The dude is awesome... This is a guy that's got his sh.. together, most def.
Just read somewhere that the 5 elements are actually something added later on to Hsing Yi, and the original Shanxi did not contain them.... I allways thought that 5 elements was the absolute basis... Anyone no anything 'bout it?
but thats kinda like saying that the english language didn't have g-r in the original style,
5 elements isn't just a movement set, it's the foundation movement patterns that the style uses for everything. it's kinda like taking the reverse punch out of karate.
Im wondering what you read said about what they did practice, if not 5 elements?
@richardshapiroII Well, my thoughts exactly! Just reread the M.A. mag. in wich i thought i read it and it turns out i misunderstood the article. Translation error! My bad!
Yes, Pao Chuan was the last segment. It does look different, but definately Pao. So the order was Pi, Tsuan, Peng, Heng, Pao. I usually do Pao before Heng. Anybody care to comment on the order? Is there a constuctive/destructive sequence that is mandatory?
i do pao before heng, too, thats the classic constructive order. I also like to use a cycle of heng-beng-tsuan-Pi-Pao-Heng it's building up the organs from bottom to top, then back to bottom. . for martial use, you need to be able to do them in any order, in any rhythm, while adjusting the distancing and direction.
also, good to know the "controlling" cycle, to know what element to use to counter. like rock/paper/scissors.
i didn't see pao, looked like the last 2 were just 2 variations of heng... not a shanxi practitioner so don't know if they do their pao differently or something??
The last one was supposed to be Pao Quan since all the others were done (Pi, Zuan, Beng, Heng...) So I was expecting Pao at the end. Was that "Pao Quan"? Because, it doesn't look like it. It looks like a modified Heng Quan!!
i think thwe last one was heng quan, it had the different arm-foot combination, as heng quan form is supposed to. but the twist on the outward looked similar to the one before it. so i think the whole set was done at the order of pi-tsuan-beng-pao-heng as i've seen in many videos.
super..technik..very.very good...thank you..and greetings from germany...berlin
lutang15 3 months ago
wow he is very impressive. I wonder how long he practices standing pole practice
daily to develop his santi shi
TheSapala 9 months ago
No he does not demonstrate Pao, He shows 1.Pi 2.Zuan 3.Beng 4.Shun Bu Heng ( smooth step) 5. Ao Bu Heng (reverse step). Hope this helps
ukguy 1 year ago
Nice!
Jubeski 1 year ago
The dude is awesome... This is a guy that's got his sh.. together, most def.
Just read somewhere that the 5 elements are actually something added later on to Hsing Yi, and the original Shanxi did not contain them.... I allways thought that 5 elements was the absolute basis... Anyone no anything 'bout it?
3rdEyeBlinking 1 year ago
@3rdEyeBlinking that's news to me. i thought they were the basis as well. but shanxi style is a little foreign to me.
Harper0911 1 year ago
@3rdEyeBlinking
that just doesn't make any sense to me.
historically, I can't say.
but thats kinda like saying that the english language didn't have g-r in the original style,
5 elements isn't just a movement set, it's the foundation movement patterns that the style uses for everything. it's kinda like taking the reverse punch out of karate.
Im wondering what you read said about what they did practice, if not 5 elements?
richardshapiroII 1 year ago
@richardshapiroII Well, my thoughts exactly! Just reread the M.A. mag. in wich i thought i read it and it turns out i misunderstood the article. Translation error! My bad!
3rdEyeBlinking 1 year ago
hands down, the best video about the 5 elements i have seen on youtube.
rAFiCoRe 2 years ago 4
this guy's fa jin is insane
yieldingbamboo 2 years ago
Yes, Pao Chuan was the last segment. It does look different, but definately Pao. So the order was Pi, Tsuan, Peng, Heng, Pao. I usually do Pao before Heng. Anybody care to comment on the order? Is there a constuctive/destructive sequence that is mandatory?
chigong980 3 years ago
@chigong980
i do pao before heng, too, thats the classic constructive order. I also like to use a cycle of heng-beng-tsuan-Pi-Pao-Heng it's building up the organs from bottom to top, then back to bottom. . for martial use, you need to be able to do them in any order, in any rhythm, while adjusting the distancing and direction.
also, good to know the "controlling" cycle, to know what element to use to counter. like rock/paper/scissors.
richardshapiroII 1 year ago
I like!
narayanr 3 years ago
i didn't see pao, looked like the last 2 were just 2 variations of heng... not a shanxi practitioner so don't know if they do their pao differently or something??
ukguy 3 years ago
The last one was supposed to be Pao Quan since all the others were done (Pi, Zuan, Beng, Heng...) So I was expecting Pao at the end. Was that "Pao Quan"? Because, it doesn't look like it. It looks like a modified Heng Quan!!
nejatarn 3 years ago
i think thwe last one was heng quan, it had the different arm-foot combination, as heng quan form is supposed to. but the twist on the outward looked similar to the one before it. so i think the whole set was done at the order of pi-tsuan-beng-pao-heng as i've seen in many videos.
lesvoskwoon 3 years ago
Very good. I especially liked your heng quan.
llNonFictionll 4 years ago
Fantastic. You can really see the difference between this & the more common Xingyi seen in Wushu demos.
Liniang 4 years ago
Very interesting version of 5 elements. Nice video.
noicecream 4 years ago