淘汰 jay chou-full version

[jaychou1994]

i like jay's version better, there are more emotions in it.

[demonsky1995]

amazing... the number of songs he wrote...

i hav a list of fave songs by different singers and after checking...

realise that most of these songs were written by jay chou... just amazing!

[yuNNb33]

got mp3 version download mar??

[Sp3ll633]

I love Jay Chou but I think easons version sounds better for that particular song

[aLOOhope]

i prefer eason's.. his voice is stronger, and more feeling... jay's voice is a bit weak for me... but nice song...

[walterjai3206]

我係香港人都鍾意JAY多D 真係好佩服佢

才華多到瀉

[winson2413]

呢首歌好明顯係jay特別為Eason而設..

[swampagIsCool]

ughhhhh i hate Eason.......................he completely destroyed this song!! I love you Jay!!

[alleon76]

different style.. i love both.. if everyone sings the same style. the music world will be really bored... we should be glad there are variety of singers of different style to keep us entertained.

[0JustMyPride0]

Jay > Eason

[richard08011992]

我覺得eason降左key好聽d~

[leanwinleng]

i show no interest this song when eason sing this,but i fall for this song when i hear this version^^(just some personal opinion)

[gunnerzjecht]

what lah.. both different style

doesnt matter who u like, they both sing good just different opinions and preference =D

i like them both tho jay is my idol and i admire eason a lot, so u see the difference

[SugaSvveet]

I'm a HUGE fan of Jay Chou *droolz* ... any translate?

[LilxZzZ]

i love jayyyyyyyyyy ^^

[SevenPlusTwo]

Eason's version is better....

[jeffthrone]

@SevenPlusTwo Agree dao Bomb, can't compare Jay version to Eason one =[

[chineseBeBu]

eason all the way.

[jaysky0502]

jay's version better..^^

maybe because he wrote this song...has his soul inside...^^

[kesel5588]

@jaysky0502 Jay's version is too draggy and a little too karaoke. His over the top by slowing it down interpretation of this song is not as good as eason's version. I understand that he's talented but he made the right decision to let someone else sing this one.

[fuktidus]

@kesel5588 this is the demo song that jay give to eason.before eason sang and people said that eason copyed jay style.

[yenyiho]

he owaz pro in singing his song^^ luckily it's eason who sings dis song, still nice to listen.

[mabonono]

At least Jay is not "King of Karoke". Eason and Jay are different style. And because Jay wrote this song for Eason, so there's a Jay's shadow in it.

[CCPJAYLPHAN1994]

JAY CHOU is much more better

[kmk1013]

jay chou's version is better =P his voice just makes it SO much more attractive.

[sevenlittlelucky]

@roackmai: you do realise that jay wrote this song so it's kinda 'his' song

[CCPJAYLPHAN1994]

definitely his song!

[roundbunny]

i love jay's version

i like his voice a lot better than eason's

[ongz]

i like jay's version...a softer way to present his emotions...

[chungkh1218]

周杰伦好D

[jekyin91]

I think Jay is sing better..

[jay22098]

i like jays version better, too bad you cant get album version of this song, too much echo...

[nanfea]

Eason's is much better

[jaysky0502]

jay version is best~the best 1~~

[cheungluluuu]

I am a fan of both jay and eason, but I really like this version than the other.... not offensive to other eason's fans..

[juztsmyle]

thanks oh ~ :"x

I like this song .... both versions ~ xD

[xBabyylollies]

this song is definitely jay's style =)

[sarangai804]

well jay chou was the one hu composed this song for eason so.... HAH

[YouVRay]

have been listening to this song so many times today... one of my favorites as of today... so sad..

[tvbifreak]

haha its true! you would get flamed lol. eason pronouces words clearer, but jay sings it with more emotion and has a voice that suits this song more ^_^

[myacnt8999]

yeah, eason sings this a bit strained.

[tvbifreak]

yep, he holds his voice back and he doesnt sing fully for chorus either, but i like both versions, jays more

[karchunchai]

好好听哦，我很喜欢这首歌，我超喜欢周杰伦版本的，陈奕迅版本的­也是很好听。

[ahmonmon123]

i hope he records this and puts it on his next cd. I want this version!

[lsc946]

只能說我認了 你的不安贏得你信任

[yoonfar]

超好听的，我超喜欢周杰伦版本的，陈奕迅版本也很好听！！！

[BlackGaiden02]

whats it called in english also the pic is it from a tv show or a movie

[RickyLily2007]

both jay and eason have their own singing style!!

i like both of them!!

[clotbeezy]

jay is better thats for sure

this is jus a demo nd its better than eason's polished version

ppl who think eason's version is better cuz they heard it first....先入為主

[crazylover888]

Maybe Eason has a better voice than Jay (depend), but Jay version is more emotional ^^

[sulukong896]

noone can replace my fav singer JAY CHOU FOR LIFE!

[magicpie77]

here here...jay is like a past love...you can never move passed him to others....LOL

[zion0204]

SHUT UP LA JAYCHOU IS THE BEST K STUP

[unoehuim]

damn u! jay is 4ever d bes!

[PZX]

can u all just shut up and enjoy this song??? haih

[asaputra123]

really nice jay ^^, this version is kind of unpolished, if Jay sings with his live version with Eason Chan, it would be more awesome....

[tvbifreak]

look whos talking, ur a blind eason chan fan -.-

[myacnt8999]

every artists have their own strenghts and weaknesses, but the way jay chou's fans defend his weaknesses is just so stupid..

[tvbifreak]

hes famous for him mumbling? is that why people worldwide love him? and eason isnt famous for a skilled singer. hes famous because his company made him. wikipedia is written by people like you. also known as BLIND fans.

[myacnt8999]

LOL..you're too stupid, dude. jay chou himself even MENTIONED that he DOES mumbling in CNN Talk Asia..or you want me to prove some songs that he did mumbling?

i can prove it if you want.

please present your arguments based on evidences. or either you're deaf, i don't know.

[tvbifreak]

voice wise, jay is better. when eason sings you cant hear him unless you turn UP the volume, and its like hes mumbling rather than singing -_- and whos the judge of the competition? YOU? if you were judging of course eason would win you BLIND fan -_-

[tvbifreak]

you probably think eason is a god, but trust me, hes not. singing isnt all about power control. its about the quality of voice and harmonizing

[tvbifreak]

no, its just becuase you heard eason sing it first, and jay is a good singer, why else is he soo popular?

[talonblazed]

you should watch eason, if you havent already, eason is one of the best singers in the world, i must say tho, eason sings this better, in my opinion

[tvbifreak]

its cuz you heard eason sing it first, they are both good, even though i like jay better

[myacnt8999]

no. eason is better at singing. he has better singing voice and power control.

no doubt jay is popular, but he is not famous for his singing skill.

[tvbifreak]

eason has been singing longer than jay, and jay has REAL talent, eason does too, but does he write the music for every single one of his songs? and if hes not famous for SINGING skillz, what is he famous for? people know him for singing, looks, and his talent in writing songs. -_-

[myacnt8999]

he is famous for his composing skill and his songs. even some of jay's fans admit jay is not really talented at singing.

ask other people out there. 80% will say eason's singing better than jay's.

[tvbifreak]

and the 80% would be people from hk. jay has a better voice than eason. more talent

[myacnt8999]

LOL...i bet you don't know at all what singing is all about..jay is more talented at composing than eason, it is true..but singing wise, eason is better. more power control.

[lsc946]

臭周杰倫 馬低 聽都聽不膩 氣阿~~~深陷其中

[tvbifreak]

ni chai si cho

[angelparadise62]

jay chou is the best. why he had to give this song to eason chan..eason sucks! jay is the best 4ever!!

[ccfishoo]

fuck you....you suck!

EAson Chan dosent sucks at all!

[24433447]

Jay Chou the best !

[angelparadise62]

fuck you too! jay is the best!! he is my husband..haha

[tvbifreak]

jay is the best globalwise. eason can just stick with hk

[myacnt8999]

globalwise?haha..can he beat whitney houston or mariah carey in singing?? his singing even can't beat those xing guang bang singers, like peter pan, judy chou, or aska yang..

you're way too overrating him, dude..

eason just stick with HK?? please present your argument with evidences..for your information, he has already been very popular in malaysia, singapore, and taiwan..

[tvbifreak]

jay is the best in tw, eason in hk

[tvbifreak]

agreeed!!

[24433447]

- -

don't agree at all ; ..;

[FaithClan]

It's from the movie secret

[BabyBluePrincezz]

hey where u get the pics from?

[honghaileng]

淘汰 jay chou-full version

[ale03000]

他自己有唱？演唱会里面吗？我喜欢：]。

[Sneakers4life]

Both versions are good in their own way.

[javin7676]

jay sing much better !!!!!!

[FaithClan]

Naice, what's the name of this song?

[blueskiies]

淘汰 tao tai its by Eason Chan 陳奕迅 ^^

[ccfishoo]

no..not really...

淘汰 is by Jay Chow..

陳奕迅 sing this song.

JAY ROCKS!!!

[raisinlaw]

to be specific, the song(淘汰) was composed by Jay Chou for Eason

[imking628]

jay wrote this song ^^ beautiful

[andyye1]

this is nit jay's voice,fake,,,sound edited

sure

[jaysentan]

its jay la idiot

[charonchen]

it's jay

[KhmerD0g]

is that edison chin fucker? that guy who sexually assualted some famouse females

[happyhappy2263]

?? aiyo.... this is jay lar :)

[chinopanda]

LOL HAHAHHA

[jerms369]

LOL....

jay's voice is waaay better than that hk dude lah...

JAY ROCKS!!

[Engine83]

You must be a person who do not know Eason and music. In the future, please make sure you really understand a person well and has years of music exposures before you make any comment on the person.

[jerms369]

dude... chill, i'm referring to Edison Chen. Not Eason Chan. I'm replying to this tread. please read who am i replying before you think i'm referring who you think I'm referring to.

geez... now i'm confused.

And I like Eason alot.

[tvbifreak]

AGREE!! JAY FTW!

[tvbifreak]

TOTALLY AGREE!!!

[reddragon36012]

周杰倫 - 淘汰

[iambee]

i am a fans of both

but i prefer jay's one.......... higher voice in this song seeems better

[lsc946]

我心中的排行由高到低

半島鐵盒->開不了口->夜曲->晴天->不能說的祕密->最長­的電影->淘汰->安靜->藉口->擱淺->黑色毛衣->止戰之­殤->瓦解->我不配->分裂->暗號->給我一首歌的時間->­困獸之鬥->四面楚歌->退後->扯->紅模仿->稻香..et­c

[crazylover888]

Jay's version has more feeling

[lovebbsproc]

It will be as good as the one comparing to Eason's version if this video quality is better.

[kwankhapoh92]

Even i like jay i am his fan i also say......Eason sound is better.....you all must compare wan......heard carefully.....

[kamrch]

Honestly...Jay's voice is not suitable for this song...Eason's better

[eber85]

jay's better!

[pcucu]

I like Jay's version better.

[hotchika]

whats the song call?

[albertsamtam]

this song is called 淘汰

[teddykute255]

Jay is so kool

[babylolIies]

this is so jay. :)

love is style to bits !

[arubiangirl04]

jay....

[fanatics94]

i think eason sings better... and jay sings a different tempo n version.....but ya l find tat BOTH is good

[wlam]

i think eason's voice is more suited for this song than jay's, but jay still did a nice job.

[angeland]

i like jay better... this so is so jay!

[whywhywhywhyu]

i think Jay's voice is stronger n more sad.

Eason's voice is softer n more romantic, more like a pop singer

[tszchung]

jay 跟 eason唱的各有 風格 感覺

畢業這個是demo ,

所以wason發行版本當然會比較好

c.y.Kong也重新編曲了

eason也說過 淘汰 還是充滿jay的影子

jay說過demo 不用唱得好聽 , 就跟草稿一樣吧

所以沒什麼好比較

jay + eason , 真是強呀 , 淘汰實在太好聽!!

[stzs1995]

Eason's version is the best. Jay has not much feelings. Not really touching.

[tvbifreak]

JAY'S has no feeling?? then what do you call "feeling"

[Vaye1986]

i think jay's version is a bit better, well i guess it's because i like jay more

but mostly because when eason sings it, when it gets to the part "even though i am the king of k", it just gets weird, i am surprised that when jay sings it, it actually sounded ok and not weird

[heiimao]

both are awesome singer..

stop comparing..

both version rocks!

[bubblegumlover148]

i like eason's version better

[FineAsianGuy]

Jay chou rocks, but he wrote this song especially for Eason, and I think his voice suits this song alot more than Jay's does :)

[tvbifreak]

jay wrote it, so i think the song's style and key suits jay

[myacnt8999]

haha..another stupid statement here. jay wrote a lot for other singers as well, so you mean it won't be good? the key can be adjusted according to the singers' vocal range, you fool..

you really don't know anything about singing.

[tvbifreak]

and you do? LMAO

[aNXie1y]

I like what SchumiKimira said. Honestly, i find Jay's version better. I ain't saying eason is bad, just jay's style fit me so much. I believe this is just demo version, with the album recording Jay will definately sound better.

[leungfeng08]

good

[kaitamasaki]

holy shit.

all you people do is compare, compare, compare.

they have different styles of singing.

and plus, even if his singing abilities aren't as good as eason's, he can put more feeling into it since he composed the song AND the lyrics. props for that.

agreed with SchumiKimira.

[itcaneat]

Eason is better

[m1xdsprx]

this version is awesome~~

do you think you can send me the mp3?

i cant seem to find it anywhere~

[SAIBT]

eason and jay are different style, for me, i love Jay's style lot more!!~ Love jay forever!!

[sweeetlolli]

jay!!! i love u..

u are the best of all!!!

[lildiana520]

how did this come out?

[wuowuo335]

jay is awesome

lov this song

his songs make me just think bout my ex that i still really really like

idk y though

they r sad and good at the same time

[gheeguan]

Jay sings BETTER! JAY is the BEST!!!

[littlefoo87]

nice song

[allankuah]

the quality damn poor...

like this olso can post?

[dreampur]

hey, dun you know this song is composed by jay but to EASON CHEN?

this is the DEMO only

Jay hvnt recorded a cd version

plz understand it before scolding

[bozobuddy]

No offence to any jay chou fans here, but eason chan does sing this song a lot better =="

[zeink]

agree!!! EASON RockSSS!!

[fineguy8910]

agree w/bozobuddy:)

btw, dreampur, i dun think allankuah is commenting on jay...-,-

[SchumiKimira]

Eason does sing this song better..but Jay's version is better....not the sound quality...but the just unexplainable nostalgic feeling...

[fineguy8910]

agree w/bozobuddy:)

btw, dreampur, i dun think allankuah is commenting on jay...-,-

[congdn]

OMG JAY CHOU ROX!TAO TAI ROX!

[nikichow]

can u send me this song. its so good!

[jaytommie]

CAN YOU SEND ME THIS DEMO?

[winnie15495]

thats great 好好聽呀! 我love jay xd

[yuchingkitten]

oh, I really love this song..

[dabosical]

I like how he sings it, very raw and sincere.

[Jamie23245]

I like how Eason sings it, the way he sings it, its much stronger but credit of course goes to Jay cuz he wrote the song...

[Kengi]

very good point :) agree!!

[sing9111]

both have diff style!!

like both

[8vin5]

Jay sounds good too in this song too. He got his own key of style which is differ from Eason. Both Eason version and jay's version are equally nice. Besides, Jay wrote this song too.

[Dtcp]

man... first sentence already have wrong pitch...

[fifiapollo]

i think easons version is better

maybe because i love eason....

i love jay jay too!!

but his version sounds more dreamy n childish

easons version is more mature..adult like...

[rabuchu]

我比較喜歡Eason的版本

jay的風格始終如一, 沒有太大特別

而Eason在這首歌中聲音有無奈的感覺強烈一點

加上可能是Eason版本的配樂有鼓聲加副歌

聽起來較有氣氛

[sangchow18]

I like Jay's version more.

[contracontroversy]

Eason sang it with more emotion and clearer,jay's vr. was decent. But credit to him,cuz he wrote it.

[holahola84]

Very, very nice song. When I heard this song sung by Eason I tot this song is v nice.. Didn't know it was written by Jay then. Now I know why it's so nice.. Cos its compose by this genius. Nothing to say, how he comes out with so many many nice songs.. And this demo version touches me alot..

[p0ps0ngs]

who can sing me this song???

[tang213]

i will. okay, let me clear my throat

[hyl3389]

me too. i can sing for u. just let me know when. ehemmm... ehemm...

[jerzz]

I will also sing it to you XD LOL...one day...

[chapter1andy]

I loved the version from Eason. The rendition was clearer, the emotions greater, but of course, Jay Chou is a credible song-writer coz if he didn't write this song, Eason would not get to sing it.

Jay is a great song-writer, but singer he is not.

[jerzz]

yeah because this is a demo, not a CD version...may be thats why it is not as good as easons

[HinLoveYing]

its not jay !

[rabiesforyou]

it is jay lol this is his demo he made for eason. cus jay wrote the song for him and sang a demo so eason could hear it and see if he liked it...seeing as eason used it lol im guessing he liked it :P

[judamani]

i wish jay will sing the songs he writes, as he inteprets it in a special way that no other can do

[suzuki128]

i totally agree with you.  i like a lot of the songs he composed for other artists (i.e. this song), and wish that he had saved them for himself.