This sounds like my Uncle Wu's karaoke version during his drag show. I'll stick to Faye Wong's cover, thanks. (Actually my uncle sings a lot better than this).
@pug1gun Everyone knows Superwoman/多得他 is famous for the high notes 真假轉音part, wonder why Sammi didn’t sing that? BECAUSE SHE CAN’T!!! Gladys’s version is actually lower than the original, but Patti belt it out one octave higher!
@CityRhythmPart1 Glady sings lower register in perfection and patti is known to be a vocal belter, I have no problem liking them equally and even to sammi and faye
LOL@pug1gun!!! Get your facts straight before you even try to debate this any further! Listen and learn, the original version of 多得他 is Superwoman by Karyn White released from her début album in 1988, Faye/Shirley Wong covered it in 1990. Gladys Knight then covered it in 1991 with her friends Dionne Warwick and Patti LaBelle. These are the FACTS.
@pug1gun Good point, but when a hit song is known for its higher key or high notes, it’s rather anticlimax not singing it, yet keeping the arrangements in a very similar style to the original version, why bother?
@CityRhythmPart1 if faye's version is the first version, you may be right, however the original version was actually a duet by Patti Labelle, Gladys Knight & Dionne Warwick. The key is the same with Sammi's, and is clearly sung better than faye's version, but again singing in different key doesnt make the song bad.
She sung this very well. Hit the high notes perfect. Her voice has improved.
womblewandering 2 months ago
love this version as much as 王菲. her and Faye both wear the weirdest hats haha.
PhukIT1865 3 months ago
@PhukIT1865
Didnt she and faye have rivalry back then? thats what i read
womblewandering 2 months ago
@womblewandering don't know anything about that
PhukIT1865 2 months ago
5想比較王菲和鄭秀文邊個唱得好,我只知道我聼王菲/曹格/憶蓮的版本,我都好有感覺,甚至整個人融入落距地把聲到,但鄭秀文的版本我就完全無感覺,But鄭秀文有D歌我都中意既。
superwoman5181 3 months ago
i love both sammi n faye
finfinn9 3 months ago
我都like sammi果個多D,聽落去冇faye果個咁沉重,and really:感覺潮D 鍾意sammi個人風格=]
csmmi20mi 5 months ago 3
好明显这个版本要潮多了 王菲的比较老土
joe9731ljy 7 months ago
@joe9731ljy 也不看看王菲的版本是哪年出的...90s年好伐~
yogi930 4 months ago
yeah~
SimonWon1 8 months ago 3
Sammi 唱的屬很有水準表現了 實力派 !
如果改要某位現今歌壇拿獎破了 梅姑 Sally Sandy紀錄的某女歌手來唱
能聽嗎......
CATHAY330 8 months ago 2
Comment removed
abcdefgkafuu 9 months ago
i actually like sammi's version o_o that CD cover with khalil fong
uohecc 9 months ago
OK la . Consider this is quite a difficult song !
Freedomhongkong 10 months ago
气不够,降KEY
lyk526 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
其實我都鍾意SAMMI個VERSION多D
但唔等於王菲個VERSION唔好囉~冇話邊個勁D~唔同FEEL者~
kwaysote講得岩,
Sammi can't sing most of Faye's songs
AND Faye can't sing most of Sammi's songs
bebebebebu 10 months ago
我怎么覺得這個version比較好聽??
hoccmyolie1026 11 months ago 8
兩個屬性完全不同的歌手
csmmi20mi 1 year ago 4
haha唔夠氣
babypiggy101 1 year ago
Let me tell this...
Sammi can't sing most of Faye's songs
AND Faye can't sing most of Sammi's songs
kwaysote 1 year ago 8
係咪佢既咬字問題? 點解唱得甘做作feel??
iceqwe 1 year ago
This sounds like my Uncle Wu's karaoke version during his drag show. I'll stick to Faye Wong's cover, thanks. (Actually my uncle sings a lot better than this).
TimTimato 1 year ago
Every singer got their differrent version...
Can't actually compare to each other.
In my opinion Sammi's version is very nice actually :D
williamhwl 1 year ago 4
同王菲真係無得比-,-!
sammi同佢差幾棒^^!
chaosb520 1 year ago
FAYE IS WAY BETTER!!
CityRhythmPart1 1 year ago
@pug1gun Everyone knows Superwoman/多得他 is famous for the high notes 真假轉音part, wonder why Sammi didn’t sing that? BECAUSE SHE CAN’T!!! Gladys’s version is actually lower than the original, but Patti belt it out one octave higher!
CityRhythmPart1 1 year ago
@CityRhythmPart1 Glady sings lower register in perfection and patti is known to be a vocal belter, I have no problem liking them equally and even to sammi and faye
pug1gun 1 year ago
LOL@pug1gun!!! Get your facts straight before you even try to debate this any further! Listen and learn, the original version of 多得他 is Superwoman by Karyn White released from her début album in 1988, Faye/Shirley Wong covered it in 1990. Gladys Knight then covered it in 1991 with her friends Dionne Warwick and Patti LaBelle. These are the FACTS.
CityRhythmPart1 1 year ago
@CityRhythmPart1 ya thx, very informative
pug1gun 1 year ago
I prefer Faye's version
OxygenOfHappiness 1 year ago
sammi 唱的也很有~sammi的味道唷~
nimo0624 1 year ago 2
This is the true original cover of this song /watch?v=f2C3EFZtCTw&p=AAB35B51737D1C31&playnext=1&index=17
pug1gun 1 year ago
其實Sammi用chest voice的方法唱, 王菲就用多了head voice, 兩個風格唔同, 兩個都好, Sammi唱別人的歌用自己的style好正確.
pug1gun 1 year ago 30
請留意唱歌唔係越高音越好聽, 係應該用最適合自己的key, 唔通你話徐小鳳, 梅艷芳個D唱得差?
pug1gun 1 year ago 2
@pug1gun Good point, but when a hit song is known for its higher key or high notes, it’s rather anticlimax not singing it, yet keeping the arrangements in a very similar style to the original version, why bother?
CityRhythmPart1 1 year ago
@CityRhythmPart1 if faye's version is the first version, you may be right, however the original version was actually a duet by Patti Labelle, Gladys Knight & Dionne Warwick. The key is the same with Sammi's, and is clearly sung better than faye's version, but again singing in different key doesnt make the song bad.
pug1gun 1 year ago
@CityRhythmPart1 try to listen to this /watch?v=Y-2olRqxK7c&feature=related
pug1gun 1 year ago
sammi is not really a great singer but it was good... faye did better on her live version..
gordillomock 1 year ago
this is much better than 多得他 --- 王菲
tchow27 1 year ago
真係低音左好多,個key係唔同
sitarabbit 1 year ago
@sitarabbit
個key係一樣,只不過sammi cut左後來的高音部分
mrmatchman 1 year ago
not too bad...very nice version actually :D
williamhwl 1 year ago 3
Was this a recent performance? Last show I saw was the Show MI one back in 07 or 08 I think
Zero0X19 2 years ago
this is from the sammi vs sammi concert
lchau0718 2 years ago
The backup singers made the song really great.
leek7001 2 years ago 7
Comment removed
trevvyboy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
My ears suffer when listening to this version..
forever1221andrew 2 years ago
yeah sammi's always in alto range
i love the higher version, but sammi's performance of the song is deep and soulful
edwinicq 2 years ago 4
冇低key呀
係sammi 把聲厚d同實d姐
不過你話呢個version 係冇王菲o個首咁難唱就真
mrmatchman 2 years ago 24
好似比王菲低左幾個key...
water123choy 2 years ago
LOVE Sammi, awesome performance, love her low range!
edwinicq 2 years ago