Its very important for us all to know what really happened back in 1984,before commenting or abusing anybody of any religion,this all happened because of the political parties and the power game,But now what we can & what we shoud do is to fina a way to support or help the people who are still suffering from the riots...!!
i must congratulate Shonali bose on her brave gesture to make a movie on 1984...:)
u get ur facts rite (abhishek1608). Guru Nanak, was born in a Hindu Khatri family. However, he declared that all are equal in the eyes of God in his famous proclamation "I am not a Hindu, nor am I a Muslim. U get it now a Sikh is not a Hindu or any other kind Sikh is a Sikh and its religion is separate from any other religion in the world. So stop saying that a Sikh is a Hindu and we're one and the same thing cuse ur not. Guru nanak said it loud and clear that a Sikh is not a Hindu.
it's all politics theyy r the ppl who caused the riots...n it jus makes me so angry that sikhs have not recieved justice!!! 1 nov 1984 this day chged everything...all thanks to indira gandhi...who attacked golden temple...n congress party...
guys if sikhs were second class citizen of india... our prime minister wunt have been a sikh...... sikhs are as much a part of india as we are... the thing is tht sikh represent india more than any other community.. proud to be an indian and proud to have sikhs in our country. we're brothers and if u get ur facts rite then u wud knw tht sikhs come from hindus..we're one and the same thing..(no offence to anyone)
@abhishek1608mayo That is like saying that Jews and Christians are one and the same OR Muslims and Christians or Jews are all just the same thing. Are you that ignorant??? Sikh's are NOT hindu's. They never were and never will be. Are you so desperate to believe that Sikh's are hindu's that u'll lie to urself and the and public? Is it becuz u hav nothing of ur own to be proud of so u try to assimilate the great history of the Sikhs?? You can't change the truth by lying, get a life.
@PervJirayia well i guess u shud get ur facts rite son, first sikhs were the eldest sons of the hindu families who were prepared to fight the mughals. sikhs are the warrior class chosen out of basic hindu families.
and wat i said earlier doesnt coincide with ur "makes no sense in regards to my comment" comment.
@abhishek1608mayo Sikh's weren't chosen out of hindu families haha wtf?? u losers got nothing of ur own to be proud of so u want to go around pretending Sikh's are anything like ur pathetic selves?? get a life lol hindus/muslims/bhuddists CONVERTED to Sikhism. "warrior class" haha yeah right Sikhism is a martial religion that earned its respect & reputation through sacrifices made by its martyrs. THAT is something your lies will never change so stop ur BS
@PervJirayia sikhism, 300 some years old, hinduism, 10,000 some years old. ask ur dad abt the history of sikhs, if ur a sikh then m sure ur dad wud know wat m talking about, how ignorant can u get that ur replying without even doing some research. GET A FUKIN LIFE.
@abhishek1608mayo My grandfather was a Nihang, so I know what i'm talking about when I say that Sikh's have nothing in common with hundus other than land and some languages. My family history is my research, something ur BS lies can't deny. Your jealousy is kinda ridiculous lol ur funny
@abhishek1608mayo ur an ignorant fool who is too immature to recognize and accept the truth. The fact is that only idiots like u believe ur crap, anyone with even half a brain knows how far apart Sikhism is from hinduism. goodluck wasting ur life believing in made up bs, truth is just too painful for fools like you.
@abhishek1608mayo That's exactly what I'm doing, for myself and millions of others: evading the darkness by not letting the sacrifices of countless martyrs go in vain because they died to preserve Sikhism's unique identity and plenty of losers like you have tried to assimilate it and distort the truth and failed, as will you.
@abhishek1608mayo yet its you who needs to grow up haha i hope i didnt hurt your feelings, my only aim is to stop liars like you from manipulating murders of innocents to your own selfish benefits.
imagine seeing people getting killed helplessly, because someone from their community killed a political figure.... THE GOVERNMENT CAN NOT JUSTIFY WHAT HAPPENED BACK THEN AND EVERYONE KNOWS THAT...
I bet the fanatics out there have no jobs. See what joblessness does to people's minds. So yeah, things happened in history every culture can trace back wrongs. How can all of us sit and have grudges? Quite stupid. The world would not move forward. You create more hate again and again.
"When a tree shook Delhi" is a book with comprehensive coverage of 1984 riots by Justice Phoolka. Published in India. It is a mirror for us to see our own face.
Another publicity stunt and nothing else.. make movies on sikh riots, godhra, babri masjid, kashmir, bomb blasts, bombay mafia - all will be a big hit in the dumb indian society. they will win awards but serve no purpose other than further dividing the already divided nation.
The 1984 genocide ( not anti - Sikh riots ) was the biggest in the history of independent India , with 12 , 000 - 20 , 000 Sikhs being killed all over India nearly 4000 of them in Delhi alone , property worth hundreds of crores destroyed . It is shame on part of Indian democracy that the justice has not still been done ( 24 yrs later ) . Are sikhs not citizens of India ? Sikhs r to be blamed partly for this . The efforts of Sikhs have been very poorly directed & unfocussed . The Sikh money is
still being wasted on Nagar Kirtans , building Gurudwaras , Langars , Gurudwara politics whereas the perpetrators of 1984 genocide r roaming free . It is matter of great satisfaction ( & shame ) that it took a non - Sikh ( Shonali Bose ) to initiate a venture like this which shall show the true history & true face of this so called secular ( theocratic ) democracy called India to the whole world as well as young generation of Sikhs who r getting lost in daily pleasures & drugs , alcohal
m happy they made a movie like that... because if you look at the comments made on the other videoss, Hindus fighting Sikhs blah blah blah... nobody really knowz wat happened they just bitching at each other like they wanna kill someone, this movie made it very clear wat exactly happened and all the comments on this trailler so far are not bad.
"It was the Congress leaders who instigated mobs in 1984 and got more than 3000 people killed. I must give due credit to RSS and the BJP for showing courage and protecting helpless Sikhs during those difficult days. BJP party leader Atal Bihari Vajpayee himself intervened at a couple of places to help poor taxi drivers." The Bharatiya Janata Party strongly condemned the riots.-Khushwant Singh
And by the way the president of India during that time was Giani Zail Singh,a Sikh,If we Hindus hate Sikh so much why is their a Sikh president in India at that time.Today India has a Sikh prime minister.
actually, you seem to be a hindu yourself, after all your information is incorrect. in case you did not know, indira gandhi started it all by ordering the indian army to attack the sikh militants that were hiding at the harmandir sahib! so many sikhs were killed and this sacred sikh shrine was damaged. so, indira gandhi's sikh guards killed her. then muslims and hindus went on to ruthlessly murder more than 2700 people! the media is always with hindus after all! try learning some history!
I am a proud Hindu.Ok,why was Bhindranwale walking all over the place with weapons,what impression is he giving to Hindus?The pseudo secular government and media of India is,no doubt,anti Hindu.If there are militias who are working against the government ,the government has right to stop it before there is anarchy.
LOL! Yeah I know Shonali Bose is a Hindu - possibly the only sane one. Obviously what you know has been passed down from biased Hindu parents. I am 15, born and living in Australia and I have studied this issue as part of a school project with live accounts from people who were present at the time. Their families were burnt and killed. I'm pretty sure they would know more than you. YOUR COMMENT - WTF???
"It was the Congress leaders who instigated mobs in 1984 and got more than 3000 people killed. I must give due credit to RSS and the BJP for showing courage and protecting helpless Sikhs during those difficult days. BJP party leader Atal Bihari Vajpayee himself intervened at a couple of places to help poor taxi drivers." The Bharatiya Janata Party strongly condemned the riots.-Khushwant Singh
Well Khushwant Singh is probably the only sane Sikh.lol
Fuck off you loser! Go get a life and get your facts right before. I always knew Hindus were biased retards but I thought that when they were enlightened to the facts, they would understand. Just back off and stop shaming your own religion you dipshit!
I'm not even going to bother arguing with an idiot like you. Obviously the previous arguments have not made any room in your shit filled brain, so I'll just call peace.
You're 15, an Australian, school-going kid. You know a lot of things but the thing you don't understand is that IGNORANCE IS ACTULLY NOT BLISS. You've never been to India, how would you really know the plight of Indian Sikhs. I'm a Sikh and a proud Indian. I see no distinction between the two. Why did you generalize the fact that HINDUS instigated the violence in 1984? Where did you learn that? Your parents, teachers or friends? Did they not tell you that the same HINDUS gave shelter to sikhs?
im glad you feel proud to be indian regularclassic. but consider this....the indian government doesnt recognise sikhs as a separate religious group, they have regularly suppressed them on a social and cultural level, not to mention 1984 and general ridicule of sikhs in bollywood films....i could go on. dont forget that in 1947 you were a signature away from being a pakistani. hindus did give shelter but many more were killing in 1984. sikhs are second class citizins in india, that is a fact
I would defidently have to agree with you. I have been working for the past 5 years with genocide awareness organizations such as Amnesty International and S.T.A.N.D., and the one strong opinion i have is that if there is anything our sikh nation is doing wrong today is blaming the ENTIRE hindu community for what happened. The more we do this the closer we are getting to becoming just like those who initiated this. Yes, majority of hindu's supported what happened (which is a proven fact) but
Yes, you're right in your observation.I wonder if it is that simple to explain why frenzied masses spontaneously do what they would normally not even think of doing. There can be many many
reasons.Incitement by a few certainly plays a major part. But a matchstick can only set fire to an inflammable material, which may appear inert till it is lit. People must understand that it was a state-sponsered violence to gain political mileage in lieu of lack of political issue to contest elections.
@Radian1991 RSS is a hindu extremist terrorist group who is responsible for spreading the lies that Sikh's are somehow hindu's. RSS are the terrorist who are responsible for the ongoing violence in Punjab and the divisions between Sikh's. They are the people who look up to HITLER and read his books! This Khushwant "Singh" is probably a member of that hateful group and none of them are sane. STOP spreading lies about Sikhism! Sikh's never were and never will be hindu's!!!
@Radian1991 Khuswant Singh was a supporter of Indira Gandhi and the Congress party when they attacked Gurudwara's across India and sent security forces to the unprotected homes of "suspected" Sikh Amrtidhari men to kill their families in Punjab. He has also been quoted as saying "I do not believe in God..." which makes him an Atheist, NOT a Sikh. Why don't you look up Khuswant "Singh" carefully before making nonsensical comments? And you are promoting RSS, who lie that Sikh's are Hindu's.
@PervJirayia Actually He has claimed to be agnostic.Being agnostic does not mean that he is not a Sikh."Though he has always claimed to be an agnostic, he comes across strongly as a Sikh first and anything else later. His pain at the operation blue star is very obvious and he still carries it. He enjoys counting how many Sikhs are in position of power and feels good when Harbhajan plays a good game. He is upset when his son cut his hair."-Anuradha Goyal
@Radian1991 This still does not change the fact that he supported Indira Gandhi who did nothing but spread hatred and caused divisions between two peaceful religions by first refusing to address the unjust treatment of Sikh's and secondly attacking them, labeling them as terrorists, when they rose up to to fight for their rights. This man was in support of that gov't, is that not enough to end this discussion of him?
@Radian1991 by who? hindu's? the gov't? How do u become an expert on Sikhism when you cannot even understand a minority's need for equal rights and justice? He's an idiot who supported an oppressive gov't, he's no expert. He's only seen as that by ignorant and hateful people.
@Radian1991 It is a joke to heartless people like you who cannot relate to the struggle of those who've had to witness the murders and rapes of their families without any justice. The criminals are the ones who are in power in political offices right now, and u sit there and laugh, its disgusting and pathetic.
@PervJirayia Why don't you go and tell that to the Sikh Prime Minister of India?And stop making nonsensical assumptions of me,you're only making a fool out of your self.☺.
@Radian1991 he's a puppet. The only thing Sikh about him is his turban and nothing else. The whole worlds knows he's sonia gandhi's puppet and has no relationship whatsoever with the Sikh community. So how about you grow some more brain cells, maybe stop watching so much of tht bollywood bullshyt, and pull ur head outta ur ass and step into reality lol u'll find a lot of surprises waiting for u
@Radian1991 Operation Blue Star was pure evil. Anyone who is remotely sane with a even shred of morals would condemn it. That does not make anyone a Sikh. Also, It is well known that the RSS is attempting to absorb the Sikh religion into the indian hindu majority. And this man called Kushwant "Singh" is actually foolish enough to believe that they supported the Sikh's then he is out of touch with reality.
@PervJirayia Allot of people see Indira Gandhi as the "Hindu" tyrant who persecuted innocent Sikhs.Indira Gandhi does not represent Hinduism/Sanatana Dharma.
@Radian1991 Fact: There would be no Christianity or Islam without Judaism. We all know how different these three religions are, no one would argue that they are all the same. That is the case with Sikhism and Hinduism, who probably have even less in common than the three mentioned above. I am aware of the origin of the word "hindu" as well as the correct name for the religion but the word hindu is far more widely known and accepted and I am not in any way using it in a derogatory manner.
@Radian1991 they are not minor differences. All they have in common is their origin. Other than that, they have different beliefs, holidays, traditions, etc. I'm not even surprised that you would say that. I'd like to see what kind of reaction that comment would elicit from an actual christian/muslim/jew. Honestly, this is getting ridiculous.
@PervJirayia Well,I stand by what I said,"Actually,Christianity,Islam,and Judaism(The Abrahamic Religions) are quite the same thing with minor differences."Like it or not!
@Radian1991 I actually don't care, your ignorance is your problem and its something will eventually give lots of regrets. so enjoy, knock urself out, be as stupid as u like in fact go on pretending the whole world is hindu haha goodluck
@Radian1991 Like what? Land? Language? What else? Everything else in Sikhism is different from hinduism, even down to our physical appearance despite the fact that we come from the same land and time as the hindu population. It is your ignorance and desperation that is driving people like you to want to think that they are the same thing when they are not anything alike. They are both peaceful religions, let that be another shared attribute and let them be as they are and stop the lies, plz.
@PervJirayia WOW! You're Feisty.Lol.I never said that Sikhism and Hinduism are the same thing,they obviously are not.I just said that they have "more in common than the Abrahamic Religions".
"It was the Congress leaders who instigated mobs in 1984 and got more than 3000 people killed. I must give due credit to RSS and the BJP for showing courage and protecting helpless Sikhs during those difficult days. BJP party leader Atal Bihari Vajpayee himself intervened at a couple of places to help poor taxi drivers." The Bharatiya Janata Party strongly condemned the riots.-Khushwant Singh
The sikh riots are a shame on Hindu people but its not the Hindus who did it ..its the fucking congress mtr fckrs who did it.. this is a bigger picture to divide the hindus and sikhs the whole nehru family is a conspiracy theory to deprive hindus and breed those mohammed mtr fckrs .. but the muslims are not to be blamed either coz the hindus are their biggest enemies
finally someone makes a film which portrays this huge covered up genocide in india, its time it got the worlds attention and people recognize the indian government for what it really is.
after i found abt 1984 i feel ashamed to be calle an indian
84WAKEUP 10 months ago
@84WAKEUP ur not da only one... im a sikh and im ashamed to be indian as well now
sizzly101 10 months ago
hate everywhere now a days.
Hedonistic100 1 year ago
Its very important for us all to know what really happened back in 1984,before commenting or abusing anybody of any religion,this all happened because of the political parties and the power game,But now what we can & what we shoud do is to fina a way to support or help the people who are still suffering from the riots...!!
i must congratulate Shonali bose on her brave gesture to make a movie on 1984...:)
shabad1984 2 years ago 10
u get ur facts rite (abhishek1608). Guru Nanak, was born in a Hindu Khatri family. However, he declared that all are equal in the eyes of God in his famous proclamation "I am not a Hindu, nor am I a Muslim. U get it now a Sikh is not a Hindu or any other kind Sikh is a Sikh and its religion is separate from any other religion in the world. So stop saying that a Sikh is a Hindu and we're one and the same thing cuse ur not. Guru nanak said it loud and clear that a Sikh is not a Hindu.
manderd1983 2 years ago 2
i m jus gonna say dat imagine 1984 happening 2 u n ur family, i think den u will understand da pain of those ppl
asianprincess56 2 years ago 2
it's all politics theyy r the ppl who caused the riots...n it jus makes me so angry that sikhs have not recieved justice!!! 1 nov 1984 this day chged everything...all thanks to indira gandhi...who attacked golden temple...n congress party...
eyurit 2 years ago
guys if sikhs were second class citizen of india... our prime minister wunt have been a sikh...... sikhs are as much a part of india as we are... the thing is tht sikh represent india more than any other community.. proud to be an indian and proud to have sikhs in our country. we're brothers and if u get ur facts rite then u wud knw tht sikhs come from hindus..we're one and the same thing..(no offence to anyone)
abhishek1608mayo 2 years ago
@abhishek1608mayo That is like saying that Jews and Christians are one and the same OR Muslims and Christians or Jews are all just the same thing. Are you that ignorant??? Sikh's are NOT hindu's. They never were and never will be. Are you so desperate to believe that Sikh's are hindu's that u'll lie to urself and the and public? Is it becuz u hav nothing of ur own to be proud of so u try to assimilate the great history of the Sikhs?? You can't change the truth by lying, get a life.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia well i guess u shud get ur facts rite son, first sikhs were the eldest sons of the hindu families who were prepared to fight the mughals. sikhs are the warrior class chosen out of basic hindu families.
and wat i said earlier doesnt coincide with ur "makes no sense in regards to my comment" comment.
abhishek1608mayo 1 year ago
@abhishek1608mayo Sikh's weren't chosen out of hindu families haha wtf?? u losers got nothing of ur own to be proud of so u want to go around pretending Sikh's are anything like ur pathetic selves?? get a life lol hindus/muslims/bhuddists CONVERTED to Sikhism. "warrior class" haha yeah right Sikhism is a martial religion that earned its respect & reputation through sacrifices made by its martyrs. THAT is something your lies will never change so stop ur BS
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia sikhism, 300 some years old, hinduism, 10,000 some years old. ask ur dad abt the history of sikhs, if ur a sikh then m sure ur dad wud know wat m talking about, how ignorant can u get that ur replying without even doing some research. GET A FUKIN LIFE.
abhishek1608mayo 1 year ago
@abhishek1608mayo My grandfather was a Nihang, so I know what i'm talking about when I say that Sikh's have nothing in common with hundus other than land and some languages. My family history is my research, something ur BS lies can't deny. Your jealousy is kinda ridiculous lol ur funny
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia ur an ignorant boy, but its ok, u misinterpreted wat i meant in the first comment on the video.
all u did is tht u became the target of something tht wasnt aimed at u.
be at peace.
abhishek1608mayo 1 year ago
@abhishek1608mayo ur an ignorant fool who is too immature to recognize and accept the truth. The fact is that only idiots like u believe ur crap, anyone with even half a brain knows how far apart Sikhism is from hinduism. goodluck wasting ur life believing in made up bs, truth is just too painful for fools like you.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia i hope u evade the darkness one day. may peace be with u.
abhishek1608mayo 1 year ago
@abhishek1608mayo That's exactly what I'm doing, for myself and millions of others: evading the darkness by not letting the sacrifices of countless martyrs go in vain because they died to preserve Sikhism's unique identity and plenty of losers like you have tried to assimilate it and distort the truth and failed, as will you.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia such a kid.
abhishek1608mayo 1 year ago
@abhishek1608mayo yet its you who needs to grow up haha i hope i didnt hurt your feelings, my only aim is to stop liars like you from manipulating murders of innocents to your own selfish benefits.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia such a kid.
abhishek1608mayo 1 year ago
it is sooo stupid to kill ur own people
hasan1119 2 years ago 2
salam_91_1990@hot
محمد
serat5678 2 years ago
abe flatu baat na kar
i am not a Sikh but i know one thing
if Sikh will leave ur battle ground then
Pakistani will piss person like modi and all indian
so value them. they have given life for this MF land
usaajan 2 years ago 4
imagine seeing people getting killed helplessly, because someone from their community killed a political figure.... THE GOVERNMENT CAN NOT JUSTIFY WHAT HAPPENED BACK THEN AND EVERYONE KNOWS THAT...
CHOHAN67 3 years ago
I bet the fanatics out there have no jobs. See what joblessness does to people's minds. So yeah, things happened in history every culture can trace back wrongs. How can all of us sit and have grudges? Quite stupid. The world would not move forward. You create more hate again and again.
goingplaces11 3 years ago
its vcd and dvd is available in india[with some cencer cuts] now in da markets,its da only serious work abt sikh tragedy dat too by a bengali.......
amardeep1979 3 years ago
"When a tree shook Delhi" is a book with comprehensive coverage of 1984 riots by Justice Phoolka. Published in India. It is a mirror for us to see our own face.
sageharmony 3 years ago
Another publicity stunt and nothing else.. make movies on sikh riots, godhra, babri masjid, kashmir, bomb blasts, bombay mafia - all will be a big hit in the dumb indian society. they will win awards but serve no purpose other than further dividing the already divided nation.
leanderpace 3 years ago 2
The 1984 genocide ( not anti - Sikh riots ) was the biggest in the history of independent India , with 12 , 000 - 20 , 000 Sikhs being killed all over India nearly 4000 of them in Delhi alone , property worth hundreds of crores destroyed . It is shame on part of Indian democracy that the justice has not still been done ( 24 yrs later ) . Are sikhs not citizens of India ? Sikhs r to be blamed partly for this . The efforts of Sikhs have been very poorly directed & unfocussed . The Sikh money is
dalbirk 3 years ago
still being wasted on Nagar Kirtans , building Gurudwaras , Langars , Gurudwara politics whereas the perpetrators of 1984 genocide r roaming free . It is matter of great satisfaction ( & shame ) that it took a non - Sikh ( Shonali Bose ) to initiate a venture like this which shall show the true history & true face of this so called secular ( theocratic ) democracy called India to the whole world as well as young generation of Sikhs who r getting lost in daily pleasures & drugs , alcohal
dalbirk 3 years ago
how true!!
riat33 3 years ago
KHALLSTAN ZINDABAAD
hindustan murdabaad
fuck hindus and specially gandhi's.
khalsa84s 3 years ago
your an idiot.
It was congress secular terrorist party mobs who murdered Sikhs. Not Hindu's, yes hindu's were part of the mobs but it wasnt a hindu vs sikh thing.
sikhbadboy 3 years ago
its banned in india
cant say u didnt know it was comming
khalsaAK47 3 years ago
To Khalsa AK47 -
Its not banned in India...
It actually also got nominated for the Indian national awards...
PassionateIndia 3 years ago
m happy they made a movie like that... because if you look at the comments made on the other videoss, Hindus fighting Sikhs blah blah blah... nobody really knowz wat happened they just bitching at each other like they wanna kill someone, this movie made it very clear wat exactly happened and all the comments on this trailler so far are not bad.
nameyoumustnottrust 4 years ago
"It was the Congress leaders who instigated mobs in 1984 and got more than 3000 people killed. I must give due credit to RSS and the BJP for showing courage and protecting helpless Sikhs during those difficult days. BJP party leader Atal Bihari Vajpayee himself intervened at a couple of places to help poor taxi drivers." The Bharatiya Janata Party strongly condemned the riots.-Khushwant Singh
Radian1991 4 years ago
ha ha bhartiya janta party
what did atal bihari did after remaining in power for 5 years did he did and soncere investigation and even a single person still hanged for that
dude all u are same it was nor congress nor bjp it is the mentality of u hindus that u hate sikhs
in the recent book of lal krishna advani he has written that he himself told indira gandhi for the operation bluestar
hindu hate sikh from day one
ur are a unthankfull community fuck u
chanpreet22singh 3 years ago
And by the way the president of India during that time was Giani Zail Singh,a Sikh,If we Hindus hate Sikh so much why is their a Sikh president in India at that time.Today India has a Sikh prime minister.
Radian1991 3 years ago
giani zail singh was also attacked by stones his car was hit by stones when he visited aims hospital to see india gandhi
chanpreet22singh 3 years ago
But as president of India he could of still done something.
Radian1991 3 years ago
wow. I didn't know that. So why are people so Hindu vs Sikh? Seems stupid now.
goingplaces11 3 years ago
Its is Sikhs vs Hindu.Look at the many anti Hindu videos on Youtube,they are by Sikhs Muslims and Christians.
Radian1991 3 years ago
actually, you seem to be a hindu yourself, after all your information is incorrect. in case you did not know, indira gandhi started it all by ordering the indian army to attack the sikh militants that were hiding at the harmandir sahib! so many sikhs were killed and this sacred sikh shrine was damaged. so, indira gandhi's sikh guards killed her. then muslims and hindus went on to ruthlessly murder more than 2700 people! the media is always with hindus after all! try learning some history!
SantiKaur 3 years ago
I am a proud Hindu.Ok,why was Bhindranwale walking all over the place with weapons,what impression is he giving to Hindus?The pseudo secular government and media of India is,no doubt,anti Hindu.If there are militias who are working against the government ,the government has right to stop it before there is anarchy.
Radian1991 3 years ago
You don't know what you're talking about! Its all a load of shit!
SantiKaur 3 years ago
You don't know what you're talking about!.You need to get your facts straight.And by the way this movie(Amu)is made by Shonali Bose,a Hindu.
Radian1991 3 years ago
LOL! Yeah I know Shonali Bose is a Hindu - possibly the only sane one. Obviously what you know has been passed down from biased Hindu parents. I am 15, born and living in Australia and I have studied this issue as part of a school project with live accounts from people who were present at the time. Their families were burnt and killed. I'm pretty sure they would know more than you. YOUR COMMENT - WTF???
SantiKaur 3 years ago
"It was the Congress leaders who instigated mobs in 1984 and got more than 3000 people killed. I must give due credit to RSS and the BJP for showing courage and protecting helpless Sikhs during those difficult days. BJP party leader Atal Bihari Vajpayee himself intervened at a couple of places to help poor taxi drivers." The Bharatiya Janata Party strongly condemned the riots.-Khushwant Singh
Well Khushwant Singh is probably the only sane Sikh.lol
Radian1991 3 years ago
Fuck off you loser! Go get a life and get your facts right before. I always knew Hindus were biased retards but I thought that when they were enlightened to the facts, they would understand. Just back off and stop shaming your own religion you dipshit!
SantiKaur 3 years ago
Based on your language,I can see who is the fanatical retard,and who is a person of moral and culture.Obviously you are not.lol
Radian1991 3 years ago
I'm not even going to bother arguing with an idiot like you. Obviously the previous arguments have not made any room in your shit filled brain, so I'll just call peace.
SantiKaur 3 years ago
Stop talking about yourself and stop being in self denial.
Radian1991 3 years ago
You have to get YOUR facts straight and stop basing it on your hatred for Hindus.
Radian1991 3 years ago
You're 15, an Australian, school-going kid. You know a lot of things but the thing you don't understand is that IGNORANCE IS ACTULLY NOT BLISS. You've never been to India, how would you really know the plight of Indian Sikhs. I'm a Sikh and a proud Indian. I see no distinction between the two. Why did you generalize the fact that HINDUS instigated the violence in 1984? Where did you learn that? Your parents, teachers or friends? Did they not tell you that the same HINDUS gave shelter to sikhs?
regularclassic 3 years ago
im glad you feel proud to be indian regularclassic. but consider this....the indian government doesnt recognise sikhs as a separate religious group, they have regularly suppressed them on a social and cultural level, not to mention 1984 and general ridicule of sikhs in bollywood films....i could go on. dont forget that in 1947 you were a signature away from being a pakistani. hindus did give shelter but many more were killing in 1984. sikhs are second class citizins in india, that is a fact
rarrapind 3 years ago
I would defidently have to agree with you. I have been working for the past 5 years with genocide awareness organizations such as Amnesty International and S.T.A.N.D., and the one strong opinion i have is that if there is anything our sikh nation is doing wrong today is blaming the ENTIRE hindu community for what happened. The more we do this the closer we are getting to becoming just like those who initiated this. Yes, majority of hindu's supported what happened (which is a proven fact) but
84NeVeRFoRGeT 3 years ago
Comment removed
84NeVeRFoRGeT 3 years ago
there were also those Hindus who risked their own lives to save the lives of Sikhs. (in response to regularclassic 's comments)
84NeVeRFoRGeT 3 years ago
Yes, you're right in your observation.I wonder if it is that simple to explain why frenzied masses spontaneously do what they would normally not even think of doing. There can be many many
reasons.Incitement by a few certainly plays a major part. But a matchstick can only set fire to an inflammable material, which may appear inert till it is lit. People must understand that it was a state-sponsered violence to gain political mileage in lieu of lack of political issue to contest elections.
regularclassic 3 years ago
@Radian1991 RSS is a hindu extremist terrorist group who is responsible for spreading the lies that Sikh's are somehow hindu's. RSS are the terrorist who are responsible for the ongoing violence in Punjab and the divisions between Sikh's. They are the people who look up to HITLER and read his books! This Khushwant "Singh" is probably a member of that hateful group and none of them are sane. STOP spreading lies about Sikhism! Sikh's never were and never will be hindu's!!!
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia I have never said that Sikhs were Hindus.
Why don't look up Khuswant Singh before making nonsensical comments about him?
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 Khuswant Singh was a supporter of Indira Gandhi and the Congress party when they attacked Gurudwara's across India and sent security forces to the unprotected homes of "suspected" Sikh Amrtidhari men to kill their families in Punjab. He has also been quoted as saying "I do not believe in God..." which makes him an Atheist, NOT a Sikh. Why don't you look up Khuswant "Singh" carefully before making nonsensical comments? And you are promoting RSS, who lie that Sikh's are Hindu's.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Actually He has claimed to be agnostic.Being agnostic does not mean that he is not a Sikh."Though he has always claimed to be an agnostic, he comes across strongly as a Sikh first and anything else later. His pain at the operation blue star is very obvious and he still carries it. He enjoys counting how many Sikhs are in position of power and feels good when Harbhajan plays a good game. He is upset when his son cut his hair."-Anuradha Goyal
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 This still does not change the fact that he supported Indira Gandhi who did nothing but spread hatred and caused divisions between two peaceful religions by first refusing to address the unjust treatment of Sikh's and secondly attacking them, labeling them as terrorists, when they rose up to to fight for their rights. This man was in support of that gov't, is that not enough to end this discussion of him?
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia The thing is,Khushwant Singh is seen as "expert" on Sikhism.
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 by who? hindu's? the gov't? How do u become an expert on Sikhism when you cannot even understand a minority's need for equal rights and justice? He's an idiot who supported an oppressive gov't, he's no expert. He's only seen as that by ignorant and hateful people.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Are you saying that Sikhs don't have equal rights in India.Then I'm saying that Hindus don't have equal rights in India either.LOL.☺
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 It is a joke to heartless people like you who cannot relate to the struggle of those who've had to witness the murders and rapes of their families without any justice. The criminals are the ones who are in power in political offices right now, and u sit there and laugh, its disgusting and pathetic.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Why don't you go and tell that to the Sikh Prime Minister of India?And stop making nonsensical assumptions of me,you're only making a fool out of your self.☺.
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 he's a puppet. The only thing Sikh about him is his turban and nothing else. The whole worlds knows he's sonia gandhi's puppet and has no relationship whatsoever with the Sikh community. So how about you grow some more brain cells, maybe stop watching so much of tht bollywood bullshyt, and pull ur head outta ur ass and step into reality lol u'll find a lot of surprises waiting for u
PervJirayia 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@PervJirayia You speak for yourself.☺
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 Operation Blue Star was pure evil. Anyone who is remotely sane with a even shred of morals would condemn it. That does not make anyone a Sikh. Also, It is well known that the RSS is attempting to absorb the Sikh religion into the indian hindu majority. And this man called Kushwant "Singh" is actually foolish enough to believe that they supported the Sikh's then he is out of touch with reality.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Allot of people see Indira Gandhi as the "Hindu" tyrant who persecuted innocent Sikhs.Indira Gandhi does not represent Hinduism/Sanatana Dharma.
Radian1991 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Fact,There would be no Sikhism without Hinduism/Sanatana Dharma.
Hinduism is not the correct word for the so called Hindu religion.Sanatana Dharma is the correct word.The RSS does not represent Sanatana Dharma.
The word "Hindu" was used by foreigners to refer to people of various religious practices, viz. the Dharmic religions, in Hindustan (India).
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 Fact: There would be no Christianity or Islam without Judaism. We all know how different these three religions are, no one would argue that they are all the same. That is the case with Sikhism and Hinduism, who probably have even less in common than the three mentioned above. I am aware of the origin of the word "hindu" as well as the correct name for the religion but the word hindu is far more widely known and accepted and I am not in any way using it in a derogatory manner.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Actually,Christianity,Islam,and Judaism(The Abrahamic Religions) are quite the same thing with minor differences.
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 they are not minor differences. All they have in common is their origin. Other than that, they have different beliefs, holidays, traditions, etc. I'm not even surprised that you would say that. I'd like to see what kind of reaction that comment would elicit from an actual christian/muslim/jew. Honestly, this is getting ridiculous.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Well,I stand by what I said,"Actually,Christianity,Islam,and Judaism(The Abrahamic Religions) are quite the same thing with minor differences."Like it or not!
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 I actually don't care, your ignorance is your problem and its something will eventually give lots of regrets. so enjoy, knock urself out, be as stupid as u like in fact go on pretending the whole world is hindu haha goodluck
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia You're funny!☺.
Radian1991 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Hinduism and Sikhism actually have more in common than the Abrahamic Religions.
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 Like what? Land? Language? What else? Everything else in Sikhism is different from hinduism, even down to our physical appearance despite the fact that we come from the same land and time as the hindu population. It is your ignorance and desperation that is driving people like you to want to think that they are the same thing when they are not anything alike. They are both peaceful religions, let that be another shared attribute and let them be as they are and stop the lies, plz.
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia WOW! You're Feisty.Lol.I never said that Sikhism and Hinduism are the same thing,they obviously are not.I just said that they have "more in common than the Abrahamic Religions".
Radian1991 1 year ago
@Radian1991 which is still wrong dumass
PervJirayia 1 year ago
@PervJirayia Again,You speak/type of yourself.☺
Radian1991 1 year ago
My family are not from the Indian subcontinent.
Radian1991 3 years ago
"It was the Congress leaders who instigated mobs in 1984 and got more than 3000 people killed. I must give due credit to RSS and the BJP for showing courage and protecting helpless Sikhs during those difficult days. BJP party leader Atal Bihari Vajpayee himself intervened at a couple of places to help poor taxi drivers." The Bharatiya Janata Party strongly condemned the riots.-Khushwant Singh
Radian1991 3 years ago
The sikh riots are a shame on Hindu people but its not the Hindus who did it ..its the fucking congress mtr fckrs who did it.. this is a bigger picture to divide the hindus and sikhs the whole nehru family is a conspiracy theory to deprive hindus and breed those mohammed mtr fckrs .. but the muslims are not to be blamed either coz the hindus are their biggest enemies
nofear0079 4 years ago
TRAILER OF AMU
_____________________
This film AMU is about the gandhi holocaust of sikhs in 1984. AMU is made by Shonali Bose.
journalist3 4 years ago
no sight of this in the movietheaters or at any official trailer sites...hm
Whiteandorange 4 years ago
the DVD is available for purchase from the official website: amuthefilm . com
hartaarn 3 years ago
its sad but yeah its nto indians hidus dotn count sikhs as different its just the congress rascals who killed the sikhs
indeed shocking
smarteddie21 4 years ago
also watch the documentary The Widow Colony. Which looks at testimonies from actual widows. Visit this website (remove spaces) thewidowcolony . com
bhangrafan 4 years ago
khalistan zindabaad! jarnail singh bhindranwale zindabaad!
999vercetty 4 years ago
Khalistan Khalistan Khalistan. Our destiny.
jayalhouston 4 years ago
finally someone makes a film which portrays this huge covered up genocide in india, its time it got the worlds attention and people recognize the indian government for what it really is.
singhisking01 4 years ago