Fox 13: Kelly Clarkson or David Cook?

[jojoxx1231]

Cookson all the way! Seriously, a Cookson duet needs to happen.

[fruitx4yay]

gokey cookson <3 haha

[JESxSY]

Kelly.

[ldlubak]

hard question beings they are both incredible and my favorite winners!!!! also carrie underwood :]

[21ctm21]

KELLY!!!!!!!!!

[mknsmkl01]

Kelly and David, the best American Idols!!! They should make a duet!!!!

[babyp35]

KELLY

[TheFear1611]

Kelly Clarkson ofc

[hughiegrant]

COOKSON FOR THE FREAKING WIN! lol =))

Allison: "Kelly C-C-Cook!" :)) Allison is our COOKSON GOD! =)) HAHA

[wordnerdsrock]

love Gokey's answer!! what a sweetie!!

[arizonaleigh]

YA KELLY COOK!!!!!

[JZ311995]

Kelly Clarkson !!!!!!! but i like david cook !!!! but i'll go with kelly

[zippy426]

David Cook!

[KrisAllisonKelly4evr]

definitely kelly cook!

[LambertIrahetaLover]

Kelly Cook :D :P

[LadyDestruction333]

I'm with Allison.... Kelly Cook.... Lol.... :D

[superstar7soso]

kelly cook!

[AnthoneikaSada]

DAVID ROLAND COOK ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!! (i got love for kelly too)

[superstar7soso]

@AnthoneikaSada who is roland?

its kelly clarkson

[Kristin2007]

David Cook!!!

[XxSongBird95xX]

David Cook!

[kcloverkc]

Kelly all the way....

[cookhasmyheart]

how can they not go with cook! i love adam's face at 0:04

[Cookiecake4me]

How could u not love cookie?

[chasimf]

come on! kelly is just the best singer of this decade

[cookhasmyheart]

david cook!

[aboo00oode992]

kelly .

there is no doubt about it. when she was in ai she blew the other away and she is the best till today no one can reach her leage. david is coool but kelly is just better .

[veetothebee]

Haha Kelly Cook.

[coolidge909]

Kelly Cook WIN!!!! love some KC/DC

still waiting for a rocking duet from the two.

[mistermagoo90]

KC/DC <3

[Cass14141]

Kelly kelly kelly. I went on to listen to the David Cook guy.... do not see what the fuss is about at all.. but in 7 more years, I'm sure Kelly will still be around. Can't say the same for this guy...he's just a newish person out there right now.. Not trying to bug his fans or anything, just can't see anything special. Sounds like any other rocker guy. There is an amazing talent and raw power and versatility in Kelly's voice.. she will always be the best one.

[propertyofjoey]

Kelly freakin Clarkson!!

[jbjbjobo]

I vote Kelly Cook

[Smartbee2007]

Kelly Cook nice. Ehh come one guys David is the bestest! lol But they're both amazing

[fruitx4yay]

Alright. Who wants (and has been wanting) a duet with Kelly and David already?

[SPN7191]

MEEEEEEEEE.

[neenaserbia]

meeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[beedoggie]

RIGHT HERE!!!!!!!!

[fruitx4yay]

GO GOKEY AND ALLISON!!!! and kc/dc, of course..

[carolinagirl009]

Ha! "Kelly Cook" love it!!

David is the male Kelly seriously. :)

From their voices to their goofy, down to earth personalities. They need to date I'm just saying. Heck David fits Kelly's description for the kind of guy she is looking for-tall, has some scruff, funny, likes dogs i think (which Kelly just said in a recent interview that the first most important thing is the guy she likes has to be a dog lover) so :)

[fruitx4yay]

And also they have the same idea of the perfect first date, AND Kelly fits David's description, too!!

[fruitx4yay]

also, she pretty much fits his description, too! funny, nice confident, compassionate, and he said 'attractive's always a plus.' woohoo! cookson FTW!

[031LUCY]

Kelly Clarkson Cook !! *---*

[fruitx4yay]

kelly cook!!

[amandamcg]

David is so much better than Kelly... at least he can make songs his own...

[hindas]

jWhat was the context for the question? What was the complete question? Anyone know?

[ai1rocks]

Charley was doing a "rapid-fire question" thing with the Idols. He gave them two options for different things and they had to choose one. This is just one of the questions he asked. Hope that answers your question. :)

[lovelybabymay]

hahaha. I love this and I love them both!

[hughiegrant]

what kind of question is this?!?! :) DAVID = KELLY,

hmmm, that's a tough one, i agree with gokey and allison!!!! KELLY COOK! WOOT! THEY SHOULD DATE!! DELLY!!!!

[fruitx4yay]

woohoo!! they sure as hell should date!! if not, we should at least get to hear ONE duet!!! they would be the cutest couple though

[carolinagirl009]

and also have some cute rocker babies. ha!, ha!

[purplesolleile]

I mean seriously, who asks that question?! I can't choose either so I have to go with BOTH!!!

[purplesolleile]

Gokey's big gasp at the beginning of his sentence was funny. *gasp!!!!* Hahahah so cute.

[FadingLetters]

LMAO.. Kelly Cook

[fruitx4yay]

i loove david too! but seriously.. two grammys, 20 million recods sold worldwide.. i think she's great

[uberlac]

kelly clarkson!

[AnneCR]

Kelly - my favorite singer of all time

Cook - my favorite male american idol :D kelly and cook should date :D

[xianmeg]

david cook is the best male idol for me... for the female it would be kelly clarkson and carrie underwood...

[fruitx4yay]

hmm.. kelly cook.. that would be cool!!

[fruitx4yay]

=( how sad. these two are the best that have come out of american idol (in my opinion) and now theyre being put against one another?? =(

i say david and kelly, should be together on stage dueting!!!

[leighie]

alison rocks.. haha

[EvFan1985]

kelly is more successful... btw

[TARGETQUEEN]

Definitely!!!

[carolinagirl009]

I love how Alison goes "Kelly Cook"

[horsecraziegal]

DAVID COOK! these kids are out of there minds, i hated this season except Danny, and Kris, but Kris said Kelly Clarkson, shame, shame, shame.... xoxo lovely

[XXskateboardgirlXX]

kelly clarkson

[frappe04]

no wonder i love MATT G so much! haha :) Danny and Allison..eh, love them too =) and i'll pick DAVID C anytime

[Shereeda2202]

OMG Allison gave my exact answer!!!

LOL she rocks!

[FlowerBee123]

Both for me. I like Kelly's music better, but David has an amazing voice, and hes' my favorite Idol winner of all time. The only problem he has is that his music is kind of lack luster cause it's all these cheesy, watered down love ballads. I don't know if that's his fault, or Idol's fault, but he definitely needs to get some better songs. and if he's trying to go rock, he's gotta totally change the direction he's going cause what he does now turns many rock listeners off, rather than on.

[Danisplace]

Both! On a stage. Dueting.

[fruitx4yay]

that would be the best duet EVER!!!!!!

[5000lololol]

My Vote: David Cook!

[bigelowrocks]

Allison iraheta... so cute. theres another reason why she has my vote

[bigelowrocks]

aww... allison is so cute! kelly Cook, thats a good one allison. YOU ROCK GIRL!!! YOU GOT MY VOTE!!!!!

[bigelowrocks]

Next year if they ask Adam lambert or Allison iraheta, you guess. whats my answer................. it`s ALLISON IRAHETA!!!. SHES SO FUNNY. LUV U ALLISON

[fruitx4yay]

aww.. =( they are my favorite idols ever!! they both are awesome, how could they ask such a cruel question? =)

[mydaydreammelody]

I wouldn't want to chose because I love both. So I liked Allison's answer. Another reason why that girl has my vote this year.

[fruitx4yay]

i agree these two are like the 2 best AI winners EVER. and allison ROCKS!!

[jovanddavid]

david cook all the way

[TheWorldOfJavi]

KELLY CLARKSON 4EVER!!

[kianpeag]

DAVID BY A MILLION MILES!!!

[bcmaze77]

Kelly kelly kelly but i do like david

[JaciVelasquezFans]

the first original american idol winner obviously KELLY CLARKSON EVER!

[MrsArchuletaXO96]

DAVID***

[MrsArchuletaXO96]

DAVVID ARCHULETA!! hahaa! archuleta is amaazinggg. he shouldve been a choiceeeee <33 =)

[o0ber]

Kelly Clarkson... I don't know why anyone would say David Cook... He was okay on idol, but his new album is garbage. It sounds like a bunch of Kelly and Daughtry reject songs, and I don't even like Daughtry.

[5000lololol]

Davids Cd is amazing!!!!!!!!! U don't know what ur talkin about

[RafaelTsang]

KC AND ARCHIE FOREVER!

[lovemelma]

david cook and david cook!

[slammie]

kelly by a mile

[mae7777123]

Kelly Clarkson because she had more hits on radio than any other idol. It's not because she is the first winner. She has proven herself. The chick has over 20 songs on the Top 100 and has broken many records. She is doing again with her latest CD after 8 years. Give the girl some credit.

[fruitx4yay]

i completely agree. she isnt successful bcuz of idol. idol is successful bczu of her.

[sanjayalover26]

David is by far the best. The only reason Kelly is as famous as she is, is because she was Idols first winner.

[buffymovies]

correction:the only reason idol is still popular is because of the amount of success kelly had.

[sanjayalover26]

But hardly anyone watched Idol during Kelly's season. I didn't start watching until season 6. And, Kelly isn't that great. Her albums only get as popular as they do because she waits 4 or 5 years to release a new one.

[5000lololol]

I'm on your side, i didn't start watchin it 'till season 6 and i think people only like kelly because they head her on the radio sometime after she won.

[joepatrick55]

i dont think anyone can even take that answer seriously when your name is "sanjayalover" lol. and kelly is as famous as she is cause shes talanted and worked her ass off to make good music. i do like david. but kelly is the best.

[caisson333]

I think we have to give david some time to build his rep, kelly clarkson has like 8 years behind her

[joepatrick55]

thats true, but the person i was replying to said kelly was only famous cause she was the first winner which is bull. shes famous cause shes great. and david will build his rep im sure, hes a great talant.

[5000lololol]

so what ur point? David's still amazing!

[sanjayalover26]

Usernames do not have anything to do with opinions. And as a matter of fact, I hate Sanjaya now. If yt would let me change my username without deleting my account, I'd gladly change it. But there's nothing I can do about that. I, for one, have the opinion that Kelly Clarkson is not as great as people say she is. Yes, I do admit, her newest album is pretty good. But opinion are opinions. We all have one, just like we have an asshole. some people just have to get used to it.

[sanjayalover26]

Yes I know. I used to like him, but now I can't stand him.

[fruitx4yay]

oh come on.. kelly made AI famous, barely ANYBODY watched the season where she won, you even said so yourself. american idol would not exist to this day if kelly hadnt been so successful, let alone be getting 35 million viewers. but i agree with you that david is AWESOME! ;-)

[nationaltreasurer]

kelly is great but david is my hero :D

[disappearingboy44]

"Kelly Cook" Bahahaha.

[fruitx4yay]

kelly cook! yay!

[kingsom12]

is there a need to ask?? of course is kelly!!!!

[doedaphna]

david cook

[RougeHeir]

Kelly Clarkson, the best idol champs

Kelly, Carrie, Jordin, and David

But the best person to ever be on the show by a landslide is

Diana DeGarmo

[WordNerd4Cookie]

DAVID COOK!!! lol Kelly Cook-Allison is soo funny. lol

[MrCooksNumber1Fan]

David! duh! lol not that Kelly is bad or anything, she sings great. :) love Gokey and Iraheta's answers.

[RockStarKimiko88]

'kelly cook' xP

~David cook FTW

[MarkusBarrett]

KELLY CLARKSON!

[kellyqueenofpop]

um yeahhh kelly totally wins!!!!

[MakMedia95]

Allison for the win!!!

[Tlatz]

David...NO CONTEST.

[ratandkow]

Kelly- NO CONTEST! :P

[fruitx4yay]

go allison and danny!! i cant decide between them they are both way too awesome

[Lee2deutz7]

David Cook...

the 3 best idol champs are David, Kelly and Carrie...

but, my greatest idol is David...

[marleman]

I am fan of kelly clarkson but David is so good singing maybe if david would make a song or the song like kelly has made in her albums. but kelly is out of this world, she is a worlwide star, she is in another league

[fruitx4yay]

omg this is so mean they are both my faves!! i love them both sooo much!! i luvd dannys answer

[randyboots]

adam should like david cook, then I would be the happiest person in the world. XD

[sHeLbYwElByGuRLiE]

DAVID COOK!!

[MakMedia95]

Kelly Cook! lolol! :P

[Moonlightfan12]

DAVID COOK!!!!!!!! <333333

[shaharusha]

kelly wins! :D

[kelfan1]

KELLY!!! duh

[dawnie701]

david

[fran9]

best answer:

danny - "both" :)

[BladeAndSoul]

Kelly wins duh david cook only have his fans cause hes hot hes voice is shit.

And simons favorite is still kelly so david fails :)

[ratandkow]

No! David's voice is not like shit..

But yeah Kelly wins.. DUH :P She's in a different league!

[5000lololol]

Yeah so um if david fails(which he dosn't) why would he stay on american idol so long, get good reviews from the judges, and actully won by like oo idk 12 million votes

[EvFan1985]

kelly's hot too. argument fail

[amylee1220]

David Cook, of course! Kudos to Matt and Scott! to Danny and Allison, too.

BTW, the man asking the quesiton is Lindsey Rose's Dad! he'd love to hear "David Cook"!

[buffymovies]

yay for kelly

[xoxkatiejonasxox]

DAVID COOK<33333

[SPN7191]

KELLY COOK FTW. LOL

[expatiates]

both! <3 (ok, but mostly david, hee.)

[waterbender09]

Love you Allison

"Kelly Cook"

[snl891]

Ooooh fail for so many people choosing Kelly over David! hehe

BUT I'll give credit to Adam because he totes deliberated over it, which means he probably loves Cookie too, just Kelly a lil bit more ;)

woota for Matt, Scott, Danny, and Allison! They win :P

[xvxStargirlxvx]

David Cook, of course!!! Adam WOULD say Kelly, wouldn't he?

[CristinaLvnMindfreak]

DAVID COOK & KELLY CLARKSON!

[jovanddavid]

David Cook!!!! Yey!

[karinab6]

hahah awesome! I vote Kelly lol

I love Allison's answer "Kelly Cook"

[chestnutiscute]

DAVID COOK!