The Devil's Arithmetic

[movieraiter1]

Im reading the book in school

[032003hulk]

I SAY IT IN SCHOOL IT WAS SOO SAD

[AGmadeline17]

Does anyone know what the song is? :)

[Anykk1]

@AGmadeline17 i love it!!! its good its called Girl Disappearing by tori amos

[Riksv1]

I saw this in school. PRETTY GOOD!

[MRSUltimateJBfan]

This movie was sooo good.

[misteriouslaughs]

We are gonna watch this at school. We are still reading it though

[KellyGarciaChannel]

she should have gone & saved Anne Frank o.o

[iiAmNicki]

We watched thiss in social studiess;p I was sick the day we were going to watch the resttttt:( Idk what happend nextt

[TYiFuZzo]

2:10 my mom cutting her hair :)

[Kampster32]

:********(

[clintonearlwalker]

I notice a lot of comments on this vid are from kids in school that apparently have to watch this film in school. I'm almost 50 and I've been reading and watching video about the Holocaust since about the second grade. Keep in mind that all this stuff happened almost 70 years ago, before I was even born. There are very few people still alive that had anything to do with it. It was certainly very bad, but it was also a long time ago.

[aTime4UandMe]

@clintonearlwalker , 70 Years ago is not a long time ago, & we must make sure that this never happens again. Israel must survive. & so is every nation that loves life.

[clintonearlwalker]

@aTime4UandMe The thing is that many kids watch these type of movies and comment on them like it's some type thing that is happening to them. Anne Frank has been dead and gone for 70 years along with her sister Margot, and about 6 million other people. There are many other things happening today that affect their lives much more than the Nazi Holocaust. 70 years is a very long time ago. There are many problems today that will be far more important to school kids in the future than the Nazi's

[ZulKoji]

These kinds of movies are so hard to watch. I only looked it up because I saw half of it long ago. I couldn't watch the whole thing though.

[09091999sam]

What school do u go to I go to arc

[xxlettice97xx]

The movie was very sad. The book was good too, but we watched this movie in school and it made me cry.

[ChubbyChipmunks123]

OMG the book is extremely 100% better. I haven't even finished reading it in schoo, i'm in 5th grade, and seriously i'm glad the teachers chose not to show this to us. Thumbs up for the book

[zacefronobsession34]

this movie scared the crap out of me when i was 10

[ZeldaWolf2000]

@zacefronobsession34 me to well the ending I remeber the most 'cuase I new she was going to the gas chambers. I actualy made an excuse to go to the bathroom during that scene. That's actualy what I normaly do when being forced to watch a scene in a movie at school that I think may be scarry. Seriusly I was like 10 or 11 when I watched this too. Scaring for life geeez stupid cariculam.

[34katpow34]

I had 2 watch this yesterday 4 school- it wuz Sooooo sad!!! I cried alot... Geez most of us were only eleven- do the teachers reuse that we could b scarred 4 life now?!

[mcflysos]

I hate how they killed Ariel...Why kill the cute guy huh?! >.<

[Goldenlillybeauty04]

we're watching this in humanities class

[ihprincess1013]

so wanna do this for my project!

[ZeldaWolf2000]

@ihprincess1013 I'm a quarter German and honestly this makes me imbarest to be. I know it wasn't the German people I'm not racist or anything, but still. If I die and go to heaven and find out that i"m realated to a Nazi I'll find him/her and punch him/her in the face.

[Vanessasmydog]

We watched this movie in class, but our priciples didn't want us to see it. It's a great movie

[ido741]

there is not gitil and here name is soppuse to be chaya when she is in poland... the book is good i looked through the cast its missing lots of the most important character

[GlobalGaming101]

I'm not jewish, but I hate this one kid that hates my jewish friend. It's messed up. I think he's part German.

[XxRhymeOrReasonxX]

@GlobalGaming101 ...I'm part German and I don't hate Jews? Please also note that it was NOT the German people in general who persecuted the Jews. It was the government. Sure, a LOT of the German people bought into the, "Jews are bad, they should die," thing, but again, some of them didn't. It's not like they could change the laws that Jews had to wear stars/couldn't have the same rights, etc. They had to live by them. So don't think it's always Germans VS Jews.

[JonKitchenisnotaguy]

I kill nazis on cod waw nazi zombies

[tally12671]

wernt the 4 men who tried to escape shot?

[ronaldorocks101]

@tally12671 in the book yes

[EmzyAnnFrsbrg]

Hannah wasn't 13, she couldn't be if she wanted that tattoo. But I'm watching this movie in Language Arts, so sad. D:

[GlobalGaming101]

@EmzyAnnFrsbrg

Yeah, I watching this movie in English class tomorrow.

[xxplayybunnyy]

i saw this movie few times and everytime i saw it , it was like i see it 4 the 1st time..

strong, tough and movie about caurage and love...its hard to watch but it won't stop dragging u to see it...

[Feelingbrookish]

LOVEEEEEEEE THIS MOVIE.

[tally12671]

@Feelingbrookish they left out alot of things from the book and in the movie the girl doesnt even look 13

[LoganHendersonFan1]

they made us watch this IN SCHOOL!!! I cried in front of every 1!

[00MsAlice]

@LoganHendersonFan1 i was watching it in history and i cried! Ur not alone!

[jelorenson]

@LoganHendersonFan1 what school did you go to

[DaFunkyPickle]

@LoganHendersonFan1 OMG. I will probably cry too. Tomorrow i have to watch it in school.

[032003hulk]

@LoganHendersonFan1 they mad us too

[xLittleprettydancer]

This to me is the most upsetting and horrible thing in all of history I cried when i read the book and cried when i watched the movie R.I.P those who were killed in the Holocaust we will never forget this tragic legacy

[KissHope]

@xLittleprettydancer

If you want to read something equally as good as the movie "The Last Jew In Berlin" is such a book. Another very deep movie is The Pianist but the most famous is "The Diary of Anne Frank". This subject matter can not be forgotten or history will repeat itself.

[xLittleprettydancer]

This to me is the most upsetting and horrible thing in all of history I cried when i read the book and cried when i watched the movie R.I.P those who were killed

[xLittleprettydancer]

I wished they at least had Esther,Shifre,Rachel and in reality Rivka is not Chaya's cousin just saying :) I had to read it in 6th grade

[laurenblahblah8]

What is the title of this sonng and is this movie too sad to watch?

[doubleg137]

@laurenblahblah8 Girl disappearing by Tori Amos. Its also in the description, don't know if you saw that. I didn't upon first viewing.

[laurenblahblah8]

@doubleg137 oh wow totaly missed that! xD Excuse me as I walk the hall of shame.. but thank you

[doubleg137]

@laurenblahblah8 no need to enter the hall.. I missed it myself. I used my cell phone to find out what it was.

[EdgeLover555]

I saw this movie in 6th grade. I cant believe Hitler did all this.

[PoncaGamerGirl]

I read the book. it made me cry!! I watched the movie it didnt have all of the stuff in it. but i still cried. Its a really good story. we read it in my reading class. it was so sad. VERY GOOD BOOK!!!

[ladyrbel]

anybody knows the title of the song in the trailer?

[doubleg137]

@ladyrbel Girl disappearing by Tori Amos.

[KittiKatti1]

I read this book in 9th grade. I think the book is a lot better but hey that just my opinion

[gtasanandreascj100]

THEY DONT GET EVEN TO THE MARRYING PART

[TheMrYummyPie]

The book had soo many things more than the movie but the movie itself was good.

[BASstorm97]

i love this movie!!

[Urzu7Angel]

love the book and movie..i love it very much =D

[1trev85]

i have to write a essay about how this movie is different to the book but the book is really good

[married2KiDcuDi]

Omg I am reading the book for a book report. I'll have to watch the movie after, looks good though

[iDIDurBFlastNIGHT95]

I like the book better than the actual movie.

[insight821]

were reading this in english its pretty good so far the movie looks good but were supposed to watch the movie at the end of the year

[imjustsayin615]

we just finished reading this book in english class its so good i cant wait to see the movie!!

[AUDR3Y001]

i was gona ask if we could watch this in class but its no graphic i guess. oh well. :/

[TheOmgism]

@AUDR3Y001 we watched this movie in class :)

[littlebuddy98]

im reading this in school so i shouldnt watch but i will LOL its not like my teacher would know but he said hell be watching me so....

:l

[AUDR3Y001]

were reading it too :)

[KrystalinasChannel]

I SAW THAT MOVIE!!!

[iDIDurBFlastNIGHT95]

@KrystalinasChannel So did like 80 % of the population. lol

[insight821]

were about to read the book in my class we have to do a resarch paper about it.

[hottyboy315]

i read the book it was so good and realy sad

[caligurlz23]

Yea were reading this in school I already finished it it's hella good!!!

[averyebrinn]

im reading this book in class so far its really good

[abyssdnb]

RIP Brittany Murphy

[amjustakid23]

@abyssdnb

she died?

[MegaDjtv]

The book is a lot better than the movie though that I can fully admit

[MegaDjtv]

I just finished reading the book I think it had a very

interesting ending but hay its my opinion not sayin its great though

[DanisTooFamous]

were reading the book at school.

its good, so i decided to watch the moviee on ytt (:

as far as ive seen, the book is better..

[andrewhoyos52]

I am reading the book with my class. I guess it wont hurt being the only one to watch the movie and knowing what will happen. right?

[utubeguy23441]

ur a dk im reading it too

[loki2687]

alguien me puede decir de quien es esta cancion??

[iyalordayy]

girl disapearing

by: tori ?

[loki2687]

@iyalordayy

Gracias !!

[mikaaa877]

There is no truth in this movie. Read about the real holocaust, then make a movie about it. A concentration camp it was blood, death, hunger, cruelty and bestiality. This movie is fuckin cakes and ale!

[tennisstars99]

u guys r right!!! the book is lik a whole lot better!!!!!!

[indychase1997]

I like the book kinda strange going back in time and stuff but it was a really good book and the part in the book were her grandfather is putting her body in the grave gives me chills....

[GetYourOwnUser]

Book is a whole lot better. This doesn't have half the things in the book!!!

[MermaidAbbey]

We're almost done with the book in school. We're seeing the movie on monday and tuesday. Is it good?

[tennisstars99]

This song is Girl Dissapearing by Tori Amos.

This is one of my favorite movies. But I read the book and it is nothing alike.

[hihipeoples]

this movie was so awazing.......kristen might of done some good movies but this has to be the best.

[Eliko6]

I don't know if you understand spanish but my english is some bad.

I only want to congratulate you for this beauty composition of images and music, I almost do mourn.

What song is it? I really interest in it.

Please answer me.

[gmd96]

fagg

[EmzyAnnFrsbrg]

@gmd96 Fuck you, how dare you say that. You don't know what went on in the Holocaust and who got killed or beaten or hurt. How dare you.

[Columboisback]

Brilliant movie...probably second only to Escape from Sobibor

[PirateXoXGirl]

i actually hate this movie. it shouldnt be called the devils arithmetic because it isnt anything like the book. first off- theyre missing half the family. they're suppose to call her Chaya when she goes back in time cuz its her hebrew name. shes only suppose 2 meet rivka when she goes to the camp, shes not her cousin, rivka worked at the camp as the person who gave them they're food. they changed the rest of the charactors names. I think the movie was cheap and not worth watching. READ THE BOOK!

[Columboisback]

What I really meant was the idea...Movie versions of book are always tend to be bad because when you read the book you've already created your own version of movie :) And movies also try to commercialize the book for box office. I shouldn't have said second best :)

[takinnn]

I like Kirsten Dunst! why people say she died?

[michellebellx]

@takinnn - she didn't, brittany murphy died.

[2cool4u1219]

how could she be 13 if she drives and gets a tattoo in the beginning of the movie

[VillagersNightmare]

Yeah, Didn't know Jews looked Northern European either..What an "accurate" film. *sarcasm*

[Nine00]

Ah somebody is stereotyping Jews. Not every Jew has dark thick hair, tan skin, a big crooked nose and dark eyes.

[julianjulianjulian7]

i loved this book

[crazycow226]

im being forced to read it in english. i hate 7th grade

[VillagersNightmare]

Say it's against your religion.

[crazycow226]

okay. ill try

[nerdsgeeksrule]

haha me too! whoa i just noticed this is you, angela. hi!

[crazycow226]

lol. nice claire. yeah, i just went on youtube and watched the videos about it instead of reading the chapters. dont tell ms.butler though...=)

[Aubsthegr8Sings]

I read the book for school but the day we watched the movie I was out sick. All my friends told me it was gross and bad but I really want to see it.

[crazycow226]

what grade are/were u in?

[Aubsthegr8Sings]

I was in 6th grade

[luisrmr90]

ive never watch this movie, this is the first video i see... it made me cry

[sonia8006]

amoreeeeeeeee

[musicisloveandlife78]

i watched it in class didnt read the book but i watched it and i was pretty good but very sad i cried

[TwistedVictorian]

i LOVE this movie!!

Its really sad and i cry every time i watch it. Its sad because of Rivka ( wrong spelling) and the guys that got hung.

[nikkithesheep]

i love the book. we had to read it in class but they didnt let us watch the movie

[GOODPLAYA20]

13? im pretty sure that girl ain't 13.

[bubblezlover7]

this movie scared me 2 death! my class had 2 watch it cause were learnin about the hollicost. and nearly allt he girls were like cryin!

[Angelkissesnj]

that's weird i just read it for my class. Is it sad b/c I cry easily.

[limersmom]

it is the saddest book in the world

[mee302]

does anyone know the name of this song?

[polarisdanexoxo]

Girl Disapearing

[trustusyeahright]

if you dont know your past you are doomed to repeat it.

NEVER AGAIN!

[thechosenone96]

we read this book it is really good and sad

[loserpickchick]

Ah, we;re watching this in my english class (: it looks good.

[DriveMeToTheCullens]

i just saw this movie earlier today i almost cried

my teacher said for everyone who couldn't take the hanging scene to close their eyes but in the book they shot them which was better and faster than hanging

[luja423]

what song is this?

[polarisdanexoxo]

Girl Disapearing

[fallboy37]

I am reading this book in my English class, and it's pretty good. I want to watch this movie.

[zxzxzx123456789zx]

this movie is pretty kool

[2014July]

i read the book and it was cool

so is the movie

[Jay16RW]

the books better than the movie... like it usually is in most cases.

[ShishioSeta]

I read this like 2 years ago, in 8th grade! I couldn't think of the name, and I really wanted to watch the movie, but now I can!!

[KrazyKristen123]

Amazing movie :)

♥

[karinrockss]

this movie was sooo good

[XxMinimaruSaruxX]

we're reading this in my english class at school, and it was kind of cool...

[12aaron77]

anyone from kingsford read this book

[candiegirlsforeva]

I watched thi movie and i swear it rox ppl jz freakin watch it k?

[candycane126]

i read the book. it was fabulous, as probably the movie is also!

[clbrow7]

Can someone plz tell me the name of this song plz thanks!!!!!

[RobotMice]

who sings this?

[danibunnygirl]

Tori Amos - Girl Disappearing

[ConstipatedBanana]

i read the book for a book report, its great!

[clbrow7]

heyyyy can someone plz tell me what this iz rated thanks and the book iz really great,i just really hate hitler and some of the natzis im so glad hitler died!!!!because we could hav been through this but im glad we didnt

[XxMinimaruSaruxX]

i second that, and im not even jewish

[musicluver266]

we watched some of it today in english, and we have been for the past couple days, the moment where the men get hung I could hardly watch. too personal.

[ItachiUchiha50999]

i read it too i didnt cry cuz i didnt understand (then i had to write a book report on it wich ended up sinking my english grade to an F)

[torchic1990]

omg read the book and i love it

[LeahLegittx]

I watched that movie in class just today.

[Iron8loser]

SHE'S NOT THIRTEEN

[startrekfreak01]

she is in the book

[roseam]

The jews are doing the same thing to the palestine woman and children only their doing it in the palestinian's own country and with bombs.

[Ru55ianGrim]

ofmg i watched this movie in 7th grade (im in 8th) and omfg my whole class wanted to watch the movie and not go home..love it..any website where i can watch the whole movie?

[selenajulia]

i read the book

[yerushalmit]

I just saw the movie now for the first time and can't stop cry... so terrifying to know that it was real and milions of people died like that:(

[tfandcs1]

in school we read this book and i read it 4 times and our whole classed cried(even the boys!!)

[Nine00]

Is Rivkah her aunt in the book too?

[Jay16RW]

In the movie, Rivka is Hannah's cousin. In the book, Rivka is a girl who befriends Hannah/Chaya who's parents and family members have all died except for her brother Wolfe, who is a Kommandos and is forced to carry the dead. Once she's back in the future, Rivka ends up being Hannah's Aunt Eva. Hannah knows by her tattoo.

[Nine00]

Thanks. I did read the book by now . It was better than the movie, but the movie was nice too.

[saxbetch]

i luv the movie!! and the book!! and brittany murphey and everyone else in this movie were amazing!! it must of been hard to pull of the part of a nazi and a prisinor

[marioz16]

shes not 13 shes like 16!

[Nine00]

In the book she's 13. But i guess she's about 15-17 in the movie.

[hanukkah1995]

i am jewish. everyone is the same. i cannot believe this actually happened.

[WBMGM]

i read the book but i never knew it was a movie

[LadyViking101]

Great video, and can anybody please tell me the name of this song?

[kaoshisane]

Name of song: Tori Amos - Girl Disappearing

[xXxBasikxXx]

ten film jest przerażajacy i nie powinnismy sie smiac z kawałów o zydach bo tu własnie jest przedstawione ich cierpienie!!

[kaoshisane]

Nie tylko żydzi doświadczyli represji.Ile naszych rodaków zmarło w obozach za ''zbrodnie przeciwko'' rzeczy niemieckiej.Ludzie są bezlitośni a niemcom NIGDY nie wybacze holocaustu i II Wojny...

[hate8like8]

I think the book is beter the movie is very interising though but they toke out so many thing from the book like Shule was her uncle

[mormonGIRL15]

i just recently saw this movie and loved it!