Just seen a copy in a London record shop for £25. Pretty tempted - this is nuts, kind of Neil meets Joy Divison meets Kraftwerk remixed by an Italio Disco don. It would be brilliant if NY's next move was to revisit this era after the feel-good nostalgia of the Buffalo Springfield reunion. Keep everyone on their toes.
Who changes more? B. Dylan, N. Young or the thin white duke? I like Neil better when he channels Dylan or Native American spirits. In this he seems to have tapped into D. Bowie(a.k.a. 'thin white duke'). But Neil is the most prolific genius to date(though B. Springsteen is giving him a run for his money). Long may you run Neil.
OK - its the sennheiser. Thanks. I've been trying out the EVOC 20 vocoder in logic pro. Using the EVOC20 in track oscillator mode you can use any synth (or other source) you have for the carrier signal. Sounds very good with Arturia's Moog Modular plugin!
This is exactly like something Neil would do and this being his trans days even more so. It's like he said of tonight's the night. You may not put it on at 10 in the AM but there is a place for it somewhere.
Hi there, is this the flipside of the same song that was on the cd trans? I have been looking for this version of mr soul for eons and no one, i mean, no one has it. Do u have it and can i get a copy somehow? I grew up with this song. I sooo wish i had it.
Anybody know what vocoder Neil was using on Trans ? A few vocoders are shown in this vid - but does anybody know for sure ? It wasn't R3 since it wasn't around in 82.
Trans was the first Neil Young LP I ever bought. A late night TV show would play clips from the Berlin show. Sample and hold was the 1st Neil Young song I ever heard at age 13. Still on of my favorites. I have worn out several copies at this point.
This came from his 1982 album "Trans". BUY IT! That's right this is a real record! My dad bought this album when it was brand new! MTV showed a video for a very short time of Neil and his band (which consisted of Nils Lofgren) performing Sample And Hold. His most innovative work ever!
yup, if i remember right neil saw devo had written it on a door in some studio, i might be remembering wrong. for all neil young information read the biography 'Shakey'
Did Geffen win? Do tell details. Sickened me that he got sued by David Geffen like that. Not interested in art anymore, eh David? Yes, this is real. One of Neil's many bizarre, unpredictible changes in direction; that genius & madness thing.
It's on the 12" single of "Sample And Hold." An extended mix of the track from the "Trans" album. One of four different mixes of the same recording done by Neil.
@Kaneoism In the 80's Neil Young was going through some changes, when his son ben was born he was diagnosed with cerebal palsy. Communication with his son was impossible. I think Neil was kinda going through this weird faze of his life because of that. The whole Computer wave was taking off, digital music was starting to become very popular, so it all kinda makes sense when you know the facts. hope this helped
@Kaneoism Check out the article on Neil Young's now out-of-print "Trans" Album on Wikipedia. I would love if they re-released it. The vocoded "Mr. Soul" caused quite a stir; old fans were outraged and a new generation (including me) were introduced to the song in that version.
@phillipremaker I was one of the old fans that loved the trans album so much that i forced my kids and their friends to listen to it every weekend for three months until they knew it by heart.
geffen thought young's target audience wouldn't appreciate this; this would make future sales of young's even non experimental music drop as they would view him as changed. Basically Geffen is an asshole who doesnt let musicians grow, but that's the whole music industry and for the same reason; that's why we listen to music from the dinosaurs even today.
I actually liked Trans quite a bit. I liked the fact that Young was trying something different and I felt that he was did an excellent job with it. Now my friend Gary who had been a longtime Neil Young fan at that point found the album to be repulsive. I could not understand that as the album was well produced.
I have always been a Neil Young fan and I have never been an electronic music dance mix fan, but I have to say Neil really nailed it with this version. Absolutely my favorite! Something about the robotic rythm really brings out what this song is about.
you know, all the mainstream success stuff and mr. soul is my favourite song ever, both the acoustic version he does on sugar mountain and mtv unplugged and the buffalo springfield album version
thanks anyway, have you ever seen it, I think it was done back in the 80's it was a cool video, we have been trying to find it for a long time, but no luck thanks again for replying
try checking out the you tuber named GnomeAddict..he has a vid called neil young 2000 and about 2 minutes into it you will find what you seek...love nils lofgren in it as well!!
This is a great version from a period of Youngs turbulent family problems and the expectancy of the time and the record label he was on at the time.
regards
jimmy
ps my daugter was around 4 at the time and she loved it.
As an aside point she also loved "sunny inside" from the bluenotes album [she must have been around 9] and we played that at her wedding last year .How weired is that.
Now to search on one of my VHS tapes for a TV special Neil did around this time, doing songs inspired by Trans and Everybody's Rockin'. He was dressed as the Transformer Man I guess, or whatever he called it. Then he did a live set with the Shocking Pinks.
Just seen a copy in a London record shop for £25. Pretty tempted - this is nuts, kind of Neil meets Joy Divison meets Kraftwerk remixed by an Italio Disco don. It would be brilliant if NY's next move was to revisit this era after the feel-good nostalgia of the Buffalo Springfield reunion. Keep everyone on their toes.
jrmullett 2 weeks ago
Who changes more? B. Dylan, N. Young or the thin white duke? I like Neil better when he channels Dylan or Native American spirits. In this he seems to have tapped into D. Bowie(a.k.a. 'thin white duke'). But Neil is the most prolific genius to date(though B. Springsteen is giving him a run for his money). Long may you run Neil.
tomadamsinva 2 weeks ago
Neil what were you thinking? I wish I never heard this.
rhymepays 3 weeks ago
Very cool. Seems like Neil's vocoder vox are clearer here than on the album. And lots of fun little extra effects added throughout. Oh Neil!
qslab92 2 months ago
Let it be known that I like this video *thumbs up*
spatoon 4 months ago
thanks so much for this! it's slaaaaaaying me!
spilledlikewine 5 months ago
OK - its the sennheiser. Thanks. I've been trying out the EVOC 20 vocoder in logic pro. Using the EVOC20 in track oscillator mode you can use any synth (or other source) you have for the carrier signal. Sounds very good with Arturia's Moog Modular plugin!
DDtelecaster 6 months ago
Sennheiser Vocoder VSM201!!!
VoiceEncoder 6 months ago
@response007 I just confirmed this myself with my copy of the book.
VoiceEncoder 6 months ago
@VoiceEncoder Actually it's the Sennheiser Vocoder VSM201...but I too used to think it was the Moog!!
response007 6 months ago
This is exactly like something Neil would do and this being his trans days even more so. It's like he said of tonight's the night. You may not put it on at 10 in the AM but there is a place for it somewhere.
TheQ1605 8 months ago
@VoiceEncoder Thanks ! The sound is distant and dangerous, fits the mood perfectly. I'm very curious how you know NY's vocoder technology from 1983.
DDtelecaster 11 months ago
Hi there, is this the flipside of the same song that was on the cd trans? I have been looking for this version of mr soul for eons and no one, i mean, no one has it. Do u have it and can i get a copy somehow? I grew up with this song. I sooo wish i had it.
danycam1 1 year ago
Neil does whatever the fuck he wants...which is why he's so amazing even today...his newest lp Le Noise is amazing.
KOSMICKEN09 1 year ago
like this version.....funky, different
shalloend 1 year ago 2
Anybody know what vocoder Neil was using on Trans ? A few vocoders are shown in this vid - but does anybody know for sure ? It wasn't R3 since it wasn't around in 82.
DDtelecaster 1 year ago
@DDtelecaster Sennheiser Vocoder VSM201!! I too like 'VoiceEncoder' used to think it was the Moog!!
response007 6 months ago
@DDtelecaster Sennheiser Vocoder VSM201!!!
VoiceEncoder 6 months ago
i believe i heard it on the streets of nyc. some black dude had on his ghetto blaster
crackheadmanning 1 year ago 2
It's like Neil Young doing The Residents doing Neil Young.
weinerbongo 1 year ago
Trans was the first Neil Young LP I ever bought. A late night TV show would play clips from the Berlin show. Sample and hold was the 1st Neil Young song I ever heard at age 13. Still on of my favorites. I have worn out several copies at this point.
Would love to hear the "Sample and Hold" remix!
umpfco 1 year ago
This came from his 1982 album "Trans". BUY IT! That's right this is a real record! My dad bought this album when it was brand new! MTV showed a video for a very short time of Neil and his band (which consisted of Nils Lofgren) performing Sample And Hold. His most innovative work ever!
jazzliscious13 1 year ago
This is really wonderful and I very much appreciate your detailed liner notes. Thank you!
ffferol 1 year ago
Another brilliant track from Trans
cbmccarthy 1 year ago
this is incredible. thanks for the upload!
alexriesenbeck 1 year ago
wow.
lotusnes 1 year ago 2
Absolutely fantastic, way ahead of it's time
kvanderaa 1 year ago 2
Mas super que nunca!
btartar1 1 year ago
hello mr soul , i saw neil and bruce palmer perform this at the cow palace in the eighties , it was really SOMETHING
GodfreRayKing 1 year ago
yup, if i remember right neil saw devo had written it on a door in some studio, i might be remembering wrong. for all neil young information read the biography 'Shakey'
roblawson88 2 years ago 2
no he sat in at a Devo gig at The Mabuhay Gardens and did My My Hey Hey and they sang "rust never sleeps" on the backups.
jeffkahl 1 year ago
Isn't "Rust Never Sleeps" a phrase created by a guy from Devo?
ruzz3ii 2 years ago
yes
jeffkahl 1 year ago
nice nice , i like
herwig666 2 years ago
This is too weird for words.
Each21 2 years ago 2
Cool mix!
louiseduvee 2 years ago
Did Geffen win? Do tell details. Sickened me that he got sued by David Geffen like that. Not interested in art anymore, eh David? Yes, this is real. One of Neil's many bizarre, unpredictible changes in direction; that genius & madness thing.
jackstpaul 2 years ago 2
Excellent!
MrHanksWorld 2 years ago
is this a real record?
Kaneoism 2 years ago
Of course. Why do you ask?
mojofilter02 2 years ago
it just doesn't seam like the record neil young would produce..... did you remix it or something :P I dont know about this one
Kaneoism 2 years ago 3
It's on the 12" single of "Sample And Hold." An extended mix of the track from the "Trans" album. One of four different mixes of the same recording done by Neil.
mojofilter02 2 years ago 6
aw alright. Well thank you for posting it! It really is different
Kaneoism 2 years ago
@Kaneoism I know Neil Young personally and it does seem like a record he would produce and it seems like this because I know Neil Young personally.
Sirveaux 1 year ago
@Kaneoism In the 80's Neil Young was going through some changes, when his son ben was born he was diagnosed with cerebal palsy. Communication with his son was impossible. I think Neil was kinda going through this weird faze of his life because of that. The whole Computer wave was taking off, digital music was starting to become very popular, so it all kinda makes sense when you know the facts. hope this helped
bigrussthefusss 1 year ago
@Kaneoism
Neil did a lot of weird shit in the early 1980s trying (perhaps -- I can only guess; it was Neil, after all) to stay relevant.
And it was only by being Neil (This Note's For You, in 1987 or 1988) that he found his audience again.
brianallancobb 1 year ago
@Kaneoism Check out the article on Neil Young's now out-of-print "Trans" Album on Wikipedia. I would love if they re-released it. The vocoded "Mr. Soul" caused quite a stir; old fans were outraged and a new generation (including me) were introduced to the song in that version.
phillipremaker 6 months ago
@phillipremaker I was one of the old fans that loved the trans album so much that i forced my kids and their friends to listen to it every weekend for three months until they knew it by heart.
Ishtar0racle 6 months ago
@Kaneoism yes i played this in the clubs an exeriment neil did for dance clubs
chascja 1 year ago
Westbam must have known this when he did * No more R&R *
totovillefranche 2 years ago
It's not fake, I have this vinyl and saw the Solo Trans tour where he recreated all the parts live by himself, using tape loops.
markbrow 2 years ago 4
markbrow,
I saw the same tour.
The music was so different "Changed," as Neil has been doing all his life,
Remember the sunglasses he wore had a mic attached so he could roam the stage, playing and singing, and made it a beautiful evening?
Peace.
Rock
rockinroller7 2 years ago
Even if this was fake, it's totally fucking cool.
kidkillaforilla 2 years ago
is not Devo, is Gino Soccio sound , is a
electronic canadian sound
gusbenson 2 years ago 2
now THAT was weerd ! phew!
sandethesandman 2 years ago 3
very cool and ever-so-rare!
thanx!!!
econoroller 2 years ago 5
I saw the Trans Tour in 1983. Totally awesome!!
luckyshortster 2 years ago 12
I saw a broadcast of it on TV. It was great
Paley 2 years ago 3
ditto!!!
silvanski 2 years ago
This sounds a bit like Devo, a bit like Kraftwerk, and a little like R. Stevie Moore.
weinerbongo 2 years ago 3
What the fuck was wrong with David Geffen? This is great.
weinerbongo 2 years ago 5
geffen thought young's target audience wouldn't appreciate this; this would make future sales of young's even non experimental music drop as they would view him as changed. Basically Geffen is an asshole who doesnt let musicians grow, but that's the whole music industry and for the same reason; that's why we listen to music from the dinosaurs even today.
-hero
fordieform 2 years ago
Now remind me ... is this the record company that sued Neil Youg for not sounding like Neil Young, AND WON!
phddddd 2 years ago
she said:your strange;but don't change
-hero
fordieform 2 years ago
I actually liked Trans quite a bit. I liked the fact that Young was trying something different and I felt that he was did an excellent job with it. Now my friend Gary who had been a longtime Neil Young fan at that point found the album to be repulsive. I could not understand that as the album was well produced.
MrHanksWorld 2 years ago
I have always been a Neil Young fan and I have never been an electronic music dance mix fan, but I have to say Neil really nailed it with this version. Absolutely my favorite! Something about the robotic rythm really brings out what this song is about.
gryzynx 2 years ago 5
That was trippy.
gobugeaters 2 years ago 3
Love it, Love it, Love it and just Love it. Thanks for uploading.
astrololee 2 years ago 9
i'm an absolute neil fanatic
you know, all the mainstream success stuff and mr. soul is my favourite song ever, both the acoustic version he does on sugar mountain and mtv unplugged and the buffalo springfield album version
and i have to say
this is fucking great! ihought i'd hate it!
buggerit2 2 years ago 2
trans is a really trippy lp if you listen too much you are too hooked.
music4uguru 2 years ago 2
I have the Sample And Hold Maxi Ep and play it constantly to enthralled crowds in Brisbane, Love it!
hypogenetic 2 years ago 2
Love it. Trans is my favorite Neil Young album. We R In Control! *headbang*
Elidoransgar 2 years ago
Do you have the Sample and Hold remix from the maxi?
bobafettuccine 2 years ago
should have let Devo do it...
Raymantico 2 years ago
Sir... ENABLE THESE RATINGS. I demand my contitutional right to give it a 4.2!!!
MoreToleranceNow 3 years ago 6
lmaoooo
KnockKnockPeas 2 years ago
Trans was fuckin strange man,,,kudos to Neil for trying to push the barriers hough
Doitchampions 3 years ago 2
do you have the original video?
terrymoser47 3 years ago
No, sorry, I don't have the video of this one.
mojofilter02 3 years ago
thanks anyway, have you ever seen it, I think it was done back in the 80's it was a cool video, we have been trying to find it for a long time, but no luck thanks again for replying
terrymoser47 3 years ago
try checking out the you tuber named GnomeAddict..he has a vid called neil young 2000 and about 2 minutes into it you will find what you seek...love nils lofgren in it as well!!
WinnersCircleMan 3 years ago
@terrymoser47 I don't remember any video produced by Neil for the Trans album. It was before video killed the radio star :-)
Ishtar0racle 6 months ago
wow definitely one for the archives! interesting twist on an old classic!
jeffkahl 3 years ago 2
I didn't really get into this until long after Springfield when Neil released this on Journey Through the Past in '72.
Never heard this version but I like it.
And the hits just 'keep on comin'. Thanks Mojo cinq*
rsensorat3 3 years ago
i thought Neil Young's "Trans" album was one of his most interesting. this song is from it, just not the dance verson.
bloggo1 3 years ago 3
This is a great version from a period of Youngs turbulent family problems and the expectancy of the time and the record label he was on at the time.
regards
jimmy
ps my daugter was around 4 at the time and she loved it.
As an aside point she also loved "sunny inside" from the bluenotes album [she must have been around 9] and we played that at her wedding last year .How weired is that.
julyarchives 3 years ago 4
Now to search on one of my VHS tapes for a TV special Neil did around this time, doing songs inspired by Trans and Everybody's Rockin'. He was dressed as the Transformer Man I guess, or whatever he called it. Then he did a live set with the Shocking Pinks.
secordman 3 years ago
That's the Solo Trans video! I would love to see the full thing sometime!
Yippykiyay505 3 years ago 2