Added: 3 years ago
From: matteman93
Views: 242,962
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (186)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • They didn't say there'll be snow at christmas in BRAZIL!

  • This is soooooo great. U2 do great covers. Love this one.

    Merry Christmas Bono, U2 and to everyone.

  • Bono should carry Lake's instrumental cases... but not sing his songs! He's so bad singer vs. to Greg. Whatever - Marry Christmas!!! :)

  • @mikedrummer00 Lake's performance of this song isn't exactly bad, but it's somewhat deadpan without as emotion. This cover summons up something other than than the jaded attitude of the original, so it's quite appropriate to put something deeper and more emotional into it. Bono is a superior singer to Lake in general, too, most definitely in this song.

  • Merry Hope This Christmas from Ohio!! (o:

  • Im so sad Bono !!! The original song is important for chldrens in the world :-( please please sing again !!! But dont fast like vertigo :-)

  • Bono singing flat and sqwauking,  No sorry this is an epic FAIL and an insult to the original.

  • Comment removed

  • Merry Christmas to all!

    

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Merry Christmas from Poland :** !

  • Beautiful Cover from the best Band of the World!!!

  • Prelijepa pjesma... još jedan dar magične četvorke... HVALA!

  • I believe in the awesomeness of this beautiful band <3

  • one, two, three, seven Lakes..... LOL he's only one Lake .....Greg forgive them....

  • Amazing....

  • aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaww!!! los amo !!!! u2 unos capos!!!

  • I for one love this, especially The Edge's guitar sound. The camera work on the video was cool, too.

  • merry christmas from France !

  • beLIEve.

  • GREG LAKE'S version will forever be my fav' version. I f@@kin HATE this version. Where is the power, where is the passion. And Bono..... make a pis@in effort. Embarces version was good, Greg Lake version my fav' xmas song ever but this one.... Not for me sorry..... Dont like it one little bit. Dont bother Bono!!!!!!!!

  • @ojwatts thats the christmas spirit., LOL

  • Not as good as the original...but what a treat this is. U2 is only second to Beatles.

  • Fantastic. Loving The Edge's work on this, too. No idea why people feel the need to watch this if they prefer the original version. I like both of them. Merry Christmas :)

  • god bless you bono

  • bono sounds better than ever

  • I agree, The Edge is highly rated. I wouldn't have picked the guitar up if it wasn't for The Edge. I love his minimalist approach.

    I don't think this is better than Greg Lake's original, just different. Still great though, but I think The Edge is the star of the show here.

  • Song does not really kick in till 2:04

  • BEST version of this song ever!

  • Personally, I believe in Larry Mullen.

  • @KangoTV I believe in Harvey Dent

  • :,)

  • Bono's Got The Edge!!!!

  • the edge is soooooooo underrated

  • @ledzelda9 Not really, he is one of the most reveered and worshiped guitarists on the face of the planet.

    So, hardly underrated really.

  • Think shane mcgowan would do a better irish version of this...passionate but aggressive!

  • Thanks. Interesting change in the lyrics to adapt the song to his own personal faith.

  • safety glasses for the good man bono

  • normally I find bono's ultra affected phrasing and voice utterly obnoxious and his lyrics no matter how profound in subject to also be insipid as to content. But, obviously I had just been waiting to hear him the right vehicle. thank you Greg Lake The Edge is awesome, same as always, (-:

  • @wardbond1974 the word insipid is insipid

  • wonderful....but the old g.lake-version is the best x-mas-popsong ever

  • wonderful....but the old g.lake-version is the x-mas popsong ever

  • I was hoping for something good, but this is murderous and so awful, Bono should be ashamed. Totally effing awful.And I rarely make comments on here.

  • This is so beautiful it almost makes me cry.. Bono & Edge are outstanding..

  • the 19 people who dislike this HATE REAL MUSIC

  • THIS IS WEAK! (I LOVE ELP's versions. And I like a lot of U2.)

    Are they on 'ludes here? This is shockingly flaccid. 

  • It's good.....but NO ONE can do it like Greg Lake.

  • as always u2 fuck everything they touch. if lake were death he will be wallowing in his tumb.

  • @Akron162 As you said he's not dead here's what he said about U2 covering the song:

    "The guitar part is very clever and the vocal, as always with Bono, sounds sincere. That is the mark of a great singer.

    Well done chaps! It is great to see the song serving such a worthy cause"

    So on one hand you have the biggest band on the planet and on the other you have the guy who wrote the song praising what they did so how about you tell me why anyone should give a shit what you think?

  • @DanotheSnitch i don't give a shit if anyone gives a shit of what i say, i just say it because is may opinion ad i can say it. Anyway, u2 has allways been terribly overrated, and this version still sucks.

  • Good version but Greg Lakeis still on the moon!

  • This is a great cover, but not even half as good as the original. But I certainly don't dislike, I think it's very well recreated!

  • Great but nothing beat the first verson

  • the intro sounds like the intro of "wanted dead or alive" by Bon Jovi.. ? ..

  • Sorry but Greg Lake's version is better.

  • I believe in father christmas

  • que asco. lo hiciste una vez mas.

  • I believe in father Christmas

  • I believe in father Christmas.

  • I Believe In Father Christmas - single by Greg is the original GorzaU2 but Edge is the Best..

  • Ah, The Edge.

  • Beautiful! Nothing strums the strings of my heart like the Edge armed with his guitar.....

  • Great song. Merry Christmas everyboy.

  • q reine la concordia y la paz en su hogares , U2 - I Believe In Father Christmas ,

  • beeewdiful...!

  • Judging by the glasses, cap and "hair", I'd say 2006?

  • Gave me the christmas feeling. Thank God.

  • parapararapara...... amzing acords Edge

  • GRANDE BONO

  • The Edge and his guitar - priceless!!

  • great son g for christmas ever from u2 i play it almost every day

  • he's singing flat

  • @funk7000 He's been singing a little flat lately. Does this mean that U2 doesn't allow auto-tune? I think I'd rather have a slightly flat singer than a CD treated with auto-tune.

  • Like them both .. the Original from Greg Lake , and the Version from U 2 

  • I love Greg Lake and Peter Sinfield - and I like U2's cover. It's not necessary to praise the originators by despising the current interpretation. Most everything Bono touches turns to some precious metal. Why not a great song from ELP's great catalog?

  • see you 2-4-11 in arg :D

  • Oh Dear!!!!!

  • Oh dear!!!!!!!!

  • This is dire. It doesn't hold a candle to Greg Lake's original.

  • we love u bono the 2nd coming

  • I feel I am not alone in thinking this band nowadays has a negative midas touch - everything since Actung baby has been a pile of Irish shit - this butchered song being no exception.

  • Sorry, Bono and U2 -- no one can top the Original from Greg Lake and Emerson, Lake and Palmer . . . although Sarah Brightman's version does give the song a serious run for the money, IMHO.

  • Great lyrics by Pete Sinfield! :oD

  • This song was wrote by the legendary Greg Lake (King Crimson, Emerson Lake & Palmer) against the usual business of Christmas time. A great version.

  • Oh dear...slaughtered!

  • I love it... 

  • @littlegypsy71 Shut up

  • @littlegypsy71 you're gay...

  • decent enough cover....bono does ok, but one of the VERY rare times his voice doesnt do the song justice... rest of the band played it beautifully.

  • horrible

  • @bobek3x How do you figure

  • @tantradrewien personal taste?

  • even if you don't like it I wish you a merry happy Christmas HO HO HO

  • Nice cover. not the original but a good cover/update

  • beautiful

  • I love the subtle changes he made in the lyrics. Rules.

  • Pretty awesome! Still prefer Greg Lake's version cuz it's the original and his voice suits it better; But I DO love the guitar work from The Edge on this one!

  • LOVE IT ...

  • so simple. so beautiful!!!!!!

  • the beatles said they were bigger than jesus so u2 should say there bigger than santa

  • @grahamleg

    Here we go again..

    another dim wit Who took the quote litterally

  • @wordimus i didnt mean it literally it was meant to be a stupid joke

  • wow great version!!!!!!!!!!

  • It's funny how everyone says it's not as good as the original one. Well - yes i am a big U2 fan, but I don't really like the original one, but Bono and Edge make this magic..

  • what a wonderful song

  • Not as good as the original, but they do a good cover of it.

  • 25 more days guys :D

  • So tired of people commenting on every cover song ever made how nobody can do it better than the original. We get it so STFU

  • U2 is great band and Bono one of the best singer ever, but this is Greg´s song and nobody can do this song better than Greg. Merry Christmas

  • can't touch Greg Lake.... sorry Bono!

  • So funny that Bono wears eyeliner in this video. Wonder why he dropped it later for the tour ; ). Love this cover tough.

  • i believe in love,we believe in LOVE!!!!fabulous 4 from dublin FOREVER!!!!!

  • anyone know where i can buy this??

  • @murraymanu2 Was available as a download from redwire .com a year ago, not sure if its still available. Can email to you if you message me.

  • merry x-mas and happy new yearz from belguim

  • first time I have ever seen or heard this cover ... true nothing like Greg Lake at all.. but I got the same goosebumps I always get every single time I hear this song!!

  • It's in too high a register for his voice. As you get older your vocal range lessens, unless you are Jackson Browne and sing ballads. The mddile 8 he was straining, and he should go up, but he dropped an octave. Not a patch on the original, imo.

  • Definitely a worthy effort, I still like Greg Lake's version better.

  • Any one know how to get a recording of this?

  • @jmartinfour it was on a starbucks ep from last year

  • Ring those bells The Edge

  • Best christmas song ever!!!

  • Edge can do the bests sounds of the world only with a guitar and effects, he's a fucking genius, listen to delay on this song, it's just brilliant!

  • @GonzaU2 I love the dotted 8th note delay setting. Its amazing! A 12 string Rickenbacker and a Vox AC30 are a beautiful combination.

  • @GonzaU2 I love the dotted 8th note delay setting. Its amazing! A 12 string Rickenbacker and a Vox AC30 are a beautiful combination. The shimmer effect makes it even more amazing.

  • @GonzaU2 the original ..I Believe In Father Christmas - single by Greg but Edge is the Best..

    Merry Christmas

  • This man Bono was on Grafton street December 24 2009 with the people of Dublin before spending the night with his family.... Is there any other frontman that would be doing something like that on Christmas eve or any other day for that matter.. Ive met Bono many times and he has been more than a gentleman

  • Awesome cover of a Greg Lake classic.!

  • this version of this song is the best piece of music i've ever listened to..

  • why am i listening to chrimbo songs in august you ask?

  • Comment removed

  • The Outro is amazing.

  • This is good; but, not good as Greg Lake's.

  • U2 wrote "Miami"

  • Awesome  - the norm for U2

  • Bono makes this a piece of magic. he is beautiful

  • hey merry Christmas everyone

  • This song is so soothing seeing that the Irish had a World Cup berth ripped from their grasp... Bono was the one who stood up to Sepp Blatter...

  • ♥♥ Lieber Engel! ♥♥

    ♥♥ Schöne Grüße nach Darmstadt! ♥♥

    ♥♥ I wish you a hopeful Christmas ♥♥

    Wolfgang

  • WOW this is absolutely amazing. such a pretty song thats even better from bono's voice. i watched this several times and each time it was amazing. They should put out a christmas CD on year.

  • Merry Christmas to Everyone, And Happy Holidays to Everyone who does'nt Celebrate Christmas.

  • No more Jingle Bells!

  • Well, after listening to this song 4 or 5 times now, I think the band still sounds great, but it may be time for Bono to change his name to "Meh Vox".

    Also, interesting that he changed the lyrics from, "'til I believed," to "but I believed". Way to betray the song.

  • @zone1doorman

    Carp?

  • I always knew U2 secretly loved prog-rock.

  • great version, i love it

  • I believe in Father Bono!

  • @u2dismantle05 Lol, I have to agree with you there!

  • @u2dismantle05 Lol, I agree with you there!

  • @u2dismantle05 Lol, I agree with you there.

  • Where can i download this?

  • they were giving away cds with this on it free at starbucks when i was there last.

  • I KNOW! I'd enjoy getting one, I wouldn't open it either. it's gonna sell for like 100$ in a year or two

  • do u no wot cd it is called

  • gimme your e-mail

  • great band

  • fuck off willy u low down shitmen.

  • your language makes you sound even more stupid and hostile than Willy!!! You didn't listen to the words of the song did you???

  • yeah i didnt listen to the words of the song. sorry ill remove my un-informed comment......

  • Awesome!

  • best irish band ever!!!

    best band ever!!!

    nough said

  • that would be referred to as class. im sure u dont understand that.

  • I cant wait for christmas day!

  • I cannot wait for the new studio album in early March.

  • The Edge, Larry Mullen Jr., Bono y Adam Clayton. Thank you and Merry cristmas

  • wow Bono...you are a