although love is unpredictable for carmen, it is still sweet and exciting and worth teasing or pursuing, and not 'just that' or 'oh, well...' like ewing's acting makes it to be. there is sensuality but certainly some curiosity still, not a wisdom or knowingness that older women would have. just my opinion on one of the greatest carmens ever.
sorry i love maria ewing and she interprets the heart and words of this song/aria incredibly well, but not entirely in character. 15 yr old carmen may be precocious and considered an 'experienced' woman in those times, but i would imagine her body language less of an older woman who's seen it all like ewing makes it to be, almost like a 'madam' -- carmen's take on love, would not be 'been here done that', but playful and speculative still.
Hi Maria - I was hoping to find a way to see how you are - I think I am in this clip behind you there at the table somewhere. You look fabulous as usual but I don't have earphones at the moment to hear all these clips. Getting set up bit by bit with these things! Would like to stay in touch. Best regards and wishes. Anne Aldridge - soprano
Mighenes-Johnson is a much better Carmen and her style is right This girl exagerates everything until she gets ridiculous and she has about 5 different voices.Ouach!!
Quite Amazing, she is perfect. I have never seen her in this role before actually I´ve always pictured her as Cherubino in Ponelle´s film of Le Nozze di figaro.
But here she is this femme fatal and with a magnificent voice. Bravo Maria!!!
Her handling of the text is not as sensual as Anna Catarinas. I prefer Anna's. This is great of course but she's missing that element that makes me believe she is a real Carmen.
OH JOyous day! Dear God! Brava Maria! Absolutely one of the best Carmen. Such an actress, mama mia! Wonderful direction and production as well.Bravi to all! THank you!
This was the first production of Carmen I ever saw! It was on a video streaming site connected to my university. ^ ^ I hope I can sing this role someday.
Maria Ewing does such a great job as Carmen. It's basically perfect for her. Throughout the whole opera you don't know whether to trust her or not! I love it!
Maria has to be the perfect Carmen. She does the bad girl so well. You know she is trouble all the way but you just can't help yourself...Poor Don Jose never had a chance (at least in this production). Outstanding.
A couple of highlights: Love is a rebellious bird that nobody can tame, and you call him quite in vain if it suits him not to come. Nothing helps, neither threat nor prayer. One man talks well, the other keeps silent; it's the other one that I prefer. He never said anything, but I like his looks. Love! Love! Love! Love! Love is a Bohemian child, it has never, ever, known law; if you love me not, then I love you; if I love you, you'd best beware!
Htshoward: venom is venim in French.You see it's not so difficult.You are a very "interesting "man". But I agree with you...I will go to a more welcome place:MacVideoCollection for instance (with you ???)Ce type abonné à une chaîne de (x)veut me montrer ses muscles sans doute....FIN
Please accept my apology. I have made many of them in the New Year. I had no right to tell someone to get the ____ out of anywhere on Youtube. I was having a bad night. Our differences in opionion are what make up the world. Again, totally sorry.
The pronunciation is a little strange in spots. I think those two were planned like that for emphasis. She seems to be able to pronounce them fine elsewhere. :/
PS. - cordoor36, bondjou was writing in French. Potentially because it is hard to identify questionable pronunciation if you haven't been exposed to a language much.
Then would you please tell her I never liked the opera Carmen until I saw her sing the role! I think she is brilliant and embodies the role the way no other mezzo even came close! I love Maria!
me flipa, esos tresillos que dan sensualidad a la voz que bonito! y ese ritmo de habanera , ella es una buena intérprete y el coro se escucha a la justa medida , no como en otras interpretaciones que se escucha más de lo debido.
I confess I was never crazy about the opera Carmen...UNTIL I saw Maria sing it. Brava! I love that feisty acting...the Habanera is superb! She doesn't posess some of the beauty of tone other mezzos do, but her acting total artistry make up for any of that. Brava, Maria!
I like Ewing a lot, but she a few times she nasalises "aime" -- is this just English-influenced anticipation, or are you actually supposed to do this?
I'm wondering if it's just a phonetic thing -- nasal vowel have really high formant frequencies, and opera singers generate additional formant frequencies not heard in normal speech, so it seems nasalised when it's not.
Well, remember that singing is different from talking, too. Sometimes some words you have to not pronounce them different but place the vowel or consenant in some other way so you can hit the high or low notes.
I'm sorry the nasalisation is not writen in the score, I checked. I thought you were talking of something else when she singing that part.
She has to do it just to connect her "chest voice" to her "head voice", all the aria is written on the break of the voice,the passagio, it's just very difficult to sing it "equally" and to make it sound in a huge theater if you don't do that.
My god, I couldn't think of anyone better than callas could suceed this performance, she is doing what callas did from the start, she is turning these ideas of opera characters life and signing her signature on every note sung. And the french is not bad either.
Foi esta ópera que me fez gostar de ópera. @roquepirata, eu saquei o vídeo completo aos bocadinhos aqui no YT.
Fonseca429 1 month ago
Maravilhosa essa interpretação! Uma das melhores personificações de Carmen que eu já vi.
Sabe onde posso achar o vídeo completo dessa apresentação?
roquepirata 1 month ago
Interpretação épica.... gloriosa....
omardammous 2 months ago
Finally a version that, to me, can actually rival that of Diva Supreme, Maria Callas
methuselus 5 months ago
como é que alguém consegue cantar e atuar tão bem ao mesmo tempo?
Ela é a própria Carmen *-*
veveu10 6 months ago
PERFEIÇÃO das PERFEIÇõES!
BRitaBRazil 6 months ago
Muito bom! Valeu pelas legendas em português.
danke89 7 months ago
Comment removed
KerstinTanja1 8 months ago
Maria Ewing me fascine et m'intrigue beaucoup:
à première vue je la trouve laide mais elle interprète , chante et joue
si bien que je donne dans son piège et que je veux aller jusqu'au
bout. Elle m'ensorcèle Je ne suis plus moi-même.
Qu'est-ce-qu'on peut exiger de plus de Carmen !!!!!!!!!
camalane 8 months ago
She is great!
milena6110 8 months ago
I like the masculinity she brings to this Carmen!! Its truly interesting...
wedidntknow 9 months ago
This is the best Carmen I've seen!
SuperRomanticheart 9 months ago
BEST! CARMEN! EVER!
FunkTrunk5 9 months ago 3
Gwyd i'r nef ar adain cân
BlackCountryPuddler 11 months ago
i am in looove
broadwaywes 11 months ago
although love is unpredictable for carmen, it is still sweet and exciting and worth teasing or pursuing, and not 'just that' or 'oh, well...' like ewing's acting makes it to be. there is sensuality but certainly some curiosity still, not a wisdom or knowingness that older women would have. just my opinion on one of the greatest carmens ever.
piax00 11 months ago
sorry i love maria ewing and she interprets the heart and words of this song/aria incredibly well, but not entirely in character. 15 yr old carmen may be precocious and considered an 'experienced' woman in those times, but i would imagine her body language less of an older woman who's seen it all like ewing makes it to be, almost like a 'madam' -- carmen's take on love, would not be 'been here done that', but playful and speculative still.
piax00 11 months ago
Jeez ...what a dish. I would spoon feed her honey glazed popcorn.
BlackCountryPuddler 1 year ago
@BlackCountryPuddler you wouldnt if you saw her now, sadly cosmetic improvements have ruined the beauty
spiderwell 11 months ago
@spiderwell Yeah well I am an ugly bastard too so yes I would. She could sing between each mouthfull of popcorn. Talent like that never dies.....
BlackCountryPuddler 11 months ago
She IS Carmen
joaofwolf 1 year ago 3
Bizet dite oui
crazystarwarsguy1006 1 year ago
What a beauty! What PIPES!
conewells 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Maria Ewing... The Greatest Carmen of all
The real one
joaofwolf 1 year ago
Maria Ewin... The Greatest Carmen of all
The real one
joaofwolf 1 year ago
One of the best versions I've heard. Bravo!
Aetion 1 year ago
magnifique bravo bravo et bravo
ghizlanghizlan 1 year ago 2
Il n'y a pas de mots pour décriver la beauté de "Carmen" de Bizet!!!
SIMPLEMENT EXCELLENT!
imirgom 1 year ago
G. Bizet:
tonnze 1 year ago
Hi Maria - I was hoping to find a way to see how you are - I think I am in this clip behind you there at the table somewhere. You look fabulous as usual but I don't have earphones at the moment to hear all these clips. Getting set up bit by bit with these things! Would like to stay in touch. Best regards and wishes. Anne Aldridge - soprano
ANNEAish 1 year ago
best clasic ever nice
nautika1 1 year ago
The sexiest, most captivating Carmen in history!
MaxwellsDemon9 1 year ago
Genius!!! She is so amazing! love her voice!!!
cloud9wannabe 1 year ago 2
viva! maria
sukarabe2 1 year ago
Soberbio....Me encanta el volúmen, la mesura, el color de voz, el manejo y forma de su vibrato....Que forma de cantar.
borres88 1 year ago 2
Seductive without ever being over the top! She's so control of her voice and her acting. So amazing :O
SsteinwayS 1 year ago 2
BELLISSIMA!
roccoprch1 1 year ago 2
Mamma mia, quanta bellezza!!!
Zenony 1 year ago 3
QUE LINDA VOZ.! SIMPLESMENTE MARAVILHOSA
victorcserra 1 year ago
Singing in French, with Portuguese subtitles, and Spanish context.
Odysseus696 1 year ago
French
Odysseus696 1 year ago
What language is this in?
browdwayloverz 1 year ago
@browdwayloverz Sang in French with Portuguese supertitles
ziachipper 1 year ago
Mighenes-Johnson is a much better Carmen and her style is right This girl exagerates everything until she gets ridiculous and she has about 5 different voices.Ouach!!
monpitt500 1 year ago
she is goooood.
really a discovery for me, this singer.
eurydike 1 year ago
beautiful aria! watched this in music appreciation. shes one of the best singers to portray carmen!
love it!
hurricanrana22 1 year ago
Wow, this is the best Carmen, and I've seen a number of great ones. She is so expressive in her singing and she acts so well.
jewelmarkess 1 year ago
Yo pensaba que María Callas era inigualable con la aria de "Habanera" de Carmen pero cuando escuché a María Ewing me quedé enamorado.
Bellísima Voz....
borres88 1 year ago
@borres88 Maria Callas es una diva eso que ni que, pero Ewing es otra, jajaja
aztequedeor 1 year ago
It is like Carmen was written for her voice. Maria is, in my oppinion, the BEST Carmen ever.
xkyousukex 1 year ago
Finally!!! A Carmen who actually acts like a Carmen! Most of them look bored on stage, but this one is having fun! Great voice and acting 5**
violinistx100 1 year ago 3
maria ewing is the best! sexy and talented! and ARIES like me! ;)
danutpopescu1 1 year ago
i freaking love this opera
Esquenitatheoriginal 1 year ago
Très sobre et élégante...Elle me fait penser à Villazon
nikolausvonkrufft 1 year ago
The liveliest Carmen Alive!
urbanitarian 2 years ago
Inigualável. Muito estudo foi necessário para atingir tal grau de perfeição.
wernerfrisio 2 years ago 9
I first saw Maria Ewing in a Sky Television production of Carmen many years ago. There is no-one better.
payitforwardeddie 2 years ago
Bravoo !!! Bravoo !!!! 5*****
tukilala 2 years ago
The Greatest Carmen!!
operaman20 2 years ago 3
Gran Carmen!!!!
fernandofernandezgar 2 years ago
Quite Amazing, she is perfect. I have never seen her in this role before actually I´ve always pictured her as Cherubino in Ponelle´s film of Le Nozze di figaro.
But here she is this femme fatal and with a magnificent voice. Bravo Maria!!!
Antillas636 2 years ago 2
Impressive...
How old is this video?
I found out that Maria Ewing was born in 1950. So she's 59??? It's hard to believe that she's still pretty at that age! It's incredible...
ALLANDSEXSYMBOL 2 years ago
best Carmen :)
zirzoppuschkintanzen 2 years ago
WOW!!! She's just the best. So confident and natural... and what a voice! She acted as if she were speaking naturally. Thanks for posting this!
ApocalyptiGirl 2 years ago
Love her acting- so intelligent and relaxed!- but not my favorite vocal performance- am I wrong for wanting a little more passion and punch?
still better than I'll ever do of course!
nightowl2430 2 years ago 2
Her handling of the text is not as sensual as Anna Catarinas. I prefer Anna's. This is great of course but she's missing that element that makes me believe she is a real Carmen.
Jtogati 2 years ago
Comment removed
StanleyKSCBP 2 years ago
MARAVILHOSO TUDO DE BOM !!
pilekcleberson 2 years ago
OH JOyous day! Dear God! Brava Maria! Absolutely one of the best Carmen. Such an actress, mama mia! Wonderful direction and production as well.Bravi to all! THank you!
LaDivaWorld 2 years ago
This was the first production of Carmen I ever saw! It was on a video streaming site connected to my university. ^ ^ I hope I can sing this role someday.
Maria Ewing does such a great job as Carmen. It's basically perfect for her. Throughout the whole opera you don't know whether to trust her or not! I love it!
Takoon 2 years ago 13
@Takoon that is well said, Carmen was meant for Maria Ewing !!!!!
aztequedeor 1 year ago
Best ever Carmen
ulisseslm 2 years ago
this is my favourit!
L'amour est un oiseau rebelle - Maria Ewing
mdance31 2 years ago 4
Maria Ewing is the very very best! I have the same version on dvd...i love it so...
Zatschana 2 years ago 4
i like the way she does it
djgoens 2 years ago 4
Maria has to be the perfect Carmen. She does the bad girl so well. You know she is trouble all the way but you just can't help yourself...Poor Don Jose never had a chance (at least in this production). Outstanding.
prends garde à toi
cujosdad 2 years ago 4
I AGREE TOTALLY!! shes the ultimate diva!! Prend garde a' toi!!!
rayeo88 2 years ago 4
bellissima!
GrannyIzergill 2 years ago 4
Would the subtites were in English... but what great acting/singing. She is a very good Carmen.... was a pretty good Salome, too.
PTCello 2 years ago
cujosdad 2 years ago
bella
GrannyIzergill 2 years ago
all my neighbours also started to love carmen LOL
GrannyIzergill 2 years ago 2
Mine too!! :)
Y2H 2 years ago
She is the best Carmet actress...I want to marry her...not Carment...Maria! Does she still live in Europe?
jnsotak 3 years ago
Sussex, UK according to Wikipedia.
wsmith68 3 years ago
najfajniejsze wykonanie na youtubie..;p
EdaKreda1400 3 years ago
even bad girls can be good!
jenaratr5 3 years ago
i just wanna say "niu bi"! amazing carmen!!!
echofaye 3 years ago
i like her acting and her voice... but not her singing...
tneprescintr 3 years ago
genialll me encanto
NymphadoraMcgonagall 3 years ago 2
what a fantastic Carmen she plays! She really has fun with it! She is rather harsh with her french (which could be why we can understand it! lol).
teamlegitdragon 3 years ago
I think Denyce Graves and Maria Ewing perform Carmen the best! This is a simply beautiful performance. :D
nekohime1378 3 years ago
I didn't like her as Rosina, but she makes a great Carmen.
Satirike 3 years ago
Maria has many friends here, Bondjou, now get the hell out. Take your venom to a more welcome place.
htshoward 3 years ago
Htshoward: venom is venim in French.You see it's not so difficult.You are a very "interesting "man". But I agree with you...I will go to a more welcome place:MacVideoCollection for instance (with you ???)Ce type abonné à une chaîne de (x)veut me montrer ses muscles sans doute....FIN
THE END.
bondjou 3 years ago
Please accept my apology. I have made many of them in the New Year. I had no right to tell someone to get the ____ out of anywhere on Youtube. I was having a bad night. Our differences in opionion are what make up the world. Again, totally sorry.
htshoward 3 years ago
hsthoward: don't worry about that....and Maria is a fantastic Carmen! If she would tell me "je t'aime" sure I could understand:-))
bondjou 3 years ago 3
Thank you, Bondjou! Happy New Year
htshoward 3 years ago
htshoward: Thank you and I also wish you all the best for 2009!
bondjou 3 years ago
Just beautiful!!!!
mamadoritos 3 years ago
mumble
kijiwoda 3 years ago
one should have "corrected"....sorry.
bondjou 3 years ago
Bravo! but she has a problem with "je t'aime" and "Bohême"...One should have correct her pronunciation.
bondjou 3 years ago
I see that Maria has friend(s)here but although I find she sings brilliantly, I maintain what I wrote about her "Je t'aime".
C'est vraiment dommage cette mauvaise prononciation de certains "je t'aime" et "Bohême" (1.26 et 1.44 par exemple)
bondjou 3 years ago
Are you some sort of theatre critic? Whatever you think means nothing to anyone but you.
cordoor36 3 years ago
I love her singing! What a voice!! :)
The pronunciation is a little strange in spots. I think those two were planned like that for emphasis. She seems to be able to pronounce them fine elsewhere. :/
PS. - cordoor36, bondjou was writing in French. Potentially because it is hard to identify questionable pronunciation if you haven't been exposed to a language much.
racehorse87 3 years ago
I am a close personal friend of Maria's.
cordoor36 3 years ago
Then would you please tell her I never liked the opera Carmen until I saw her sing the role! I think she is brilliant and embodies the role the way no other mezzo even came close! I love Maria!
htshoward 3 years ago
Haha. I told her, and she that was very sweet.
cordoor36 3 years ago
so what?
Marissa7656 3 years ago
Brava, Maria! I have high regard for Maria Ewing -- the most underrated of sopranos.
Dogaradodia 3 years ago
best habanera version!
RotzingJen 3 years ago 19
Maravilhoso, Wonderful, Mmrveilleuse...
brunooliveira96 3 years ago 3
You can watch this and practice your comprehension in French and learn some Portugese at the same time!
b43xoit 3 years ago
when and where was this filmed?? i love it!!
Tommy211hick 3 years ago
Hi.
I would say this is the Covent Garden production from 1989.
hvaderledigt 3 years ago
thanks!!!
Tommy211hick 3 years ago
me flipa, esos tresillos que dan sensualidad a la voz que bonito! y ese ritmo de habanera , ella es una buena intérprete y el coro se escucha a la justa medida , no como en otras interpretaciones que se escucha más de lo debido.
gato90 3 years ago
Wow! That was magic... I am your new fan, Maria!!!
rodzaulips3 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's a beautiful actress and singer, but what happened to her face?
LittleBlueBunny 3 years ago
I confess I was never crazy about the opera Carmen...UNTIL I saw Maria sing it. Brava! I love that feisty acting...the Habanera is superb! She doesn't posess some of the beauty of tone other mezzos do, but her acting total artistry make up for any of that. Brava, Maria!
htshoward 3 years ago
I like Ewing a lot, but she a few times she nasalises "aime" -- is this just English-influenced anticipation, or are you actually supposed to do this?
JohnRiemannSoong 3 years ago
She has to do it, cuz is on her score.
Jeandy767 3 years ago 2
They mark for nasalisation on the score, really?
I'm wondering if it's just a phonetic thing -- nasal vowel have really high formant frequencies, and opera singers generate additional formant frequencies not heard in normal speech, so it seems nasalised when it's not.
A pure linguistic question.
JohnRiemannSoong 3 years ago
Well, remember that singing is different from talking, too. Sometimes some words you have to not pronounce them different but place the vowel or consenant in some other way so you can hit the high or low notes.
I'm sorry the nasalisation is not writen in the score, I checked. I thought you were talking of something else when she singing that part.
Jeandy767 3 years ago
She has to do it just to connect her "chest voice" to her "head voice", all the aria is written on the break of the voice,the passagio, it's just very difficult to sing it "equally" and to make it sound in a huge theater if you don't do that.
foropera 3 years ago
I like her!-she is the most feisty carmen Ive seen so far
tubeninja1 3 years ago 2
:-*
knaz44 3 years ago
:-*
knaz44 3 years ago
when was that? it's wonderful! thank you :)
scordeteyla 3 years ago
This is the real art
MakBDF 3 years ago
She is excellent.
memecapotte 4 years ago 2
Apprezzo molto Maria Ewing è molto brava. Ho avuto modo di apprezzarla anche in altre opere fra cui il Barbiere di Siviglia di Rossini.
nikesfly 4 years ago
She's so good, incredible voice!!
ahim48 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Too much make up!
classicalgal14 4 years ago
magnetica...dopo la Callas la più grande attrice dell'opera...
gohar002 4 years ago
Thios is the Royal Opera staging and I think at her peak. Immortalised!
redtubeline 4 years ago
had a huge crush on her when i was 17...
bbbaz11 4 years ago
很好聽
indietoy 4 years ago
My god, I couldn't think of anyone better than callas could suceed this performance, she is doing what callas did from the start, she is turning these ideas of opera characters life and signing her signature on every note sung. And the french is not bad either.
jamroymg 4 years ago
Very well said
htshoward 3 years ago
Sin duda Teresa Berganza es la mejor Carmen
Carlosgar1962 4 years ago
Sin menospreciar a las demás
Carlosgar1962 4 years ago
Is this production on DVD? I have a DVD of Maria Ewing singing Carmen, but it's filmed like a movie...it's not a live production.
tornprinze 4 years ago
Que excelente voz, pero para mi Maria Callas siempre será la mejor Carmen =)
LadySyriana 4 years ago
Simplemente genial
Melisa48 4 years ago 2
Sabes se há disponível em dvd ou bluray? Fiquei apaixonado por esta versão ao vivo de Carmen com Maria Ewing.
rodzaulips3 3 years ago
she is sooooooooo sexy!!! with that big mouth, and her voice, perfect Carmen to me.
cantanteporsiempre 4 years ago 3