Dude, you are amazing! i was planning on singing this song next semester and add it to my repertoire but talented people like you make it very hard for people like us to sing such songs after you sang it so well haha! keep it up man!! cheers ;)
Thank you! Lots of good singers out there doing this song but so many of them don't seem to have the acting in their voice that tells the story! Bravo!
This is really great! What a difficult song. This a great execution! Continue on! Audition for stuff, man! You need to be seen by some serious casting directors!
whenever I have bad days I just listen to you sing and it makes me feel better. creep? basically, but whatever, haha. thanks for sharing your talent with us. :-) can't wait for SCA this summer! =D
Hey Caitlyn.. Unfortunately I can't make it this summer... I'm so upset about it... I'm doing a new off-broadway show in NYC... grrrrrrr. I hope you enjoy it though!!
Ay. Dios. Mio.... Not gonna lie... I think that I am at least 30,000 of those views... This is one of my FAVORITE songs. You killed it. You're absolutely fantastic, and you deserve nothing but praise for this. I intend to upload a version of myself singing this soon. I would definitely love to get your opinion.
nice singing. however, cadences are very important in music, and you missed the first cadence in every "and now we're lost in the wilderness"..i hope a musician would know better
well, I spent practically 3 hours trying to find a good cover of this song. you nailed it. props to you. your voice is flawless and your stage presence is great, too! not to mention you're cute (;
Voice is amazing, but I'm not sure about the interpretation. He's singing very joyfully and I'm not sure how the words justify that. I thought the character was supposed to be pretty pissed off.
you have an amazing voice, but one thing i would suggest is working on your character a little more. I know it was mostly about the singin but if you developed your acting in this is would improve so much. But ya overall you did an awesome job!
Wow. What an amazing performance. Well Done ~ Such a tough song to sing, as I found out! Such a shame I can't sing all those high notes. Well done though man, Such a great voice!! :-)
It's sad that not many people know about "Children of Eden" the reason is because the play calls for a whole choir to back up the singers...i saw it last night...the guy who played Cain was H-O-T...and plus he sounded like you so it made him even hotter:]
Great job! This is the best version that I've heard of this song (with the tiny exception of Darius DeHaas, who sang it on the original soundtrack). You have a very clear and well-defined vocal tone. You looked a little nervous at the very beginning, but as you got into the song and started hitting those power notes you that all went away. Congrats!
Great job jmshew!! This is among my favorite songs and I have seen videos of performers who performed this song well. I must say that you outdid them with this performance. GOOD JOB!!
I've heard you sing this live, and I've listened to this video many times and yet it never gets old. You are unbelievably talented and I hope you are on Broadway someday so everyone else can have a chance to hear your incredible voice!
Hands down. Best non-pro version around man. This song is one of my favs and you do it more than justice. I've got most of it down but I could never do that run so effortlessly. Where did you go to school?
Wow I gotta give it to you, you sent shivers up my spine with those high notes. I was just in a production of this play, and I had to sing this song. I loved it but my high notes werent that good, part ly because Im fifteen and those arent supposed to be notes in my range. BUT DUDE YOU CAN SING
So, I've watched this video almost every day for at least the last... month or so and it still amazes me every time. You have an amazing voice and you make that high B sound easy! Have you always had that range or if not, how do you work to that?
you are probably one of the ten top singers in america no joke that freakin sicknasty i wish i could sing like you but unfortunately my voice dropped and even though i train i still cant hit those high a's and b's it really sucks
That was lovely. Very nice voice, very very good tone very good... everything. You should have seen me at 1:40-1:48, holy crap, haha. So clear. Anyways, beautiful :)
my favorite part of your video is how easy u make this song look...this is not a easy song...I am a tenor and finding the right placement is really tough in the middle section!
BRAVO dude...u knocked it outta the park...kinda jealous! LOL
I admire this performance. The riff is incredible, but to me the best part are the octave leaps in the chorus, (eg. And if anyone's watching). These are normally strained by singers, but you do them completely relaxed and open.
But why did you change the melodyyyy of the first motif of the chorus? It drives me a little crazy, but seriously: amazing performance.
so effortless! love 'if you ever have you KN00OOOooooww' hah and the support on the last note; you ended and still had room to breathe out without gasping for air! nice!
What? I came here to reply back but I can't find my original comment! Don't even remember what it said. Anyway, you rock dude! Shelly has good taste! And she just gave you a major shout out in her latest video! Everyone will be jealous!
Isn't it enough that nature gave you good looks? Is it fair to give you that voice also? Is it fair on other men? Is it fair on the women who watch? Who can answer these questions?
1:40 - 1:48 is my JAM. it's why i fell in love with this show in the first place and i sing that EVERY DAY. we're so singing this together in harmony whilst dancing on the streets of new york in like, 2 months... YOU KICKED THIS SONG'S... ya know.
That riff. So smooth, so effortless. Just amazing.
airinkincaid 5 days ago
Dude, you are amazing! i was planning on singing this song next semester and add it to my repertoire but talented people like you make it very hard for people like us to sing such songs after you sang it so well haha! keep it up man!! cheers ;)
davidyanesito 1 month ago
wow! amazing job!
Stevenxnevets 3 months ago
Thank you! Lots of good singers out there doing this song but so many of them don't seem to have the acting in their voice that tells the story! Bravo!
ladybuglover95 3 months ago
Wow. This is the first time I've ever been bored by this song. Could you have less passion?
mtschrei 4 months ago
you are very, very talented. =) what are you're next big plans?
laurendpennington 7 months ago
You're Amazing!
Maxkustrap 8 months ago
This is really great! What a difficult song. This a great execution! Continue on! Audition for stuff, man! You need to be seen by some serious casting directors!
rosiewebber94 8 months ago
whenever I have bad days I just listen to you sing and it makes me feel better. creep? basically, but whatever, haha. thanks for sharing your talent with us. :-) can't wait for SCA this summer! =D
singinstar1213 8 months ago
@singinstar1213
Hey Caitlyn.. Unfortunately I can't make it this summer... I'm so upset about it... I'm doing a new off-broadway show in NYC... grrrrrrr. I hope you enjoy it though!!
jmshew 8 months ago
SHOOT!!! The control you have is great!!!
evilemperordude12 9 months ago
I sure hope that you are studying Musical Theatre, you are fantastic! This is a career path for you! :)
EmmaButterflyBeauty 9 months ago
Ay. Dios. Mio.... Not gonna lie... I think that I am at least 30,000 of those views... This is one of my FAVORITE songs. You killed it. You're absolutely fantastic, and you deserve nothing but praise for this. I intend to upload a version of myself singing this soon. I would definitely love to get your opinion.
buhzatez 10 months ago
You're absolutely incredible. Totally an inspiration
dramajames8 10 months ago
Definately the best version of this on youtube.
EidahageFeroe 11 months ago
omg truly amazing!!
GeaAy 11 months ago
The note at 1:42=fabulous.
410627 11 months ago
nice singing. however, cadences are very important in music, and you missed the first cadence in every "and now we're lost in the wilderness"..i hope a musician would know better
daniel72389 1 year ago
well, I spent practically 3 hours trying to find a good cover of this song. you nailed it. props to you. your voice is flawless and your stage presence is great, too! not to mention you're cute (;
singdancesmile517 1 year ago
Voice is amazing, but I'm not sure about the interpretation. He's singing very joyfully and I'm not sure how the words justify that. I thought the character was supposed to be pretty pissed off.
bugleboy777 1 year ago 2
6 people are still lost in the wilderness.
rebel3489 1 year ago
wow.
you are such an amazing singer *.* <3
it sounds sooooooo damn good.!!!
You did a really brilliant job !
// xx Maggie
MaGGiiYii 1 year ago
Every time I look at this, I think it's Pacey (from Dawson's Creek) singing. Singing amazingly well for that matter - but Pacey nevertheless.
Anybody else feeling like this?
FabianWilliam 1 year ago
the 6 people who don't like this are on crack.
singinstar1213 1 year ago
you have an amazing voice, but one thing i would suggest is working on your character a little more. I know it was mostly about the singin but if you developed your acting in this is would improve so much. But ya overall you did an awesome job!
Nf9456 1 year ago
effortless highs... great job.
theetrfreek413 1 year ago
Wow. What an amazing performance. Well Done ~ Such a tough song to sing, as I found out! Such a shame I can't sing all those high notes. Well done though man, Such a great voice!! :-)
mikeride101 1 year ago
FLAWLESS.
i want you.
to sing for me every night.
dalys09 1 year ago
Love it!
rorolilred 1 year ago
ummm why are you so good?
haha i was told to do this and i <3 and miss you!!
afiorini3100 1 year ago
LOVE
rycliffmc 1 year ago
This is one of my favorite songs in musical theatre and you definitely did it justice! Riff at 1:45 gave me chills.
ohblakegee 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
anybody know the notes for the high riff? and awesome job dude.
sk8ngr0ckr 1 year ago
anybody know the notes for the high riff? and awesome job dude.
sk8ngr0ckr 1 year ago
You're beautiful. Your voice is beauutiful. Ahhh so wonderful.
Kabelski101 1 year ago
It's sad that not many people know about "Children of Eden" the reason is because the play calls for a whole choir to back up the singers...i saw it last night...the guy who played Cain was H-O-T...and plus he sounded like you so it made him even hotter:]
yaimrandome 1 year ago
@yaimrandome That wasn't in Leawood, KS, by chance, was it?
Kellie3315 1 year ago
Ugh...I hate you. You make it look effortless. SOME of us have to squeeze our butcheeks really tight to get those notes...asshole...
But in all seriousness you were jaw dropping
Woullard2fresh 1 year ago 4
Great job! This is the best version that I've heard of this song (with the tiny exception of Darius DeHaas, who sang it on the original soundtrack). You have a very clear and well-defined vocal tone. You looked a little nervous at the very beginning, but as you got into the song and started hitting those power notes you that all went away. Congrats!
dreamtheaterfan12 1 year ago
Great job jmshew!! This is among my favorite songs and I have seen videos of performers who performed this song well. I must say that you outdid them with this performance. GOOD JOB!!
clarkybun80 1 year ago
Dear jmshew, Will you marry me? Okay, may that's a little too forward--But on a more serious note, wonderful job.
sing4food 1 year ago 12
@sing4food Sure. You tell me when a good time is. Let's make it happen :-P
jmshew 1 year ago 5
@jmshew (3 months later..) Hahaha, alright. :P
sing4food 1 year ago
@jmshew Hey, If sing4food thinks it's too forward, how about I volunteer? Or you're fine with a polygamy, right?
Great job, and tons of kudos. Way to make an amazing song that much more amazing. :D
Princ3ssPurity 10 months ago
unreal. so amazing
Theory993 1 year ago
I've heard you sing this live, and I've listened to this video many times and yet it never gets old. You are unbelievably talented and I hope you are on Broadway someday so everyone else can have a chance to hear your incredible voice!
tarebear12 1 year ago 2
Dude....you NAILED this! Congrats, It's DREAMY! :)
carnivalfreakshow 1 year ago
OMG... absolutely amazing! Next stop.. Broadway :-)
Hecjuan27 1 year ago
Hands down. Best non-pro version around man. This song is one of my favs and you do it more than justice. I've got most of it down but I could never do that run so effortlessly. Where did you go to school?
keakdasneak63 1 year ago 2
Hey Johnathan!
That was amazing! I love your voice :D You've really got a gift! Flawless performance!
I'm a composer and write a lot of music theatre song, do you take sheet music from composers? Would love you to sing something of mine!!!!!
I wish you all the best for the future. It's looks like your really going places :D
jplu7139 2 years ago
Awesome!
KanaFish 2 years ago
Amazing
wickedude 2 years ago
Phenomenal. Nothing else needs to be said. Perfect tone, effortless. Amazing.
PHollens3837 2 years ago 5
Thanks!!
jmshew 2 years ago
wow! you are just so talented! i love hearing you sing, your intonation is perfect, and I find myself being very impressed! are you on myspace?
Starlight08080 2 years ago
Wonderful voice, and version of this song Johnathan
biz663 2 years ago 3
Wow I gotta give it to you, you sent shivers up my spine with those high notes. I was just in a production of this play, and I had to sing this song. I loved it but my high notes werent that good, part ly because Im fifteen and those arent supposed to be notes in my range. BUT DUDE YOU CAN SING
checkcheck2012 2 years ago 4
Thanks man.. Thanks for the posivite comments :-)
jmshew 2 years ago
wow..i have seen the song done alot but you did it phenomenal...the high riff sounded so effortless for you.
HEYJoeSergio 2 years ago 3
Okay, to all the people critiquing his acting...
He's singing this at a JAZZ CLUB, not in an actual production of the show or some kind of musical theatre competition. He's just singing the song.
wickedphant0m 2 years ago 3
nice voice, but try acting. you do alost look bored. but my biggest problem is you sound...nice. in this song, you should be ANGRY!
bambam111992 2 years ago
He's singing this for a cabaret set at a jazz club, not for an acting competition.
wickedphant0m 2 years ago
WOW!!!!!! you hit those notes with great ease! you have an amazing voice!!
vivalavieboheme14 2 years ago
Curt Hansen is definitely better, but this isn't bad.
crashandtumble8 2 years ago
it's kinda slow....no it's really slow. It's good, just slow.
Spencerleexo 2 years ago
slow??
biz663 2 years ago
Ya, a little slow. He sings it well, I just think the tempo drags.
Spencerleexo 2 years ago
Great singer not a great actor, but i love his voice.
fishSG1 2 years ago
So, I've watched this video almost every day for at least the last... month or so and it still amazes me every time. You have an amazing voice and you make that high B sound easy! Have you always had that range or if not, how do you work to that?
cymbalsmasher93 2 years ago
Great voice.....i see a lot of nothing on your face in many of these performances though.
italianadam04 2 years ago
I'm pretty sure you should do a duet with Natalie Weiss. . .
choirjunkie01 2 years ago 23
Wow I love your version a lot!! Such a smooth voice.
superduperstar44 2 years ago
so you're pretty much a badass.
just throwin that out there.
you can take it or leave it.
LayanGAR 2 years ago 2
OMG. i wish i had his range.
jagc9110 2 years ago
you are probably one of the ten top singers in america no joke that freakin sicknasty i wish i could sing like you but unfortunately my voice dropped and even though i train i still cant hit those high a's and b's it really sucks
sk8terman246 2 years ago
HEY JOHN sounds great man.!
vocallynice18 2 years ago
Amazing!!
VocalCoachBway 2 years ago
That was lovely. Very nice voice, very very good tone very good... everything. You should have seen me at 1:40-1:48, holy crap, haha. So clear. Anyways, beautiful :)
xterpsichorex 2 years ago 2
Thanks for the comment..
Jonathan Shew
jmshew 2 years ago
Hope your callback for JCSS went well! Maybe we'll be on tour together! I sang this ending for my callback... sound awesome man!
TheSimplyFabulous 2 years ago
amazing!! great voice!!!!
mikez123454321 2 years ago
Comment removed
holyknightthatpwns 2 years ago
this gave me chills. so good.
JoRegan3 2 years ago
what the hell
are you even aware that this song is insane?
that you are insane?!
you're fucking amazing. holy shit
somethingoldschool 2 years ago 3
Why can't I find a man like this? Talented AND Beautiful!
eulisk 2 years ago
my favorite part of your video is how easy u make this song look...this is not a easy song...I am a tenor and finding the right placement is really tough in the middle section!
BRAVO dude...u knocked it outta the park...kinda jealous! LOL
anmjbfilm 2 years ago
michael....why are laughing out loud? hmmm? love you....mean it....
Janelle and Eesh
eesh16 2 years ago
The insane part is...he makes the song sound like it's not high at all.
I love everything about your voice...tone, placement, production, vibrato, vowels, resonance...it's just spectacular.
wickedphant0m 2 years ago
Thank you very much!
jmshew 2 years ago
Nice.
nymgbp 2 years ago
Fierce much. Ur amazing. AMAZING. lol nice job.
Adanci24 2 years ago 4
awesome
alextaurus1991 2 years ago 4
Thank you very much!
jmshew 2 years ago
amazing.
shellybeanxox3 2 years ago 2
I eargasm every time. So about once daily. Thank you, kind sir.
hplotrf 2 years ago
Unbelievably beautiful. You have a wonderful voice. Bravo!
dorthy0220 2 years ago
Holy cow! There is no tension at all in your upper range, wonderful support.
crashandtumble8 2 years ago
When you hit the high notes, I went to rate you 5 stars...but I'd already done that.
Great great great job!
FedoraExplorer 2 years ago
thank you very much!
jmshew 2 years ago
i wish you had been performing the night i went there
i love this song, it would have been the highlight of my entire trip
by the way amazing job
invisiblechild4 2 years ago
right...i've now watched all you vids....simply amazing!
brettell11 2 years ago
thanks a lot!
jmshew 2 years ago
Congratulations on being able to sing one of the hardest and most vocally demanding tenor songs in the musical theatre repertoire!
jayms74 2 years ago
that was unacceptably intense.
quit being so damn good. >=D
LuckiOne777 2 years ago
This is Amazzing, you're great and will go far.
joshymcfalloutboy 3 years ago
<33
that's all i have to say.
he is amazing.
shakeurbootay 3 years ago
you're flawless. great job!!
MagandaKanta 3 years ago
From 1:43 to 1:49 you became a god to all those singers who have ever wanted to hit notes!!! utterly fantastic!! favorited!!!
I loved your own little touches scattered throughout as well!!
Sylvairians 3 years ago
I admire this performance. The riff is incredible, but to me the best part are the octave leaps in the chorus, (eg. And if anyone's watching). These are normally strained by singers, but you do them completely relaxed and open.
But why did you change the melodyyyy of the first motif of the chorus? It drives me a little crazy, but seriously: amazing performance.
epricq 2 years ago
good job my high school is doing this musical im aysha if you know that characterr this is by far my favorite song great job
sierra14ising 3 years ago
You sound really good. I think I might use this song as an audition piece for a choral program I'm doing this summer.
matzahboy 3 years ago
OUTSTANDING!!!! BLEW ME AWAY!!!
eiknarf2012 3 years ago
Literally the best version i have ever heard of this song
Utterly Amazing!!
keithcubfan 3 years ago
OH MY GOSH! You are so AMAZING! You have such a beautiful gift!
adrianachanel 3 years ago
its my dream to sing at birdland!
shermanrory 3 years ago
this is better than the orig. recording...
lightscameraaction24 3 years ago
my lord, what a set of pipes you have!
JennaLeighhh 3 years ago
WOW!!!! great voice!!! i wish i could sing like u
crazysnare 3 years ago 2
HA! You're too nice.. You can! Just keep practicing. Thats all it takes!
jmshew 3 years ago
your voice is so lovely!! You are like a pro and it sounds amazing!!!
riskykitty1 3 years ago
Thank you so much! Thanks for checking out my videos :-)
jmshew 3 years ago
You're very good. You should consider making a career out of it
DirectlyFresh 3 years ago
Beautiful when you go to the high notes. Some of the choices that you did with timing was interesting but still way good.
Awesome!
nxzjfqg 3 years ago
You rock! Pretty cool!
KateMcGowan5 3 years ago
Wow! Awesome job! Your voice is amazing. Just brilliant
koooltrumpet 3 years ago
beautiful. oh, and you're voice in great too. : )
jmack129 3 years ago
Incredible! You're really REALLY good!
jordie150 3 years ago
Thank you so much!
jmshew 3 years ago
ace!
wrightstateboy45 3 years ago
so effortless! love 'if you ever have you KN00OOOooooww' hah and the support on the last note; you ended and still had room to breathe out without gasping for air! nice!
crazychel 3 years ago
go on broadway now. please. just like..ummm yeah. you're incredible.
themusicalgeek22 3 years ago
This is amazing....
renegade15 3 years ago 4
Wow you are unbelievable :O
Arriivaa 3 years ago 3
You're too nice. thanks
jmshew 3 years ago
my dear lord, you have a beautifull voice, thanks for posting this
vinceinelkins 3 years ago 3
Thank you so much!
jmshew 3 years ago
What? I came here to reply back but I can't find my original comment! Don't even remember what it said. Anyway, you rock dude! Shelly has good taste! And she just gave you a major shout out in her latest video! Everyone will be jealous!
MeLikey1980 3 years ago 2
I know! That was so nice of her!!
jmshew 3 years ago
joshua jackson?
jasn01 3 years ago 2
Ha! Thanks, I've gotten that before.. too many times
jmshew 3 years ago
Isn't it enough that nature gave you good looks? Is it fair to give you that voice also? Is it fair on other men? Is it fair on the women who watch? Who can answer these questions?
mynameisava 3 years ago 4
Wow- thanks Shelly for adding this to your favorites!
RLFosse 3 years ago 3
ps-
1:40 - 1:48 is my JAM. it's why i fell in love with this show in the first place and i sing that EVERY DAY. we're so singing this together in harmony whilst dancing on the streets of new york in like, 2 months... YOU KICKED THIS SONG'S... ya know.
you're amazing. that's it.
sbort 3 years ago 2
hey shew...
*hug*
you're incredible.
sbort 3 years ago
sugoi desu yo!
slut4688 3 years ago
wow... good job... nice
karbearkarinana 3 years ago 3
You never cease to amaze me. Wonderful.
LHeim89 3 years ago 5
hey you're cute and i like your voice, call me sometime Jonathan
dma052 3 years ago
Fantastic as always, Mr. Shew. :)
CelebrateAdoption 3 years ago