One of the saddest scenes in recent film history. Susan Sarandon's ability to act without words is really incredible here: the way she initially jerks backwards in shock, and then scans the room with her eyes in confusion at the sight of the charred remains of her son is easily some of the most genuine acting I've ever seen. "Is that everything? ...Is that all of him?" The fact that a mother would ever have to ask that of her child is truly heartbreaking. Great film.
what is perhaps the most intense part of that scene is Jones' silence and...empty look on his face throughout the whole scene, and the look on Sarandon's face when he says My sympathies.
ok...I just saw this film on HBO over the weekend and I was just floored. This movie was outstanding. I'm clueless as to why people thought this was 'Anti-american', which was far from. I thought this movie brought attention to the countless of veterans who struggle and go through PTSD....The ending was symbolism at it's best, in regards to people struggling with PTSD. 6 stars.....
The fact that this film wasn't nominated for Best Picture and that Tommy Lee Jones did not win Best Actor, and that Susan Sarandon didn't even have a nomination for Best Supporting Actress proves that the Academy is afraid to stand up and make any form of political point whatsoever. This was THE best film with THE best performances of last year. Period.
This is a brilliant film. And a fantastic scene. The actors are of course doing their job perfectly. But remember about the work of the director. Paul Haggis is now one of the best american filmmakers, I'm waiting for his next film.
This film was one of the most powerful films I have seen in a long time. Such strong performances by Jones, Sarandon and a surprisingly intense performance by Charlize Theron. I live in Australia but was devastated by the truth behind this film. Also, I just have to say that Susan Sarandon, although her part was small, she shone for me. Amazing portrayal. She really deserves an oscar nom and win for this too !!!
This movie was extremely disturbing to me and I feel like everyone in this country, especially those who support this insane war & occupation in Iraq, should see this movie. Google and check out the Winter Soldier testimonies from the website from Iraq Veterans Against the War.
This is heartbreaking
HikingForSpirit 2 months ago
wow saddest thin I've seen. Just shows you what some American and British families (with other allies) have had to endure.
bantermelon 11 months ago
@bantermelon yeah, who gives a fuck about afghans, right?
ElephantRage 4 months ago
One of the saddest scenes in recent film history. Susan Sarandon's ability to act without words is really incredible here: the way she initially jerks backwards in shock, and then scans the room with her eyes in confusion at the sight of the charred remains of her son is easily some of the most genuine acting I've ever seen. "Is that everything? ...Is that all of him?" The fact that a mother would ever have to ask that of her child is truly heartbreaking. Great film.
Apatheria 1 year ago
what is perhaps the most intense part of that scene is Jones' silence and...empty look on his face throughout the whole scene, and the look on Sarandon's face when he says My sympathies.
naruhinaaddict1000 1 year ago
ok...I just saw this film on HBO over the weekend and I was just floored. This movie was outstanding. I'm clueless as to why people thought this was 'Anti-american', which was far from. I thought this movie brought attention to the countless of veterans who struggle and go through PTSD....The ending was symbolism at it's best, in regards to people struggling with PTSD. 6 stars.....
mforce1 2 years ago
The fact that this film wasn't nominated for Best Picture and that Tommy Lee Jones did not win Best Actor, and that Susan Sarandon didn't even have a nomination for Best Supporting Actress proves that the Academy is afraid to stand up and make any form of political point whatsoever. This was THE best film with THE best performances of last year. Period.
JonBoo418 3 years ago 13
TTT
ElephantRage 3 years ago
Right is right
rndtuet 2 years ago
@JonBoo418 I rather enjoyed it as well. The academy is full of those who are afraid to nominate films with political messages. great performances.
scottmanduzy 1 year ago
This is a brilliant film. And a fantastic scene. The actors are of course doing their job perfectly. But remember about the work of the director. Paul Haggis is now one of the best american filmmakers, I'm waiting for his next film.
WielkiDzikus 3 years ago
This film was one of the most powerful films I have seen in a long time. Such strong performances by Jones, Sarandon and a surprisingly intense performance by Charlize Theron. I live in Australia but was devastated by the truth behind this film. Also, I just have to say that Susan Sarandon, although her part was small, she shone for me. Amazing portrayal. She really deserves an oscar nom and win for this too !!!
darkstorm84 3 years ago 5
I'm also an aussie and echo your comments entirely! Aboslutely love this moving film, this particular scene really got to me.
MrPymmie 1 year ago
lol i worked on this film it was a old abandoned gov building they used and they dead body was made of rubber it was really cool
drunknbaztard 3 years ago
This movie didnt get as much attention as it deserves.
GIGIDIEGIGIDIE 3 years ago 3
This movie was extremely disturbing to me and I feel like everyone in this country, especially those who support this insane war & occupation in Iraq, should see this movie. Google and check out the Winter Soldier testimonies from the website from Iraq Veterans Against the War.
Jacksonholenativ 3 years ago
Thank you sieeemens for posting this scene. I have been looking for it for quite some time...
Does anyone know the score or the composer of the song that accompanies this scene?
Thanks
ptillman42 4 years ago
It's so sad...the song: "Viewing" Mark Isham
SergioMelone 3 years ago
one of the greatest movies of all time.
I bet TLJ gets the accademy for this
valzgris 4 years ago 2