I know this was a tribute to her friend but am I the only one that thinks this song is also about her first miscarriage? "And I'm just having thoughts, said I'm just having thoughts, having thoughts, having Marianne." Provided this was after the first of course. I know they occurred around this era, but I have no idea if the first would be before here.
Imo this is one of her "purest" songs, if that makes any sense. Reading the story behind it, it's a really poignant lament and tribute to someone from her childhood. It's rare for an adult of the age she was when she wrote this to still carry such strong and warm feelings about someone they knew when they were so young. Most people just discard those things as the illusory trappings of youth or something.
Now my idea of the video would have been where the singer actually killer Marianna through getting axed to death! Has to be a death like that for the video! lol
for years tori has held the soundtrack to me life... always there to comfort me, help me vent, help me to just whatever it is i need.... she is amazing and is a living embodiment of the goddess!!!!
My best friend Kim died very young - this song will always remind me of her and how special she was. Even though this song makes me cry every time I hear it, I still thank you Tori.
my favorite song by Tori, thanks for sharing
persevere67 4 weeks ago
and i knew you pigtails and all girls when they fall------and i said not a chance not a chance.. :(
skyerockit420 1 month ago 17
i only found this because i googed my name...if i ever die young this song shall be played
penny3852 2 months ago
Comment removed
learnedbyheart 3 months ago
am I the first person to notice how pretty Tori's feet are? so small with such cute little piggies
utoobuser101 3 months ago
So much personal feelings to this song.
elaiza88 3 months ago
I know this was a tribute to her friend but am I the only one that thinks this song is also about her first miscarriage? "And I'm just having thoughts, said I'm just having thoughts, having thoughts, having Marianne." Provided this was after the first of course. I know they occurred around this era, but I have no idea if the first would be before here.
UltimateEnd622 3 months ago
Imo this is one of her "purest" songs, if that makes any sense. Reading the story behind it, it's a really poignant lament and tribute to someone from her childhood. It's rare for an adult of the age she was when she wrote this to still carry such strong and warm feelings about someone they knew when they were so young. Most people just discard those things as the illusory trappings of youth or something.
Vamphaery 3 months ago
@Vamphaery I agree
pionstail 1 month ago
Something about this song always tears me up.
floknowsbest 5 months ago
this song reminds me of being 14-15... and discovering what it was like to have a voice in society.
Alykatpitts 5 months ago
Great song. Impossible. Made my day. It seems like she's talking right to me. <3 <3
RecoveredTree 6 months ago
this one nails me to the floor every time.
SquishedButterfly 7 months ago
i miss this tori
jokersovi 7 months ago 21
@jokersovi Don't we all? :(
sickofwaitingtables 7 months ago 9
@sickofwaitingtables God..this woman made me who I today... that was 1996..i dont listen to her any more....still love her..just cant go there....xx
ninizoomer 5 months ago
@sickofwaitingtables *sigh* I so agree
Maaian 2 months ago
@jokersovi shes not dead lol. she still has great albums every year pretty much. and her daughter is a great singer too
guineapiggyman 1 month ago
:''] <3
ParamoreFrida 8 months ago
*_*
flavorata 8 months ago
Now my idea of the video would have been where the singer actually killer Marianna through getting axed to death! Has to be a death like that for the video! lol
MissTia777 8 months ago
for years tori has held the soundtrack to me life... always there to comfort me, help me vent, help me to just whatever it is i need.... she is amazing and is a living embodiment of the goddess!!!!
butterflyladywings 8 months ago 3
The musical and vocal change at 2:32 is simply breathtaking and purely Tori <3 <3 <3
whirljackman 9 months ago 8
one of my favs for sure
DeddRockStars 11 months ago 4
My best friend Kim died very young - this song will always remind me of her and how special she was. Even though this song makes me cry every time I hear it, I still thank you Tori.
elledriver76 11 months ago 18