Your clearly drunk if you don't have Carson, Banks, Bavaro, or Barber. Thorpe wasnt much of a factor. The fact that you have Strahan at #7 is a joke. Take this video down you suck.
Of course it is always hard to pick a 10 best for a team with a history as long as the Giants. You could make arguments for Carl Banks, Mark Bavaro, Tiki Barber, Amani Toomer and Y.A. Tittle who held the single season touchdown pass record for 21 years.
Jim Thorpe was a great athlete but he was not a starter and only played in 3 games for the Giants. I mean no disrespect but he really doesn't belong on this list. I agree that Harry Carson should be on the list and he should place high. Harry was not only a Giant great, he was one of the best inside/middle linebackers in NFL history. I saw Tarkenton play for the Giants and he made a respectable team out of a bunch who would have been lucky to win 2 games a season without him.
Ummmmmmm interesting take but I think the only one you got right was Taylor , Eli & Simms belong much higher , Carson is missing , Tarkenton doesnt belong at all ...
Your clearly drunk if you don't have Carson, Banks, Bavaro, or Barber. Thorpe wasnt much of a factor. The fact that you have Strahan at #7 is a joke. Take this video down you suck.
blackwolak 1 week ago
Of course it is always hard to pick a 10 best for a team with a history as long as the Giants. You could make arguments for Carl Banks, Mark Bavaro, Tiki Barber, Amani Toomer and Y.A. Tittle who held the single season touchdown pass record for 21 years.
soracs 3 weeks ago
Jim Thorpe was a great athlete but he was not a starter and only played in 3 games for the Giants. I mean no disrespect but he really doesn't belong on this list. I agree that Harry Carson should be on the list and he should place high. Harry was not only a Giant great, he was one of the best inside/middle linebackers in NFL history. I saw Tarkenton play for the Giants and he made a respectable team out of a bunch who would have been lucky to win 2 games a season without him.
soracs 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am not sure what you were thinking with Tarkenton on this list.
mrmulet 3 weeks ago
THIS SONG IS AWESOME!!!!!!
RyanSmith1923 1 month ago
Ummmmmmm interesting take but I think the only one you got right was Taylor , Eli & Simms belong much higher , Carson is missing , Tarkenton doesnt belong at all ...
unklega 1 month ago
@unklega - I am not sure what this guy was thinking with Tarkenton on this list.
mrmulet 3 weeks ago
You forgot Harry Carson...
qwerty123bam 1 month ago
Eh being a Giants fan I say Eli is better than Simms
snakeeye223 1 month ago
Harry Carson?
livingdead67 2 months ago 3