ur cantonese is pretty good, just continue with the hard work ;)
nomad2817 2 years ago
I think you speak it pretty good! You do have the accent but I can totally understand you. Add oil! :D Don't give up!
brightsidexchoke 2 years ago
Not a failure at all. I understand your Cantonese. You spoke a bit too fast. Slow down and pronounce the words clearly. Keep up the good work.
SCADFDS 2 years ago
i hate it how ppl swear a lot these days...as if it's our nature to do so....
KevoCatz302 2 years ago
Very good!! Cantonese is difficult to learn but you did a very good job here
Even some Mandarin-speaking Chinese who are living in HK for a long time can't even speak as good as you ... You can be their teacher, really!!
mooncake1507 2 years ago 9
that's right!!! cheer up brother!!! we're all with u here~~~~~~~~
KevoCatz302 2 years ago 2
You're absolutely right! Native Mandarin speakers often have difficulty with Cantonese tones because there are more tones in Cantonese than Mandarin.
On the flip side, Cantonese speakers often don't have difficulty with Mandarin tones but have difficulty with the pronunciation of some words like 只 because of the "r" sounding beginning.
thibaulthalpern 2 years ago 2
一 di 都唔失敗,你 di 廣東話講得非常好, 勁! 努力!
forgotsick2005 2 years ago 11
慢慢嚟呀兄弟,講得幾好,唔使咁急。
kryptonite747 2 years ago 2
awesome
alicia2r18 2 years ago
香港人學左幾十年英文 仲慚愧:(
simon0114 2 years ago 6
咪係lo....好勁ga la!!!!!!!
KevoCatz302 2 years ago 3
HongKong people learnt English for few years still sucked at it because Hong Kong got bad English education..
lol02468 2 years ago
nice...speak good
Jennywang0323 2 years ago
You're already speaking quite good Cantonese compared to some Chinese who are raised up outside China/Hong Kong. So don't be too harsh on yourself.
I have the same problem as a Cantonese speaking person learning Mandarin (so I can talk with my girlfriend in her language, hehe...). Even though many words are like the same, it's hard to get the pronunciation right.
Anyways, keep up the good work and don't give up :)
PaC00l 2 years ago
add oil add oil!!!!!!!!
KevoCatz302 2 years ago 3
Great vocabulary, much better than mine! But work on the accent some more...
powabiatch 2 years ago
hey,
I am learning German as a native Chinese and I know how you feel. Sometimes it is annoying hearing German people complain about how weird my German is. But then I will say back, my native language gives me ZERO advantage into German, The same like you, you should tell them how hard it is as foreigners to learn Cantonese.
So add oil!
wallytang 2 years ago
terrific !!
sounds like a native speaker ^^
hitthebed 2 years ago
Wow... I am impressed. you can speak good cantonese. :) ..
mattida 2 years ago
加油呀!!!!! =]
你好勁呀
poll220892 2 years ago
Good job. I'm very impressed. FYI, I've found that a big factor to learning a foreign language is speaking it with confidence. If you feel shy or hesitant, it will only hold a person back.
jungyew 2 years ago
it's ok bro... i hv Canton accent in English too
hkremixboy 2 years ago
Beginner my arse
Cantocourse 2 years ago
Your accent is okay.Don't be too hard on yourself.I know a lot of Mandarin speakers who don't speak Cantonese as well as you do even though they have been in a Cantonese speaking environment for years.Keep on the good work.
WinnieNotThePooh 2 years ago
我諗我大概兩年冇聽過你講廣東話﹐我覺得你有好大進步呀。如果冇寫稿可以講得咁流暢﹐我覺得已經非常唔錯﹐我覺得你最大問題唔係個別單字讀得唔啱, 而係講廣東話嘅時候唔夠穩定。有啲時候你發音好準確﹐但係過咗一陣﹐會突然間甩咗咀﹐之後啲聲調就開始錯。呢個時候最緊要令自己習慣返廣東話嘅讀音﹐試下讀下報紙﹐或者重覆人地講嘅嘢﹐慢慢就會愈嚟愈穩定。
chaakming 2 years ago
Good luck! Accent is pretty good too, but you should still try sounding more relaxed and natural.
TsanGwanWai 2 years ago
i dont think u r a beginner anymore , your cant is good!
gorillaz1920 2 years ago
you speak great cantonese!!! keep up the good work.
你講廣東話講得好好呀!繼續加油 =)
你说广东话说得很好哦!继续加油吧 =)
dreampianist 2 years ago