Eleanor Rigby - Thrice Cover

[Onedreamtolive]

I like this cover and Thrice is the shit. And to the people who are saying it sucks, what the fuck are you expecting? Are you expecting perfect vocals? Sorry Dustin Kensrue isn't over producing and auto-tuning his voice. Recordings like this are about as real as it gets. The guitar tone, the amp distortion, the vocals aren't fixed. A simple mix and master was put on this and that's it. If this isn't good enough for you then don't listen to it. Go listen to Bruno Mars and jerkoff.

[heiboo810]

I am a rainbow mushroom.

[sean13754]

This is embarrasing.

[starwarsking91]

40 people don't know where all the lonely people come from.

[Andrew070792]

The Beatles did such a good job covering this song.

[invaderkitton]

Check this song by The Zoot. That's how to cover this song. This makes me sick into my own scorn.

[paynexkillerAOTF]

But.. It DOES sound like McFly.

[yjgnhdgh]

This is fucking terrible

[ITCHOBOYROB]

This is the ONLY Beatles cover that I actually like.

[WaketoWonder]

Thrice are awesome!

[TheMatthewrox]

I like at the end when he demands to know "all the lonely people, WHERE DO THEY ALL COME FROMMM"

[Hubcool367]

Style is too much different for me, lack of strings and all. It's good but doesn't touch the original, at all. Anyway it's a great song choice, props to the band a tribute to an overlooked song, even by Beatles fans

[jiffinbigles]

Pretty good, didn't think I'd like it but I do

[Masamune1378]

This is a gutsy and amazing cover. I love it. I just wish the audio sounded mixed and mastered better.

[bradley7387]

@Masamune1378 it could just be a bad upload but it is an 8 year old recording if I got my dates right. I agree 100% though!

[PlatonicMadness]

WTF is this shit? This cover butchered the meaning of the song.

[rbennett0210]

@PlatonicMadness by butchered the meaning of the song do you mean that by playing it with more energy and infusing anger rather than despair into the way the lyrics are sung it ruined the meaning?

or were you referring to some other criteria?

[jellie2252]

@PlatonicMadness gtfo

[monkeyslaye]

@PlatonicMadness What the fuck are you talking about? It's the best cover for this song around.. Fucking idiotic pile of shit, you have no taste.

[omfgdianageez]

The cover is good, but the whole slow chorus ruins it.

[adonutstar]

this is the second worst Beatle cover I've heard from them, the worst is I've Seen A Face. Whoever is singing this should know that he isn't Paul McCartney... he should stop hitting the high notes. ALso: screaming a Beatles song that DOESN'T HAVE SCREAMING IN IT TO BEGIN WITH is sacrilegious.

[pedritti]

@adonutstar

A good cover is one that doesn't just imitate a song like copy paste.

This is genious because it picks it up and they adaptate it too their style of music.

And that is what a good cover is.

[138bdfowler]

I can appreciate this cover for what it is but to me the cover of this song Godhead did is the best one.

[bakhn]

This cover is great. It preserves the melancholy of the original song, and they keep their own musical style.

[josepe5622]

This is vastly superior to the original.

[blburrito]

@josepe5622 Woah there, sailor. It's good, but the original's classic.

[jesseenriquez]

I have herd about 40 covers for this epic song... this is top 5.

[12345JJBB]

this is fucking epic

[brandnewbysink]

I guess I'm not up on all the coolest slang nowadays, but could someone please explain to me what the highest rated comment means? Like what is exactly being said?

[captainwesker09]

@brandnewbysink Its wizard.

[littlerin2]

@brandnewbysink It means what has the highest thumbs up ^^

[AxleVest]

one of the very few bands that can cover this song right, it adds a very modern twist to an already awesome song, just wish they had a bigger fan base, they deserve it

[r1chochet]

anyone who can scream a beatles song and do it very well deserves a fucking grammy

[ericmcfadden]

@r1chochet shiina ringo should get one too, then. :D

[Armagedon2030]

Shit pure shit!!!

[brandnewbysink]

Oh and I'm sorry if I sounded elitist in any way, I didn't mean to. I fucking despise elitism, myself.

[swiftverbicide]

About Wayne's cover for this song is way better

[CaptainCocaine]

Sadly, I prefer the version David Cook did on gayass American Idol. I don't remember if that was one of his original covers, or borrowed. It was way heavier than this, though.

[IrishbadBoy81]

@CaptainCocaine Keep on snorting your coke buddy, David Cock is just a wannabe Chris Daughtry and will never be as hard or as big as Thrice. Open your ears and learn what good music sounds like. it is obvious that you think all great musicians come from Idol, if you didnt then you wouldnt watch the show and think that they are great. Maybe you have too much powder coating your miniscule brain.

[CaptainCocaine]

@IrishbadBoy81 Who said anything about David Cook being bigger than Thrice? And what part of my statement "gayass American Idol" makes you think I believe all great musicians come from it? Some great singers come from there. Most of them fuckin suck though, because their audition system is completely corrupted. So, maybe you should read what a person actually types, instead of reading a small part and making up a strawman to suit your needs.

[shreddinmetal4life]

Eeeesh....I like Thrice, but this is pretty bad.

[DarkFire4599]

@shreddinmetal4life GTFO Noob

[shreddinmetal4life]

@DarkFire4599 STFU dumbshit. You either know nothing about music or you're one of those retarded fanboys who support EVERYTHING a band will do, even if it sucks ass.

[DarkFire4599]

@shreddinmetal4life No, I just learned about Thrice I don't support everything. If you don't like it, then don't comment negatively on this video.

[shreddinmetal4life]

@DarkFire4599 Oh, my bad.....I forgot that youtube law says you can't comment on videos if you don't like them.

[DarkFire4599]

@shreddinmetal4life Youtube Law # 507; No haters on Thrice :p

[shreddinmetal4life]

@DarkFire4599 Nah, it wasn't #507......can't remember which one it was, but I wasn't hating on Thrice, just their crappy cover of a great song.

[DarkFire4599]

@shreddinmetal4life Lol. I won't win this. You win. I wave my white flag. My first youtube defea

[brandnewbysink]

@shreddinmetal4life

What you're defining is a fan (short for fanatic, as all of us [including myself] seem to forget).

I'm not going to respond to your retort on this (which would be nonsensical to put any effort into, considering that just I'm stating fact, and not arguing over the internet [because I have much, much more important things to do, as all of us do]).

Have a good night, man. Hold fast hope.

[shreddinmetal4life]

@brandnewbysink Your comment almost contradicts itself. And whereas I respect some of what you said, you remind me of one of those people that say they don't argue on the internet when in fact that's exactly what they're trying to get started.

[igarees]

It's a great cover, the sound really changes, is better than others....

..

[420316777666]

the vocals sound like a boy bands vocals eewwww

[fireproof213]

@420316777666 you sound like a boy bands vocals. NOW GTFO MY THRICE

[420316777666]

@fireproof213 Thrice is an emo boy band =P

[fireproof213]

@420316777666 You're an emo boy band.

[sLuuugZz]

@fireproof213 What's an emo boy band? Emo is short for Emotional. All song have emotional aspects in songs. I Listened to TBS and Brand New and all other bands before the word Emo even existed. Don't be ignorant against music cause you can't win. Btw Emo or w/e the fuck you wanna call it has a bigger fan base then rap does so to say its bad means you have narrow minded view on music.

[fireproof213]

@sLuuugZz Read the person I was replying to. He called Thrice an emo boy band, and I was just fucking with him by saying "You're an emo boy band" Your statement should be directed at him not me, I love what is classified as "emo" music.

[Pirhannaman]

@420316777666 Lolz, thinks Thrice is emo when thrice is post-hardcore punk

He has no idea what emo is

[daniiloveful]

Gosh, I like it, it's cool, and cute :3

[420316777666]

ewww an emo pop cover

[stabbinguup69]

@420316777666 Although i do not like this band, it is a rally good cover, but thats easy because this song is awesome!

[DefWish]

@420316777666 Not emo and not pop.

[allybellas]

@420316777666 LOL, FAIL.

[KillerDrummer88]

.....rape.... I really don't like this version, not interesting...

[bazzle118]

i heard this cover on wsou and had to find it..unfortunately i heard a terrible cover by panic at the disco in the attempt. oh the horror

[Overnumerousness]

When you listen to the original, then this, this one sounds ridiculous.

[asslber]

@Overnumerousness The original is SOOOO much better though.

[Overnumerousness]

@asslber Exactly what i mean :D

[baykerboy]

There is a cool new version of Eleanor Rigby by Voltaire 7.  Check it out on Voltaire 7 website or itunes

[1kevpap]

they also do killer version of beatles she's so heavy.

[Truggyftw]

rock out with your cock out~!

[kissorkill11]

This is the most terrifying peice of shit cover (by a reputable band) that I have ever heard. I would rather never listen to music again than hear this garbage once more.

[FrederickVirus]

@kissorkill11 Haha, you think this cover is bad? You should get a hearing aid kid. You want to hear shit covers of this song, check out Godhead, Pain and David Cooks version of it.

[asslber]

@FrederickVirus Filter's is the worst cover I've ever heard. David Cook's is the best cover I've ever heard.

[FrederickVirus]

@asslber When they stray away from the original soft vocals it sounds horrible and botched. The original will forever be the best.

[TheOrangeTroll]

its a great cover, but it doesnt give you that same lonely feeling you get when you listen to the original...

[justinbob33]

Love this cover. Hate Pain's cover.

[parkourjosh]

I love this cover!!

[xanderwess]

this cover sucks. you suck.

[syferload]

U are not a human being if u dont like this cover

[ktmad]

best cover ever!

[UsedRomanceCH]

To date, 25 people can't stand the Beatles to be covered... Get over it, they won't make any new song XD (I love this cover, love the Beatles and Thrice)

[mistersusan1471]

@UsedRomanceCH nah, I love Pain's cover of this song. I just don't like this cover that much. Don't think there's very good musicianship involved.

[RhythmicAlice]

i love the original. but this one isn't so bad :)

[pljames82]

Best Eleanor Rigby cover available.

[greatestxgift]

@masontrueblood The two lamest comments that appear on every music video: 1. - the unoriginal, unfunny Justin Bieber comment 2. - the comment about the amount of dislikes using an unwitty reference to the song. Congrats...You managed to be such a big tool that you combined both of those cookie cutter comments in one.

[masontrueblood]

@greatestxgift that was the POINT my friend....hahahha

[greatestxgift]

@masontrueblood No, it wasn't. Is that why you deleted your comment?

[MrAleChild]

All the lonley people, where do your comments come from?

[RoflPopcicleStick]

OP is a faggot

[heywhatsup202]

>A very good cover of eleanor rigby

worst cover ever

[blazeadam09]

I thought this was way better than helter skelter.

[itstristanyo]

Their cover of Helter Skelter is great. This cover is...eh. I don't think Eleanor Rigby works as a fast paced hard rock song

[Nothingineternity]

I dislike the falsetto..... but other than that nice cover

[iamlucas2012]

@ksdarkwolfv1 just cause you like metal music doesn't make anything with actually thought into the structure and value into the musicianship of a song lame or "Jonas

Brother" This is what actual musicians do, write good music.

[Cecilson]

fucking love beatle's and i can honest;y say thrice have got this song down so well no1 has ever coverd a beatles song as good as they have, <3 thrice truley such great musicans and so underated. i really hope they go down with the greatist and inspirational bands of all time they really deserve it (yes i know my spelling is bad for all u sad twats that have nothing better to do than correct ppl's spelling get a life)

[EvilCheesypoof]

I think John would have liked this.

[BandOfAwsomeness]

Great cover!!!!!!!

[xxAsteriskxx]

Eleanor Rigby, picks up Thrice in the church where an epic win has been.

[ksdarkwolfv1]

oh god, I liked the metal vetrsions better, this is just shit jonas brother music.

[pichu4850]

@ksdarkwolfv1 what an insult to thrice... to be compared to fucking jonas brothers. lmfao.

[ksdarkwolfv1]

@pichu4850 GO

[melocotoso]

Horrible -_-

[combatcommand]

Would have been a nice cover, except for the gay ass way he says "do"

[hipgigmellowyellow]

disgraceful



[myphoneisretro]

that falsetto bit is pretty good

[LOTDASC]

oh my god i never thought this was possible.

that and how does he hit such a high note?

[Nothingineternity]

@LOTDASC Falsetto

[tagnit123]

Rest among ruins dose a wicked cover of this song, if you like metalcore,

[TheXog]

I like this version better, but its probably because I have liked Thrice a lot longer than the Beatles and I kinda prefer this hard rock and speedy feel.

[ksdarkwolfv1]

@TheXog the version you hear first will always be the better version for you, because that is the way you are automatically used to hearing, but all in all the ORIGINAL original is always better because it is how its supposed to be played and emotionally passed.

[tonyakabadboii]

love it <3

[TheLeggio]

i feel like the vocals are rushed

[TheLeggio]

dont like it . . . cool rock spin but it could be better

[rodriguez256]

Love Thrice and love this version. The sound quality from this video doesnt sound as good though

[jordan10la]

Oh god oh god oh god. I never actually made it to the end of this cover before but I just skipped to it because someone said it was good. What a travesty that was, such a beautiful song reduced to screaming garbage? Why?

[maikeru01]

@jordan10la it sounds like asshole. i can't finish. the problem is that thrice is a band known for loudness, intensity, speed, and stuff like that. they thought they could appeal to everyone by playing a beatles song since everyone loves the beatles, but they removed what was good about it (being all slow and weird), just made it flat and generic by cranking up the gain knob, and also didn't live up to the standard of their own music because its not fast or crazy. This is just a mess.

[mediumhardass]

@maikeru01 they're not known for being fast and intense and all that shit, granted some of their songs are slightly more fast paced, but thrice is better known for their inspirational lyrics more than anything. hell just listen to any song on beggars, its probably their most relaxed album yet in my opinion. this is a decent cover of a good song, and honestly i like it better since this is the first version i heard.

[elitepunkrocker]

@jordan10la because they felt like it

[sadlyim]

I love this thrice,they make elenor rigby intense

[FlyingShiftKick]

@sadlyim LOL no, no they don't

[reverendjackyll]

Wow...another horrible cover of such an amazing song...The only cover that I've heard that could even be called decent is Godhead's...This is worse than the Pain cover...

[FlyingShiftKick]

@reverendjackyll The Pain cover isn't that bad, id say Pains version is better then Thrices, Thrice butchered this song id say, Godhead's is good, but i like the violin in Pains version

[curtbassist]

So I think that cantthe is a complete retard, and tries to act like a bad ass because he has no fucking testicles and wants to fuck some little 3 year old boy and fingers his ass when he thinks about the thought of a little boy. Why don't you just get the fuck off of here before you make an even BIGGER ass of yourself ya fuck nut

[zeroexe003]

going once! going twice! going thrice!!

[dragonknight123455]

pain and the beattles were awesome this is ok

[crazydude123ify]

i love the ending so awsome

[tyger131313]

@cantthe ur a piece of crap

[balughinosi]

you are all pathetic..go to work

[SebazeroX]

no es un mal cover, de hecho se admira que le hayan puesto su toque, pero aun asi la version de los Beatles es mejor e intocable

[cantthe]

speak english

jk be yourself;)

peace love and live forever

[cantthe]

this is complete shit

i hate it when bands who have no right to cover beatles songs do

his voice is sooo bitchy and doesnt work at all

thrice can go fuck themselves

[RoyalzDevil]

@cantthe Your fucking retarded. You lose at the internet.

[MonsterxHunta7]

@RoyalzDevil im with you dude, hes a dumbass. thrice kicksass!

[cantthe]

u and royalzdevil should get a room and fuck to this song.

then u guys can talk about what should be on the internet

[TheSound0fTruth26]

You're a pussy ass troll.

Get off the internet.

Nobody thinks you're cool.

Stupid fuck.

[cantthe]

thrice is a pussy ass troll

they should get off the internet

nobody thinks they're cool

thesoundoftruth26 is a stupid fuck name

and the music you like is more retarded than your dumbshit name

[ryguy9034]

@cantthe i think thrice is cool. You, however, are a douche.

[cantthe]

well ryguy9034 (wow that's a retarded name) even though i dont agree with your opinion i will fight to the death for your right to say it... dont reply to my post anymore... peace love and live forever

[ryguy9034]

@cantthe it's quite obvious that nobody likes you or your comments. It amazes me that you have commented 11 times on one video and continue to comment on it (even after saying "i'm done"). You're narcissistic for thinking you can tell people (3 times) to stop replying to your comments. you can't insult people and then just say, "time out! let's all be friends before i get made fun of again." I agree with you that we all have a right to say what we want. You, however, are a douche.

[cantthe]

ryguy ryguy ryguy i get emails

that is why i reply

ryguy ryguy ryguy i write mean posts

is that why you cry

ryguy ryguy ryguy

thrice is a the worst fucking shit band i have ever heard and this song proves it... i just hope paul never hears this song we cant afford to lose another beatle. but i do hope thrice hears this song so they realize how fucking horrible they are.

[crazydude123ify]

@cantthe wow

[Bobbias]

@cantthe

I couldn't care less who the fuck ryguy is, but you ARE a douche. Well so am I when it comes to online discussions, so coming from another douce, how about you shut the fuck up and stop making youself look like a fucking moron.

[TheWentzMachine]

win.

[cantthe]

royalzdevil royalzdevil can eat a big fat dick

monsterxhunta can eat a fat dick

thrice can eat a fat dick

if i wanna bitch about thrice, im gonna bitch about thrice

[MonsterxHunta7]

@cantthe ok man shut the fuck up. like honestly why are you even listening to this song if you hate thrice? whos the dumbass there? and if you wanna bitch about thrice go bitch somewhere else you fucking faggot

[cantthe]

wow someone's a little homophobic

second i was listening to beatles song when i came across this crap ass shity thing and i was so disgusted that i had to say something

so now why dont u calm down and go jack off to thrice or some other fucking horrible generic band...

OR you could try listening to some good music

[MonsterxHunta7]

@cantthe ok dude just shut the fuck up. your done. and thrice isnt a generic band. this is badass. like JukeB0xHero said you just really need to not bitch

[venusfly9108]

Agreed, these guys can play unlike most of the post hardcore bands and their sophomore album proves it. FOB couldn't stand a chance. they were able to do an awesome solo on that MJ cover, though, Oh wait, that's John Mayer who did the solo for that cover, never mind.

[cantthe]

lets be friends and put all of this shit behind us

peace love and live forever

[MonsterxHunta7]

@cantthe dude ill put all this shit behind me if you just shut the fuck up, and go live ur life, and i live mine, and u stop writing shit about thrice on a fucking video where almost everyone who comments loves thrice.

[JukeB0xHero8996]

@cantthe thrice is amazing the beatles are amazing and this is an amazing song and cover u really need to not bitch just because u don't like the song cuz honestly, me and alot of other people DO NOT give a crap and btw of course they had to get approval before they made the song so don't make up excuses just to hate on the band

[cantthe]

anyone can cover any song, u only need approval if u want to put it on an album or something like that.

and thrice amazing hahahahahaha, they sound like a band that would open for fall out boy

[cantthe]

no one should try to cover a beatles song that's my point

now stop replying to my posts... peace love and live forever

[venusfly9108]

Now I so want to keep replying to your comment and cover Eleanor Rigby on my acoustic all at the same time.

[CJS925]

@cantthe

what do you listen to?

[cantthe]

the beatles, oasis, the stones roses, rolling stones

good shit like that

thanks for asking

but honestly stop replying to my post im done.... peace love and live forever

[MonsterxHunta7]

@cantthe you sucha fucktard. if your gonna talk shit about something dont even say shit you fuking dumbass cuz your just gonna get shit from people.

[subwaycaleb]

It's a decent cover, not as good as the original, but No one comes close to the Beatles. Thrice has a better cover then Godhead. That's for sure.

[aaronbobaron]

@subwaycaleb

Not sure if you've heard it, but Thrice also has a sweet cover of Helter Skelter

[imtellintim]

VOMIT

[AkagenoAdol]

Hey guys let's argue about classic rock instead of enjoying a fuckawesome song

[SarahNaeNae]

Not anywhere near as absolutely amazingly awesome as The Beatles. This is like .000001 compared to The Beatles' 1000000 on the scale of awesomeness.

[jreyes87]

but you gotta admit it was a good cover

[MissFormald3hyd3]

This is alright...it sucks overall,though. gODHEAD's was better.

[fenderbassist205]

bluedragonoz you fuckin stupid electronica douche pain blows,and nothing close to the original

[bluedragonoz]

pain owned it, stop crying

[bluedragonoz]

Pain's cover is probably the best i've found, almost better then the original, ALMOST