James so did not deserve to go so early i was so pissed for days when he got voted off james is freakin unbelievable he entertained every week what was up with america seroiusly i thought lauren would of went for sure the top 3 was not my pick i thought james,pia and stefano or casey and James announced the winner. James is too good for idol cant wait for his album James ROCKS.
u know what they say, weed out the competition (strongest contestants). tweens, u may have sabotaged the talented singers, but all you are left with is a plain peice of stale bread at the end.
I cried. The only reason I continued to watch it was because I wanted to see Haley get voted off. I hated her, She was horrible. I was so mad. This, was the worst result EVER. James will allways be the winner to me <3
@BluePolcadots Thats what I hated the most was that growl. I dont care if you like her. Thats you. I think what I wanna think and you think whatever you want to think.
@Peaceandlove270 she wasnt horrible, your taste in music is. and i think its a little unfair to say someone is "horrible" if its your tastes in music arent the same. you dont have to be a bitch about it, just say haleys music style wasnt for my taste. someone being horrible would be...well probably what you sound like when you try to sing but it just comes out as shit.
@ando1135 I'll admit, I did go overboard with the whole thing, but I just dont like her voice. I wasn't trying to offend anyone. Or be rude. I just don't like her voice. And yes, I do have a bad singing voice. But you don't need to point that out. So, Again. Sorry if I offended anyone by sharing my opinion. But thats no reason to call me out. So just stop with the rude comments.
I WAS SO MAD AT THE AUDIENCE WHEN THEY WERE CHEERING SCOTTY'S NAME. JAMES SHOULD'VE WON THIS COMPETITION. HE SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ELIMINATED. SCOTTY BROUGHT THE SAME OLD THING OVER AND OVER AGAIN WITH HIS LOW NOTES. THE ONLY REASON SCOTTY WON WAS BECAUSE THE LADIES LOVED HIM BECAUSE HE WAS CUTE. WHAT A DUMB REASON TO VOTE FOR SCOTTY.
@KingofDrums19 oops i didnt mean to *thumbs up* -- i know right?! ive seen many people say that they were totally sure that he would not be eliminated but he did anyway :/ america prefers country singers, not rockstars :/ what a shame
lauren and haley are jerks, all happy that james is gone, and look at lauren right when james was eliminated , james is better than all 3 of them, ironically those were the first 3 people i wanted eliminated at the top 13
@balotelli456 that's because they both know that they made it farther than they should have based on luck and pity, and now that the real competition is out of the way they're happy. Seriously I called Haley out at 11th and Lauren out at 5th I don't know what happened. This voting system is fucked!
@11gothicprincess of course and that is why this season was robbed and im just glad someone else agrees with me about at least haley getting voted off 11th i personally think she was completely fake mainly at the beginning of the competition
@PrincessNicole101 shut the hell up it was the song he sang love potion number 9 that no one liked and haley did 10000 times better then him on that night
@PrincessNicole101 shut up! I'd like to c u do better, Haley was the best in that competition even if she didnt win! James was a good singer, but just becuz he got sent home doesnt mean tht u gotta trash somebody else thts actually good!!!!! have a heart for cryin out loud jeeeeesh!
I seriously was convinced it was Scotty going home. Then i was like...oh. Scotty is good too, but i assumed it gonna be Lauren and James in the finale with Lauren winning. Whatev Haley shouldn't have been there.
You people are starting to act like Adam Lambert Fans, pissed over your pick losing and taking it out on the other contestant. I was very angry over James losing, but you don't see me taking it out on Scotty, Haley, or Lauren because it is not their damn fault.
James is better but there is no need to hate on scotty. Scotty is amazing to. Anyway james is my favorite and it should have been james scotty and casey in the finals.
fuck, James is the best, really the best, i'm in Brazil, and was accompanying James, and i must say, he should have won, maybe more people around the world think the same...
James, you represent a lot of rockers on the world, me included, just because the way you are, and the songs you sang, thanks man
God! They both are amazing! Haley should have gone! HATE HALEY!!!!!!!!!!! Scotty is amazing and the real and true American Idol...but I like James too! Where the hell Haley deserves to be in Top 3! And if u are with me people then thumbs up! ;)
JAMES SHOULD HAVE WON that makes me super pissed off james was the BEST out of all of them... fuck all scotty fans country music is gayyyyy he sounds like a josh turner wanna be his music careger is gonna go doooooowwwn the toilet! james is gonna be MUCH MUCH MUCCCHHH more famous than scotty McQUEERY, or scotty mcCREEPY!!! :D for reals, scotty is an ugly redneck big eared FREAK everyone who didnt vote for the AH-MAZING James durbin and instead voted for scotty mqueery has no taste in music. :)
Excuse me....Scotty has such beautiful and proffessional voice! You don't even know what is music...you just like drama and the people who kills the stage! And better watch your tongue....
I was trying not to fall asleep during those last two competition shows of the season because they were so boring. How did Scotty get to the top 3 and win American Idol? Not in million years, based on all the talent, I would've thought Scotty McCreery was the American Idol back in the Top 13. "His voice is so low and amazing." I can sing exactly like him, and the reason America made a mistake was because you'll find thousands of Scotty singers out their, but there's only one James Durbin.
first pia, paul,stephano,casey and now james you voters out there have no taste what so ever . james durbin is too talented for american idol . GO JAMES GO JAMES
first pia, paul,stephano,casey and now james you voters out there have no taste what so ever . james durbin is too talented for american idol . GO JAMES
okay, scotty, hayley, lauren, and james were all good. but james was the best. he didnt deserve to lose. even the judges had the WTF face expression. that shows that he is still gonna be famous
james durbin is the most talented of this season without a doubt, votes can't take that away from him and they BETTER give him a record deal, cuz i would def buy and i'm sure many would too
This made me wanna cry!!!!!!:( seriously... James was very inspirational... So I'm sad!! He should have won... But now since he's gone I want Scotty to win
Forget about the negative comments Scotty because you will gonna make it! You're such a great singer and you're the reason why I have country songs on my music lists.:)
everytime i watch this i feel like i 'm watching a dream . i still cannot believe hes gone from the show :( but im glad he'll be back in a few days (:
He was and still is the best of all the contestants this season. It is so unfair that he was not included in the top three. He should have won first place. He has it all, talent, creativity, carisma, feeling. He is the best. Go James. You will succeed. Smart producers must have noticed you already.
lauren is a real fucking bitch and you know, i say that actually she'll win why???? because she was the only contestant to do whatever she was told, randy saying that they want an artist is shit, they want someone they can control and unfortunately american voters usually vote for the ones that without these shows would do nothing about their lives. lauren to be a diva like you believe you are yoou've got way long road ahead and yet i believe you'll stay way too short!
James was for singing for his family, America ! people should have voted for him and he was the best ! people just don't go for their singing and no sympathy only they look at the style, features and all it's about SINGING people not just looks ! If I could vote I would only vote the one who was good at singing and who did great that day ! but, now there is no use of saying this James is out now ! I pity for him=( but no worries James you got a Million fans to support you ! and you are My Idol !
well,I wanted James to win but he didn't, so now I wish Haley should win , I've always hated Haley but as she came nearer and nearer she got better and better and now I guess she is the best among Scotty and Lauren ! Scotty only sings country type songs ! and Lauren sings only one type of songs ! so, they are no use. Haley you go girl ! GOOD LUCK with Haley =) Plus, I'm so sad James is out I wish if they never used the wildcard for Casey they should've used it for him atleast !
@MegaRockstare: I agree about jazz being an art, but so is heavy metal. People only see it as noise, but if you think about it, its a pretty complex type of music.
OMG Hayley and Lauren had the nerve to be grinning? I'm loving the judges and Scotty atm. They were all obviously upset to see James go and the girls are grinning and smirking?Thats just mean. I'm going to grin and smirk when THEIR dreams get smashes
I love the show and all the contestants this season :) Hopefully one day I'll make it on the show, and I'm working hard for it! I would love if everyone went to my page a gave me their HONEST opinions
First they get rid of Chris Medina after using his story for ratings, then Pia, then Casey and now James Durbin?!?!
Do the producers have ears?!?! Both Pia and Chris landed record deals. James has an amazing voice and can put on a show that won't get boring...who'll we be hearing from more? Some redneck or real talent?
I DONT CARE HOW THAT PIECE OF GARBAGE "SCOTTY IS SPELLED,,, HE IS STILL A PIECE OF GARBAGE . LIKE DRUNK HALEY AND LAUREN, THE WORST FINALISTS EVER ,EVER EVER IN A.IDOL
A.IDOL IS NOT A SINGING COMPETITION ANYMORE " IS A NOT CONTEST"
AND IS A RUBBISH COMPETITION BETWEEN HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
WITH A 120 MILLIONS DOLLARS PAID TO THE THREE STOOGES JUDGES A.IDOL IS F...G.. FRAUDE. THAT WILL BE DOWN FOR GOOD...
o GOD all the voters suck!!!! i cant believe this happend. i dont care for this show no more.
im not sure what scotty is doing there or why he has made it this far. i thought james was really going to win this whole thing. none of them really desrive to be there.casey should have still be on.most voters dont know how to vote how does james never got in the bottom and just next week he goes home. whats up with that?i guess i just dont get it.im pissed but i know we will hear from james again!
@TheAlsala Yes my friend for some reason I just hate Lauren I wanted James or Haley to win now HALEY FTW!! I hate Scotty he sounds like he's singing the same song over and over.
I agree I the top three from the beginning would be James/Haley/Casey never thought Scotty would make it this far. We all know he's going to win though. Regardless but we can try but he has been number one since day one and none of the top four would of beaten him! Not that he is bad just not my cup of tea he can hit low notes but no high ones. American Idol can be someone thats going to blow the house out like James or Haley. My opinion
SCOTTY FOR THE WIN.....HE CAN SING...HAILEY SUCKS.....SHE SHOULD OF GONE HOME NOT JAMES....JAMES KICKED ASS......I VOTED SEVERL TIMES FOR BOTH JAMES AND SCOTTY....WAS HOPING THEY WOULD GO TO END TOGEATHER......LOVE YOU BOTH....YOU BOTH ROCK
I want Haley to win this year. Country music is my least favorite type of music. I at least like Haley's jazz/blues background.
After watching more of Scotty, I realize that he's drained out by the band because his voice really is that weak. I watched a homecoming video on youtube and Josh Turner blows him out of the water.
As for Lauren, she simply doesn't have enough confidence. She didn't go for the high note(s) on Unchained Melody 2 weeks ago and was messing up notes last week.
@strikebowler585 BOOO HAILEY SHOULDNT WIN SHE SUCKS....I HOPE THAT SCOTTY WINS....JAMES WAS SO AWSOME.....AND IDOL SUCKS FOR KICKING JAMES OFF...IT WAS BAD ENOUGH WHEN THEY LET PIA, CASEY AND PAUL GO....BUT NOW JAMES.....SO IF SCOTTY GOES...I WILL NEVER WATCH IDOL AGIAN....
Please help James Durbin! Justice must be done! The phonelines were crazy that night and the numbers were all mixed up. Please watch my video. Send it to people. Justice must be done here! We contacted Fox, talked to us. They might bring James Durbin back! Please people! Continue to fight for the best!
@ricardodanielm hi who is more stupid, its u coz u are blaming others just bcoz james is voted off? its ur fault coz u didnt voted 4 him so dont say bad words ok...dont blame scotty 4 that coz scotty deserve the title....
@amaina123 I wish that you learn about REAL talent next season. Scotty is good BUT he is so boring, predictable and we can compare him with others... Haley and James are kinda different and original. But whatever scotty won... I don't care I'm not going to buy anything from him and everyone happy... Have a Nice summer;)
@reylCHiNoe91 really funny that haileys been in the bottom several times and james had never been in the bottom at all....he was amazing singer i hope the best for him and i really hope scotty wins....Hailey NEEDS TO GO HOME...SHE SUCKS...
She hasnt been in the bottom in a long time!! Just to let you know Lauren was in the bottom two last week dont blame James elimination on Haley, if anyone it was whoever was in the bottow the week previous
James was robbed. He's AMAZING. But why put the blame on Haley? Lauren and Scotty took his votes as much as Haley did. Sheesh. If you're a fan, why don't you go and vote so you don't complain later on.
@singinglover2010 LOL I love Haley and all and yourenright about Lauren smirking but I think she was just happy her best friend Scotty made it through :-) oh and yes Haley's Maah girl too ;)
I would believe that but she smirked before she even looked to see he was coming over ?? I dont know at least its clear everyone knows Haley didnt smile!
well judges, that's what you get for not giving REAL criticism when it was desperately needed (closer to the edge), and making it blatantly obvious you were more interested in getting him to the top 3 than actually judging...and also making it obvious who you wanted to leave (haley, which i still don't understand why they hate her so much). im actually happy that their plan to get rid of haley backfired, although unfortunately it's james who's paying the price.
This is bull his two performances Wednesday were flawless as opposed to Haley who slaughtered her first song then gave the judges attitude. If the voting was truly based off of performance Haley would've gone home. Hope Scotty wins now
@11gothicprincess Agree with you totally. Haley should be gone based on her trashing of the MJ song and smiling when Pia was voted off, and the fact that Lauren smirked when James was voted off was not pretty. Now I hope Scotty wins, and I had wanted a girl to win this time, but no more.
this show is rigged why do you think they never announce the votes or why do all the idol winners never give credit to american idol, BECAUSE ITS FAKE, the ppl who make idol work get money every time the winner of the previous season sells a record, so obviously they just pick the person they think will make money and give them the win, if thats not enough then why did they give arkansa free texting right when the finals where on between adam and kris??? can you say rigged
I think Haley actually has a chance of winning now!!!! All the country voters will split the votes between Lauren and Scotty, thus giving Haley a spot in the finale. GO HALEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I think after this year, the judges should get to choose who goes on after the top 5. This way the best people really do move on, and not the kids that just get voted by little teenage girls.. If this happened, James would still be in this competition, like he should be.
Can I politely ask what you don't understand about your favorite getting the least amount of votes? I mean just cause I like Haley more then James doesn't mean it's Haley's fault that James is gone. It's all about who people like. Just cause someone doesn't like what you like doesn't make their taste shittier then yours.
OKAY EVERYONE STOP IT AT 36-37 SECONDS, DOES ANYONE NOTICE HER FACE? LAURENS FACE? SURPRISE SURPRISE EVERYONE TALKED ABOUT HALEY SHE WAS SAD AND ONLY SMILED WHEN HE PERFORMED LIKE PROUD OF HIM. ENOUGH SAID
Scotty didnt steal James' spot, Haley did cuz Scotty has been top receiver of votes. All the James fans should vote for McLaina cuz Haley deserved to go not James.
@LaUtNeRLuVr23 Excuse me, but Haley did how? She sang her heart out just as James and the others did and her fans voted their butts off. I loved James and was very upset he left because I really hoped for a James Haley top 2 but there's no need to blame Haley. She didn't hack the voting system to make herself stay..? So don't blame her. She deserves to be there just as James does.
SORRY HONEY BUT LAUREN WAS IN THE BOTTOM TWO SO IF ANYONE STOLE JAMES VOTES IT WAS LAUREN! SHE WAS IN THE BOTTOM TWO THE WEEK BEFORE. THANKS FOR TRYING TO PUT HALEY ON THIS ONE
I HATE AI NOW AFTER JAMES WAS ROBBED!!!!!!!!I CALLED AND VOTED FOR JAMES SINCE DAY 1 AND WED NIGHT THE LINES WERE BUSY I SAY RECOUNT THE FLAWED AI VOTING SYSTEM AND BRING JAMES BACK!!! HE WAS THE ONLY REASON I WAS WATCHING THIS YEAR A TRUE BRIGHT STAR. HALEY IS NOT MARKETABLE AND IS A NOBODY WITH A ATTITUDE, BUT JAMES YOU ARE A TRUE STAR!!!!!!!! WILL BUY YOUR MUSIC ANYDAY AND LOOKING FORWARD TO YOU SIGNING A MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR CONTACT!! :0
Look at the judges faces.........says it all. Hope Scotty goes next round. Who cares who wins now ............you sent the only real talent home America.
lol it's a joke that Scotty Mcreery went through!! I'm shocked he is this year's Nikki Mckibbin!!! I'm glad casey went home though a long time ago, he was good in hollywood but nothing else all he did was shout and scream
James so did not deserve to go so early i was so pissed for days when he got voted off james is freakin unbelievable he entertained every week what was up with america seroiusly i thought lauren would of went for sure the top 3 was not my pick i thought james,pia and stefano or casey and James announced the winner. James is too good for idol cant wait for his album James ROCKS.
anitagorsic82 5 months ago
Young girls are dumb and so predictable. Why not just yell James! James! Before the results were anounced? Just sayin.
shwonsh 5 months ago
i got to meet james
teddybear4422 6 months ago
u know what they say, weed out the competition (strongest contestants). tweens, u may have sabotaged the talented singers, but all you are left with is a plain peice of stale bread at the end.
ando1135 6 months ago
i was so upset when i heard that james was eliminated. he was my favourite! he deserved to win!!! he needed it for his family!! i was so upset! :(
nancydrew0987 6 months ago
Steven tyler shouldve like, Cussed them out. He knew James was the real talent
GoGurt102102 6 months ago
I cried. The only reason I continued to watch it was because I wanted to see Haley get voted off. I hated her, She was horrible. I was so mad. This, was the worst result EVER. James will allways be the winner to me <3
Peaceandlove270 7 months ago
@Peaceandlove270 How was haley bad how many singers do you kno that can control their voice like hers... She can growl and hit high notes.
BluePolcadots 6 months ago 2
@BluePolcadots Thats what I hated the most was that growl. I dont care if you like her. Thats you. I think what I wanna think and you think whatever you want to think.
Peaceandlove270 6 months ago
@Peaceandlove270 Well damn dont gotta be a bitch bout it...
BluePolcadots 6 months ago
@BluePolcadots I wasnt. At all. Sorry if it came out that way.
Peaceandlove270 6 months ago
@Peaceandlove270 she wasnt horrible, your taste in music is. and i think its a little unfair to say someone is "horrible" if its your tastes in music arent the same. you dont have to be a bitch about it, just say haleys music style wasnt for my taste. someone being horrible would be...well probably what you sound like when you try to sing but it just comes out as shit.
ando1135 6 months ago
@ando1135 I'll admit, I did go overboard with the whole thing, but I just dont like her voice. I wasn't trying to offend anyone. Or be rude. I just don't like her voice. And yes, I do have a bad singing voice. But you don't need to point that out. So, Again. Sorry if I offended anyone by sharing my opinion. But thats no reason to call me out. So just stop with the rude comments.
Peaceandlove270 6 months ago
I WAS SO MAD AT THE AUDIENCE WHEN THEY WERE CHEERING SCOTTY'S NAME. JAMES SHOULD'VE WON THIS COMPETITION. HE SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ELIMINATED. SCOTTY BROUGHT THE SAME OLD THING OVER AND OVER AGAIN WITH HIS LOW NOTES. THE ONLY REASON SCOTTY WON WAS BECAUSE THE LADIES LOVED HIM BECAUSE HE WAS CUTE. WHAT A DUMB REASON TO VOTE FOR SCOTTY.
spquinn14 7 months ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
JAMES DURBIN FANS PLEASE WATCH, PARTICIPATE, AND SPREAD THE WORD
THUMBS UP
watch?v=nJc78B_NqOU
PeaceLoveDurbin 7 months ago
@KingofDrums19 oops i didnt mean to *thumbs up* -- i know right?! ive seen many people say that they were totally sure that he would not be eliminated but he did anyway :/ america prefers country singers, not rockstars :/ what a shame
angelkitty2205 7 months ago in playlist james durbin
i was so shocked by this that i cried :( that was unfair. UNFAIR I TELL YA! =/
angelkitty2205 7 months ago in playlist james durbin
i love you james!
TURDUCKENSRRUS 7 months ago
lauren and haley are jerks, all happy that james is gone, and look at lauren right when james was eliminated , james is better than all 3 of them, ironically those were the first 3 people i wanted eliminated at the top 13
balotelli456 7 months ago
@balotelli456 that's because they both know that they made it farther than they should have based on luck and pity, and now that the real competition is out of the way they're happy. Seriously I called Haley out at 11th and Lauren out at 5th I don't know what happened. This voting system is fucked!
11gothicprincess 7 months ago
@11gothicprincess of course and that is why this season was robbed and im just glad someone else agrees with me about at least haley getting voted off 11th i personally think she was completely fake mainly at the beginning of the competition
balotelli456 7 months ago
Comment removed
balotelli456 7 months ago
Haley should have been the one to go home not James!!!! Haley sucks at singing!!!!!!!!!!
PrincessNicole101 8 months ago
@PrincessNicole101 shut the hell up it was the song he sang love potion number 9 that no one liked and haley did 10000 times better then him on that night
floodedtick 8 months ago
@floodedtick FUCK YOU BITCH!!!!!!!!!! Haley has zero talent!!!!!
PrincessNicole101 7 months ago
@PrincessNicole101 nooo she has 1000000 times more then James he's good but she's better so fuck off
floodedtick 7 months ago
@PrincessNicole101 shut up! I'd like to c u do better, Haley was the best in that competition even if she didnt win! James was a good singer, but just becuz he got sent home doesnt mean tht u gotta trash somebody else thts actually good!!!!! have a heart for cryin out loud jeeeeesh!
TayTay5289 7 months ago
I seriously was convinced it was Scotty going home. Then i was like...oh. Scotty is good too, but i assumed it gonna be Lauren and James in the finale with Lauren winning. Whatev Haley shouldn't have been there.
shwonsh 8 months ago
You people are starting to act like Adam Lambert Fans, pissed over your pick losing and taking it out on the other contestant. I was very angry over James losing, but you don't see me taking it out on Scotty, Haley, or Lauren because it is not their damn fault.
Utubeman67 8 months ago
James is better but there is no need to hate on scotty. Scotty is amazing to. Anyway james is my favorite and it should have been james scotty and casey in the finals.
Pzeidenberg1 8 months ago
Scotty deserves the same respect as Justin bieber and Rebecca black
PieceOPWN 8 months ago
you guck stupid idiot guy of scotty
marianaguell23 8 months ago
I hate scotty macrury for winning what I thinck is james should have won and scotty should be crying becuse he couldent pass trough the top 24
marianaguell23 8 months ago
go to hill 44 haters
marianaguell23 8 months ago
fuck, James is the best, really the best, i'm in Brazil, and was accompanying James, and i must say, he should have won, maybe more people around the world think the same...
James, you represent a lot of rockers on the world, me included, just because the way you are, and the songs you sang, thanks man
TheKillerFrog19 8 months ago
God! They both are amazing! Haley should have gone! HATE HALEY!!!!!!!!!!! Scotty is amazing and the real and true American Idol...but I like James too! Where the hell Haley deserves to be in Top 3! And if u are with me people then thumbs up! ;)
meMYSELFandI295 8 months ago
its so sad that he had 2 go b/c i really liked him. i loved his version of may b im amazed. it was so good it gave me chills when i heard it.
penquin402 8 months ago
JAMES SHOULD HAVE WON that makes me super pissed off james was the BEST out of all of them... fuck all scotty fans country music is gayyyyy he sounds like a josh turner wanna be his music careger is gonna go doooooowwwn the toilet! james is gonna be MUCH MUCH MUCCCHHH more famous than scotty McQUEERY, or scotty mcCREEPY!!! :D for reals, scotty is an ugly redneck big eared FREAK everyone who didnt vote for the AH-MAZING James durbin and instead voted for scotty mqueery has no taste in music. :)
Macy64CP 8 months ago
Excuse me....Scotty has such beautiful and proffessional voice! You don't even know what is music...you just like drama and the people who kills the stage! And better watch your tongue....
meMYSELFandI295 8 months ago
poor james :(
TheSamryan12 8 months ago
u r wrong james and lauren both rule!!!!! how dare u!!!!! that is so mean!!!!!
simsim0125 8 months ago
After James and Casey, how much more shicking can it get?
TheBridFlyingSolo 8 months ago
Retard voters. Scotty is nothing compared to James. BOO
LittleMissToad1 8 months ago
he is the best guy ever.if i was in america id vote a million times
MrJogimico 8 months ago
i´m portuguese... i cannot understand... the other guy sucks all the way... i don´t understand ... James or Pia shoud´ve won...
macedo5 8 months ago
I was trying not to fall asleep during those last two competition shows of the season because they were so boring. How did Scotty get to the top 3 and win American Idol? Not in million years, based on all the talent, I would've thought Scotty McCreery was the American Idol back in the Top 13. "His voice is so low and amazing." I can sing exactly like him, and the reason America made a mistake was because you'll find thousands of Scotty singers out their, but there's only one James Durbin.
redber16 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
first pia, paul,stephano,casey and now james you voters out there have no taste what so ever . james durbin is too talented for american idol . GO JAMES GO JAMES
audrey11able 9 months ago
first pia, paul,stephano,casey and now james you voters out there have no taste what so ever . james durbin is too talented for american idol . GO JAMES
audrey11able 9 months ago 9
_|_ Scotty _|_ Yeah that's right. I'm still sore over this shit
blazinpok 9 months ago
NO! Stupid voters! u have cost us yet another talent once again. as if killing off Pia wasn't enuff
MCRadmirer 9 months ago
I'm gonna follow James, always will ... but you can't make "bum notes" when the "public ear" is your judge.
newtonscat 9 months ago
He should've been at least in the final 2. I hope he gets a record deal.
HotCelebGuysTurnMeOn 9 months ago
SCOTTY DIDN'T DESERVE TO WIN IDOL...
NeonAngel0714 9 months ago
@NeonAngel0714 oh he has already proven that he deserved
Nayaniify 8 months ago
okay, scotty, hayley, lauren, and james were all good. but james was the best. he didnt deserve to lose. even the judges had the WTF face expression. that shows that he is still gonna be famous
LesleyIsAwesome 9 months ago 2
Haley is so hot! And shes hella good at singing
COOLSTORYHAN5EL 9 months ago
Haley sucks ass haha. I don't get why everyone loves her. She is the biggest bitch on stage..
MakutaThe2 9 months ago
thumbs up for NO REASON!!!!!
Themusicmega 9 months ago
The judges look guilty.
kckc1975 9 months ago
He sucked anyways...How he made it to the final 4 baffles me
AandM4eve 9 months ago
I know that scotty win
SaintedRv 9 months ago
why does it have to be james! :(
OboyJave17 9 months ago
aww jame is so much better than scotty :(
fancywords 9 months ago
i'm sad u left james but U BETTER WIN SCOTTY
GoGirl9923 9 months ago
james durbin is the most talented of this season without a doubt, votes can't take that away from him and they BETTER give him a record deal, cuz i would def buy and i'm sure many would too
TheSidhappens 9 months ago
This made me wanna cry!!!!!!:( seriously... James was very inspirational... So I'm sad!! He should have won... But now since he's gone I want Scotty to win
BlondeVSme 9 months ago
Forget about the negative comments Scotty because you will gonna make it! You're such a great singer and you're the reason why I have country songs on my music lists.:)
jTever08 9 months ago
everytime i watch this i feel like i 'm watching a dream . i still cannot believe hes gone from the show :( but im glad he'll be back in a few days (:
beccabby900 9 months ago
I HATE SCOTTY
Valeriavaleria06 9 months ago
He was and still is the best of all the contestants this season. It is so unfair that he was not included in the top three. He should have won first place. He has it all, talent, creativity, carisma, feeling. He is the best. Go James. You will succeed. Smart producers must have noticed you already.
MultiPelangocha 9 months ago
lauren is a real fucking bitch and you know, i say that actually she'll win why???? because she was the only contestant to do whatever she was told, randy saying that they want an artist is shit, they want someone they can control and unfortunately american voters usually vote for the ones that without these shows would do nothing about their lives. lauren to be a diva like you believe you are yoou've got way long road ahead and yet i believe you'll stay way too short!
rocilluvi1 9 months ago
Watch Haley, She is so Stuck on Herself!!!!!! You can tell she thinks she has it in the bag. She Looks Totally Conceited!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bifirefly420 9 months ago 2
AMERICAN IDOL NEED THE MONEY FROM THE SPONSORS FOR 2012,
A.IDOL TRYNG TO CONVINCE THE SPONSORS THAT THE RATINGS ARE HIGH
THATS A BIG LIE
THE RATINGS ARE LOW 12% AND IT ,,WERE NOT 90 MILLIONS VOTES THATS ANOTHER BIG LIE.
THE RATINGS ARE LOW AND A.IDOL KNOW.
manguera9 9 months ago
I SAID BEFORE THIS COMPETITION IS A " NOT CONTEST"
THE QUALITY OF THE 2 FINALIST ARE VERY LOW ,THIS IS THE WORST FINAL A.IDOL EVER, EVER, EVER.
GOOD FOR THE TRHEE STOOGES JUDGES THE GOT THEIR PAY 120 MILLIONS DOLLARS ,FOR NOTHING, SPEC, J LOPES THE TRASH TALKER.
manguera9 9 months ago
I MADE A COMMENT IN "IDOLX FACTOR" YOU TUBE PAGE, OVER SCOOTY AND
HE BLOCKED ME ,PROBABLY HE RECIEVE MONEY FROM A.IDOL.
IS VERY SAD TO HEARD LAST THURSDAY THAT THEY WERE 90MILLIONS VOTS
THATS THE BIG" LIE"
AMERICAN IDOL IS LYING THERE WERE ONLY 32 MILLIONS VOTES
A.IDOL WANTS TO RENEW A CONTRACT WITH THE SPONSORS FOR THE NEXT 2012
A.I WANT THE SPONSORS TO BELIEVE THAT THE RATING ARE HIGH BUT NO
THE RATINGS ARE LOW ONLY 12 %,IS VERY SAD THAT THIS SHOW IS IN DECLINE .
manguera9 9 months ago
James was for singing for his family, America ! people should have voted for him and he was the best ! people just don't go for their singing and no sympathy only they look at the style, features and all it's about SINGING people not just looks ! If I could vote I would only vote the one who was good at singing and who did great that day ! but, now there is no use of saying this James is out now ! I pity for him=( but no worries James you got a Million fans to support you ! and you are My Idol !
TwilightFreakFairy 9 months ago
well,I wanted James to win but he didn't, so now I wish Haley should win , I've always hated Haley but as she came nearer and nearer she got better and better and now I guess she is the best among Scotty and Lauren ! Scotty only sings country type songs ! and Lauren sings only one type of songs ! so, they are no use. Haley you go girl ! GOOD LUCK with Haley =) Plus, I'm so sad James is out I wish if they never used the wildcard for Casey they should've used it for him atleast !
TwilightFreakFairy 9 months ago
What the hell! James was the best person on the show!!!!!! Seriously America? Seriously? Lauren and Scotty? WTF is that about?
MadMadameMim22 9 months ago 3
@MadMadameMim22 TOTALLY AGREE
Valeriavaleria06 9 months ago
Lauren is gonna beat Scotty. It's a plan for a girl winner. That's why Haley was 3rd, and James only got 4th.
shwonsh 9 months ago
WHAT THE HELL JAMES DURBIN IS OUT ?! AMERICA ITS SO WRONG BRING HIM BACK ! HE DESERVES TO WIN =(
TwilightFreakFairy 9 months ago
@MegaRockstare: I agree about jazz being an art, but so is heavy metal. People only see it as noise, but if you think about it, its a pretty complex type of music.
sonicnator 9 months ago
I cant belive he lefted i dont like scotty at all.
Andy1995loveyou 9 months ago
Didn't deserve it
Swimmergirl89ify 9 months ago
Thanks america this Durbin guy has such a annoying voice
jade007z 9 months ago
@jade007z
You have no taste of music, seriously.
tino258 9 months ago
@tino258 I AGREE WITH YOU JADE U HAVE NO TASTE IN MUSIC SERIOUSLY MAN
TwilightFreakFairy 9 months ago
In america loserS fare better than the winners.Don`t worry about James............
sande882 9 months ago
Really???????????????????????
perrysalembinks 9 months ago
OMG Hayley and Lauren had the nerve to be grinning? I'm loving the judges and Scotty atm. They were all obviously upset to see James go and the girls are grinning and smirking?Thats just mean. I'm going to grin and smirk when THEIR dreams get smashes
BlondeTheEagle 9 months ago
@BlondeTheEagle OZMGOD, they're human, someone go shoot them now!
1satchvai 9 months ago
0:53 James aint throwin "im ok signs" those aware already know this..
rocknflip66 9 months ago
@rocknflip66 Yes he is...he said in an interview he was telling his fiancee Heidi everything was okay
BlondeTheEagle 9 months ago
This is so fucking sad!
whatdhellusername 9 months ago
I'm not a big fan of James, I'm sorry, but I totally wanted him to stay over Scotty. Ugh Scotty.....
flan6 9 months ago
wtf?!!! i thought he was gonna be the next american idol!!
i2l3e4a5n6a 9 months ago 2
Fuck this rigged voting!!!! First pia now james!! I refuse to watch the rest of the season abdolutely refuse
James durbin 4ever-3
Luv4EverNatalie 9 months ago 2
I love the show and all the contestants this season :) Hopefully one day I'll make it on the show, and I'm working hard for it! I would love if everyone went to my page a gave me their HONEST opinions
EliasMedranoMusic 9 months ago
Randy's pissed! It's okay, James will be more famous than all of them
snc020193 9 months ago
James = My idol
TheBlacke99 9 months ago
Haley's awful. She should have been gone in the beginning. Scotty and Lauren both have real talent. Hopefully one of them wins it all over her.
Elau8827 9 months ago
SO SAD IDOL!!!!!YOU DONT MAKE IT......
I WILL BUY UR ALBUM SOON.....:-))
WE FILIPINO LOVE U
dadulaism 9 months ago
hurray
james is out lol!!!!
juanmagsasaka19 9 months ago
@juanmagsasaka19 you are an idiot...he definitely had the best voice there
SamRaisbeck 9 months ago
@juanmagsasaka19: He was the best one one that show.....
sonicnator 9 months ago
WOW this is a rigged contest.
First they get rid of Chris Medina after using his story for ratings, then Pia, then Casey and now James Durbin?!?!
Do the producers have ears?!?! Both Pia and Chris landed record deals. James has an amazing voice and can put on a show that won't get boring...who'll we be hearing from more? Some redneck or real talent?
aloha2302 9 months ago
I DONT CARE HOW THAT PIECE OF GARBAGE "SCOTTY IS SPELLED,,, HE IS STILL A PIECE OF GARBAGE . LIKE DRUNK HALEY AND LAUREN, THE WORST FINALISTS EVER ,EVER EVER IN A.IDOL
A.IDOL IS NOT A SINGING COMPETITION ANYMORE " IS A NOT CONTEST"
AND IS A RUBBISH COMPETITION BETWEEN HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
WITH A 120 MILLIONS DOLLARS PAID TO THE THREE STOOGES JUDGES A.IDOL IS F...G.. FRAUDE. THAT WILL BE DOWN FOR GOOD...
" THE VOICE" AND X FACTOR ARE THE REAL DEAL.
manguera9 9 months ago
Same thing happened with Pia
thegriffinsutube 9 months ago
o GOD all the voters suck!!!! i cant believe this happend. i dont care for this show no more.
im not sure what scotty is doing there or why he has made it this far. i thought james was really going to win this whole thing. none of them really desrive to be there.casey should have still be on.most voters dont know how to vote how does james never got in the bottom and just next week he goes home. whats up with that?i guess i just dont get it.im pissed but i know we will hear from james again!
misszalah 9 months ago
james should of won the whole thing. you voters suck
kokane187211 9 months ago 2
thumbs up if lauren shouldve gone
TheAlsala 9 months ago 18
@TheAlsala Yes my friend for some reason I just hate Lauren I wanted James or Haley to win now HALEY FTW!! I hate Scotty he sounds like he's singing the same song over and over.
Quincyincy 9 months ago
@TheAlsala @ricardodanielm both of yu think exactly like me no joke
CiTayTunEz 9 months ago
i love scotty and all but James is sooo much better!
WeBeCrazy138 9 months ago 2
This should have never happened, it should have been Scotty !!!!
born2besomebody12 9 months ago 2
WOW LAUREN IS A BITCH!!!! SHE HAS A SMIRK ON HER FACE AT :36 GRRR.... :(
MrButterBrownies 9 months ago 10
@MrButterBrownies think its cause shes like going out with scotty
mattymanten 8 months ago
@mattymanten true haha but still...
MrButterBrownies 8 months ago
I agree I the top three from the beginning would be James/Haley/Casey never thought Scotty would make it this far. We all know he's going to win though. Regardless but we can try but he has been number one since day one and none of the top four would of beaten him! Not that he is bad just not my cup of tea he can hit low notes but no high ones. American Idol can be someone thats going to blow the house out like James or Haley. My opinion
singinglover2010 9 months ago
Out of all them Haley was the saddest
nmjaim 9 months ago 2
@nmjaim Yeah people are so mean to her because she stood up for herself now that James is gone he actually wants Haley to win.
Quincyincy 9 months ago
SCOTTY FOR THE WIN.....HE CAN SING...HAILEY SUCKS.....SHE SHOULD OF GONE HOME NOT JAMES....JAMES KICKED ASS......I VOTED SEVERL TIMES FOR BOTH JAMES AND SCOTTY....WAS HOPING THEY WOULD GO TO END TOGEATHER......LOVE YOU BOTH....YOU BOTH ROCK
Sallywebb67 9 months ago
I want Haley to win this year. Country music is my least favorite type of music. I at least like Haley's jazz/blues background.
After watching more of Scotty, I realize that he's drained out by the band because his voice really is that weak. I watched a homecoming video on youtube and Josh Turner blows him out of the water.
As for Lauren, she simply doesn't have enough confidence. She didn't go for the high note(s) on Unchained Melody 2 weeks ago and was messing up notes last week.
strikebowler585 9 months ago 4
@strikebowler585 BOOO HAILEY SHOULDNT WIN SHE SUCKS....I HOPE THAT SCOTTY WINS....JAMES WAS SO AWSOME.....AND IDOL SUCKS FOR KICKING JAMES OFF...IT WAS BAD ENOUGH WHEN THEY LET PIA, CASEY AND PAUL GO....BUT NOW JAMES.....SO IF SCOTTY GOES...I WILL NEVER WATCH IDOL AGIAN....
Sallywebb67 9 months ago
@Sallywebb67
So whose cares so if Haley gets voted off we wont watch it ever again either, no one wins its a comptetition!
singinglover2010 9 months ago
@Sallywebb67 IKR?!?!??!
MrButterBrownies 9 months ago
@Sallywebb67 Haley rocks she is amazing this was meant for opinions and show favorites not trolls...
Quincyincy 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please help James Durbin! Justice must be done! The phonelines were crazy that night and the numbers were all mixed up. Please watch my video. Send it to people. Justice must be done here! We contacted Fox, talked to us. They might bring James Durbin back! Please people! Continue to fight for the best!
LabanDERO155 9 months ago
At 0:36 and 0:37 Lauren is smirking!!!!!!! Ugh I loved James but still vote for Haley on Wednesday!!
mcollier1235 9 months ago 2
Stupid Scotty McBitches. You totally ruined the show. BITCHEEEEEEES. HALEY FTW!!
ricardodanielm 9 months ago 23
@ricardodanielm hi who is more stupid, its u coz u are blaming others just bcoz james is voted off? its ur fault coz u didnt voted 4 him so dont say bad words ok...dont blame scotty 4 that coz scotty deserve the title....
amaina123 9 months ago
@amaina123 I wish that you learn about REAL talent next season. Scotty is good BUT he is so boring, predictable and we can compare him with others... Haley and James are kinda different and original. But whatever scotty won... I don't care I'm not going to buy anything from him and everyone happy... Have a Nice summer;)
ricardodanielm 8 months ago
:: among they three, HALEY is simply THE BEST~! n yet ONE OF THE BEST CONTESTANT ever! HALEY FTW!!
reylCHiNoe91 9 months ago
@reylCHiNoe91 really funny that haileys been in the bottom several times and james had never been in the bottom at all....he was amazing singer i hope the best for him and i really hope scotty wins....Hailey NEEDS TO GO HOME...SHE SUCKS...
Sallywebb67 9 months ago
@Sallywebb67
She hasnt been in the bottom in a long time!! Just to let you know Lauren was in the bottom two last week dont blame James elimination on Haley, if anyone it was whoever was in the bottow the week previous
singinglover2010 9 months ago 2
@Sallywebb67
well.. haley still there nway HAHA :) america stilll voting for her n yet want her to win :))
reylCHiNoe91 9 months ago
are you kidding my god james is amazing i would like to know what you consider talent you must be tone deaf. JAMES IS AWESOME
anitagorsic82 9 months ago 2
The country boy is going to win or the country girl Haley should win but she is better off not winning
kikolounge 9 months ago
0:36 Lauren Alaina happy and Haley sad. Scott sucks. I hope Haley wins now. The world are waiting for you. From Venezuela.
fuentealba1982 9 months ago 21
Scotty is a country boy nothing much.We Need SIMON!!
SuperNichkun21 9 months ago 3
This show really really REALLY needs Simon back!!
MissDidz 9 months ago 2
James was robbed. He's AMAZING. But why put the blame on Haley? Lauren and Scotty took his votes as much as Haley did. Sheesh. If you're a fan, why don't you go and vote so you don't complain later on.
WingDaisy 9 months ago
@singinglover2010 LOL I love Haley and all and yourenright about Lauren smirking but I think she was just happy her best friend Scotty made it through :-) oh and yes Haley's Maah girl too ;)
k3vinlee 9 months ago
@k3vinlee
I would believe that but she smirked before she even looked to see he was coming over ?? I dont know at least its clear everyone knows Haley didnt smile!
singinglover2010 9 months ago
well judges, that's what you get for not giving REAL criticism when it was desperately needed (closer to the edge), and making it blatantly obvious you were more interested in getting him to the top 3 than actually judging...and also making it obvious who you wanted to leave (haley, which i still don't understand why they hate her so much). im actually happy that their plan to get rid of haley backfired, although unfortunately it's james who's paying the price.
smileydm66 9 months ago 3
This is bull his two performances Wednesday were flawless as opposed to Haley who slaughtered her first song then gave the judges attitude. If the voting was truly based off of performance Haley would've gone home. Hope Scotty wins now
11gothicprincess 9 months ago
@11gothicprincess
Haley got three satnding ovations through out the show scotty got how many? right...
singinglover2010 9 months ago 3
@11gothicprincess Agree with you totally. Haley should be gone based on her trashing of the MJ song and smiling when Pia was voted off, and the fact that Lauren smirked when James was voted off was not pretty. Now I hope Scotty wins, and I had wanted a girl to win this time, but no more.
puddya 9 months ago
this show is rigged why do you think they never announce the votes or why do all the idol winners never give credit to american idol, BECAUSE ITS FAKE, the ppl who make idol work get money every time the winner of the previous season sells a record, so obviously they just pick the person they think will make money and give them the win, if thats not enough then why did they give arkansa free texting right when the finals where on between adam and kris??? can you say rigged
TimeisMoney164 9 months ago 3
I think Haley actually has a chance of winning now!!!! All the country voters will split the votes between Lauren and Scotty, thus giving Haley a spot in the finale. GO HALEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jumptoit3 9 months ago 2
I think after this year, the judges should get to choose who goes on after the top 5. This way the best people really do move on, and not the kids that just get voted by little teenage girls.. If this happened, James would still be in this competition, like he should be.
R41nM4n07 9 months ago
HOW DID AMERICA HAVE THE FUCKIN BALLS TO DO THIS???
OkieDookie12 9 months ago
Can I politely ask what you don't understand about your favorite getting the least amount of votes? I mean just cause I like Haley more then James doesn't mean it's Haley's fault that James is gone. It's all about who people like. Just cause someone doesn't like what you like doesn't make their taste shittier then yours.
coolmanccp20035hf 9 months ago 2
OKAY EVERYONE STOP IT AT 36-37 SECONDS, DOES ANYONE NOTICE HER FACE? LAURENS FACE? SURPRISE SURPRISE EVERYONE TALKED ABOUT HALEY SHE WAS SAD AND ONLY SMILED WHEN HE PERFORMED LIKE PROUD OF HIM. ENOUGH SAID
singinglover2010 9 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
worst decision ever.
CharaLover33 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
worst desision ever.
CharaLover33 9 months ago
worst desision ever.
CharaLover33 9 months ago
Scotty didnt steal James' spot, Haley did cuz Scotty has been top receiver of votes. All the James fans should vote for McLaina cuz Haley deserved to go not James.
LaUtNeRLuVr23 9 months ago
@LaUtNeRLuVr23 Excuse me, but Haley did how? She sang her heart out just as James and the others did and her fans voted their butts off. I loved James and was very upset he left because I really hoped for a James Haley top 2 but there's no need to blame Haley. She didn't hack the voting system to make herself stay..? So don't blame her. She deserves to be there just as James does.
mle4realz 9 months ago
@LaUtNeRLuVr23
SORRY HONEY BUT LAUREN WAS IN THE BOTTOM TWO SO IF ANYONE STOLE JAMES VOTES IT WAS LAUREN! SHE WAS IN THE BOTTOM TWO THE WEEK BEFORE. THANKS FOR TRYING TO PUT HALEY ON THIS ONE
singinglover2010 9 months ago 4
I hate scotty, James is the B-E-S-T
Valeriavaleria06 9 months ago
I HATE AI NOW AFTER JAMES WAS ROBBED!!!!!!!!I CALLED AND VOTED FOR JAMES SINCE DAY 1 AND WED NIGHT THE LINES WERE BUSY I SAY RECOUNT THE FLAWED AI VOTING SYSTEM AND BRING JAMES BACK!!! HE WAS THE ONLY REASON I WAS WATCHING THIS YEAR A TRUE BRIGHT STAR. HALEY IS NOT MARKETABLE AND IS A NOBODY WITH A ATTITUDE, BUT JAMES YOU ARE A TRUE STAR!!!!!!!! WILL BUY YOUR MUSIC ANYDAY AND LOOKING FORWARD TO YOU SIGNING A MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR CONTACT!! :0
abeezy813 9 months ago 4
Look at the judges faces.........says it all. Hope Scotty goes next round. Who cares who wins now ............you sent the only real talent home America.
squirrel1612 9 months ago
I LOOOOOOOOVVVVVEEEEDDD JAMEEESSS MAAAAAANNNN<33333333333333<333333333333 UR MY OTHER ADAM LAMBERT BUT ADAM'S FIRST BUT WHO CARES U ROCK TOO!!!<333
Ilovecakesandmusic 9 months ago
Scotty and Haley will be top 2. they both have own power of voice.
wen8812 9 months ago
lol it's a joke that Scotty Mcreery went through!! I'm shocked he is this year's Nikki Mckibbin!!! I'm glad casey went home though a long time ago, he was good in hollywood but nothing else all he did was shout and scream
yangster982000 9 months ago
Don't worry, you got a bright future ahead, James. AI was just the start. True fans will stay with you.
rockhardzacky 9 months ago 2
The night where I stopped watching American Idol.
TheWWExpert 9 months ago 3
this just sucks man!! like scotty and lauren in the top 3? Half of the americans blind?
nate24ification 9 months ago