Added: 5 years ago
From: roo2687
Views: 654,060
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (928)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she shoud go back to this type of music... nadine is a gem!

  • Shes sooooo good how did anyone not realise

  • Ahhh if she would have put this on her solo album it would have not had as much bad reviews. I love this rendition her voice is gorgeous and honestly I just want her back singing in GA cause giiirl did not pick very strong vocal songs for her solo record, but at least the peeps behind GA know how to showcase her voice.

  • Listening to the ending, that's naturally a very strong voice - unlike 'someone' who is much more successful than her just because her every move is in the media accompanied always by photographs. Hmm...

  • omg shes amazing

  • someone cant spell doors :D

  • @fmbg89 ha-i checked it out. how can anybody can doors wrong!!!

  • The best version of this song!

    

  • she would get her back dores smashed in

  • watch this version : KC4rndEeGWM = search it on youtube

  • Better singer than Cheryl and much, MUCH nicer looking. But shes irish, so ....no chance with ''the nations sweetheart'' whatever that even means only cowell knows.

  • this is the best performance ever on any reality tv show.

  • cant believe her album didnt do well , shes way better than cheryl. so many tone deaf people these days lol

  • who are you lot to judge Cheryl cole or any other famous singer. Least they have the guts to get up in front of thousand of people and do what they love.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Shes just....so....AMAZING!!!!!

  • Shes amazing!<3

  • Comment removed

  • Nadine should have went solo from the start of this! she would have been Major!!

  • Nadine has amazing voice and cheryls out of tune alot of the time :/

  • Cheryl who?

  • STOP comparing Cheryl and Nadine. They are different people with different voices. So just stop.

  • Comment removed

  • THE VOICE in Girls Aloud

  • I hate how most of the comments here are putting down Cheryl. Nadine wouldn't want that, guys. Can't we just appreciate Nadine's gorgeous voice without putting down one of her band mates?

  • IMHO this is a reasonably good version of this song from Girls alouds best singer. There are much better versions out there, for instance Eva Cassidays rendition wipes the floor with this. The reason I think this, is that Eva sang from the heart, but this feels like a taught performance and I don't think Nadine is feeling the song IMHO. I'm sure others will see it differently, especially G.A. fans.

  • nice, but pity they have to overblow songs and ruin them on these talent shows. its not needed, just sing the song and it would have been much better.

  • Bad press and worse management, she deserved more than she got.

    But I believe time puts everyone in their position and this girl will get all the success she truly deserves.

  • Nadine got a lot of bad press because of her newly found (apparant) accent with a hint of Americianisms? Which I DONT agree with ... However, Cheryl is now taking elocution lessons (just like Nadine was informed to) .... and I sincerly hope that Mrs Princess Nations Sweetheart Cheryl get's as much bad press as lovely Nadine did! Nadine is the true star in my eyes, her performances are simply incredible and I will back her to the bone. She's a superstar in her own right!!!!

  • @DearbhlaMcG I think Nadine and Cheryl are equal. And for the record, Cheryl was told she would be fired if she didn't take them, so she took them, and then she was fired anyways.

  • If the world was fair & rewarded people for talent alone, we'd be asking "Cheryl WHO?". Nadine has 1m% more talent than Tweedy but what's talent got to do with it when you've got ITV Primetime?

  • goosebumps.

  • this is exactly why girl groups are put together to look good , it tells you something when the only one in the group with tone , isn't actually amazing she's just ok! it's just cheryl looked the best , and can't sing , why i don't listen to any of this crap

  • @catherinek94 Disagree. Think Nadine is brillo pads.

  • Nadine is the best,good Derry girl.:)

  • FOR GOD SAKE! I am fed up of seeing 'Nadine is the best singer in girls aloud' or 'nadine's better than cheryl' etc. THEY ARE A GIRL GROUP.. GROUP THEY WORK TOGETHER, CHERYL AND NADINE ARE REALLY GOOD FRIENDS. CAN U PLEASE STOP COMPARING THEM! IT DOESN'T MATTER WHO IS BETTER, THEY ARE BOTH SUCCESSFUL!

  • l0l_ÄNÿ_gUys_wÅñt_t0_chàt_wÌth­_mé

  • i love girls aloud chezzas always bee my fav but i just cant stop liste n2 tis

  • @elani97 She has the most beautiful voice<3

  • Amazing Voice!!!!!!!!!

  • shes the only singer in girls aloud.

  • @MegaMegaAlex not. there are four more......

  • good

  • im not a nadine fan AT ALL! but this is very very beautiful. and she is the best singer in GA!

  • I like the 'eva cassidy' version better, but nadine can sing! wow, beautyful voice!

  • she does NOT give this song justis

  • @niamhybbz You dont give the English language justice. Learn to spell idiot.

  • @Lynnch1 shut up im not a idiot i have dislexia so leav me alone! god i only sayin my opinion!

  • AWESOME!!!! SHES MY SECOND FAVORITE SINGER IN THE WORLD!!! CHRiSTINA AGUILERA IS THE FIRST OF COURSE! WHAT AN AMAZING VOICE! I LOVE HER n_n!!!

  • I actually love this so much.Nadine has such raw talent♥♥♥

  • she is by far the bestttttttt!

  • stunning. she's like an Irish Mariah Carey! :)

  • cheryl is actually rubbish compared to Nadinee ... just shows how far you can get with you looks ...

  • @MegaSmileywiley dont be so bloody stupid Nadine is just as good looking

  • @jason0898 I never said she wasn't good looking. Don't be dim because Cheryl has had a better career than nadine, but that was not because she had the best voice, it was because of her looks. Don't try and tell me it was because cheryl has an amazing voice like nadine. -_-

  • @MegaSmileywiley and marrying a footballer

  • An utter disgrace she was allowed to do that. Why do I say that? You may find it helpful to listen to Eva Cassidy's version.

  • I don't get why singers smoke as it can damage their voice. Will young smokes and quite a few others do.

  • I remember taping this per4mance and watching it so many times. That end ad-lib, phew! She has got such a lovely soulful voice. I always thought she was wasted on GA material and I don't think her solo single does her justice either.

  • she thinks she's better than she is. too much smoking aswell, she sounds raspy now.

  • wow outstanding vocals knw thats what u call singin! not bloody cheryl cole nadine should be up on x factor judging dont u all agree?

  • absolutley amazing , i reckon she has been robbed in terms of solo sucsess, I mean how the fuck is cheryl cole getting number ones , when she sounds like a load of dog bollocks?!

  • @GodivaMiyagi i will tell u why cheryl cole and the likes of katy perry who cant sing to save her life get to number 1. its media manipulation/brainwashing of the mass media and appearences on xfactor. they all knew if nadine performed on xfactor she would have out performed and got more popular than others and they didnt want to upset the status quo (they including simon cow)

  • 1 word- WOW

  • so annoyed that her album sales are not doing better. she produced and co wrote all 13 songs of the album. What did cole do she gets her voice to be auto tuned so it sounds better and she only co-wrote 2. And then gets other singers like Will.Iam to feature on the album so it will do better.

  • she's the only one in GA that has a chance of getting 2 the live finals if they auditioned 4 x factor

  • why does everyone lick cheryl cole's arse! oh cuz she got married to ash cole...pppffffttt... nadine should have all the attention cuz she is where the talents at!

  • UGH! Brits, GO BUY HER DEBUT ALBUM!!! Listen to that voice!! She's the only one of GA that deserves a solo career.

  • better then the original

  • Cheryl Cole can only dream of being able to sing like this. All Cole does is mime but gets to number one. Whereas Nadine only chooses to sing live on TV but yet gets criticised. Cole go and learn to sing.

  • unbelieveable

  • shes da best singer of all of them, da rest cant sing, especially cherl

  • b-e-a-utiful voice! I wish she released this, you can really appreciate her voice better in ballads than insatiable

  • @OopsIDroppedTheMilk i think she actually has recorded this in a recording studio. look for it on here there definitely is a studio version.

  • i hope her new insatiable song goes to number 1,

  • She has a beautiful voice, but why did she completely change the melody of the song?

  • she would have won this competition if it had just been one winner and not a group search

  • she has a great voice, so rich such warmth.

    leona has a cold voice.

  • She can sing! I'm quite shocked.

  • amazing

  • lovely soothing voice :).

  • wooow she is the one with the best voice from all the girls aloud girls

  • @TimeHasGoneBy Totally agreed.

  • AMAZING.com!!! full stop!!

  • Amazing!

  • omg this is so beautiful....cant see cheryl doin a bettr verison

  • What was this girl doing wasting her talent in a girl band?

  • goosebumps..such a nice voice!!!

  • omg this is the only performance i remember from this show, amazing

  • canned applause.

  • lovely voise

  • Comment removed

  • WOW ! nadine has a really great voice much much much better than cheryl cole..

    amazing singing.

  • i am so sick of the world wanking over cheryl cole, she can't sing for shit. nadine is amazing but how often do u ever see or hear anything about her

  • @boybandbowes ummm, she's signed to tesco's record label and she's a bitch...that's why

  • @boybandbowes she had an album.. it flopped. no fans, no personality. simple as.

  • She Definatley Has The Best Natural Voice, She Is Better Natural Than AutoTuned She Is The Best Singer In Girls Aloud.

  • stunning. i love nadine

  • Comment removed

  • @ngomaneh77 : Cheryl....does she really has a voice to be in such a spotlight? IMHO she does not.

  • Comment removed

  • Beautiful Irish tallent x

  • Omg this is wonderful!! And honestly this song is not easy!!

  • omfg she sang this liek a angel.. love nadine .. love cheryl cole to :) xxx

  • How the hell can 50 people dislike this? Bunch of idiots! Did ur finger slip?!!

  • She doesn't feel the music. She feels the fame.

  • lmao

    this is shit,chec out eva cassidys version...thats beautiful.

  • Its too bad the music industry loooks at appearance first then talent.

  • mann! i new she can SING,but WOW! they shuld show her voice off more in girls aloud! well done nadine :) x

  • Wow, this is bad! She has a geat voice yes, but this song is not for her at all.

  • @RachelCF2 are you fucking joking?

    it's amazing, get a pair of decent ears.

  • @iLoveVision - wow, you're intelligent.  Everyone is entitled to their opinion, I happen to think you need a decent pair of ears but I won't come down to your level and swear back, just proves your lack of intellect.

  • @RachelCF2 because I said FUCKING. I'm unintelligent, grow up.

    I'm expressing my opinion. I just don't know how you can think this song isn't matched for her, she sings it beautifully x

  • @iLoveVision Yes, swearing shows a lack of vocabulary, it's like a child trying to shock an adult. You have your opinion, you like this version of the song, I have my opinion, I don't like it, let's just leave it at that. No need to swear at someone just because they don't share your interests.

  • @RachelCF2 swearing does not show a lack of vocabulary nor does a lack of vocabulary show a lack of intelligence. You have proven your intelligence. Well done. You completely shot yourself in the foot. You're entitled to your opinion but your wrong.

  • @KrisDoherty - Honestly, I have expressed an opinion, I don't like this song sung by her, seriously is it that offensive to you that someone doesn't agree with you? Get a life and let others live theirs! Swearing is offensive to some people, opinions on songs should not be. By the way if we are talking about a lack of intelligence, your grammar isn't helping your case.

  • Beautiful.

  • Herr And Nicola Are Amazing :D

    The Others Are Good But Not As Good :)

    x

  • Goosebumps. She is so amazing. Too bad she doesnt get all the fame and Cheryl does... NOT fair!

  • wow...amazing!

  • i think this is a very good version of the song i had never heard of the girl before i now know shes in girls aloud and this like a audition show ,eva cassidy is a better version but reading the comments and starting to watch the other videos i think cheryl tweedy/cole just looks amazin very nice looking of course nadine is also and what legs but i think you just look at cheryl and forget whats shes singing about its the male fanasty thing going on its sex , raw but the truth i think .

  • I can not believe I sawher today at the airport where I work when she arrived, I asked if she was a singer that I read on in a formula that she filled, I was very polite with her course, she was with Jason Bell and good is the second time that I talk to someone famous in my workplace, after talking with Steven Tyler of Aerosmith and I did not even know it was the ja ja ja

  • I agree. She's amazing.

  • HOW CULD ENY1 NOT LUV THIS SONG R SINGER

  • if you think that Nadine is good, listen to Eva Cassidy's version. No one can sing it better!!! nadine is an amateur!

  • @jlkgodan Eva cassidy's version is more beautiful and more slower ... whereas nadine version as more power and soul into it,, thats why i prefere i love both ! the song is just amazing !

  • @jlkgodan erm.... that's kind of the point? She was a 16 year old on an audition show for a girl band!

  • Watching this makes me feel proud to b Irish!

  • why is cheryl the 'star' when nadine can sing like this ?

  • @ZoeIsLostAlone

    Pretty simple really, Nadine is rather dull and not as good looking.

    See how fast Leona Lewis went out of fashion? it's partly because she's got the personality of a tin of sardines.

  • i never really liked nadine. but shes starting to grow on me. shes a GREAT singer but i dont know what it is she only suits some songs oh well. love her <3

  • This is beautiful! I soo hope she does this song on her album!!???

  • Really, Really Beautiful!

    She's the best ever female singer in any of the uk talent competitions by far!

  • @mrcwalk Her vocals aren't as good as leona lewis'.

  • @andwhat93 thats a matter of opinion, i didn't realise i'd provoke comments from retards.

  • @andwhat93 but she has more emotion in her voice that only leona could dream of, leona is an amazing singer but she has the personality of a wet fish licking a wet rock on a wet day

  • @mgblue lmao, a very discriptive perception of leona's 'emotion' Maybe that how u think, but leona has a better vocal ability, her voice has more range. Im not denying that nadine is a good singer, but she not in the same catagorie as leona :)

  • @andwhat93 i know she has better vocal ability but theres no emotion in her voice, she got an amazing gift when she was born but i think whoever picked her to give that gift to picked an empty vessel, id rather watch nadine than leona, leona is boring, if leona tried to sing fields of gold she would give you a pitch perfect version and you will say wow amazing but nadine will make you cry thats the difference oh and learn how to spell you mong

  • @mgblue LMAO, firstly, i have to agree nadine has a great voice, i actually really like her new song. But i prefer leonas voice and thats the whole point of SINGING. Oh and you obviously need to get out more :)

  • @andwhat93

    i am very energetics.. love singing and preforming..

    i do it often..

    im getting a good reception so far...

    and could get a record deal any time soon

    good luck with that...loser

  • @mrcwalk Please tell me you're joking...

  • @mrcwalk apart frm she has no vocal range and very pitcy unlike leona lewis who is considered the best female singer of her generation....and leona has sold 30 million records, i voted for nadine...but c'mon....even shitty alexandra burke is a better singer

  • @numba1danman are you joking ? are the deaf ? seriosuley man wise up ! nadine coyle is fucking amazing like to see you or any other female singer sing like that im sure some of them could pull it off but im pretty sure nadine would pone alexandra and leonas little arse :) gone listen to her and your saying shes shit honestly ... ? you need a slap

  • @numba1danman

    Leona lewis has sold 10m records at the absolute maximum.

  • @yesyesohyay10 ohh reaaaly? well fyi..bleeding love sold just under 10 million worldwide, her debut album spirit has sold over 7 million copies...thats already 17 million, then u have better in time - 2.5 million, run .1.4 mil, forgive me 500k, happy 2 mil, echo 2.5 mil, momenty in time 1.3 mil. leona has sold between 25- 30 million records...put that in your pipe bitch!

  • @numba1danman

    oh right you're counting singles. well even adding them it's about 20m max. Just looked it up.

  • @yesyesohyay10 well im sorry your wrong, taking just one single and album...spirit and bleeding love leona has sold 17 million records. so that leaves 3 million to make up from echo, happy, better in time, moment like this, run, forgive me, i will be and i got you.

    her RECORD sales are between 25- 30 million.

  • @mrcwalk except leona 

  • this is y ive lost so much respect for modern day music cz its so not the best of the crop who r at the top! this just proves it...cheryl can barely hold a note and nadine is really the 1 with the talent but cz cheryl makes the pulse of an average man race faster shes the 1 with the contract!

  • Shes Sooo Good This Gives me Goosebumps.. and she is way more talented than Cheryl Cole

  • This is beautiful...

  • Anybody know how I can get her to sing this in my wedding?

  • @GirlsAloudGeek - marry her!

  • @TheFayser :P

  • she's the best one out girls aloud.

  • Shes sounds so amazingly beautiful!:D <3

  • This is good but listen to this:

    Watch the version from Linda Teodosiu of this song.

    Linda was 15 years as of this and she was 3rd in German Idol. Far better than this.

  • Eva Cassidy's version is really fantastic. She sings very well but not so magical as Eva's one :-)

  • omg i am crying cause she is so beautifal and talented

  • amazingg GA 4 eva!

  • i love this song and i have to say she sing this like i have never heard it sung before it touches me every time i here it x

  • @MrKerry77 listen to Eva Cassidy singing fields of gold, that, i'm sorry, is the best version ever...

  • Did you know that she is the only person IN THE WORLDD AND HISTORY to ever win 2 singing talent shows, she is amazingg, can'tt WAITT for her album :) xxxxxxx

  • Nadine is to release her album in the US then the UK

  • @milkybarkid16 butt whenn????

  • cheryls my favourite over all but nicola and nadine have the best voice by far!

  • mint xxx

  • she was obviously gonna be in that band the moment she walked in the audition room!

  • she can actually sing wow

  • This is the song I want at my funeral.

  • BY FAR the best singer from Girls Aloud, just isnt press crazy like Cheryl Cole!