Skye Sweetnam with Rancid- "Who Would've Thought"

[o7ViiGHTMAREo]

Skye and tim did the song into action for poets life and it was awesome, but this wasn't very good :(

[hissybitch]

Hah, i met her once... She's dating some dude from a band from around where I live... Shot them at a show once and was chatting with them and her afterwards. She seemed a bit stuck up. xD

[mrjinx87]

@hissybitch She's really nice, actually.

[hissybitch]

@mrjinx87 maybe i didn't get long enough t'talk to her. ahah.

[mrjinx87]

@hissybitch Most likely, yeah. 

[MrBobbymcBobbers]

Wow ruined a perfectly good punk show

[Gorcyt]

lol Rancid. Never did like them.

[TheMlboy]

:'((((

[WMackbd]

I take that back after watching some of her other stuff. She's too pop-idol sounding for my liking.

[WMackbd]

Never judge her. She's like the female equivalent of Tim Armstrong's voice.

Last thing we'd need is some chick from American Idol.

[salasam75]

i am sick



[jotacaccere]

"who would've thought skye sweetnam with rancid"

[TheZ00Man]

Long time Rancid fan. I couldn't finish watching this....it was murdered!

[LaZebraRiot]

Ma questa non vale proprio un cazzo per cantare con i Rancid.

[TrashcanJimmy]

She has talent, actually.

[CandiFan1]

May 'ave 'ad a lil to drink there. Still luv 'er, though <333

And, this is her real voice, y'all. Y'should 'ear her live. Her throat's gone raw, all that singing (Or booze, haha).

Oh, Grim, I love that lady <33

[XxXRancidxBastardXxX]

this bitch is fucking fine.

fuck all you god damn haters

because i know for a fact

i'd shaggg her raw

and she sang with RANCID

Your the poser sittin on yo ass

bitching you butt-nugget bastards!!

hahahhaa..

*G.R.Lopez

[blitzkreig40]

I still think she had been drinking... GO SKYE!

[technoman232]

this skye sweetnam is a ripping off piece of fuckin dog shit

[mario6sic6]

@technoman232 good thing your opinion doesnt mean anything, to anyone.

[technoman232]

@mario6sic6 fuck you

[mario6sic6]

@technoman232 no but thank you for the offer ; ]

[blitzkreig40]

shes so sexy!

[Wenzens]

Good job, Skye!

[crusterpuke]

being a great punk rocker like rancid makes you have a lot of those "friends" (cute chicks with no brain) i guess.

[blitzkreig40]

drunk lol

[arsinic12295]

wow....i mean, shes a good artist, for her usual type of music....but rancid?? no way dude. she shudve just used her own voice if she was even gunna try and sing this song....If it were any other band, i dont think people would show much support, cause...well..theyre punk and shes, well she just tries way to hard to come of as punk. they should just stick to their own shit.

[blitzkreig40]

could be drunk?

[Ayuemi81]

Je crois que je vais pleurer si j'écoute jusqu'au bout.... sorry girl... Tim's my hero!

[badtown88]

She shoulda sung it in her regular voice and not tried to sound like Tim. What's the point?

[theravingpunk]

looks like it was a good concert, nice small stage, small venue, keeps it intimate in a way

[VaBeachLoserKid]

It gives what was a kinda mellow song a snotty attitude that makes it sound even 'more Rancid' than the original. I like it almost better than the original. I'd like to hear a studio version.

[Rattnuff]

I dunno..but I guess its better for girls to look up for her than britney spears...

[kiwucha]

I hope that Skye goes on a Canada tour soon, I've never seen her in concert and I want to really badly ^u^

[sagov9]

I like skye, and I'm not afraid to admit it

[IrishDroog]

Only at a Rancid show would you get away with this. If a different punk band tried a stunt like this that chick would been bottled offstage.  She blows, btw, I checked out her music.

[BCity4life]

mm, i dunno, i like rancid, the girl's kinda weird. but ok :)

[MaxRide284]

Skye's Awsome. She wrote Into Action with Tim Armstrong. She has a video for it. She's really cute and quirky. Her songs are fun to dance to.

[wiggles37]

UMMM, GET LOST!! Skye Sweetnam is the most down to earth girl EVER! and ALOT of people look up to her, She rocks, and she is great! So shut your keyboard!

[antwanswan1]

HAHA down to earth me ass shes just a product of a record company

rancid are deadly but i was dissapointed in them for this

[cautiontapegirl]

This is exactly what I did with my uncle TIM this year.  Wowzerz. xD

[limoncello182]

skye, she's from canada just like avril

[TheSolicitors]

........................No.

[pukeonmyshoe2130]

i kinda like her voice

[blekaut90]

she's pretty cool

[KAAOS909]

im all fucked up from watching T.V all day :D

[G3tAdDiCted]

lame

[elhefe1138]

that was fucking sweet and i call everyone faggots posers and sell-outs...

[Redsox7612]

she sings pop and she's trying to sing punk rock and it dosn't work

[iluvpeterposh1]

she didn't murder it like i was anticipating but i would have rather heard rancid sing there song.

[dasfsadg]

ahes cool any friend of ranicd is rad

[maggot22]

dude brody is awesome and so is rancid and skye.

[fuckxyeahhh]

it's like avril's singing with the casualties.

[fuckxyeahhh]

oh my god.

[gabba1gabba1hey]

well.. its better than that cunt brody singing it, amirite?

[DarthSkater6]

love this song, skye did it fine.

[DemiAndSelenaFan894]

can everyone stop dissing skye? its a song.i think shes good at it. i bet if half of you tried singing it you guys would all fail. people would be mean to you just like you guys are to her. so stop. treat people the way you want to be treated.

i love you skye! <3

[ridintheconcretewave]

its got more meaning when tims on lead

[watchingITbaked]

im preaty sure tim just let her fuck one song up so he could fuck the shit outa her.,llol

[rigokent]

WHAT!!!!! that was terrible, you have lars fredrickson a bad ass who is oooooing. she sounds like brody from distillers but skye sucks. chance 156 ur completly stupid. im not impressed. yas this is my opinion but if thats urs then u dont deserve one.

[assholitis]

That's actually what Lars usually does during this song anyways. Tim sings lead, so he just does the backing and also the chorus. I agree she lacks the intensity and the punk background of Rancid, but still I thought it was a cool twist on a great song. Plus I know Tim really likes her and Lars himself gave her a nice intro. Brody would have been a cool way to do this song, but I don't see her doing a duet with Rancid any time soon, right? lol

[ELE4T]

false false false false

[immortalcorruptor087]

im disappointed....

[btxdalelobo22]

la mato

[cuppycakes3393]

i do like skye and all but i basically worship rancid and she sorta kills this song lol. im not feeling this at all.

[ryan33blevins]

yeah, i don't think she is feelin' Rancid. she didn't seem into the song. i'm glad they didn't let her sing sidekick or somthing good. i would be pissed.

[cuppycakes3393]

yea im pretty sure she if she would have tried to sing like red hot moon or fall back down...i might not be able to listen to rancid anymore hahaha

[xgodfreedomx]

better than original

[assholitis]

I don't know if I'd say it's better, but I love the feel. It's just a completely different twist on Rancid - hearing a female do lead vocals. Love it.

[HinkyPunkerinde]

I like the original much better, but it was fun to listen to this too.

[Chancee156]

wow she does pretty good, impressed.

[awwturnitup]

i am a LONG time rancid fan and i think she does a good job. plus this is a great song.

[CrowbarSka]

she doesn't sing very well at the start... a bit too low for her vocal range I think,

[xgodfreedomx]

guys...

lyric plz???

[VaBeachLoserKid]

I'd like to get an audio copy of this. It's a diffferent vocal delivery, but it really works.

[StrongTang]

Skye is awesome! Haters should perhaps think about getting a life instead of trying to instigate comment battles over a music video? Just a thought.

[LittleRudeGirl22]

why the fuck are all you bitches minusing me on MY opinion

[Ricer1968]

PUSSIES WHAT NEXT PARIS HILTON

[Congest]

You lack common sense if you're too stupid to figure out why you're juvenile and insulting comment got thumbed down.

[LittleRudeGirl22]

you know what fuck you i was stateing my opinion and ppl thumbs downed me its stupid any one with ears knows she blows i mean she kills it you just cant have a power pop chick sing a song like this it just dosent sound right

u can go fuck off

[Congest]

Your comments demonstrate how befitting your username is. Not wishing to lose any more brain cells, I won't respond to you any further.

[LittleRudeGirl22]

and it would be diffrent if she sang it good

[IrishDroog]

Cause they're Skye fans who got linked to this vid from that interview. I think most Rancid fans would agree with you.

[moonyusuf]

this is great i love skye so unique..

who wants to be so melodic like celine dion anyway

this is cool hip and lots of fun

[LittleRudeGirl22]

dumb bitch ruined the song her vocals fucking suck

wow that was crapy

now i gotta go listen 2 tim sing it like three times and it will be all good again

[neeks6]

Is that Hanna montana?!

[NiQui101]

all i can say is that she's lucky! rancid wont even dare to call a bitch to sing a song with `em....she's lucky! so lucky! but that doesnt mean she's a punkrocker.....she's still on the mainstream but its just happened that she's with the punkrockers.....she's a good friend of the rancid...so all i can say is that i respect that......nice effort.....

[LimeDolli]

She's mainstream?. I don't know a single person in Australia who knows of her and I've never heard her on the radio..

[LaceyDodoShowNews]

if you think this is stupid your stupid cuz this rocks

[punkasfuuck]

oh no not good tim has to sing it ...shes to much

[dmellow45]

i really like the music in this song, but the vocals are kinda neither here nor there

[JoeYY182]

can some people not exept different styles?

i thought this was awesome.

[Congest]

Nope

[TomTriangle]

your opinion...

I think Skye and Rancid are both great. ♥

Have a nice day. :)

[Mopadfu]

"Tim has to sing it"

And you are?

[Kalcia21]

skye it's amazing! you rocks!

[chrystalyx144]

Music is supposed to not only be a career, but to have fun with doing it. People who are overly judgmental on how a band should sound or if someone wants to join up on the stage and enjoy some enjoyable moments; they need to have a reality check.

Music is entertainment and I think it is awesome how Skye joined in and shared a fun moment.

[chrystalyx144]

I like this sound. Rock on!

[G6a6g6e]

stupid ho! i eat shit like her for breakfast

[emilyraffa6]

why does it fucking matter?did lars SAY she was punk?

no.

it shouldnt matter.he just said they wanted to do a song with her andthat she was a sweet girl and shit.i fuckin hate posers too, buti didnt see her posing as anything.she just looked like some chick having fun singing with some friends.back the fuck offanddeal wt yourown problems before you judge others.

[anaxautopsy]

i dont see what all the fuss is about.

they were just having fun.

i happen to be a big san of skye & rancid

and even if she isnt doing her best its

because this is a different style fo her.

[punX5notdead]

WHAT THE FUCK IS THIS?

[jackylcale]

This is Skye an tim and the boys havin way more fun than most of us'll ever get to.

[wildcatmonkey]

she's just trying to copy tim's style of singing, she normally sounds like ashlee simpson, and is about as lame.

[PaperWings666]

OH god no... What the shit?!

[Liekkek]

rancid > whoever this bitch is LOOOOOOOOOL

[Flosspasta]

Wrong.

[Swedert]

Hey Liekkek, fuck you AND yo' mama! Skye and Rancid are both cool in my book.

[Liekkek]

yes rancid are cool in any book, shame you cant read :< hoohoohoo

[Schansuperrad]

I think this is fine for a live low Q recording... I've never considered Skye "punk" and I've been a fan since the first CD... but to me she's kinda a singer that can sorta cross over genres and make it work besides rancid does awesome work and no one said they had to be genre exclusive...

I wanna stab the asshole who decided artists could only stick to a narrow variety of genres and somehow coned the world into believing it. :)

hehheh... go Skye!

[djfatdex]

omg she has just bought down rancid awsomenese ssooo much

[mmagdah]

what? WHAT? WHAT????

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­O!!!!!!!

only tim armstrong can sing this song

[cautiontapegirlvideo]

I love Skye and she has insane talent but this song is sometimes too low for her best vocal range.

For all the people who think Skye isn't punk... maybe she isn't but what IS punk? If you try to make yourself feel better by saying Skye is a poser and you are punk just shut the fuck up because people and people. They are themselves! A skirt can be punk, a jacket can be punk, a song can be punk... a person SHOULD be themselves.

[thenscream]

stop your incoherent rambling. if youre gonna defend someone, at least make some sense. a skirt is not punk, what you said makes no sense.

[homstar]

you said it best man. I agree 100%

[thenscream]

wow shes so lucky. but such a fucking poser. shes just like avril, thinking wearing plaid skirt and putting a pink streak in her hair makes her hardcore.

[ImaTeachYaHowToRock]

shutup!shes as real as she gets!avril is fake

[thenscream]

shes like all those teenager girls with pink in their hair that you see at your average suburban mall who go to hot topic cuz they think it makes them cool.

[Brainiac83]

hahaha right on..

[allieissuperbad]

Have you performed with Rancid?

Then shut the fuck up.

[boihunter0014]

wtfs your problem with skye!?..she rocks and you cant do anything about it!

[thenscream]

ooooh youre right. clearly, since no one knows who the fuck she is, she must be really awesome.

[melikespunk12]

MAN wtf she is so punk "SHUTUP!!!" (SARCASM) this made me puke a placenta...Hi guys im skye...lame...but i dont agree with the statement about her being a poser and like avril....aahahhaahhahahahahh couldnt say that with a straight face

[LilMiissRockstar]

Skyes not a poser. She's been wearing plaid skirts and all that since she was really young. Avril just recently started doing that. if anything, Avrils the poser.

[thenscream]

avril is a total poser also. neither of them has any "punk" cred, and their music is shit.

[popscifan1]

you're right, because wearing plaid skirts makes you punk... wow i think that i am going to go burn all of my Rancid records b/c i dont have one!

[popscifan1]

thats not to say that i dont like skye, im just saying wearing plaid dosn't make u punk

oh and whoever utered the phrase "punk cred"  is really stupid

[vomitfromyourmouth]

I think Skye Sweetnam would have been better off if she did punk music instead of the pop/rock thing she does. But I still like her!

[54spiritedwill54]

Skye did great. Looks like a fun time.

[adnyyyyyy]

avril suck!

[vomitfromyourmouth]

Dont even start... talking about her will only cause chaos.

[fbunny074]

haha u were right it did cause chaos lol the comments r funny too oh well cool vid

[realmccoyxdfxrudeboy]

gabba1gabba1hey your an idiot,

rancid destroyed the punk scene they opened it up for greedy marketers with their out come the wolves album ...them and skye sweetnam are perfect for each other...they both belong in hot topic together

[strawberrysocks13]

woah, way better than i thought it'd be

so, 5 strars

[gabba1gabba1hey]

i bet its 10x better if your there, we all know camrea phones dont do punk bands justice

[Kwaszk]

uuugh.... puketastic

[abrasivewt]

she doesnt really do a very good job singing this song. i lol'd at her saying that shes an 'angry man' though

[vomitfromyourmouth]

I enjoy listening to both Skye and Rancid.

Cool video!

[limoncello182]

i love both skye and rancid!!!

but avril is better than skye!!!

[jpodjpod]

HAHAHAHA you must be retarded or joking! Avril is a tool.

[limoncello182]

^shut up asshole!!! you know nothing about emo and punk rock music

[gabba1gabba1hey]

you aint no fuckin rancid fan.

hoes like avril lavigne are destrying OUR scene.

not your scene.

go back to hot topic little bitch.

[limoncello182]

^destroying? you are ridiculous!!! so what if i don't like rancid that much, i can listen to whatever music i want, get that you stupid poser? coz you don't know anything about punk!!! want to learn what real punk is? go to my channel, read my description!!!

[gabba1gabba1hey]

i did.

and your song list is:

AVRIL LAVIGNE - FREAK OUT

GREENDAY - MINORITY

BLINK 182 - GIVE ME ONE GOOD REASON

SUM 41 - FAT LIP

sorry but your a poser bitch.

[limoncello182]

so what the hell is your problem with my fav songs??? get a life you fucken idiot!!!

[Listen2Strummer]

if you think thats true punk u must b dumb

[PunxNOTdeaD2009]

WOW you know the names of the songs, I actually ha to look them up to see if you were right.

[gabba1gabba1hey]

lol it was on his youtube page i just copy and pasted

[calidakotaskunk]

i feel like taking a dump

[bucktoofus]

2:30 proves this is a swing and a miss for me

[Voteforten]

Skye did great. Screw the narrow-minded idiots leaving negative comments.

[dozerrock]

I think the are great together...

[PowerInAUnion]

it's funny how people neg-repped my comment about punk rock dying at this very moment... do they honestly believe that this girl has any legitimacy in the punk scene? What a joke.

[Congest]

Skye has fans. Rancid has fans. Some people are fans of both. Deal with it.

And generally, if you're making a negative comment on a video, it will get voted down. That's just the way it works on Youtube.

[jpodjpod]

punk is dead for people who jump from genre to genre, make up your mind and listen to what you like.

[mourningbeloveth]

I wonder how well it would go over if she did the same thing at a Discharge show.

[kittysugar]

she didnt even know rancid when lars came up to her what a dumb broad

[1969yugt]

why didnt they play the kiss a girl song??