shame liam wasnt as talented or decent as gem.noel sings better than liam he writes the songs gem blends with noel.its about time to tell liam to fuck off loser
OK, I do agree with you that Gem and Noel work great together, specially in concerts like this, but Liam gave Oasis that attitude that made them so famous, that larger than life mentality without which Oasis would only have had half the appeal, to me at least. Liam is BY FAR not as talented as Noel, but Noel on his own isn't the real thing either. I think that they kind of needed each other. Noel would have made it one way or another but we would never have had Oasis.
Ahh yes... you suck simply because you speak a certain language totally...wow another idiot who's idiodic way of thinking makes the world's IQ drop a double digit...you dum fuck.
I don't know if I've ever read anything more downright DUMB in my life. Or maybe it was very existential and ethereal and intelligent. Either way, pissoff.
the truth? thats comment is not the truth you farkin idiot, yiou could say that about anything, still it doesnt make it relevant, unless of course your a fuckin jumped up idiot armchair detective like your self who pulls excuses and revalationary ideas out of his arse at the same time
get back to playing with your warhammer and fuck off to noddy noddy land.
that statement..... er ok some idiot thinks that this song could possibly have been listened to by a rape victim so would have bad connatations to the tune ( obviously you would but this could be said about any thing, and is compleatly interchangable therfore not relvant) then thsi same tool goes on to compound his stupidity say that people who think him strange allows things like genocide to happen. ie he puts the hollacost and his mussings on the same level therefor compeat idiot
you say that i dont take people dying seriously enough but you are Posting comments about it on YOU TUBE under the catagory noel gallager
hahahaha
you see the obsurdity im sure
your obviously mental, and was indecently touched as a kid, but please dont try and lay these hangups on people listening to music on the internet its just wrong. please stop post rape comments on oasis songs they are unrelated even if you see abuse in everything
I know it's a bit late but that's a Gibson j200 Studio cost around 2300 €. Hell of a guitar though, but truthfully if you're willing to spend that much on a guitar you might aswell go for a Gibson j200 standard, cost a bit more but you get the looks aswell as the sound ;)
Noel HAD heard it before. He borrowed the vocal melody for the verse, the phrasing, the middle eight change, the stabbing piano, and even the sound of the words from Innes. That's why they had to pay up. But in the end this is an all time classic. One of my favourite Oasis songs. This isn't the best live version, but I love it all the same.
It doesn't really matter anyway. All singer/songwriters are influenced by other's and pinch little parts of people's song's and re-work them. Some people don't mind and other's make a huge fuss and demand a payout when the song is a bigger hit than their original.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
The only thing about this song that isn't absolutely perfect is Noels horrible luck with Neil Innes. He had never heard it before and for that two or so second similarity of vocals there is a stain on the entire song now.
Noel Gallagher and Oasis are the greatest of all time. Forget about writing a song like Whatever and performing it in the multitude of ways they have over the years, but, nearly 14-15 years later, how many bands can adapt their material like this? Check back with Fall Out Boy, Coldplay, and all the fakers....
I am a huge fan of Definitely Maybe. I love Oasis, interesting, Oasis and Black Crowes were double-billed for a tour together, and they suck? You obviously have not seen them live. Dave Matthews is a different type of music, but to say he sucks? What are you, like 16? His band is full of amazing musicians...
I am a huge fan of Definitely Maybe. I love Oasis, interesting, Oasis and Black Crowes were double-billed for a tour together, and they suck? You obviously have not seen them live. Dave Matthews is a different type of music, but to say he sucks? What are you, like 16? His band is full of amazing musicians...
i dont understand how someone could dislike this kind of music! i could see not really caring either way unfortunately, but how could someone actually dislike it? its got a great chord progression (as do all oasis songs) great lyrics (as do all oasis songs) but most importantly its got heart! not many songs these days have heart and I think thats what makes a song really.
My man Moel is amazing. Listen I know America doesn't produce many great artists of this musical genre. America does have some great college radio stations. I prefer English bands, but guys like Jack Johnson, The Black Crowes, Dave Matthews, Rivers Cuomo, have done a good job as song writers here in the States. Unfortunately, the crappy rap/pop/ and emo bands rule the Top 40.
to monkeyboy well i think your xfactor comparrison is just well shite to be honest and of course oasis are big because of noels great tunes and liams delivery i think thats a bit obvious its hardly because of there hair now is it jesus man
i think there's only 5 or 6 singers who are are famous and have been famous who could win x factor and i think noel probably could give them a run for their money. The difference noel has got, love oasis or hate them, the songs he has written has defined a generation and that makes him on his own a legend. The reason oasis were so big was 2 reasons. The quality of noel's tunes and liam's delivery.
The X-factor, to me; comes across as a show where singers show off their technical ability. They don't seem to be particularly capable of singing with emotion or like they mean it, and in the bigger picture they aren't very good singers as a result.
There is no passion, where as many of Noels performances have sent shivers down my spine.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
neil innes sued noel gallagher because noels 'whatever' uses the same introduction as neils 'how sweet to be an idiot' by the way...has any1 heard how sweet to be an idiot?
Hendrix and Noel. God, only on Youtube do you get such a preposterous argument. The only comparison you could make is that they both play Rock n' Roll.
I think the best part about this mini-tour supporting Stop the clocks was the fact that a lot of songs they don't play as a full band we're played, such as this one, since Liam hates it. great tune.
the original version of this song really made liam's voice pop-it summed up how he sang perfectly. nontheless, i love this version. noel is a god...pity he supports the wrong team from manchester
u cant compare noel and hendrix!!!cause they had huge differences in style hendrix was more soul real,noel is more acoustic with rock as well, there is no comparison there....
dont compare noel and hendrix, noel gallagher is a songwriter, who is tryin to speak the truth, hendrix wanted to be an innovator, and that he was, music isnt for comparison, its for enjoyment, just let it take you to a place where you are happy
If you have Firefox, download the extension "DownloadHelper", and you'll be able to download videos on YouTube in .flv format (they can be watched with VLC).
gem is the fucking man
aldooraffs 2 months ago
Essa música é do caralho...sinceramente uma das mais bonitas do OASIS
Recife-Pernambuco-Brasil.
GrossRafael 2 months ago
God, I love that guitar. Unfortunately, it's dead
domingos123456789 3 months ago
where is the adidas sticker
eksistentialisti 1 year ago 2
@eksistentialisti he got more than just the one six-string, dude ;-)
videoscorn 8 months ago
AMAZIN'!
ValkenburgHoug 1 year ago
gem is the man
Jammo91 1 year ago
yeah, noel sounds half good with gem as well.
OhianaRB 2 years ago
shame liam wasnt as talented or decent as gem.noel sings better than liam he writes the songs gem blends with noel.its about time to tell liam to fuck off loser
onewayalan 2 years ago 7
I guess that's what just happened!
SirJoaquin 2 years ago
OK, I do agree with you that Gem and Noel work great together, specially in concerts like this, but Liam gave Oasis that attitude that made them so famous, that larger than life mentality without which Oasis would only have had half the appeal, to me at least. Liam is BY FAR not as talented as Noel, but Noel on his own isn't the real thing either. I think that they kind of needed each other. Noel would have made it one way or another but we would never have had Oasis.
chrissme92 2 years ago 8
that is a very good analysis. plus liam is the only original member of oasis
treytoshable 2 years ago
il top
frentania66034 2 years ago
PLEASE COME BACK TO SAO PAULO !!
plasticbottleofbeer 2 years ago
hes not interested in playing for french fuckers :)
kookooo1 2 years ago 4
aahahahhah.....that's for sure !!
French people suck !
plasticbottleofbeer 2 years ago 2
hahaha the french are just so, so.... french
urmomsoldballs 2 years ago
Ahh yes... you suck simply because you speak a certain language totally...wow another idiot who's idiodic way of thinking makes the world's IQ drop a double digit...you dum fuck.
99vincent99 2 years ago
I dont care for the faster tempo but noels vocals are insane
Stamminho 2 years ago
Noel should do more of these gigs
iampaulrus 2 years ago 7
favourite oasis song
joocaster 3 years ago 9
mine too.
leethehypno 2 years ago
just wanted to say after all them daft previous comments before me. what a band. what a song
gromit789 3 years ago 10
quali sono gli accordi per chitarra di questo brano??? ho cercato in giro ma nn sono gli stessi che suona Noel....aiutatemi....thanks
Master85Na 3 years ago
love this version can i get some help with a strumming pattern?
chal0072 3 years ago
practice mate thats all, look at lots of covers on youtube and listen to noels live/acoustic versions, ul catch on then
foxyfoxy06 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
standard flat pickign man
ericlikesyou 3 years ago
yeah hes not the best guitar player but hes one of the best songwriters. the amount of good songs he has wrote makes him special
benvanbad 3 years ago 4
i fucking agreed with you!i always thinked that way
quicklist25 3 years ago 2
YEAH..but he is very rich and very famous...something you never will be. get over it.
TimeToDwell 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the thing you have to think about however is that although we love this song...
someone could have suffered a terrible rape or disease and this song was on in the background..and so it will remind them of the event...
know what i mean?
davesni 3 years ago
stupidest comment ever made.
rrcollig 3 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
makes u think tho...
davesni 3 years ago
I don't know if I've ever read anything more downright DUMB in my life. Or maybe it was very existential and ethereal and intelligent. Either way, pissoff.
hrhadam 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how dare you try to banish me from youtube for speakin the truth!
its people like you who allow things like genocide etc to take place
davesni 3 years ago
you're a bit weird :o
Kougeki1000 3 years ago 2
the truth? thats comment is not the truth you farkin idiot, yiou could say that about anything, still it doesnt make it relevant, unless of course your a fuckin jumped up idiot armchair detective like your self who pulls excuses and revalationary ideas out of his arse at the same time
get back to playing with your warhammer and fuck off to noddy noddy land.
deltawhack 2 years ago
what the hell?
u better be able to back that up
Donjeur 2 years ago
back what up
that statement..... er ok some idiot thinks that this song could possibly have been listened to by a rape victim so would have bad connatations to the tune ( obviously you would but this could be said about any thing, and is compleatly interchangable therfore not relvant) then thsi same tool goes on to compound his stupidity say that people who think him strange allows things like genocide to happen. ie he puts the hollacost and his mussings on the same level therefor compeat idiot
deltawhack 2 years ago
u be as well taking a long look at urself in the mirror. there is nothing funny about these things.
u might not take them seriously but people are DYING ok?
all im saying is have the wits to back up what u say before u start messing with peoples lives
Donjeur 2 years ago
your logic is a bit fucked isent it,
you say that i dont take people dying seriously enough but you are Posting comments about it on YOU TUBE under the catagory noel gallager
hahahaha
you see the obsurdity im sure
your obviously mental, and was indecently touched as a kid, but please dont try and lay these hangups on people listening to music on the internet its just wrong. please stop post rape comments on oasis songs they are unrelated even if you see abuse in everything
deltawhack 2 years ago
Know idea what you mean?
What has this song got to do with that?!?
swhyte316 2 years ago
someone know whats that for a guitar? ty
mimak512 3 years ago
I know it's a bit late but that's a Gibson j200 Studio cost around 2300 €. Hell of a guitar though, but truthfully if you're willing to spend that much on a guitar you might aswell go for a Gibson j200 standard, cost a bit more but you get the looks aswell as the sound ;)
chrissme92 2 years ago
Anyone know what the tabs are to this version of the song?
ffmcracdcftw 3 years ago
normal chords but capo 2nd fret
DURRbrainn 3 years ago
you notice that he does`nt have the adidas sticker on this one???maybe he was reminded on the break!!
leonidas2256 3 years ago
i think i saw it on another vid? probably on a diff guitar or something
ffmcracdcftw 3 years ago
maybe like alt tuning or something
fluxrugged 3 years ago
Noel is a fuckin genius
balboa858 3 years ago 8
who is that dude on the drums???
leonidas2256 3 years ago
thats terry
bringitondown66 3 years ago
Noel HAD heard it before. He borrowed the vocal melody for the verse, the phrasing, the middle eight change, the stabbing piano, and even the sound of the words from Innes. That's why they had to pay up. But in the end this is an all time classic. One of my favourite Oasis songs. This isn't the best live version, but I love it all the same.
MrSifter8 3 years ago
It doesn't really matter anyway. All singer/songwriters are influenced by other's and pinch little parts of people's song's and re-work them. Some people don't mind and other's make a huge fuss and demand a payout when the song is a bigger hit than their original.
Shakermaker
She's electric
cigarettes & alcohol
Hello
are just a few noel's been cheeky with
SupersonicStu06 3 years ago 6
fooking class version that
wardy25 3 years ago 3
Not interested in any bla bla fuckin bla bla.
This is a great version of a classic! If u dont agree then dont listen.
Buckets321 3 years ago 28
LOL!
gjm1997 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The only thing about this song that isn't absolutely perfect is Noels horrible luck with Neil Innes. He had never heard it before and for that two or so second similarity of vocals there is a stain on the entire song now.
Cuoin 3 years ago
what you talking about
lovablehunni 3 years ago 4
Neil Innes - How sweet to be an idiot
TheWar182 3 years ago
AWESOME!! love it
dudersmart 3 years ago 3
this version is awesome!
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago 5
Noel Gallagher and Oasis are the greatest of all time. Forget about writing a song like Whatever and performing it in the multitude of ways they have over the years, but, nearly 14-15 years later, how many bands can adapt their material like this? Check back with Fall Out Boy, Coldplay, and all the fakers....
hrhadam 3 years ago 19
Coldplay can fuck off
moarajuliana 3 years ago 31
socan those puffs Fuck Off Boy.....
nield8 3 years ago 9
I am a huge fan of Definitely Maybe. I love Oasis, interesting, Oasis and Black Crowes were double-billed for a tour together, and they suck? You obviously have not seen them live. Dave Matthews is a different type of music, but to say he sucks? What are you, like 16? His band is full of amazing musicians...
drewoasis 3 years ago
I am a huge fan of Definitely Maybe. I love Oasis, interesting, Oasis and Black Crowes were double-billed for a tour together, and they suck? You obviously have not seen them live. Dave Matthews is a different type of music, but to say he sucks? What are you, like 16? His band is full of amazing musicians...
drewoasis 3 years ago
noel is a legend he got was the1 who made me start playing guitar 5 years ago
arsenalgunner321 3 years ago 6
i dont understand how someone could dislike this kind of music! i could see not really caring either way unfortunately, but how could someone actually dislike it? its got a great chord progression (as do all oasis songs) great lyrics (as do all oasis songs) but most importantly its got heart! not many songs these days have heart and I think thats what makes a song really.
redsoxbsball3338 4 years ago 8
the music worlds needs a new band to live up there with, the beatles and oasis and have a bit of passion and soul in there music
02robbo 4 years ago 2
i don't like how he uses the snair in this one..
misseptember 4 years ago
nah me neither actually too fast i think
lovablehunni 4 years ago
My man Moel is amazing. Listen I know America doesn't produce many great artists of this musical genre. America does have some great college radio stations. I prefer English bands, but guys like Jack Johnson, The Black Crowes, Dave Matthews, Rivers Cuomo, have done a good job as song writers here in the States. Unfortunately, the crappy rap/pop/ and emo bands rule the Top 40.
drewoasis 4 years ago
Everyone you just named, sucks. Surprising fer someone to like Oasis and also those "acts." Lemme guess, you're not a big fan of Definitely Maybe....
hrhadam 3 years ago
Whatever you do whatever you say yeah i know it's allright. beautiful
tomvdveer 4 years ago
WOW!!!! Excelent!!
menaltun83 4 years ago 3
plz someone knows if a video of this show is avalaible somewhere??
vaness1210 4 years ago
i totally love this song and this version
marialuizaa 4 years ago
the best!
papzilla44 4 years ago
Brilliant song. Sad that these bands here in the US can't write a great song like this one! Oasis 4 ever!
lebman06 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sad that Oasis'll never write a song like this ever again either
angmalgeetar 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
uhauhauhauha
ridiculuos...
Uvazzo 3 years ago
you are ridiculos
oasishalftheworldawa 3 years ago
i'm wrong my ridiculous was the answer to someone not to this vid. i love oasis and i love all their songs
Uvazzo 3 years ago
agree 100%
american music sucks, and i live here.
ha the grammys were a joke last night.
definitely not rock n roll, all it is is rap and hiphop. there needs to be a seprate show for that crap.
of course there are some good bands here- the strokes, killers, kings of leon.
but still, nobody will ever comapare to Oasis, especially Noel.
Legend
electricxbluee 4 years ago 9
eheh, but also Queen! :P
xyourxnightmare 4 years ago
ill second that lol!
woosh1234567890 4 years ago
Oasis, led zepplin, queen? Defenitely Oasis!!!!
chazzlovesoasis 4 years ago 3
to monkeyboy well i think your xfactor comparrison is just well shite to be honest and of course oasis are big because of noels great tunes and liams delivery i think thats a bit obvious its hardly because of there hair now is it jesus man
ryna07 4 years ago
Well stupid arguement but Hendrix was a very skillful guitar player but a poor songwriter Hendrix is far far far far away from noel in songwriting
Xpektz 4 years ago
hendrix and poor songwriting? naah
okay, noel gallagher is better, but hendrix was a good songwriter too.
klarklar 4 years ago 6
this version is awesome! XD
oasismoni 4 years ago
i just can't get this song out of my head instant happiness!
btw OASIS ROCK!!!!!!!
rosaline4 4 years ago 4
shut up and listen oasis are god!!!!!
gluecifer0815 4 years ago
how the fuck can u compare xfactor with oasis? get a fucking grip.
dan21mufc 4 years ago 7
HAHA..Nice-1.
markustard 3 years ago
i think there's only 5 or 6 singers who are are famous and have been famous who could win x factor and i think noel probably could give them a run for their money. The difference noel has got, love oasis or hate them, the songs he has written has defined a generation and that makes him on his own a legend. The reason oasis were so big was 2 reasons. The quality of noel's tunes and liam's delivery.
monkeyboy0910 4 years ago 2
Noel = Personality of a King
RARB1977 4 years ago 2
The X-factor, to me; comes across as a show where singers show off their technical ability. They don't seem to be particularly capable of singing with emotion or like they mean it, and in the bigger picture they aren't very good singers as a result.
There is no passion, where as many of Noels performances have sent shivers down my spine.
Cuoin 4 years ago 2
lets be honest
how sweet to be an idiot
or be noel gallagher
with whatever
who agrees???
02robbo 4 years ago 5
he'll never win the x-factor
serverfour 4 years ago
LOL You stupid, yet unintentionally funny,twat
DaveyCrockett1985 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
neil innes sued noel gallagher because noels 'whatever' uses the same introduction as neils 'how sweet to be an idiot' by the way...has any1 heard how sweet to be an idiot?
WHAT A WANK SONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! absolute shit!!!
topstix 4 years ago
Hendrix and Noel. God, only on Youtube do you get such a preposterous argument. The only comparison you could make is that they both play Rock n' Roll.
kurtcrowbain 4 years ago
That's silly. Jimmy Hendrix couldn't write as song to save his life.
sceludwi 4 years ago
I think the best part about this mini-tour supporting Stop the clocks was the fact that a lot of songs they don't play as a full band we're played, such as this one, since Liam hates it. great tune.
Stones007 4 years ago
spot on. nice one noel, best version of the song i ever heard
lawtontom 4 years ago
the original version of this song really made liam's voice pop-it summed up how he sang perfectly. nontheless, i love this version. noel is a god...pity he supports the wrong team from manchester
thisisatrueeestory 4 years ago
u cant compare noel and hendrix!!!cause they had huge differences in style hendrix was more soul real,noel is more acoustic with rock as well, there is no comparison there....
rock12341234 4 years ago
Gallagher. Hendrix. Two completely different things. Both amazing. Am I wrong in saying this would have been awesome with a cello in it too?
mikenorris125 4 years ago
This song should have been on Stop the Clocks instead of Songbird.
manutdfan1990 4 years ago
they're were copyright issues with Neil Innes' song "How Sweet to Be an Idiot", therefore they would have had to pay out to use the song
OasisDublin 4 years ago
love it ..just great ..noel is fucking awesome
rocknrollsheep 4 years ago
love this song a lot! just me
annecy6 4 years ago
best oasis song far better with noel singing
Vr122 4 years ago
Please tell me - what fuckin' similarity is between Hendrix and Gallagher? I can see only one thing - they both play guitar and sing. Period.
Comparing them is like comparing vet and surgeon - completely senseless.
Krowencja 4 years ago
Noels amazing better than Hendrix in my eyes but not at playing guitar but hes amazing
Oasisbobo 4 years ago
I rate it!
profpixel 4 years ago
man he can rate WHATEVER he wants
everano14 4 years ago
dont compare noel and hendrix, noel gallagher is a songwriter, who is tryin to speak the truth, hendrix wanted to be an innovator, and that he was, music isnt for comparison, its for enjoyment, just let it take you to a place where you are happy
rowley103 4 years ago 2
i rate hendrix and noel the same both legends
1ciaran 4 years ago
i want a new guitar and some Dr. Pepper with a Mars bar
oasis1q 4 years ago
So fucking good....
esparoona 5 years ago
Every Oasis song deserves to be on stop the clocks!!! Amazing song!
clubbyklose 5 years ago
Noel is the man! Hendrix was good, Noel is in that same class
kingshane700 5 years ago
Can Noel play with his teeth? LOL. Don't compare uncomparable. Hendrix was Hendrix, Noel is Noel.
CharlieJoy 4 years ago
Noel isnt a better guitar player than hendrix, but he writes better tunes. Hes wrote so many classics
g1982m 4 years ago
definitely it should be on the stop the clocks album!!! NOEL, YOU'RE A GENIUS!!!
kriiis3 5 years ago
Great, fabuloso, NOEL is the MAN....
We love him and this song too in Mexico,.
i agree this song should have been on STOP THE CLOCKS.
pollopanic1982 5 years ago
i agree it shuld av been on stop the clocks along with stand by me
Philpy07 5 years ago
Who else agrees this should have been on `Stop the Clocks`?
Wildhat8 5 years ago
oasis, live forever!
w0nd3rw411 5 years ago
CANT SAY MUCH MORE THAN EXCELLENT
tope71 5 years ago
Live 4ever! Legend.
BlueIceGallagher 5 years ago
every version of this song is awesome!!! i'd like to be, under the sea in an octapuses garden you and me!!
englands1 5 years ago
I really prefer Noel he is great!
tjas 5 years ago
awesome-the original is bettr though-liam-strings-slower amaze
pottsy1 5 years ago
T'as bien de la chance alors... :D
azertyrobaz 5 years ago
J'y étais!!
Johnballzi 5 years ago
If you have Firefox, download the extension "DownloadHelper", and you'll be able to download videos on YouTube in .flv format (they can be watched with VLC).
azertyrobaz 5 years ago
Wow, it was wonderful. Thank you for posting this, I watched live online two days ago and they were great.
How can I get a downloadable version?
solidwissam 5 years ago