Vocal Battle: Carrie Underwood vs. Taylor Swift (Part 2)

[doritos1010]

Taylor is manufactured and Carrie is the talent.

[kathyli1310]

Technically, Carrie is a better singer. Not gonna deny it. She has a powerhouse voice. But who you like better all depends of taste. I like Taylor's version of the National Anthem better, but that doesn't mean everyone else has to. I prefer Taylor's gentle voice to Carrie's big and boisterous one. and

[ilovespellingbees]

Carrie Underwood sings the National Anthem Better than Taylor Swift

Carrie Underwood has a stronger voice and a better voice

Carrie Underwood deserved to win American Idol

[kellytaylorjenegarth]

CARRIE CARRE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE

[peaceloveerin100]

Why did Taylor win Female Vocalist of the Year? Because she's a pretty girl with a terrible live singing voice!! The real FVOTY should've been Martina McBride or Carrie!

[row759]

to me, this isn't a very fair contest. Putting this contest was a completely stupid idea. Carrie wins this contest without question?

[mellynumerounoo]

@row759 I only made it because Taylor was actually given the Female Vocalist of the Year award over Carrie back in 2009.

[row759]

@mellynumerounoo yeah, I know, Carrie should have won that award easily, but that is normal at the CMAs.

[wk1kat1]

There is absolutely NO comparison between these two artists, at a young age or in between, or now. Carrie is a powerhouse, with a vocal range that can't be surpassed by anyone in the industry today!! I have never understood how anyone could ever compare Taylor to Carrie. Taylor can play a guitar, and write songs about life's experiences. I have never heard a song of hers that is not about a relationship!! Carrie can sing anything and do it well. The star-spangled Banner is a disgrace! Carrie!!!!

[pricelessangie]

@wk1kat1 i know! taylor's songs all sound the same...soo annoying. she should just hide under a rock with miley and justin bieber

[wk1kat1]

@pricelessangie I agree. I will never understand how she can win the awards she does. She is a hard worker but cannot sing at all.

[Xzamilloh]

I love how Taylor Swift moves across the stage with all of that stupid hair twirling and jumping around......as if that's gonna mask how mediocre her voice is. And the Star Spangled Banner? The creator of this video could have saved themselves a lot of editing and just used that clip as proof that Carrie is better. And honestly? Taylor Swift just has an awful voice and I'm glad more people see through the hype, because I thought something was wrong with me... I wasn't hearing what others were.

[MsViictoriia13]

taylor!!!



[TaylorSwiftFan399]

We all know carrie wins

[row759]

There is no contest between Carrie and Taylor. Carrie wins contest without working up a sweat.

[sassylady1225]

Carrie outsings Taylor Swift and all others. If Taylor was performing in front of Simon Cowell he would say something obnoxious to her and send her packing! NO COMPARISON! Carrie rocks!

[Silver54ful]

It's perfectly clear why Taylor recieved a record deal. She's a beautiful girl. (Can't deny that) Therefore she's marketable product. If she wasn't, people would have seen the light along time ago. Since she is, people don't give a rip that she can't sing. They've turned the blind eye & ear all beacuse she's pretty. Carrie wasn't the hot bombshell she is now when she started on AI. But people loved her anyway for her powerhouse voice. We continue to love her because her voice rocks! Enough said

[tephinhazinha]

man... it's weird the way that Taylor moves around the stage, it's like she's having a heart attack or somethin'.... I think she does this to disguise she cannot sing at all !!!!!

and there is something else, Taylor can't hit a high note, instead that she screams... and her screams are all the same!!!!!

I am judgin' Taylor as a performer not as a person ok.... let's make this clear.... (even though I am so not her fan, but ok...) so don't take it personally okay!!!! =D

Just Sayin' =D

[magarooski]

Is this a joke? Taylor is barely qualified to hold a candle beside Carrie vocally...sorry but its true...I can barely keep track of the amount of times I have heard Taylor singing off key and don't recall a single time I have heard Carrie even a little bit off vocally...

[4leafclover546]

Carrie Underwood can nail a song just by simply standing or siting with a chair and sing while Taylor Swift still needs those head bangs and running around stunts just to get the audience's attention. Even though she is doing those stunts, still she couldn't beat Carrie.

[0804lisbeth]

I dislike the fakeness of Taylor, Carrie is down to earth:) I love Carrie in concert she sounds like her albums amazing!!!

[0804lisbeth]

I dislike the fakeness of Taylor, Carrie is down to earth:)

[paulbritney]

Carrie Underwood s2 COME TO BRAZIL

[besseslo]

CARRIE UNDERWOOD -- BRAZIL

[xxxchris1891]

Taylor knows nothing but to bang her head again and again like getting rid off a cockroach in her head.. LOL

[sandraerskine]

i think that they were very good but honstley i think that taylor was better because she has really has good singing but carrie underwood is very pretty! :)

[xxxchris1891]

@sandraerskine your opinion can be, I guess, more acceptable if you reverse your statement.. Taylor - more prettier by an inch.. Carrie - more talented by a thousand miles..

[CarrieUnderwood2710]

@xxxchris1891 not really taylor has to put on more amke up and carrie goes by more of a natural look

[xxxchris1891]

@CarrieUnderwood2710 Yeah.. I only said that just to "give way" with the Taylor opinion... LOL

[andrenalalle]

@xxxchris1891 : heehee for me carrie is more beautiful too. taylor is just taller than her

[wormqueen3]

.... why would u even compare the two??? Carrie is OBVIOUSLY better!

[xxxTeamUnderwoodxxx]

Carrie is amazing and Taylor is...I'll just stop there because Carrie and Taylor have different vocal ranges so stop comparing them!!!

[row759]

this isn't even a contest, Carrie easily out vocals Taylor without even trying.

[meggy1095]

CARRIE CARRIE CARRIE!!! shes amazing!

[carrieu4eva]

I don't think I can laugh much harder than this.

The video goes from Taylor's 13-second long, off-key note with no vibrato to one of the most amazing versions of "O Holy Night" I've ever heard.

If you didn't catch my vote in there, it's Carrie by a million miles.

[taytayswiftify]

vocals-carrie

looks- carrie

songs-taylor

[stizzltastic]

Taylor is lipsinging in some of these.....She sucks. Carrie has never does that. There is no comparison. And yes Taylor may write all of her songs but look what they're about?? Proms and mess. And I don't think she writes every last word on them either. Thats just a lie. They're tweeked. I don't like her. Carrie is much better. She has better stage presence too.

[AbigailTaylor2010]

Not only does Carrie's vocals totally put Taylor to shame but her songs have a variety, they are not all about love, and I think that's all Taylor has.

[TSwizle13]

OKay, I Absolutly LOVE Both Taylor & Carrie, But Carrie Wins This One, Taylor Has A Nice, Fine Voice, But Carrie's Has More Range To It Than Taylor's Does

[megaroxylover]

yap, have to agree with xtinafan06.

vocals- carrie

looks- carrie

personality- both

songs they write- taylor (although i have to comment, most of her songs, if not all, are about love or breakup)

[LaughLiveSmileSing11]

You know what? The truth is that we don't even have to make a whole video of a vocal battle between Carrie and Taylor... we all know that the obvious winner would be Carrie, no doubt. But this is one great video!

[musicChick023]

Carrie Singing "I know you won't" Totally gives me chills!!!

This Goes to show that you can't have a fight between a Cat and a Lion. If I were Taylor, I would be afraid if i win top female vocalist against Carrie :)) I mean, Carrie slaughtered the hell out of Taylor, and she isn't even freakin' trying!

[besseslo]

Carrie bem melhor

[rottincherrie]

Carrie is better than Taylor vocally, that I readily and easily agree to. I love Carrie and if I could ever have a hundredth of her talent, I'd be happy. :)

The thing that bothers me about this is that people say that Carrie is a brilliant (if not the best) female vocalist (true), but then talk about how horrible/untalented/etc. Taylor is (false). Saying Taylor is horrible because she's not as good as Carrie is like saying we all suck at drawing because most of us will ever amount to Van Gogh.

[skeetv123]

I fucking hate Taylor Swift with disgust. She has no right to be in the same sentence as Carrie.

[taylorswift091196]

@skeetv123 I fucking hate Taylor Swift is such a nice person anyone who hates her is jst showing their own inferiority complex and inability to appreciate beauty.

[pagiewoern445]

Singing (Carrie rocks) (Taylor SUCKS monkey nuts)

Stile (Carrie sings all diffrint things like bad ppl good ppl here mom and all that) ( taylor all boys that hurt here that sucks monkey nuts)

Cuteness (carrie HOT!!!!!!!!!)(Taylor just got a in a poop fight)

[pagiewoern445]

Ok peeps for your info Taylor swift SUCKS Ok Carrie Underwoo is well she the best female cuntry singer ever. Taylor can't sing Carrie can sing like a angel and if taylor and Carrie had a live sing of Carrie wood win by a land slide.

[MrDexx03]

Seems like tay's fans have nothing to say cause their idol already crushed by our idol hahaha let's just face the reality that carrie is the true country superstar and taylor cant sing. PERIOD

[taylorswift091196]

@MrDexx03 just because the videos are puposely chosen to sound bad doesn;t mean that Taylor actually sounds bad. How then, did she win so many awards? Like 4 Grammys. If she's as bad as you like to think she wouldn't have gone multi-platinum and earned 18 million last year. I love them both, but Taylor is just as good as Carrie in terms of looks and personality and only a little worse in vocals. And just because someone can't sing as nice as your idol doesn't mean that you should hate and curse.

[xxxchris1891]

SSSSSSHHHHHHHHHHHUUUUUUUUUTTTT­TTT UUUUUUUUUUPPPPPPPP TAYLOR!!!! Like a rat, screaming for her dear life, being chased by the lion! Hahahaha!!! Panting... Panting... Screaming... Screaming...

[taylorswift091196]

@xxxchris1891 it's called a performance asshole. If you ever heard of one, that is:(

[marshall9amplified]

pshh NO DOUBT Carrie Underwood CRUSHES little Taylor Swift. Feel so bad for Taylor if she thinks she is better than Carrie. Got news for you Swift, Underwood is MUCH HOTTER and MUCH MORE TALENTED!!

[taylorswift091196]

@marshall9amplified she never said she was it's actually you haters who start comparing and then imagine that she believed she was better. FYI, she's not the best, but she's not the worst either and in fact she's really quite good. Taylor's just as hot as Carrie and she is so sweet and nice you won't believe.

[randomosiity]

i love how carrie could EASILY sing any of taylor's songs. however, if taylor were to even attempt to sing carrie's songs, she would miserably fail.

[msUniverse4lyf]

So stupid to compare two incomparable persons!!!

everybody knows that Taylor is not worth comparing to CARRIE coz CARRIE will always be and always be GAZILLION times better!!!!

just AGREE!!!

it is the hurting reality for you Taylor fans...

[CarrieIsGirlicious]

Carrie = PWNS Taylor Swift. Im glad you made a video to prove it.

[NappturalDancer2K10]

Carrie Underwood!!!!

Taylor who?!

Carrie puts so much passion into her performances and her vocals, her glorious vocals make me cry!

[jessica10234fromcp]

Carrie Underwood FTW!

[annxiong]

LMAOOOO. I absolutely friggin LOVE how Carrie sings better than Taylor even when sitting down. Oh goodness. LMAO. Taylor pwned while singing & standing and pwned at age 19 by a 14 year old Carrie.

[lizzyvance]

Carrie is Incredible live. She does not need props to wow people because her vocals do that. I like how you showed her playing guitar and piano. At least she sings about variety of stuff. Carrie can also sing any genre. I’m not saying you have to be powerhouse to be great singer. Alison Krauss has angelic voice and is amazing performer. If Taylor did not have props she would be nothing. To me first and foremost if you are going to be labeled singer you should have to know how to sing.

[pinkraindrops13]

Carrie of course!! I mean anyone who thinks Taylor sings better than Carrie is just..delusional. You can't compare them..Taylor needs her guitar and props to get someone excited to see her perform, Carrie does not. Also, minus a couple of songs Taylor sings about boys. Just boys. Carrie is much more of a well rounded artist, she sings about everything which is much more appealing.

[Claire2004S]

What was that note that Carrie sustained at the end of O Holy Night? Amazing!

[Michillie1995]

Taylor Swift=Level 20

Carrie Underwood=Level 200

There really is no fight, it's like a on hit knock out. people should really stop saying that taylor swift is a better vocalist than carrie because they are lying through their teeth.

[musicChick023]

In all fairness, Taylor sounded quite good on her song "change" at the ACMs. but apparently, she's still no match for Carrie. every song Carrie sings it's like "BINGO! you hit the jackpot" kind of thing... :)

[terpguy84]

There is no battle to be fought.... Carrie crushes Taylor as well as the majority of female singers in country music.

[ivantot12]

uhhh....Carrie. lol

[juelzssexymama]

LMAO, this whole video is hilarious, especially the clips of "The Star Spangled Banner"...it's like hearing the voice of a mouse followed by that of a lion. Carrie's voice could swallow Taylor's in one tiny little gulp. There's no comparison here, but I understand the need to make a video like this when there's scores of little teenyboppers swearing up and down that Taylor is better than Carrie lol.

[mellynumerounoo]

@juelzssexymama rofl, that was an amazing analogy. thank you for bringing a smile to my face. :D

[shaunmikex]

@juelzssexymama Perfect!

[brittneyviolet]

@juelzssexymama & I do believe those teenyboppers that swear by Taylor Swift.. were "swift"-ly shut up haha :)

[carriefan020492]

CARRIE!!!!!!! ALL THE WAY.

[xtinafan06]

lol, this is like a vocal "battle" of christina & britney! i love it, especially how u show that carrie can also play guitar and piano at the end! duh, carrie trumps taylor vocally though, "with one vocal cord tied behind her back" as someone else so brilliantly stated!

so:

vocals- OBVIOUSLY Carrie. Taylor can't even hit a single high note.

looks- Carrie is MUCH prettier

personality- Carrie wins again, maybe she's not super bubbly like Taylor, but at least she doesn't seem fake!

[mellynumerounoo]

@xtinafan06 lol thanks for noticing about the instruments. :p

[lizzyvance]

@xtinafan06

I agree with everything you said. It's amusing when people compare singers like Christina and Carrie to Britney and Taylor. I don’t have to watch the video to know who is going to win this.

[taylorswift091196]

@xtinafan06 wth you are sadly misinformed Taylor can also the play the guitar, piano and the ukulele. The uploader got some great Carrie clips and some bad-quality Taylor clips so that she sounds bad. Actually although she's not the best she's still awesome. Taylor is just as pretty as Carrie, if not more, and for personality Taylor beats Carrie totally because she's so sweet and not fake at all. Carrie was super jealous of her at an award show. Don't get me wrong I love both of them.

[AshleelovesCarrie]

@taylorswift091196 Taylor sucks...she can't sing and her lyrics suck!

[carebearjttw]

Have no problem with Tay but Carrie wins hands-down =)

[donniefan4life]

lmfaooooo

u must have it your head on the ground as a child if you don't know who thewinner is.

Miss Carrie Underwood by farrr

[iamready16]

ummm, lets see...... :/ carrie! yea enough said.

[zebracake125]

what is that hot mess at 5:42 - 6:14.OMG terrible....

followed by that amazing HGTA.

Yeah Carrie wins with one vocal cord tied behind her back.:)

[countrymusiclover53]

CARRIE UNDERWOOD !!!!!!!!!! not only because i don't like taylor (since she cant make up her mind over country or pop- clearly your pop) but carrie underwood can sing and hold a note like there is no tomorrow !!!! CARRIE CARRIE !! i saw em both in concert (taylor was keith thats why...) & CARRIE IS AWESOME !!!! there is no competion !!!

[coolidge909]

Why is Taylor saying "Halle-YOU-yah"?? And what was the note she sustained? It's not a high note but still it's impressive judging by her standards. That was a good Taylor note. She stayed in key too, for the most part except when I thought she was going to die from singing it.

Carrie is without doubt the winner here. Doesn't even need a video.

[mellynumerounoo]

@coolidge909 The note Taylor sustained was C5 then down to A4.

[coolidge909]

@mellynumerounoo so she went went down 3 notes to be able to sustain it? Anyway that's a good enough Taylor note. She sounded okay in the first half but then started sucking again.

You could've included Carrie singing Some Hearts from the Play On tour. She has an electric guitar.

[musicChick023]

OMG, Taylor my poor ears! I had to go through your singing so I could just hear Carrie sing. and WTH happened to picture to burn at the near ending?! is that the way it's suppose to be sung? because I haven't heard of it until now... she's like reciting a poem or something.....

Carrie on the other hand is Awesome as always! no words could describe the awesomeness of her voice :))

and BTW, I know you won't and How great thou art = EPIC WIN! it's feels like listening to an angel!

[rytanya26]

No competition. Carrie OWNS Taylor Swift!!!

[KennyChisholm1]

No competition at all.

[logotgr]

I don't know why there even needs to be a video; Carrie sounds a million times better than Taylor even when she's sick. I have still yet to hear any vibrato from Taylor, so those long notes of hers aren't what I'd call pleasing to listen to. They're not terrible though, Taylor has gotten a tiny bit better. But I am still baffled how Taylor won Female Vocalist of the Year at the 2009 CMAs. the CMAs need to either review their criteria for the category or change the title of the award.

[bedibye813]

Taylor sounds considerably better in this video than the other one. Still Carrie owns her.

Taylor sounds better in a large concert setting than in an intimate or open setting.

[MoopowerX]

Carrie...yup

[Jon34L]

No contest. Taylor wins.

lol jk Carrie just owned her.

[EpicAmends]

Carrie puts Taylor to shame. It's most obvious in the national anthem comparison, probably because they're singing the same song. Could Taylor ever tackle one of Carrie's songs? Especially something like "I Know You Won't"? Not a chance. Carrie on the other hand could make Taylor's songs sound about 1000x better.