Added: 3 years ago
From: Mapthestars
Views: 9,704
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (54)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Nice, i can't see why Salinger never wanted a screen adaptation of this. It would have made such a good film

  • @Samiie19

    You're right. No one would want to read the book they'd just want to watch the goddamn movie.

    I love the catcher in the rye. I read it two times and it's never boring to me! :)

  • That's a great work, but to me, this book should never be a movie. 

  • my mom does that when she is in a manic phase.

  • wooow...that´s a good one!

  • This is REALLY good!!! Love the Catcher in the Rye

  • is your name sam brooks?

  • @TheMagicofCurtis Nope, Torrance Klimoski.

  • @Mapthestars oh hahayou look like a guy I know. nice job btw

  • @TheMagicofCurtis haha, no problem :) anyways that's not me in the video. it's a friend of mine, Danny Gerchakov.

  • @Mapthestars russian?

  • Very Nice :)

  • Awesome!

    Just finished the book, and as an amateur filmer myself, i've been wanting to adapt Catcher since i started reading. but man, this is a pretty damn good eight minutes. acting and direction was pretty cool.

    Bravo! Cheers mate

  • @CCScorseseVideos thanks :) I'm glad you liked it.

  • Comment removed

  • Oscar goes to.. Holden Caulfield! :)

  • weird ambience -_- are you trying to make it like final destination lol?

  • @xXTiberiusXx No. Never seen final destination.

  • that was actually good. Great job ;)

  • Not bad kiddo. Go to film school, if you want.... it seems like everyone does. You, however, may be able to compete with all the phonies. Good luck.

  • dont they make fun of that book in south park o.o`?

  • Wow, fantastic acting and conceptual storytelling.

  • Great acting and special effects. Holden Caufield's character was represented well.

  • this is good.

  • If only Spielberg or Scorsese had the rights to a film version....

  • Excellent portrayal of Holden.

  • Very impressed. What a great Holden! This is exactly what I imagined him like. I teach high school English as a foreign language and I'd like to use this video in my unit on American literature. I've watched a lot of really silly videos about this book. This is BY FAR the best I've seen.

  • @sofiel77 thanks :) hope your class likes the video too.

  • Defenitly the work of a 10th grader, I guess that's kinda the point.

  • this is creepy. not like the holden i imagine :p anyway it's a good job.

  • this is so good. the guy playing holden is such a great actor!

  • Best contemporary Holden I've seen so far. I sort of see him with an accent of some sort. Not an east coast one. It's because of the syntax of it. I don't see any contemporary boys with my Holden image, but this boy and film is the best contemporary version of him I've seen so far. Love the atmosphere created as well. Terrific job!

  • Thanks so much! :) I'll tell my friend you liked him as holden. :)

  • Definantly. If you guys want some good constructive critism on any of the work, I'll be glad to give it in a message. I'd have to watch it a few times though because the only thing I can come up with now is what I've already said about the accent.

  • Sure, I'm always looking for good crit on any of my films. feel free to message me whenever you want.

  • you're schizo :=) ...shame on you! :-)

  • this is really good! but psycho! it made pretty clear that holden is a bit of a freak, and that he can't stop and needs to bring more and more examples to prove his point. sally was perfect, i just thought, that these were the right characteristics to portrait both of them...my friend and me are writing a play right now out of novels and we included the sally and achkley scene although ours will be more of a tragical comedy...really great job!!!!! good movie cutting and quality too!

  • This is definitely the best one I've seen so far. Could use some work, but pretty good.

  • this is so goofy and wrongheaded.

  • The guy playing Holden is actually really good, and this was a good part of the book to do, well done!

  • great movie=] i read catcher in the rye in english class and my final project is a graphic novel. i had the option of making a movie, but i don't have a camara=[

    good job anyway

  • cool movie, you are very talented!

  • This was good but the music was out of place. Like 'purpledinosrockout' said it was a bit too dramatic. Star Wars Episode III soundtrack?..

    Other than that very good angles and shots.

  • Yeah. it was Star Wars Episode III. And thank you for the other compliments. :)

  • Music was a teensy bit dramatic. but other than that, it was great.

  • lol this should be a comedy

  • como es posible que no hayan sacado una pelicula sobre el libro hasta ahora ?

  • wow, that was amazing!

    beautiful acting and special effects.

    & this reallyy helped me out on an essay im about to write on this book! heh thank you! (:

  • Hey. Thanks. see, my movies help write Essay and are Cinematically awesome. :) I did this for my English class and got a 96 on it. So what was the essay topic? (Also some of the things in the film don't happen in the book; but for the most part it's as true to the book as possible.)

  • Good job, bro.

  • by the far, the best Catcher in the rye

    video i have seen

  • Thanks, I'm glad you liked it.

  • TJ, very nicely done. 5 stars for you. Thank you

  • TJ, five stars for you. Very nicely done. I got your message. Thank you

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more